fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2018 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2018Alt forum Nikon Z resource, discussion and image thread

  
 
mawz
Offline
Details
p.5 #1Alt forum Nikon Z resource, discussion and image thread
A few thoughts from the perspective of an Alt user who shoots primarily Nikon AI lenses on an A7II.

The Z6 seems a clear win in terms of EVF, getting the better EVF that the A7III lacks. The Z7 does not net this advantage, Overall ergonomics look better for the Nikons, especially the human-sized buttons (Sony really needs to drop the NEX-5-sized buttons now that they're selling larger bodies).

One thing many have forgotten is it appears Nikon has retained their Non-CPU lens data interface. this stores up to 9 lenses, with aperture & focal length data. The FL is written to EXIF. This will be necessary for IBIS, and is a LOT better than Sony's current interface since you can pre-populate data and it writes to EXIF.

Be prepared for battery life to be decidedly better than CIPA. The battery used (the 7.2V, 1900mAh EN-EL15 series) is actually the largest capacity battery in the class. Nikon's either got a firmware gotcha that's causing the low CIPA numbers or needs firmware optimizations. Either way, I expect to see A7III level battery life after a couple firmware revisions.

I expect to see a mechanical-only Sony E to Z adapter by January. That will allow adaptation of CV and Loxia lenses directly, and they should work very well on the Z's.

I think that it's likely that for Alt lens purposes the Z's are poised to become favourites, with some definite but not huge advantages over the Sony mkIII's. For AF/native lens use the mkIII's are probably a bit better (and a lot better for continuous shooting).
Sep 07, 2018 at 12:58 PM
joakim
Offline
Details
p.5 #2Alt forum Nikon Z resource, discussion and image thread
Sony A7R3 is 34k SEK
Nikon D850 is 39k SEK
Nikon Z7 is 40k SEK

Sony A73 is 24k SEK
Nikon Z6 is 25k SEK
Canon R is 27k SEK
Sep 07, 2018 at 01:05 PM
ilkka_nissila
Offline
Details
p.5 #3Alt forum Nikon Z resource, discussion and image thread
mawz wrote:
The Z6 seems a clear win in terms of EVF, getting the better EVF that the A7III lacks. The Z7 does not net this advantage,



Dpreview says the Z7 EVF displays the LV image at the full resolution whereas the A7R III EVF displays a reduced resolution image for LV and full resolution only in playback.
Sep 07, 2018 at 02:17 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.5 #4Alt forum Nikon Z resource, discussion and image thread
ilkka_nissila wrote:
mawz wroteThe Z6 seems a clear win in terms of EVF, getting the better EVF that the A7III lacks. The Z7 does not net this advantage,
Dpreview says the Z7 EVF displays the LV image at the full resolution whereas the A7R III EVF displays a reduced resolution image for LV and full resolution only in playback.


But what do they mean by reduced resolution of the A7r III? Are only some of the pixels operating? That doesn't seem very likely to me. The EVF is only a certain number of pixels and it is less than the resolution of the sensor, so you have to downscale the image with all of these cameras to show it on the EVF. So none of the EVFs can show the image at full resolution. The question is how do they downscale and what does that mean for the image in the EVF. I suspect what they are saying is that Sony uses one type of downscaling for shooting (which is probably less computationally intensive) and a different type of downscaling for image preview, which is more computationally intensive, but I doubt that one is using more pixels than the other. So, they actually have the same resolution (i.e., the same number of pixels) but the way you get to that resolution is different. This probably results in a trade off so that some aspects of the viewfinder experiences are better (perhaps refresh rate) using the downscaling used for shooting, whereas other aspects of the viewfinder experience (perhaps distinctions between neighbouring pixels) is better using the downscaling for review. What exact mode of downscaling is used in each scenario and by each camera is what I would really like to know.
Sep 07, 2018 at 02:51 PM
rico
Offline
Details
p.5 #5Alt forum Nikon Z resource, discussion and image thread
zhangyue wrote:
4. Z's glass motor are weaker than f2.8E. Reviewers feel f2.8E have better tracking than 24-70S which is better than 35mmf1.8S.

First, Michael, thank you for keeping us informed via the Middle Kingdom. Re lens motors, the 24-70E is surely optimized for speed as required by pro shooters. That performance will be paid in product price and in battery drain. If the S version is engineered for cost reduction and battery life, that would be prudent on Nikon's part. I don't think we have yet seen the pro-grade Z rig, but it will probably take a big 6-cell, 11V battery and shooters will be invited to use the F-mount E lenses because, well, they don't care about the weight.

As for the the CIPA rating, the MILC versus DSLR comparo is increasingly difficult because use pattern becomes the dominant factor, not frames captured. If I avoid chimping and menu diving, my D3X can take pictures all week, 8 hrs a day, on one charge. That is particularly true if I set the meter timeout to 4sec. The big advantages of today's DSLR is instant wakeup from standby, plus I can set up my shot through the OVF for free. Conversely, I'm in a cold sweat every time I hold up my A7ii because the battery is draining second by second. Both types of camera can take thousands of frames if one mashes on the shutter release until battery expiration, but I don't work that way. Other may do so, and that is why CIPA ratings need a serious overhaul.
Sep 07, 2018 at 05:54 PM
mawz
Offline
Details
p.5 #6Alt forum Nikon Z resource, discussion and image thread
ilkka_nissila wrote:
mawz wroteThe Z6 seems a clear win in terms of EVF, getting the better EVF that the A7III lacks. The Z7 does not net this advantage,
Dpreview says the Z7 EVF displays the LV image at the full resolution whereas the A7R III EVF displays a reduced resolution image for LV and full resolution only in playback.


Until the Z7 is in the wild, the impact of that is unknown. So I won't call the Z7 EVF superior to the A7RIII right now.
Sep 07, 2018 at 11:37 PM
nikonos6
Offline
Details
p.5 #7Alt forum Nikon Z resource, discussion and image thread
zhangyue wrote:
Now, there is at least two more full review in Chinese for the Z7 along with more users review.

I will generate a few info I feel interesting.

1. Adapting 14-24mm on Z7 gave poorer performance than on D850 at corner. This is disturbing. However, most SLR lens also have poorer performance with adapter on MILC. It seems either due to sensor stack or slightly altered light path by adapter. and one report complain the FTZ adapter build quality is not upto high Nikon standard.

2. There is no backlight strip noise on Z reported here for most Sony cameras.
...Show more →

About the prices of the 3 comparable cameras in Germany in € :

Sony a7III is 2300,- €

Nikon z6 is 2450,- € for the body allone and 3050,- € for the body + the 24-70mm zoom + the FTZ adapter

Canon EOS R will be 2500,- for the body and 3500,- € for the body + 24-105 f4 EOS R zoom + adapter

The prices seem quite comparable, though the Nikon package is quite a bit cheaper than the Canon one ( mostly because of the lense I guess) and that could be in favour for Nikon, since there is no such bundle for Sony either ( combined with their very good 24-105 f4) and this would make it a much pricier package ( the sony a7III for 2300,- € + 1350,- € ( ! ) for the 24-105mm , so 3650,- € in total! ).
Sep 08, 2018 at 02:54 AM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.5 #8Alt forum Nikon Z resource, discussion and image thread
mawz wrote:
A few thoughts from the perspective of an Alt user who shoots primarily Nikon AI lenses on an A7II.

The Z6 seems a clear win in terms of EVF, getting the better EVF that the A7III lacks. The Z7 does not net this advantage, Overall ergonomics look better for the Nikons, especially the human-sized buttons (Sony really needs to drop the NEX-5-sized buttons now that they're selling larger bodies).

One thing many have forgotten is it appears Nikon has retained their Non-CPU lens data interface. this stores up to 9 lenses, with aperture & focal length data. The FL is written to
...Show more →

That's interesting about the Non-CPU lens db, Adam. I'm not familiar with this feature. Are you limited to a selection of Nikon's classic focal length/f-stop combinations, or is a fully-programable type thing? How does it handle zooms?

I think they definitely have some features that will make them great for alt lenses, but I don't see anything there that makes me long to switch from my rII's. If I wanted to pay for a better EVF, I'd go with the rIII because then I'd get the bonus of pixel shift. I don't know what having the focal length in the EXIF would do for me. It's not like it would help with manufacturer-specific auto-profiling in post, and I know my lenses well enough to be able to tell what was used by finding the unique flaws. I guess it would make it easier to pull data from the catalog, but I don't feel like I'm missing much there. Mostly, though, there's nothing there that makes me feel like the hassle and expense of waiting for then wading through the sea of adapters to find the ones that require the least shimming/flocking would be all that rewarding.

I will envy you your top plate LCD, your display switch, and your better compatibility with the bang-for-the-buck wonder that is the 200-500/5.6. Just not enough to do anything about it.
Sep 08, 2018 at 02:58 AM
zhangyue
Online
Details
p.5 #9Alt forum Nikon Z resource, discussion and image thread
mawz wrote:
ilkka_nissila wrote
mawz wroteThe Z6 seems a clear win in terms of EVF, getting the better EVF that the A7III lacks. The Z7 does not net this advantage,
Dpreview says the Z7 EVF displays the LV image at the full resolution whereas the A7R III EVF displays a reduced resolution image for LV and full resolution only in playback.
Until the Z7 is in the wild, the impact of that is unknown. So I won't call the Z7 EVF superior to the A7RIII right now.


I personal don't think there is any doubt that Z7 EVF is superior now. DPREVIEW stuff mentioned it and Multiple initial feedbacks from first hand review also confirmed it. Even there are many current MILC used this 3.69M EVF, they were not implemented the same way either in optics or electronics.

I believe the A7RIII low resolution during shooting is true based on all discuss linked in this thread from DPREVIEW discuss.
People also complained that x5 is blurred (based on low resolution version I guess) and only x10 give full resolution review during magnified shooting. (I even believe this is related to Nikon Z7 low battery rating for CIPA because of high resolution live feed EVF ).

Again, I don't know exactly how Sony implement this. However, 42M sensor only take raw data, LV implementation is like video feed that require either downsample the raw data and do the JPEG(or other picture format) feed at 60/120fps, or they just sample low resolution raw data from sensor directly and convert to JPEG feed,(most likely this way IMO) Either way, this low resolution mode will reduced process load and save battery power.

3.69M EVF at full resolution is about 1280X960 and at full 120FPS(for A7RIII spec) will give about 150M/s. It is not a light load by any means especially during shooting.

I really want to see how Canon R implement this. I also wonder about how FUJI and Leica Q&SL did this.

Edited on Sep 09, 2018 at 02:24 AM · View previous versions
Sep 09, 2018 at 01:58 AM
zhangyue
Online
Details
p.5 #10Alt forum Nikon Z resource, discussion and image thread
Latest review from Nikonrumors by Marsel Van Oosten is the best review I have read so far. He absolutely know what he is talking about. Very honest review.

The description about EVF match exactly my feeling in field especially during high contrast light shooting.


However, there was one thing that I really struggled with: the EVF brightness. When you look through the viewfinder of a DSLR, you see the scene at the same brightness as with your bare eye. With an EVF that's different because you're basically looking at a miniature Live View monitor, and you need to set the brightness level for that yourself. Several times I found myself being fooled by the brightness of the EVF, tricking me into thinking that I shot a nice and bright image with tons of shadow detail, whereas in reality the image was actually horribly underexposed. While
...Show more →

He also talked about EVF during night shooting here.
Overall, I found that the EVF was the only challenge when shooting at night. Our eyes are so amazing at picking up the tiniest details in the landscape even during new moon, there is no EVF that can match that. When using a regular viewfinder, once you're eyes are used to the darkness you will be able to see the landscape even when the only light source is the stars. I usually switch off the camera so that I don't get blinded by the bright numbers inside the viewfinder, and then fine-tune my composition. With an EVF this is not possible,...Show more →

One possibility is he stand the same perspective as a DSLR user (me the same). So preference of OVF during shooting is understandable. However, it is clear EVF is superior at certain condition as well in his review and I agree.

Looks like even superior Z EVF will not solve the problem I had. I can safely predict for myself for foreseeable future, EVF based system will not replace OVF, at least for me.
Sep 09, 2018 at 02:22 AM
charles.K
Offline
Details
p.5 #11Alt forum Nikon Z resource, discussion and image thread
zhangyue wrote:
Latest review from Nikonrumors by Marsel Van Oosten is the best review I have read so far. He absolutely know what he is talking about. Very honest review.

The description about EVF match exactly my feeling in field especially during high contrast light shooting.

Earlier quoteHowever, there was one thing that I really struggled with: the EVF brightness. When you look through the viewfinder of a DSLR, you see the scene at the same brightness as with your bare eye. With an EVF that's different because you're basically looking at a miniature Live View monitor, and you need to set the brightness level for that yourself. Several times I found myself being fooled by the brightness of the EVF, tricking me into thinking that I shot a nice and bright image with tons of shadow detail, whereas in reality the image was actually horribly underexposed. While it is true that one look at the histogram would tell me this, in the heat of the moment that sometimes did not compute. An overly dark scene like the one above will easily look well exposed in the EVF, but later turn out to be way too dark. There have been moments where I was looking at the image in the viewfinder and then to the histogram next to it, and realized those did not seem to belong together - the image looked so much brighter than what it should look like according to the histogram. At first, I started to change the brightness level of the EVF to match what I was seeing, but that didn't prove to be a definitive solution either. I ended up more or less ignoring the brightness level of the image in the EVF and only use it for composition, light direction, focus, depth of field, and instead relying on the histogram for exposure. Overall, I would say the default setting of the EVF is too bright.

Read more: https://nikonrumors.com/2018/09/07/nikon-z7-field-report-by-marsel-van-oosten.aspx/#ixzz5QaeqF3yy
He also talked about EVF during night shooting here.
Earlier quoteOverall, I found that the EVF was the only challenge when shooting at night. Our eyes are so amazing at picking up the tiniest details in the landscape even during new moon, there is no EVF that can match that. When using a regular viewfinder, once you're eyes are used to the darkness you will be able to see the landscape even when the only light source is the stars. I usually switch off the camera so that I don't get blinded by the bright numbers inside the viewfinder, and then fine-tune my composition. With an EVF this is not possible, after all: it's an illuminated micro monitor. In total darkness it will always be too bright, and it will never be able to show the amount of detail that your eyes can see at night. This is not a shortcoming of just the Z7, but a general phenomenon for all mirrorless cameras. When you look through the EVF on a really dark night, it's hard to see what you're doing.

Read more: https://nikonrumors.com/2018/09/07/nikon-z7-field-report-by-marsel-van-oosten.aspx/#ixzz5Qag2WXbi
One possibility is he stand the same perspective as a DSLR user (me the same). So preference of OVF during shooting is understandable. However, it is clear EVF is superior at certain condition as well in his review and I agree.

Looks like even superior Z
...Show more →

I have the same perspective regarding the OVF and EVF's. I am equally comfortable with both if I need to and I do prefer EVF for videos. I am now doing more videos clips so this is where I see the Z7 or Z6 will be ideal alongside the D850
Sep 09, 2018 at 04:25 AM
joakim
Offline
Details
p.5 #12Alt forum Nikon Z resource, discussion and image thread
I enjoyed reading the review by van Oosten as well, not sure how objective it was but a good read anyway.

I guess there are some shortcomings of an EVF that we will not get pass for a long time but I hope and believe that aside from those that this EVF will be very good, going by own brief experience with the camera but also from what I have read so far. I am really looking forward to this camera now and fingers crossed that it will be delivered as promised at the end of this month.
Sep 09, 2018 at 08:50 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.5 #13Alt forum Nikon Z resource, discussion and image thread
zhangyue wrote:
mawz wrote
ilkka_nissila wrote
mawz wroteThe Z6 seems a clear win in terms of EVF, getting the better EVF that the A7III lacks. The Z7 does not net this advantage,
Dpreview says the Z7 EVF displays the LV image at the full resolution whereas the A7R III EVF displays a reduced resolution image for LV and full resolution only in playback.
Until the Z7 is in the wild, the impact of that is unknown. So I won't call the Z7 EVF superior to the A7RIII right now.
I personal don't think there is any doubt that Z7 EVF is superior now. DPREVIEW stuff mentioned it and Multiple initial feedbacks from first hand review also confirmed it. Even there are many current MILC used this 3.69M EVF, they were not implemented the same way either in optics or electronics.

I believe the A7RIII low resolution during shooting is true based on all discuss linked in this thread from DPREVIEW discuss.
People also complained that x5 is blurred (based on low resolution version I guess) and only x10 give full resolution review during magnified shooting. (I even believe this
...Show more →

But Michael, I think you are mixing up full resolution here in your discussion. The way the Sony EVFs all work is that you can get the full resolution of the sensor read out at the highest level of magnification. In use, the highest level of magnification is thus an excellent representation of what the 100% view will look like on the computer after the shot is taken. If you think about it 3.69 MP is of course way too few to project the whole image of any mirrorless camera without downscaling, but if you only present a small part of the image (as when you magnify) then 3.69 MP is enough to present it at the full resolution of the sensor. So, with Sony's what you get is when shooting one type of downscaling, when doing the mid-level magnification a second sort of downscaling, and at full magnification you get the full resolution of the sensor. Because with full magnification you get the full resolution of the sensor I think we can rule out that they sample low resolution data to convert to JPEG, because they have full sensor resolution at full magnification. One thing that is definitely true about the existing Sony models is that the downscaling especially at moderate magnification does not always result in the same quality of image. Sometimes this downscaling clearly works better than others. For example, I think the A9 moderate magnification works a lot better than my Sony A7r II.

Now what does this mean for the Nikon Z7? First we know that you can not present a 45MP image at full resolution onto a 3.69MP EVF, so whatever people are saying at DPreview, the Z7 will not be presenting the full resolution of the sensor onto the EVF when in shooting mode. Neither will they be doing so at moderate levels of magnification. I do hope they have a mode where at the highest levels of magnification they will be presenting the full resolution of the sensor, like Sony does, and I expect they will have that sort of magnification.

The question that remains is how good is the video feed between the Sony A7r III and the Nikon Z7 in shooting mode and at moderate levels of magnification. This will be determined by at least two major factors. The way each company does the downscaling that they will both do, and how good are the optics in the EVF. We don't know anything about how that comparison will come out and this talk about the Nikon Z7 presents the image at full resolution and the Sony doesn't is not helpful. What may (and I stress may be the case) is the Nikon downscales the sensor image to 3.69 MP whereas Sony downscales to some multiple of 3.69 MP (say 1.845MP) and doubles the images to fill the EVF. That would mean that the Nikon present the shooting image at full resolution of the EVF (but certainly not full resolution of the sensor) and the Sony only presents the image at (half resolution of the EVF and is doubling the image in the EVF). I think that is highly unlikely, however, I think what is much more likely is that both Nikon and Sony downscale the data from the sensor to 3.69 MP and they just do so in different ways. Now the Nikon might present a clearer image in this downscaling but that might not be the case either. The Sony could even be better. Until the cameras are available we just can't know and we can't even compare specs unless the companies start to give specs on how they downscale and what exactly they use as the video feed to their EVF. And even if one company (say Nikon) chooses a video downscaling that emphasizes clearer resolution, that choice will come with tradeoffs. Such a downscaling will likely mean more lag between shots and perhaps a lower refresh rate. Some might prefer the downscaling that emphasizes resolution of the image and some might very well prefer the smoother rendering and short black out of a different downscaling approach that does not emphasize resolution so much but that allows a faster refresh rate and a shorter blackout. Of course the optics in the viewfinders are going to affect the apparent resolution of each viewfinder as well.

So, IMO, this talk about the Nikon Z7 being at full resolution and the Sony A7r III not being at full resolution is just way more confusing than it is helpful. First, it has to be completely wrong if we are talking about full resolution of the sensor. Second, it is likely (and I think very likely wrong) if we are talking about full resolution of the EVF. Third, what really matters is how the downscaling was done and what tradeoffs that requires and how good the optics are in the EVF. In short what does the image look like in the EVF and that we will know soon enough when the cameras can be compared side by side. The Nikon Z7 may well have superior optics, but I am not sure of that. I am pretty sure that whatever is done with the downscaling, however, will have tradeoffs. My best guess right now is that the Nikon Z7 will have downscaling that makes the image look sharper, but that will come at the cost of a lower refresh rate and a longer black out time between images than the Sony A7r III. Now is that a superior viewfinder? To some people it would be--in fact it would be for me--but I think there are lots of people that would prefer the Sony approach--and Michael I would not be surprised if that were you because you hate blackout between images. So, I think it will ultimately be more useful to talk about the tradeoffs in the viewfinder between Sony and Nikon and less useful to talk simply about one being superior and the other inferior.
Sep 09, 2018 at 12:13 PM
zhangyue
Online
Details
p.5 #14Alt forum Nikon Z resource, discussion and image thread
My resolution about EVF meant full 3.69M dot or 1280X960 of course. There is no way 1.23M screen represent full 42/45M files unless show a crop.

My take is Sony sampled at even less than 1.23M during shooting. Only At X10, it use its full 1.23M resolution to represent part of 42M file. And at video shooting it use its full 1.23M downsampled resolution.

Since I don’t have first hand experience for both and don’t really know what is the difference and how they each get handled. I can only guess. maybe both don’t use full 1.23M resolution, Nikon use half and Sony use quarter or Nikon is full and Sony use half or could be both use quarter or half or full resolution but just Nikon has bettter dowmsample algorithm.

However, the initial feedback is clear there is difference during shooting. For now, I can only share this based on people who handled both.

My purpose is not spec game between two, the only hope is EVF with more resolution and clarity will help me shoot manual glass WO without focus aid such peaking and magnification that I don’t enjoy during daily family images.

Steve Spencer wrote:
zhangyue wrote
mawz wrote
ilkka_nissila wrote
mawz wroteThe Z6 seems a clear win in terms of EVF, getting the better EVF that the A7III lacks. The Z7 does not net this advantage,
Dpreview says the Z7 EVF displays the LV image at the full resolution whereas the A7R III EVF displays a reduced resolution image for LV and full resolution only in playback.
Until the Z7 is in the wild, the impact of that is unknown. So I won't call the Z7 EVF superior to the A7RIII right now.
I personal don't think there is any doubt that Z7 EVF is superior now. DPREVIEW stuff mentioned it and Multiple initial feedbacks from first hand review also confirmed it. Even there are many current MILC used this 3.69M EVF, they were not implemented the same way either in optics or electronics.

I believe the A7RIII low resolution during shooting is true based on all discuss linked in this thread from DPREVIEW discuss.
People also complained that x5 is blurred (based on low resolution version I guess) and only x10 give full resolution review during magnified shooting. (I even believe this is related to Nikon Z7 low battery rating for CIPA because of high resolution live feed EVF ).

Again, I don't know exactly how Sony implement this. However, 42M sensor only take raw data, LV implementation is like video feed that require either downsample the raw data and do the JPEG(or other picture format) feed at 60/120fps, or they just sample low resolution raw data from sensor directly and convert to JPEG feed,(most likely this way IMO) Either way, this low resolution mode will reduced process load and save battery power.

3.69M EVF at full resolution is about 1280X960 and at full 120FPS(for A7RIII spec) will give about 150M/s. It is not a light load by any means especially during shooting.

I really want to see how Canon R implement this. I also wonder about how FUJI and Leica Q&SL did this.
But Michael, I think you are mixing up full resolution here in your discussion. The way the Sony EVFs all work is that the information from the sensor to present it isn the EVF, but you can get the full resolution of the sensor real out at the highest level of magnification. In use the highest level of magnification is thus an excellent representation of what the 100% view will look like on the computer after the shot is taken. If you think about it 3.69 MP is of course way too few to project the whole image of
...Show more →
Sep 09, 2018 at 12:30 PM
zhangyue
Online
Details
p.5 #15Alt forum Nikon Z resource, discussion and image thread
Another thought, Steve, since you have A9 on hand. Maybe you can take a look. Put camera on tripod, use iPhone take a image (through EVF hole) for both EVF reprent the scene, one before shooting, one for image review and compare yourself for image resolution and clarity.

I can do the same later once I have the Z.
Sep 09, 2018 at 12:42 PM
zhangyue
Online
Details
p.5 #16Alt forum Nikon Z resource, discussion and image thread
About delay and blackout. I do have high interest about comparison between the two. Though if the difference are stem from this EVF shooting resolution is hard to verify.

My hope is there is some inside info can be revealed from expert who know the matter better. Or hopefully late I can collect more information and update here.

In the mean time, I agree if blackout and delay is bad enough I may just sell the Z. It is a total package matters that I am willing to take some trade off if it is really excel at others.

I have to handle it than read review from others or compare spec sheet.


Steve Spencer wrote:
zhangyue wrote
mawz wrote
ilkka_nissila wrote
mawz wroteThe Z6 seems a clear win in terms of EVF, getting the better EVF that the A7III lacks. The Z7 does not net this advantage,
Dpreview says the Z7 EVF displays the LV image at the full resolution whereas the A7R III EVF displays a reduced resolution image for LV and full resolution only in playback.
Until the Z7 is in the wild, the impact of that is unknown. So I won't call the Z7 EVF superior to the A7RIII right now.
I personal don't think there is any doubt that Z7 EVF is superior now. DPREVIEW stuff mentioned it and Multiple initial feedbacks from first hand review also confirmed it. Even there are many current MILC used this 3.69M EVF, they were not implemented the same way either in optics or electronics.

I believe the A7RIII low resolution during shooting is true based on all discuss linked in this thread from DPREVIEW discuss.
People also complained that x5 is blurred (based on low resolution version I guess) and only x10 give full resolution review during magnified shooting. (I even believe this is related to Nikon Z7 low battery rating for CIPA because of high resolution live feed EVF ).

Again, I don't know exactly how Sony implement this. However, 42M sensor only take raw data, LV implementation is like video feed that require either downsample the raw data and do the JPEG(or other picture format) feed at 60/120fps, or they just sample low resolution raw data from sensor directly and convert to JPEG feed,(most likely this way IMO) Either way, this low resolution mode will reduced process load and save battery power.

3.69M EVF at full resolution is about 1280X960 and at full 120FPS(for A7RIII spec) will give about 150M/s. It is not a light load by any means especially during shooting.

I really want to see how Canon R implement this. I also wonder about how FUJI and Leica Q&SL did this.
But Michael, I think you are mixing up full resolution here in your discussion. The way the Sony EVFs all work is that you can get the full resolution of the sensor read out at the highest level of magnification. In use, the highest level of magnification is thus an excellent representation of what the 100% view will look like on the computer after the shot is taken. If you think about it 3.69 MP is of course way too few to project the whole image of any mirrorless camera without downscaling, but if you only present a small
...Show more →
Sep 09, 2018 at 12:59 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.5 #17Alt forum Nikon Z resource, discussion and image thread
zhangyue wrote:
Another thought, Steve, since you have A9 on hand. Maybe you can take a look. Put camera on tripod, use iPhone take a image (through EVF hole) for both EVF reprent the scene, one before shooting, one for image review and compare yourself for image resolution and clarity.

I can do the same later once I have the Z.


That is what people are doing to talk about full resolution or not? Pretty awful test, IMO. The obvious problem is that a faster refresh rate could look like a blurrier image because of motion blur. I don't see much point in doing this test unless you can get the shutter speed up to at least 1/500, which isn't really something you can do with an iPhone.
Sep 09, 2018 at 01:23 PM
zhangyue
Online
Details
p.5 #18Alt forum Nikon Z resource, discussion and image thread
I don’t follow the logic. Both case have the same refresh rate either image review or EVF review during shooting.
You still get apple to apple comparison that most people complain about the resolution difference.
The experiment suggested by me only. Nobody did anything other than they DO SEE THE DIFFERENCE by anyone handle both camera the same time.

Why iPhone is a problem? It is only 1.23M real resolution JPG thumbnail.

BTW, Sony default 60fps. At 120fps there were some other limitation mentioned I don’t remember. I’d suggest use 60fps only as I see no reason 120fps will give preferred results for this test.

No worry, I can test this later myself.

Steve Spencer wrote:
zhangyue wroteAnother thought, Steve, since you have A9 on hand. Maybe you can take a look. Put camera on tripod, use iPhone take a image (through EVF hole) for both EVF reprent the scene, one before shooting, one for image review and compare yourself for image resolution and clarity.

I can do the same later once I have the Z.
That is what people are doing to talk about full resolution or not? Pretty awful test, IMO. The obvious problem is that a faster refresh rate could look like a blurrier image because of motion blur. I don't see much point in doing this test unless you can get the shutter speed up to at least 1/500, which isn't really something you can do with an iPhone.

Sep 09, 2018 at 01:37 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.5 #19Alt forum Nikon Z resource, discussion and image thread
zhangyue wrote:
About delay and blackout. I do have high interest about comparison between the two. Though if the difference are stem from this EVF shooting resolution is hard to verify.

My hope is there is some inside info can be revealed from expert who know the matter better. Or hopefully late I can collect more information and update here.

In the mean time, I agree if blackout and delay is bad enough I may just sell the Z. It is a total package matters that I am willing to take some trade off if it is really excel at others.

I
...Show more →
Steve Spencer wrote
zhangyue wrote
mawz wrote
ilkka_nissila wrote
mawz wroteThe Z6 seems a clear win in terms of EVF, getting the better EVF that the A7III lacks. The Z7 does not net this advantage,
Dpreview says the Z7 EVF displays the LV image at the full resolution whereas the A7R III EVF displays a reduced resolution image for LV and full resolution only in playback.
Until the Z7 is in the wild, the impact of that is unknown. So I won't call the Z7 EVF superior to the A7RIII right now.
I personal don't think there is any doubt that Z7 EVF is superior now. DPREVIEW stuff mentioned it and Multiple initial feedbacks from first hand review also confirmed it. Even there are many current MILC used this 3.69M EVF, they were not implemented the same way either in optics or electronics.

I believe the A7RIII low resolution during shooting is true based on all discuss linked in this thread from DPREVIEW discuss.
People also complained that x5 is blurred (based on low resolution version I guess) and only x10 give full resolution review during magnified shooting. (I even believe this is related to Nikon Z7 low battery rating for CIPA because of high resolution live feed EVF ).

Again, I don't know exactly how Sony implement this. However, 42M sensor only take raw data, LV implementation is like video feed that require either downsample the raw data and do the JPEG(or other picture format) feed at 60/120fps, or they just sample low resolution raw data from sensor directly and convert to JPEG feed,(most likely this way IMO) Either way, this low resolution mode will reduced process load and save battery power.

3.69M EVF at full resolution is about 1280X960 and at full 120FPS(for A7RIII spec) will give about 150M/s. It is not a light load by any means especially during shooting.

I really want to see how Canon R implement this. I also wonder about how FUJI and Leica Q&SL did this.
But Michael, I think you are mixing up full resolution here in your discussion. The way the Sony EVFs all work is that you can get the full resolution of the sensor read out at the highest level of magnification. In use, the highest level of magnification is thus an excellent representation of what the 100% view will look like on the computer after the shot is taken. If you think about it 3.69 MP is of course way too few to project the whole image of any mirrorless camera without downscaling, but if you only present a small part of the image (as when you magnify) then 3.69 MP is enough to present it at the full resolution of the sensor. So, with Sony's what you get is when shooting one type of downscaling, when doing the mid-level magnification a second sort of downscaling, and at full magnification you get the full resolution of the sensor. Because with full magnification you get the full resolution of the sensor I think we can rule out that they sample low resolution data to convert to JPEG, because they have full sensor resolution at full magnification. One thing that is definitely true about the existing Sony models is that the downscaling especially at moderate magnification does not always result in the same quality of image. Sometimes this downscaling clearly works better than others. For example, I think the A9 moderate magnification works a lot better than my Sony A7r II.

Now what does this mean for the Nikon Z7? First we know that you can not present a 45MP image at full resolution onto a 3.69MP EVF, so whatever people are saying at DPreview, the Z7 will not be presenting the full resolution of the sensor onto the EVF when in shooting mode. Neither will they be doing so at moderate levels of magnification. I do hope they have a mode where at the highest levels of magnification they will be presenting the full resolution of the sensor, like Sony does, and I expect they will have that sort of magnification.

The question that remains is how good is the video feed between the Sony A7r III and the Nikon Z7 in shooting mode and at moderate levels of magnification. This will be determined by at least two major factors. The way each company does the downscaling that they will both do, and how good are the optics in the EVF. We don't know anything about how that comparison will come out and this talk about the Nikon Z7 presents the image at full resolution and the Sony doesn't is not helpful. What may (and I stress may be the case) is the Nikon downscales the sensor image to 3.69 MP whereas Sony downscales to some multiple of 3.69 MP (say 1.845MP) and doubles the images to fill the EVF. That would mean that the Nikon present the shooting image at full resolution of the EVF (but certainly not full resolution of the sensor) and the Sony only presents the image at (half resolution of the EVF and is doubling the image in the EVF). I think that is highly unlikely, however, I think what is much more likely is that both Nikon and Sony downscale the data from the sensor to 3.69 MP and they just do so in different ways. Now the Nikon might present a clearer image in this downscaling but that might not be the case either. The Sony could even be better. Until the cameras are available we just can't know and we can't even compare specs unless the companies start to give specs on how they downscale and what exactly they use as the video feed to their EVF. And even if one company (say Nikon) chooses a video downscaling that emphasizes clearer resolution, that choice will come with tradeoffs. Such a downscaling will likely mean more lag between shots and perhaps a lower refresh rate. Some might prefer the downscaling that emphasizes resolution of the image and some might very well prefer the smoother rendering and short black out of a different downscaling approach that does not emphasize resolution so much but that allows a faster refresh rate and a shorter blackout. Of course the optics in the viewfinders are going to affect the apparent resolution of each viewfinder as well.

So, IMO, this talk about the Nikon Z7 being at full resolution and the Sony A7r III not being at full resolution is just way more confusing than it is helpful. First, it has to be completely wrong if we are talking about full resolution of the sensor. Second, it is likely (and I think very likely wrong) if we are talking about full resolution of the EVF. Third, what really matters is how the downscaling was done and what tradeoffs that requires and how good the optics are in the EVF. In short what does the image look like in the EVF and that we will know soon enough when the cameras can be compared side by side. The Nikon Z7 may well have superior optics, but I am not sure of that. I am pretty sure that whatever is done with the downscaling, however, will have tradeoffs. My best guess right now is that the Nikon Z7 will have downscaling that makes the image look sharper, but that will come at the cost of a lower refresh rate and a longer black out time between images than the Sony A7r III. Now is that a superior viewfinder? To some people it would be--in fact it would be for me--but I think there are lots of people that would prefer the Sony approach--and Michael I would not be surprised if that were you because you hate blackout between images. So, I think it will ultimately be more useful to talk about the tradeoffs in the viewfinder between Sony and Nikon and less useful to talk simply about one being superior and the other inferior.


Michael,

I think you probably know but Jim Kasson is planning a thorough review of the Z7 as soon as he can get one. I suspect after his review we will know exactly how the Z7 EVF works compared to the Sony A7r III, so really it is only a couple of more months to wait. I am sure he will give us detailed information about black out, refresh rate, and sensor read out, and no doubt some good ideas about resolution as well.
Sep 09, 2018 at 01:46 PM
pookipichu
Offline
Details
p.5 #20Alt forum Nikon Z resource, discussion and image thread
Do you all think we'll see lens adapters with EOS R style drop in filter slot?
Sep 10, 2018 at 01:03 PM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister