serhan_ wrote:
What about the field curvature eg corners? Do you have a shot of building facade?
realVivek wroteA few snaps from a brief outing (rainy). All f/1.4 and on A7R (my color cam). Unsharpened and with no distortion corrections applied. There was no filter on the lens. I do not have a shade for it and I just added a 52 to 62 step up ring. Specular highlights do not bother this lens for my use.
Well I talked to their reps on FB. They said they would think about offering a less flare prone version. I imagine if more people send them a message, it will likely happen. This one is sharp at WO, so it could really be the poor man Lux 28.
I tried to get the ring flare by shooting against light sources. It happens and it is unpredictable. For some it may be totally unacceptable.
Here is one example (one of the very few I got the ring, I might add): On a Monochrome converted Sony A7rII, with a strong UV/IR cut filter on the lens. No hood. f/1.4. The Sony A7rII(m) has a total of 1mm cover glass on the sensor.
Now you've got me really excited. DHL says mine should be in sometime on Thursday. Assuming all goes as planned this weekend, I should be able to get some landscape testing done between a stock rII and UT mod rII.
On the overhead street lamps if you stopped down a little does the halo go away. I read in that one review if you stop down that flare goes. Could someone try it
I’m really liking this rendering. A bit hard but makes me think of CV at least at web sizes, which is a compliment. I could see preferring an inked version but probably could do it myself if it really bugged me. @serhan_ what do you mean by “full price”? Selling for $480 direct as well now?
I did. It is still there all the way down to f/16.
Wrong info from that anonymous review.
GMPhotography wrote:
On the overhead street lamps if you stopped down a little does the halo go away. I read in that one review if you stop down that flare goes. Could someone try it
One more bokeh shot without the ring flares (would have been a lot sharper if it had not been shot "on the go"). About 1.5m. Cropped during levelling in the post.
Long time not posting, unfortunately my health hadn’t been to good earlier this year and took some time off work/ other things to recover.
Anyhow, wanted to comment that I received this lens today, shipped to me from Hammish at 35mmc in the UK.
My copy is impressively sharp wide open, it is sharper to me then my Voigtlander 35mm f/1.2 II Nokton at 1.2 or 1.4.
The 7Artisans 28mm lens is also very similar size and weight to the Voigtlander also.
However, it is not as sharp as modern aspherical lenses like the Voigtlander 50mm f/1.2.
My copy of the Voigtlander 28mm f/2 ASPH Ultron is only just sharper in the centre at f/2.
I’ve tested the lens today on both my Leica M240 and Sony A7RII.
One thing I immediately did was find the brightest light source after the sun had set, and began to try and induce the ring flare.
It is there of course, however on my copy, if I stop down to even f/1.5 (moving the aperture ring just off the the wide open f/1.4 Mark), the ring flare goes away.
I could not for the life of me could induce the ring flare from about f/1.5 onwards. However, as soon as I opened the lens to f/1.4, the ring flare came back. This prompted me to comment here, as I’ve heard conflicting reports across the web on when or if the flare ever goes away.
Others have reported that stopping down slightly makes the ring flare go away also.
I’ve no explanation for why realVivek’s lens continues to do it to f/16?
It’s possibe sample variation may cause the flare to go away at different apertures on different lenses?
I’ve tried to inspect inside the lens to ascertain what is causing the flare, and the one area that looks suspicious to me is a very thin ring right below the aperture blades on my lens. It appears to be silver when I look into the rear of my lens and the ring itself looks as if it’s a mere 0.5mm thick.
If I take the lens off the camera, and hold it towards a bright light source wide open, and look at the rear element at an angle, I can see this reflective ring ‘illuminating’ and thus it’s going to potentially cause the flare issue we see.
However, if I stop down to about f/1.5-1.6, I can no longer see the ring ‘illuminated’ on my copy. Conversely, this is where the ring flare disappears when using it on my digital cameras.
I can’t be certain, but it appears that the ring stops illuminating on my copy because by the f/1.5 aperture area, there is just enough aperture closure to block the ring from receiving light, and begins to shade it almost.
While I’m not ready to disassemble this lens just yet, I actually had expected the ring flare was going to be a bigger issue on my copy, which would justify me taking it apart to ink the offending area.
To all who eventually get copies of this lens, If you could post at what aperture causes the flare to go away, and in worst cases, if it never does even by f/16 (like RealVivek’s copy).
Maybe there was different batches 7Artisans made for their first run, and some batches are more ring flare prone at smaller apertures then others? As stated above, mine is a UK copy ordered from 35mmc.
realVivek wrote:
I did. It is still there all the way down to f/16.
Wrong info from that anonymous review.
GMPhotography wroteOn the overhead street lamps if you stopped down a little does the halo go away. I read in that one review if you stop down that flare goes. Could someone try it
candreyo wrote:
I’ve tested the lens today on both my Leica M240 and Sony A7RII.
I know this is only posted in the Sony forum, though being an M lens really should be cross-posted in Alt, too. Wondering if you noticed anything undesirable in your M240 images, like edge color shift, LOCA in high contrast transitions, etc? The samples at 7artisans look good, but it's always nice to get forum member feedback.
Mine came. I haven't had time to take more than a couple dog shots, but is anyone else finding the friction cap to be very tight? Like, unreasonably tight?
freaklikeme wrote:
Mine came. I haven't had time to take more than a couple dog shots, but is anyone else finding the friction cap to be very tight? Like, unreasonably tight?
Mine is tight, but not unreasonably tight. It’s good and snug without being unreasonably so. Having a 52mm filter installed may help, as the cap will have less area to secure itself to the lens before bottoming out.
I know with the 35mm f/2 M lenses they had, the initial push on caps were so loose, they would often fall right off.
Maybe they have made the 28mm push on cap much snugger to mitigate any falling off issues due to tolerances.
I hope to try the lens out more this weekend with my M240. I have been using it much of today on the Sony A7RII, and I’m very impressed so far. The colour is really nice and stopping down to f/8 give really nice sharpness in the central 95% of the frame. Only the far edges could do a bit more, but I think this is due to field curvature. Sharpness in the centre from already f/2-2.8 is excellent.
Field curvature with the lens is no where near as extreme as say the Voigtlander 28mm f/2 Ultron I have.
I’ve not noticed any weird anomalies so far that haven’t been covered in the reviews online. I’m a person who has owned many Leica, Zeiss ZM/ ZF, and Voigtlander VM lenses, and I’m honestly really amazed how much lens you get for $375.00. I was examining it today pondering how they are able to sell it at this price and still make profit?
The quality construction is similar to Voigtlander VM and Zeiss ZM. However, I don’t like too much the focus ring knurling, I think this could use maybe some softening up, but this is really the only nitpick I can give it.
One thing I have noticed is, changing the aperture from 1.4 to 2.0, results in my camera measuring -0,7 stop reduction in light. Going from 2.0 to 2.8, is measured as should be, -1.0 stop.
I suspect, while the lens is labelled a f/1.4 lens due to the ratio between entrance pupil and exit pupil, the transmission might be closer to T/1.6.
I have been trying and trying to get my lens to have ring flare beyond the f/1.5 aperture, and it just wont do it, neither on the Sony or the Leica.
Oddly enough. I am actually liking the ring flare ability when using the Sony with EVF. It allows very precise manipulation and placement of it, and I already have some ring flare emitting out of a light source and enveloping the top star of a Christmas tree that looks really cool. Considering it disappears by f/1.5, I can actually see why some at 7Artisans thought this was cool and decided to leave it there. Tweaking the aperture slightly almost acts as a switch between ‘ring flare on’ and ‘ring flare off’.
candreyo wrote: freaklikeme wroteMine came. I haven't had time to take more than a couple dog shots, but is anyone else finding the friction cap to be very tight? Like, unreasonably tight?Mine is tight, but not unreasonably tight. It’s good and snug without being unreasonably so. Having a 52mm filter installed may help, as the cap will have less area to secure itself to the lens before bottoming out.
I know with the 35mm f/2 M lenses they had, the initial push on caps were so loose, they would often fall right off.
Maybe they have made the 28mm push on cap much snugger to mitigate any falling off issues due to tolerances.
I hope to try the lens out more this weekend with my M240. I have been using it much of today on the Sony A7RII, and I’m very impressed so far. The colour is really nice and stopping down to f/8 give really nice sharpness in the central 95% of the frame. Only the far edges could do a bit more, but I think this is due to field curvature. Sharpness in the centre from already f/2-2.8 is excellent.
Field curvature with the lens is no where near as extreme as say the Voigtlander 28mm f/2 Ultron I have.
I’ve not noticed any weird anomalies so far that haven’t been covered in the reviews online. I’m a person who has owned many Leica, Zeiss ZM/ ZF, and Voigtlander VM lenses, and I’m honestly really amazed how much lens you get for $375.00. I was examining it today pondering how they are able to sell it at this price and still make profit?
The quality construction is similar to Voigtlander VM and Zeiss ZM. However, I don’t like too much the focus ring knurling, I think this could use maybe some softening up, but this is really the only nitpick I can give it.
One thing I have noticed is, changing the aperture from 1.4 to 2.0, results in my camera measuring -0,7 stop reduction in light. Going from 2.0 to 2.8, is measured as should be, -1.0 stop.
I suspect, while the lens is labelled a f/1.4 lens due to the ratio between entrance pupil and exit pupil, the transmission might be closer to T/1.6.
I have been trying and trying to get my lens to have ring flare beyond the f/1.5 aperture, and it just wont do it, neither on the Sony or the Leica.
Oddly enough. I am actually liking the ring flare ability when using the Sony with EVF. It allows very precise manipulation and placement of it, and I already have some ring flare emitting out of a light source and enveloping the top star of a Christmas tree that looks really cool. Considering it disappears by f/1.5, I can actually see why some at 7Artisans thought this was cool and decided to leave it there. Tweaking the aperture slightly almost acts as a switch between ‘ring flare on’ and ‘ring flare off’. ...Show more →
Another nice report. Not that I need one but it's very tempting . I'm on a buying spree lately. As for the light transmission at WO, I think it's pretty normal for all lenses that the stop difference between WO and one aperture stop down wouldn't equate 1-stop of light. Vignetting is definitely the culprit.
I'm glad to hear that the ring flare is only at around WO aperture. Then it might be less of an issue. I haven't had any 7Artisans lens myself so this could be my first. I have been lusting over that Lux 28 for a long while now.
I don't expect this lens has a good coma performance, especially on a stock Sony. But for those of you with a Leica body, I wonder if you guys can test for that. I believe the ZM 35/1.4 is near perfect in this aspect.
candreyo wrote: freaklikeme wroteMine came. I haven't had time to take more than a couple dog shots, but is anyone else finding the friction cap to be very tight? Like, unreasonably tight?Mine is tight, but not unreasonably tight. It’s good and snug without being unreasonably so. Having a 52mm filter installed may help, as the cap will have less area to secure itself to the lens before bottoming out.
I know with the 35mm f/2 M lenses they had, the initial push on caps were so loose, they would often fall right off.
Maybe they have made the 28mm push on cap much snugger to mitigate any falling off issues due to tolerances.
I hope to try the lens out more this weekend with my M240. I have been using it much of today on the Sony A7RII, and I’m very impressed so far. The colour is really nice and stopping down to f/8 give really nice sharpness in the central 95% of the frame. Only the far edges could do a bit more, but I think this is due to field curvature. Sharpness in the centre from already f/2-2.8 is excellent.
Field curvature with the lens is no where near as extreme as say the Voigtlander 28mm f/2 Ultron I have.
I’ve not noticed any weird anomalies so far that haven’t been covered in the reviews online. I’m a person who has owned many Leica, Zeiss ZM/ ZF, and Voigtlander VM lenses, and I’m honestly really amazed how much lens you get for $375.00. I was examining it today pondering how they are able to sell it at this price and still make profit?
The quality construction is similar to Voigtlander VM and Zeiss ZM. However, I don’t like too much the focus ring knurling, I think this could use maybe some softening up, but this is really the only nitpick I can give it.
One thing I have noticed is, changing the aperture from 1.4 to 2.0, results in my camera measuring -0,7 stop reduction in light. Going from 2.0 to 2.8, is measured as should be, -1.0 stop.
I suspect, while the lens is labelled a f/1.4 lens due to the ratio between entrance pupil and exit pupil, the transmission might be closer to T/1.6.
I have been trying and trying to get my lens to have ring flare beyond the f/1.5 aperture, and it just wont do it, neither on the Sony or the Leica.
Oddly enough. I am actually liking the ring flare ability when using the Sony with EVF. It allows very precise manipulation and placement of it, and I already have some ring flare emitting out of a light source and enveloping the top star of a Christmas tree that looks really cool. Considering it disappears by f/1.5, I can actually see why some at 7Artisans thought this was cool and decided to leave it there. Tweaking the aperture slightly almost acts as a switch between ‘ring flare on’ and ‘ring flare off’. ...Show more →
I haven't added a UV filter, I'm just slipping it on until I feel a good amount of resistance. I've got a couple of hood and cap combinations coming to try out on it, so hopefully one of those will make it a non-issue.
I concur the ring flare goes away stopped down, but there's still a "normal" flare to it that doesn't go away when stopped down (probably not an issue with streetlights). I was testing with the sun directly in the frame at different locations and then again with the sun reflecting off buildings. So far, this is looking like money well spent.
I received a message today from Hammish at 35mmc UK Regards the non-flare version of the lens being released apparently imminently.
Message below:
I have today had solid news from 7Artisans that they are going to replace the current version of the 28mm 1.4 m-mount lens with a version that does not flare (or suffer from internal reflections to be more exact) when shot wide open.
I currently have a few of the old version with the flare in stock, and have just placed an order for the new version without the flare and am taking preorders against that delivery.
The things to take into account:
- The flare issue only happens with the lens at 1.4, stop down just passed 1.4 and the issue disappears completely. If you haven't experimented you can see my test result here
- There are only 100 of the original version in existence i.e. it's quite rare.
- If you want a version with flare, you need to decide quite quickly because they have asked me to return any unsold lenses to them, and want me to instigate the process of returning them quite soon.
- If you want the version without flare, it is a preorder and they will be with me asap (it's Christmas, so that might delay things)
—————————
So, it seems 7Artisans listened to feedback and is now releasing en mass a non-ring flare or ‘inked’ version.
I happen to have the ring flare version, and am tempted to hold onto it for. If there are only less then 100 ring flare versions out there, its possible the value of the ‘ring flare versions’ of the lens to increase? I also don’t mind stoping down to f/1.5 to simply make the ring flare go away either if needed.