fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2018 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 20187Artisans 28/1.4 for Leica M

  
 
Krzysieka2
Offline
Details
p.9 #17Artisans 28/1.4 for Leica M
Has anyone tried that lens on an apc camera? I'm hoping to use it instead of fujinon xf27/2.8 mostly due to 1.4 .
Feb 08, 2019 at 02:28 PM
mcbroomf
Offline
Details
p.9 #27Artisans 28/1.4 for Leica M
GMPhotography wrote:
Thanks Mike and I guess order direct from them or Amazon. I’ll probably order it on the 9th when my smugmug money hits my bank.


---------------------------------------------

GMPhotography wrote:
Found it on eBay.

https://www.ebay.com/itm/7artisans-28mm-F1-4-Large-Aperture-Lens-For-Leica-M-M-M240-M3-M5-M6-M7-M8-M9-M9P/173655852449?hash=item286eb205a1:g:qpIAAOSwJ~5b96ov

Looks like March and 486.00


I just noticed the it's listed on B&H now, although 2-4 weeks for new stock.
https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/1445473-REG/7artisans_photoelectric_a001b_28mm_f1_4_leica_m.html#customerReview
Feb 09, 2019 at 06:00 AM
candreyo
Offline
Details
p.9 #37Artisans 28/1.4 for Leica M
I have a Fuji XE-2, and the lens works absolutely fine on it.
To be fair, the lens works absolutely fine on even the the Sony 42MP FF sensors. It especially works nicely with Velvia film mode doing some artistic nature photos.
Main drawback is, it weighs about 490g due to the all metal design.

On full frame, stopped down a bit to, even the corners are sharp.
The 7A lens does not seem to suffer the adverse affects on thicker sensor stacks, like many other rangefinder lenses do. It’s possible 7A knew these would be used on cameras beyond just Leica’s, and designed the lens formula to accommodate this as best they could.
To be fair, the performance of the lens is amazing for the price, as long as you get a good copy that is centered.
I’ve compared it to the Voigtlander 28mm ultron, and the Voigtlander is only a hair sharper at f/2 then the 7A, but ofcourse the Voigtlander can’t do f/1.4.

I also prefer the bokeh of the 7A vs Voigtlander and even the Zeiss 28mm Biogon. Have since sold the Biogon and considering selling the Ultron now aswell.

For any leica user, the lens is a no brainier, the only other alternative in Leica world is the insanely expensive Summilux.

My one criticism of the lens after owning it for about 2 months now is, the knurling on the focus ring is a bit sharp, and would like it to be smoother a tad. No real criticism of the optics though.

On a side note:
I’m eagerly waiting for 7A to release a 90mm f/1.8 in M mount, as I have suspicions this is there next Leica M lens on the horizon.
I know someone who talks to them often, and send him a message to relay to them about creating a telephoto next.

I’m hoping a 7A telephoto lens may be a Sonnar design also, which would be amazing. As for Leica users, we have limited selection of 85mm f/2 Sonnars to choose from without each having drawbacks. There is the very expensive and poorly mechanically designed ZM Sonnar, the Jupiter 9 lenses are nearly impossible to use with the rangefinder due to the contax vs leica focusing calibration, and the pre-war Sonnars are very heavy all brass/ chrome designs. The Nippon Kogaku’s are also heavy brass designs and Nikon over-corrected the optics in theirs to increase contrast while decreasing bokeh appeal.

We need a true 85/ 90 Sonnar made for Leica, with modern coatings and modern mostly aluminium (partially brass) construction. And the user could choose whether hey wanted wide open or f/2.8 as the focus calibration, so each user could choose how they wanted to deal with the Sonnar shift on the rangefinders. I think 7A is perfect to take on that task.
Basically, I want there 50mm f/1.1 in a 85/90mm f/1.8 focal length that is rangefinder coupled

Krzysieka2 wrote:
Has anyone tried that lens on an apc camera? I'm hoping to use it instead of fujinon xf27/2.8 mostly due to 1.4 .

Feb 09, 2019 at 06:24 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.9 #47Artisans 28/1.4 for Leica M
Thanks that was helpful. As I thought about just getting the CV 28 Ultron again. Love the lens but corners are tough to get going.
Feb 09, 2019 at 07:42 AM
serhan_
Offline
Details
p.9 #57Artisans 28/1.4 for Leica M
Thanks for the report.

There are already light 73mm & 90mm Sonnars:
MS Optics Sonnetar 73mm f1.5

and leica m converted Contax g 90mm:
Contax G Sonnar 90/2.8 Black for Leica M

It is rare, but you can find used converted Contax g 90mm also...

candreyo wrote:
We need a true 85/ 90 Sonnar made for Leica, with modern coatings and modern mostly aluminium (partially brass) construction. And the user could choose whether hey wanted wide open or f/2.8 as the focus calibration, so each user could choose how they wanted to deal with the Sonnar shift on the rangefinders. I think 7A is perfect to take on that task.
Basically, I want there 50mm f/1.1 in a 85/90mm f/1.8 focal length that is rangefinder coupled

Feb 09, 2019 at 10:53 AM
Krzysieka2
Offline
Details
p.9 #67Artisans 28/1.4 for Leica M
Candreyo, thank you. Since you got e2 are you familiar whith 23/1.4 or 27/2.8 to compare them?
Feb 09, 2019 at 11:05 AM
realVivek
Offline
Details
p.9 #77Artisans 28/1.4 for Leica M
Happy Lunar New Year!

Untitled by Vivek Iyer, on Flickr

Sony A7R, 7 Artisans 28/1.4, The Hague
Feb 09, 2019 at 01:48 PM
candreyo
Offline
Details
p.9 #87Artisans 28/1.4 for Leica M
Unfortunately, I’ve not owned or used either of those lenses.
I mainly have Fuji zoom lenses, and the one prime I had for the system was the 32mm f/1.8 Zeiss Touit.

The Touit was a sharper lens, but I’ve also heard the 32mm Touit is one of the sharpest lenses for APS-C there is also.

The bokeh of the 7A works very nicely with the Fuji.
I had the Sony 28mm FE lens also, and have since sold it. The bokeh (IMO) is better on the 7A still.

The one 28mm lens I think is probably better then the 7A, within the below $1000 price range (which excludes the modern Leica Summicron and Summilux then) is the Zeiss 28mm f/2 ZF/ ZE (aka. Hollywood Diatagon in the Contax days). I had the original Contax Distagon and this was my favourite 28mm I’ve owned.

However, as I’m a Leica Digital & Film user in addition to a Fuji and Sony user, I prefer lenses that are rangefinder coupled, so they can be used across the board on all the cameras I own.

It’s here where the 7A fits the bill better then the Zeiss 28mm Diatagon.
If one didn’t care about the rangefinder coupling, I’d strongly suggest the 28mm Diatagon as an excellent alternative.
Many other 28’s like the Zeiss ZM and Voigtlander VM’s have too many issues on the thicker filter stacks that, without correction lenses, fall short on corner performance and field curvature.
7A, fortunately, doesn’t seem to suffer these issues as nearly as bad as the VM and ZM lenses do on Sony and thicker stacks.

Hope this helps!

Krzysieka2 wrote:
Candreyo, thank you. Since you got e2 are you familiar whith 23/1.4 or 27/2.8 to compare them?

Feb 09, 2019 at 02:18 PM
realVivek
Offline
Details
p.9 #97Artisans 28/1.4 for Leica M
Well, I do not agree with your assessments on the Nikkor or the Zeiss, Candreyo.

FWIW, it is Distagon and not "Diatagon" and there is an updated version that is called Milvus.
Feb 09, 2019 at 02:37 PM
mcbroomf
Offline
Details
p.9 #107Artisans 28/1.4 for Leica M
Actually the 28/2 has never been released as a Milvus, so only available as the "Classic" or original C/Y. It appears that Zeiss have discontinued that too (the Classic) as it's in their Historic section, not the current/active Classic. B&H have a ripping good deal on an EOS version though, close to 1/2 price. I wonder if that's because Zeiss will release a Milvus version soon?
Feb 09, 2019 at 03:05 PM
imagesfromobjects
Offline
Details
p.9 #117Artisans 28/1.4 for Leica M


candreyo wrote:
I have a Fuji XE-2, and the lens works absolutely fine on it.
To be fair, the lens works absolutely fine on even the the Sony 42MP FF sensors. It especially works nicely with Velvia film mode doing some artistic nature photos.
Main drawback is, it weighs about 490g due to the all metal design.

On full frame, stopped down a bit to, even the corners are sharp.
The 7A lens does not seem to suffer the adverse affects on thicker sensor stacks, like many other rangefinder lenses do. It’s possible 7A knew these would be used on cameras beyond just Leica’s, and designed
...Show more →
Krzysieka2 wroteHas anyone tried that lens on an apc camera? I'm hoping to use it instead of fujinon xf27/2.8 mostly due to 1.4 .


I'd buy the 7A 85-90 f/2 tomorrow if it were released, and I'm primarily a Sony shooter on digital.

There's a void in the FE lineup for a compact short tele, we covered this recently on the forum. I'm using a g90, which is optically outstanding, but the user experience is not ideal due to the adapter. Other options are the CV Heliar 75's, but the f/1.8 version is pushing it in the bulk factor, and the Jupiter, else declare bankruptcy and go Leica.

We could really use a reasonably priced, optically up-to-speed, light and compact 85-90mm with a good mf helicoid. I'd take 2.8 or even 3.5 if it focuses close, just to keep the size down.
Feb 09, 2019 at 04:59 PM
AdaptedLenses
Offline
Details
p.9 #127Artisans 28/1.4 for Leica M
And they have a used copy for $552... hmm, I’d much prefer ZF though.

mcbroomf wrote:
Actually the 28/2 has never been released as a Milvus, so only available as the "Classic" or original C/Y. It appears that Zeiss have discontinued that too (the Classic) as it's in their Historic section, not the current/active Classic. B&H have a ripping good deal on an EOS version though, close to 1/2 price. I wonder if that's because Zeiss will release a Milvus version soon?

Feb 09, 2019 at 07:26 PM
bjornthun
Offline
Details
p.9 #137Artisans 28/1.4 for Leica M
mcbroomf wrote:
Actually the 28/2 has never been released as a Milvus, so only available as the "Classic" or original C/Y. It appears that Zeiss have discontinued that too (the Classic) as it's in their Historic section, not the current/active Classic. B&H have a ripping good deal on an EOS version though, close to 1/2 price. I wonder if that's because Zeiss will release a Milvus version soon?


The only Classic lenses left in the current lenses section of the Download Centre are the doble Gauss Planar 50/1.4 and 85/1.4, when I checked the German language Zeiss pages. This is also reflected on Cosina's Japanese web site. So, I guess the classic line is about to go entirely. 28mm is the only focal length that hasn't been converted to Milvus yet.

You can't access the Classic section from the list of lens families, inly the pdfs in the Download Centre.

Maybe some news will come from Zeiss soon?

Btw, what about the Zeiss ZM line?
Feb 09, 2019 at 07:37 PM
candreyo
Offline
Details
p.9 #147Artisans 28/1.4 for Leica M
I’m aware about the Distagon proper naming, on my phone, it unfortunately auto-corrects it to Diatagon.

What Nikkor are you talking about that you don’t agree with me on? I don’t recall talking about a Nikkor 28mm, and have never owned one either.

If you are referring to the 8.5cm Nippon Kogaku, it’s well documented this lens was boosted for contrast by Nippon (which became Nikon later on) by over correcting the spherical abberations, which resulted in a bit harsher bokeh. This is well discussed on rangefinderforums.
I’ve owned Jupiter 9 M39, the Zeiss 85mm ZM Sonnar, Contarex 85mm f/2, Contax G 90mm f/2.8 w/ adapter and 85mm Batis.

Of all these lenses, none were an ideal Sonnar for me. The Jupiter 9 got close, but lacked modern coating so flared a lot and it couldn’t focus right on my Leica even after trying to adjust it. The Zeiss ZM version, while optically quite impressive, has known mechanical issues, that resulted in Zeiss discontinuing after 600 units. I posted on FM forums my struggles with this lens a few years ago. My copy had to go to Zeiss twice to be repaired, and broke a third time after that aswell. The repair bill were over €1,000 nearly each time.

The contarex was impressive and very original Sonnar like, but it’s not rangefinder coupled. The Nippon is over-corrected so its bokeh is harsher and the brass body lens is over 500g, though I have been trying to buy a black one to get the weight down.
The Contax G 90mm version is a stop slower then its brothers, and the adapted helicoids are never as smooth as a manufacturer designed one.

So, there really isn’t a new 85/90mm f/2 Sonnar with modern coating that will work on Leica rangefinders right out of box from the manufacturer enjoyably IMO.
I have heard that if you use a Contax Jupiter 9 with an Amedeo Contax/ Kiev to LTM adapter, it will work properly on Leica rangefinders, and this is something I plan on trying very soon.

realVivek wrote:
Well, I do not agree with your assessments on the Nikkor or the Zeiss, Candreyo.

FWIW, it is Distagon and not "Diatagon" and there is an updated version that is called Milvus.

Feb 10, 2019 at 03:15 AM
candreyo
Offline
Details
p.9 #157Artisans 28/1.4 for Leica M
I don’t think there will be a Milvus version of the 28mm of the Hollywood Distagon design. If there is a Milvus version eventually, it very well may be a new design all together.
The Hollywood Diatagon design is going over 30 years old now, and if used in the Milvus, would be the third time the lens formula was recycled up into a new body. I suspect this is why there wasn’t one already released yet.

mcbroomf wrote:
Actually the 28/2 has never been released as a Milvus, so only available as the "Classic" or original C/Y. It appears that Zeiss have discontinued that too (the Classic) as it's in their Historic section, not the current/active Classic. B&H have a ripping good deal on an EOS version though, close to 1/2 price. I wonder if that's because Zeiss will release a Milvus version soon?

Feb 10, 2019 at 03:21 AM
candreyo
Offline
Details
p.9 #167Artisans 28/1.4 for Leica M
Regrettably, many suspect Zeiss has discontinued the ZM lens line, without an announcement (similar to how Sony treats A mount).

I would really love it for Zeiss to continue to make more ZM lenses, but they seem focused on other areas like ZX1 at the moment.😭

bjornthun wrote:
mcbroomf wroteActually the 28/2 has never been released as a Milvus, so only available as the "Classic" or original C/Y. It appears that Zeiss have discontinued that too (the Classic) as it's in their Historic section, not the current/active Classic. B&H have a ripping good deal on an EOS version though, close to 1/2 price. I wonder if that's because Zeiss will release a Milvus version soon?
The only Classic lenses left in the current lenses section of the Download Centre are the doble Gauss Planar 50/1.4 and 85/1.4, when I checked the German language Zeiss pages. This is also reflected on Cosina's Japanese web site. So, I guess the classic line is about to go entirely. 28mm is the only focal length that hasn't been converted to Milvus yet.

You can't access the Classic section from the list of lens families, inly the pdfs in the Download Centre.

Maybe some news will come from Zeiss soon?

Btw, what about the Zeiss ZM line?

Feb 10, 2019 at 03:24 AM
realVivek
Offline
Details
p.9 #177Artisans 28/1.4 for Leica M
The Nikkor over corrected for what? If it is for spherical aberrations, then it bodes well for a Sony body.

I use the 10.5cm f/2.5 Nikkor P.C (Sonnar clone). Fabulous on Sony cams.

I also have the Jupiter 9, 8.5cm. Not worth the bother.

Olympus OM (F Zuiko) 85/2 is a great Sonnar clone. Tiny and lightweight.

I don't like the Contax G 90/2.8.

Yes, the ZM Sonnar is a disaster ("Made in Germany" ?). Users were shafted while some collectors were overjoyed (at the discontinuation).

7 A is the future, I am convinced.


candreyo wrote:
I’m aware about the Distagon proper naming, on my phone, it unfortunately auto-corrects it to Diatagon.

What Nikkor are you talking about that you don’t agree with me on? I don’t recall talking about a Nikkor 28mm, and have never owned one either.

If you are referring to the 8.5cm Nippon Kogaku, it’s well documented this lens was boosted for contrast by Nippon (which became Nikon later on) by over correcting the spherical abberations, which resulted in a bit harsher bokeh. This is well discussed on rangefinderforums.
I’ve owned Jupiter 9 M39, the Zeiss 85mm ZM Sonnar, Contarex 85mm f/2, Contax G 90mm
...Show more →
realVivek wroteWell, I do not agree with your assessments on the Nikkor or the Zeiss, Candreyo.

FWIW, it is Distagon and not "Diatagon" and there is an updated version that is called Milvus.

Feb 10, 2019 at 05:12 AM
candreyo
Offline
Details
p.9 #187Artisans 28/1.4 for Leica M
Yes, it was for aspherical abberations. It resulted in the Nippon getting a large boost in contrast and sharpness, at the expense of its bokeh.

I agree, the Nippon is way better then the Jupiter 9 in terms of sharpness, flare resistance and contrast, but its bokeh as been affected also by the changes Nippon introduced into the formula.

I do own a Nippon 10.5cm f/2.5 LTM, and it’s rendering is indeed fantastic. This is how I’d expect true Sonnars to render.

It poses a challenge on Leica rangefinders though, because it sits in between the 90mm and 135mm framelines. Making framing a bit of an estimate at best.
But I do use it on Sony bodies and have been very satisfied withtbits results. 😇

realVivek wrote:
The Nikkor over corrected for what? If it is for spherical aberrations, then it bodes well for a Sony body.

I use the 10.5cm f/2.5 Nikkor P.C (Sonnar clone). Fabulous on Sony cams.

I also have the Jupiter 9, 8.5cm. Not worth the bother.

Olympus OM (F Zuiko) 85/2 is a great Sonnar clone. Tiny and lightweight.

I don't like the Contax G 90/2.8.

Yes, the ZM Sonnar is a disaster ("Made in Germany" ?). Users were shafted while some collectors were overjoyed (at the discontinuation).

7 A is the future, I am convinced.

candreyo wroteI’m aware about the Distagon proper naming, on my phone, it unfortunately auto-corrects it to Diatagon.

What Nikkor are you talking about that you don’t agree with me on? I don’t recall talking about a Nikkor 28mm, and have never owned one either.

If you are referring to the 8.5cm Nippon Kogaku, it’s well documented this lens was boosted for contrast by Nippon (which became Nikon later on) by over correcting the spherical abberations, which resulted in a bit harsher bokeh. This is well discussed on rangefinderforums.
I’ve owned Jupiter 9 M39, the Zeiss 85mm ZM Sonnar, Contarex 85mm f/2, Contax G 90mm f/2.8 w/ adapter and 85mm Batis.

Of all these lenses, none were an ideal Sonnar for me. The Jupiter 9 got close, but lacked modern coating so flared a lot and it couldn’t focus right on my Leica even after trying to adjust it. The Zeiss ZM version, while optically quite impressive, has known mechanical issues, that resulted in Zeiss discontinuing after 600 units. I posted on FM forums my struggles with this lens a few years ago. My copy had to go to Zeiss twice to be repaired, and broke a third time after that aswell. The repair bill were over €1,000 nearly each time.

The contarex was impressive and very original Sonnar like, but it’s not rangefinder coupled. The Nippon is over-corrected so its bokeh is harsher and the brass body lens is over 500g, though I have been trying to buy a black one to get the weight down.
The Contax G 90mm version is a stop slower then its brothers, and the adapted helicoids are never as smooth as a manufacturer designed one.

So, there really isn’t a new 85/90mm f/2 Sonnar with modern coating that will work on Leica rangefinders right out of box from the manufacturer enjoyably IMO.
I have heard that if you use a Contax Jupiter 9 with an Amedeo Contax/ Kiev to LTM adapter, it will work properly on Leica rangefinders, and this is something I plan on trying very soon.

realVivek wroteWell, I do not agree with your assessments on the Nikkor or the Zeiss, Candreyo.

FWIW, it is Distagon and not "Diatagon" and there is an updated version that is called Milvus.

Feb 10, 2019 at 05:53 AM
BastianK
Offline
Details
p.9 #197Artisans 28/1.4 for Leica M
Can someone tell me how many aperture blades this 28mm 1.4 has?
I did not manage to find that information yet.
Feb 19, 2019 at 04:38 AM
realVivek
Offline
Details
p.9 #207Artisans 28/1.4 for Leica M
13.

Untitled by Vivek Iyer, on Flickr
Feb 19, 2019 at 05:48 AM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister