p.5 #1Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar
NRKStudio wrote: RexGig0 wroteDesmolicious wroteOf note, I always find it entertaining how we keep these threads going long after the OP has made his decision and checked out!Well, the additional discussion can benefit others, such as moi.
I would like to add a second M-mount 50mm lens, for the times I shoot my M10 and Monochrom together, to shoot relatively equivalent images I can later compare. I can already do this with a 35mm Leica Summaron-M and a Zeiss 1,4/35mm Distagon ZM.
I had known, from several years of internetting, that I loved ‘Lux 50mm images, and actually decided upon a particular pre-owned Summilux-M 50mm ASPH E46 before I knew which body I would become my first M-mount camera. In a perfect world, I would simply buy a second ‘Lux 50mm ASPH, perhaps a Black Chrome E43, for “apples-to-apples” comparison, plus another Fifty for a different rendering, but I live in a world where money matters. (Of course, I realize that having more than one Leica-M camera is, itself, a very “First World problem.”)A little off topic, but when you compare the 35 Summaron to the 35/1.4 ZM, isn’t the Zeiss just worlds apart? I have a 35ZM and love it. It has the most severe transition from focus to OOF that just makes a subject pop. Really does make me a believer of the Zeiss 3D pop people talk about. Also, according to some testing and my use, it’s one of the sharpest M lenses out there.
Yes, indeed, worlds apart, the only thing these two Thirty-Fives have, in common, is angle-of-view. I have only just started using my Zeiss Distagon 1,4/35mm ZM, but the different “signature” is readily apparent. Neither, of course, is anything like my Summilux 50mm ASPH.
p.5 #2Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar
NRKStudio wrote: RexGig0 wroteDesmolicious wroteOf note, I always find it entertaining how we keep these threads going long after the OP has made his decision and checked out!Well, the additional discussion can benefit others, such as moi.
I would like to add a second M-mount 50mm lens, for the times I shoot my M10 and Monochrom together, to shoot relatively equivalent images I can later compare. I can already do this with a 35mm Leica Summaron-M and a Zeiss 1,4/35mm Distagon ZM.
I had known, from several years of internetting, that I loved ‘Lux 50mm images, and actually decided upon a particular pre-owned Summilux-M 50mm ASPH E46 before I knew which body I would become my first M-mount camera. In a perfect world, I would simply buy a second ‘Lux 50mm ASPH, perhaps a Black Chrome E43, for “apples-to-apples” comparison, plus another Fifty for a different rendering, but I live in a world where money matters. (Of course, I realize that having more than one Leica-M camera is, itself, a very “First World problem.”)A little off topic, but when you compare the 35 Summaron to the 35/1.4 ZM, isn’t the Zeiss just worlds apart? I have a 35ZM and love it. It has the most severe transition from focus to OOF that just makes a subject pop. Really does make me a believer of the Zeiss 3D pop people talk about. Also, according to some testing and my use, it’s one of the sharpest M lenses out there.
To add a bit more, my Zeiss 1,4/35mm ZM Distagon is challenging my Summilux-M 50mm ASPH for the title of “favorite,” not because I like the ‘Lux less, but because 35mm has become my more-used focal length, and the Distagon is, indeed, so very sharp and contrasty. (Yes, I just learned that “contrasty” is a word, as spell-check did not get itself exercised. )
Realistically, my ‘Lux, being my first M-system lens, the gateway lens that drew me into the Leica-M system, before I had decided which M camera to buy, will always be a favorite, but I already had a prior relationship with Zeiss 2/135mm APO Sonnar and 1,4/85mm Otus SLR lenses, plus, much more recently, 4,5/21mm and 4/85mm ZM lenses, so I do not see ZM lenses as settling for a lesser/cheaper alternative, though the less-expensive part is much-appreciated.