fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2018 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2018Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar

  
 
petermendelson
Offline

p.1 #1Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar
I am trying to decide between these two lenses for the M10. I used to have the 50mm Summilux ASPH and loved it, but now I am thinking about the Zeiss for its much cheaper price and reputation for great color and 3D pop. Focus shift should NOT be an issue for me since I will use the Visoflex EVF to focus. I assume the Summilux will be a bit more clinically perfect, especially wide open, but I am intrigued by the characteristics that are attributed to the Sonnar.

I shoot a wide range of subjects, mostly travel and street and casual use at friends' events, etc. (By the way, I also just got a used 35mm Summicron ASPH as my other main daily shooting lens for the M10).

I'd love to hear people's experiences and thoughts, especially if they have used both lenses.

Thanks!

Peter
Apr 08, 2018 at 05:04 PM
RickOptic
Offline
Details
p.1 #2Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar
I don't have the Sonnar. I can recommend the Summilux. Thought by many to still be the best 50mm lens made. All around, I believe the Summilux is the best when all aspects of lens performance are considered. Compared to the Sonnar the Summilux is much sharper across the field, about twice as sharp or more.

Not sure what you mean by clinical. I guess I've always thought the Summilux had a beautiful rendering and creamy bokeh with great color. Maybe you could comment on what clinical means?

Hope this helps.
Apr 08, 2018 at 06:53 PM
petermendelson
Offline
Details
p.1 #3Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar
I agree - I think clinical was the wrong word. Maybe it’s more neutral than the Sonnar? I love the Summilux rendering.
Apr 08, 2018 at 07:49 PM
RickOptic
Offline
Details
p.1 #4Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar
Here a couple of articles from Ken Rockwell. He gets some things wrong but I get a kick out of reading him. He had a 4 year old rental with unequal edge sharpness but, he went ahead and reviewed the Summilux anyway. The Summilux is sharper than the Summicron. But, fun reads:

https://www.kenrockwell.com/zeiss/zm/50mm-f15.htm

https://kenrockwell.com/leica/50mm-f14-asph.htm

And, here is Roger from Lens Rentals. Read this one first:

https://www.imaging-resource.com/news/2014/06/05/which-50mm-lens-is-the-best-lensrentals-roger-cicala-set-out-to-answer-this
Apr 08, 2018 at 09:06 PM
petermendelson
Offline
Details
p.1 #5Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar
Thanks Rick. Wow according to that Lens Rental review the Sonnar's MTF is quite bad. But I know many people are happy using it. I think if I shot people more often I might try the Sonnar, but I more often shoot travel, architecture, still lifes, etc so for my purposes I am going to go for the Summilux, especially since I loved it when I used to have it (now which of my Sony/Canon lenses do I sell to help pay for it? .
Apr 09, 2018 at 05:46 AM
karambol
Offline
Details
p.1 #6Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar
Since I bought Lux asph, I simply do not remove it from the camera.

I've used minilta 50/1.4, Rokkor 58/1.2, Leica-R 50/2, Zony 50/1.8, Nokton 50/1.5 and few others.

For me Lux - simply the best 50mm ever!
Apr 09, 2018 at 05:59 AM
expwmbat
Offline
Details
p.1 #7Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar
petermendelson wrote:
Thanks Rick. Wow according to that Lens Rental review the Sonnar's MTF is quite bad. But I know many people are happy using it. I think if I shot people more often I might try the Sonnar, but I more often shoot travel, architecture, still lifes, etc so for my purposes I am going to go for the Summilux, especially since I loved it when I used to have it (now which of my Sony/Canon lenses do I sell to help pay for it? .


You have to remember--these are comparisons of individual lenses, so any copy variation is overlooked. I haven't used the Summilux, but I am on my second copy of the Sonnar, and it is considerably sharper at all apertures than my first one. I'm sure the 'lux is sharper overall, but my Sonnar works great for the kinds of photos you mention, and excels at images of people. Still, I'd be surprised if many preferred the Sonnar as an all-arounder.

Why not rent copies of each to see what you think?

Cheers,
Daniel
Apr 09, 2018 at 06:03 AM
Desmolicious
Offline
Details
p.1 #8Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar
I have both. If you can afford the Lux, get the Lux. If you are looking for 3D pop, the Lux has more of it.
I also have the Planar, and honestly that is much closer to the Lux than the Sonnar. It is a fantastic lens and to me is a better choice than the Sonnar if you are comparing against the Lux.
If you like to shoot into the sun, both Zeiss lenses are better than the Leica, as their coatings are far more effective.

If you want character, get the 7Artisans 50 1.1. I prefer it to my Sonnar. It is also about 1/4 of the price.
You can get the 7A, and the Planar for less than the Sonnar...
Apr 09, 2018 at 08:36 AM
petermendelson
Offline
Details
p.1 #9Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar
Thanks everyone for the helpful replies. I decided to go all in on the Summilux - I know I will have no regrets...
Apr 09, 2018 at 01:49 PM
bushwacker
Offline
Details
p.1 #10Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar
Peter,

Man why are you giving me ideas spending more money, posting thread like this.? Lol. Just posted another similar thread involving 50 c sonnar vs 50 planar on a7 body. Now the summilux clearly out of reach.
Apr 10, 2018 at 06:31 AM
Tmuussoni
Offline
Details
p.1 #11Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar
I see you already made up your mind. I just wanted to post these two links to help make up your mind. Images taken with both of these lenses.

https://www.flickr.com/groups/summilux50asph/pool/

https://www.flickr.com/groups/zeissikon50mm-c/pool/

Both lenses have their advantages and disadvantages. ZM Sonnar 50 is one of the nicest 50mm portrait lenses ever, imo. And yes, its bokeh is even better than that of the Summilux-M 50 ASPH and it has amazing character. Sonnar shines in black and white. Imho. That said, the wonderful thing about Summilux-M 50 ASPH is the fact it comes damn close in terms of bokeh, despite being an aspherical design. ASPH obviously brings lots of other goodies to the table, which the Sonnar 50/1.5 does not have: much sharper especially wide open, less aberrations, more even sharpness across the frame. If I had to pick only one 50mm lens: Summilux-50 ASPH would be my choice. If I would have infinite money: Sonnar 50/1.5 for portraits and Apo-Summicron 50/2 as general purpose lens . Obviously there is no such thing as a perfect lens, so Lux 50 ASPH has also its faults, such as price and that slightly annoying mid zone dip in sharpness (also quite visible in Leica's MTF charts). It can be visible in some landscape shots.

Edited on Apr 12, 2018 at 09:19 AM · View previous versions
Apr 10, 2018 at 09:36 AM
rico
Online
Details
p.1 #12Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar
The 'Lux pre-ASPH aka ver 2 is another contender for less money. It was unchanged in design for 40 years which should say something about its rep.
Apr 10, 2018 at 04:22 PM
Humble_Glory
Offline
Details
p.1 #13Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar
There is another lens worth considering: Nikkor S 50 1.4 'Millennium', sharpness is comparable to 50 lux but cheaper, lighter and has character.

petermendelson wrote:
Thanks everyone for the helpful replies. I decided to go all in on the Summilux - I know I will have no regrets...

Apr 10, 2018 at 04:30 PM
petermendelson
Offline
Details
p.1 #14Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar
Thanks. When you look at the Flikr galleries for both lenses, the 3D pop of the Summilux really comes through - there's something about the way it can isolate subjects from the environment that I love. I did order a used Summilux ASPH and can't wait to start using it again (this time I hope to hold onto it for many, many years). My Sony gear is going to be very lonely for a while...
Apr 10, 2018 at 04:39 PM
bushwacker
Offline
Details
p.1 #15Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar
Does the 50 summilux have focus shift?
Apr 12, 2018 at 05:55 AM
expwmbat
Offline
Details
p.1 #16Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar
bushwacker wrote:
Does the 50 summilux have focus shift?


I believe the report is that at least one of the earlier versions does. However, focus shift is irrelevant unless a) you are using a rangefinder, or b) you focus prior to stopping down (something that is unnecessary on the A7).

DJK
Apr 12, 2018 at 07:25 AM
petermendelson
Offline
Details
p.1 #17Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar
I don’t know about focus shift on the 50mm Summilux . I’ll be using the Visoflex evf a lot so in those situations it won’t matter. I haven’t heard about focus shift being a real issue in this lens, unlike others like the Sonnar.
Apr 12, 2018 at 07:36 AM
Alex Phan
Offline
Details
p.1 #18Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar
i still love the size and color rendition of Leica lens. Yes, price wise is cheaper but the 50 summilux is a very very special lens. You will not regret it.
Apr 12, 2018 at 11:55 AM
shujert
Offline
Details
p.1 #19Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar
I'd wholeheartedly recommend the Voigtlander 50mm f/1.5 Nokton ASPH - it's easily 90% of the 50 Lux ASPH at 25% of the cost. I've personally only had trouble with the 50 Lux ASPH, and I've been through 3 or 4 copies. Nope, never again for me; I'd go the Voigtlander route for a good 50mm, no question.
Apr 12, 2018 at 01:24 PM
bushwacker
Offline
Details
p.1 #20Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar
shujert wrote:
I'd wholeheartedly recommend the Voigtlander 50mm f/1.5 Nokton ASPH - it's easily 90% of the 50 Lux ASPH at 25% of the cost. I've personally only had trouble with the 50 Lux ASPH, and I've been through 3 or 4 copies. Nope, never again for me; I'd go the Voigtlander route for a good 50mm, no question.


How's the 3d effect on this? Voigtlander 50mm f/1.5 Nokton ASPH
Apr 13, 2018 at 03:51 AM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister