I might as well. I doubt it will be close to the Lux 28, but no one expects it would (still nice to see how far apart they are). Been waiting for a great, small 28/1.4.
To put things in perspective.. the price of this lens is less than twice of the list price of the sun shade (a special order item!) for the ZM Distagon 35/1.4!
Looks pretty good. I've been getting back into the swing of 28mm with my Leica R. This would be an interesting alternative. I hope it performs well on a Sony
What do you guys think of the intentional ring flare? Why went all out for a modern look then decided to do this? I don't think this lens will look anything like their 50/1.1, that MTF is pretty good.
hiepphotog wrote:
What do you guys think of the intentional ring flare? Why went all out for a modern look then decided to do this? I don't think this lens will look anything like their 50/1.1, that MTF is pretty good.
My uneducated guess is that it's from a part of the lens barrel (internal of course) that is not properly blacked out and causing an internal reflection. As the lens he was using was still a prototype I'd hope they used his feedback to fix it for the final release.
mcbroomf wrote: hiepphotog wroteWhat do you guys think of the intentional ring flare? Why went all out for a modern look then decided to do this? I don't think this lens will look anything like their 50/1.1, that MTF is pretty good.My uneducated guess is that it's from a part of the lens barrel (internal of course) that is not properly blacked out and causing an internal reflection. As the lens he was using was still a prototype I'd hope they used his feedback to fix it for the final release.
From his article, he said they did that intentionally:
"This flare is something they tell me they’re intentionally leaving in. I was told that they could add a bit of “ink” to an internal part of the lens that would resolve it, but after showing it to a friend of the business in China who liked it, they have decided to keep it as a feature. Make what you will of this, but for me, this is entirely typical of the approach this company takes to its designs, and something to continue to expect from them in future lenses. They seem to enjoy including some character trait that’s slightly less than conventionally “good”."
mcbroomf wrote: hiepphotog wroteWhat do you guys think of the intentional ring flare? Why went all out for a modern look then decided to do this? I don't think this lens will look anything like their 50/1.1, that MTF is pretty good.My uneducated guess is that it's from a part of the lens barrel (internal of course) that is not properly blacked out and causing an internal reflection. As the lens he was using was still a prototype I'd hope they used his feedback to fix it for the final release.
From the linked article above:
"I sent a couple of the photos to the guys at 7Artisans, without mentioning the flare specifically to see what they said. The response was about as interesting as I could have possibly hoped. This flare is something they tell me they’re intentionally leaving in. I was told that they could add a bit of “ink” to an internal part of the lens that would resolve it, but after showing it to a friend of the business in China who liked it, they have decided to keep it as a feature. Make what you will of this, but for me, this is entirely typical of the approach this company takes to its designs, and something to continue to expect from them in future lenses. They seem to enjoy including some character trait that’s slightly less than conventionally “good”."
I missed that. Yes, if possible I'd ink it as well, but I have no experience opening lenses. May be a deal breaker .... I wonder if they could be persuaded to make 2 versions
mcbroomf wrote:
I missed that. Yes, if possible I'd ink it as well, but I have no experience opening lenses. May be a deal breaker .... I wonder if they could be persuaded to make 2 versions
If I find it too objectionable for my use and manage to “ink” the right area (and if that takes care of the flare.. lots of ifs..), may be we can convince them to?
hiepphotog wrote:
What do you guys think of the intentional ring flare? Why went all out for a modern look then decided to do this? I don't think this lens will look anything like their 50/1.1, that MTF is pretty good.
My gut reaction is that I could live without it, but it won't stop me from giving it a shot. I think it could be useful in one in a million photos, but I'm wondering if it can't be worked around for the other 999,999.
The MTFs look impressive, but given the drop between 10 and 30 wide open, I'd say the 28's only going to have the 50 beat in the corners with both at 1.4.