fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2018 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2018Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar

  
 
genji
Offline
Details
p.3 #1Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar
Alpha_Geist wrote:
Genji, it’s never left my M10. It has been on it since I bought it late last year. I will get around to trying it on the A7Rii(m) and A7Riii sometime, but I just love the way it works on the Leica. I am curious of how the 50 APO performs on the A7Rii(m) though, as I sold my M246 before I purchased the APO. If I stilled owned the M246, I strongly feel that the 50 APO would be the only Leica M Lens I would ever use on it.

Also, my 50/1.5 ZM and 7Artisans 50/1.5 haven’t touched my
...Show more →

That's so interesting. It makes sense to me that, as far as the APO 50 is concerned, the M10 would be supplanted by an M246. Though I'm curious about your choice to restrict the 50/1.5 ZM and 7A lenses to the A7RII(m)...
Apr 26, 2018 at 05:59 AM
genji
Offline
Details
p.3 #2Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar
bushwacker wrote:
how is Sony/Zeiss 1.8/55 rendering? very clinical ? and no character? these are the reports I am hearing.

I've struggled mightily to use legacy lenses such as the G 45/2, ZM 50/1.5 ZM, and CV 50/1.5 to make the kinds of pictures that currently fascinate me: close-up portraits taken at waist level of strangers on the street. I'm not interested in standing off with an 85mm/100mm/135mm lens because I'm looking for a greater sense of engagement and I want more than mush in the background. The Techart PRO is useless when either I, or my subject, or both of us are in motion. So I've reluctantly had to accept that only the FE 55/1.8 can do the job. These pictures, taken at the Anzac Day march, don't seem too clinical to me...
https://d1u92k3d1w68j5.cloudfront.net/photos/portraits-strangers/jd-20180425-104226-1576-a7rIIIb-copy01-w1095bc.jpg
https://d1u92k3d1w68j5.cloudfront.net/photos/portraits-strangers/jd-20180425-103731-1531-a7rIIIb-copy01-w1073bc.jpg
https://d1u92k3d1w68j5.cloudfront.net/photos/portraits-strangers/jd-20180425-103811-1538-a7rIIIb-copy01-w1051bc.jpg
https://d1u92k3d1w68j5.cloudfront.net/photos/portraits-strangers/jd-20180425-103802-1533-a7rIIIb-copy01-w1200bc.jpg
Apr 26, 2018 at 06:17 AM
bushwacker
Offline
Details
p.3 #3Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar


genji wrote:
bushwacker wrotehow is Sony/Zeiss 1.8/55 rendering? very clinical ? and no character? these are the reports I am hearing.
I've struggled mightily to use legacy lenses such as the G 45/2, ZM 50/1.5 ZM, and CV 50/1.5 to make the kinds of pictures that currently fascinate me: close-up portraits taken at waist level of strangers on the street. I'm not interested in standing off with an 85mm/100mm/135mm lens because I'm looking for a greater sense of engagement and I want more than mush in the background. The Techart PRO is useless when either I, or my subject, or both of us are in motion. So I've reluctantly had to accept that only the FE 55/1.8 can do the job.
...Show more →


Very nice man... i’d like to see if you have another version somewhere 6 to 9 feet focusing distance.. wide open.

Thanks
May 02, 2018 at 06:04 AM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.3 #5Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar
Jonathon, love your work. The FE55 has its place firmly cemented in the Sony ecosystem and even many of its most trenchant critics keep using it.

On the C-Sonnar, in these dark days of postmodernism some of us are interested in lenses that help impart emotion to our images. Here is a very unusual response by Carl Zeiss to the editor of Michael Reichman's site, in 2011. (asters are mine):

'Information about special features for dealers and users

The C-SONNAR T* 1.5/50 ZM is a very special lens; based on a classical lens design concept from the 1930´s. The additional letter “C” in the name of the lens expresses this designation.

This lens design helps to achieve pictures with *a special artistic touch*. This lens *‘draws’ your subject in a fine, flattering manner* and is therefore ideally suited for portraiture. It renders a sharpness that is slightly rounded, being *less aggressive than in contemporary lens designs*, but at the same time not soft in its rendition.

Many *famous portraits of glamorous and prominent people during the 1930´s used this technique* to great effect. These images are characterized by portraying the person *in a shining, nearly celestial way*. This effect is very well balanced and not exaggerated; therefore *many viewers see it in a subconscious way*. The trained observer, however, understands the underlining technique and enjoys the results.

The special features of the C-SONNAR T* 1.5/50 ZM are *best used in emotional, artistic, narrative images, portraits or atmospheric landscapes*.'

They are telling us the why, the how and what to expect from it.
https://luminous-landscape.com/zeiss-sonnar-50mm/

May 07, 2018 at 07:42 PM
genji
Offline
Details
p.3 #6Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar
bushwacker wrote:
Very nice man... i’d like to see if you have another version somewhere 6 to 9 feet focusing distance.. wide open.


Sorry for the tardy reply. As it happens, now that daylight saving is over, I've become interested in shooting at or near wide open in the late afternoon and early evening. I'll test a variety of lenses before settling on one to use through autumn and winter. The lenses I have in mind include the Sonnar FE 55/1.8, Canon FD 55/1.2 Aspherical, Rokkor MC 58/1.2, Nokton 50/1.5, and C-Sonnar 50/1.5. When I get some satisfactory results, I'll post them here and probably in the main FE Images thread.
May 08, 2018 at 05:29 PM
genji
Offline
Details
p.3 #7Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar
philip_pj wrote:
Jonathon, love your work. The FE55 has its place firmly cemented in the Sony ecosystem and even many of its most trenchant critics keep using it.

On the C-Sonnar, in these dark days of postmodernism some of us are interested in lenses that help impart emotion to our images. Here is a very unusual response by Carl Zeiss to the editor of Michael Reichman's site, in 2011. (asters are mine):

'Information about special features for dealers and users

The C-SONNAR T* 1.5/50 ZM is a very special lens; based on a classical lens design concept from the 1930´s. The additional letter “C”
...Show more →

Phillip, thank you, your compliment means a lot to me.

I spent a bunch of time and money looking for a lens that provided the "rounded sharpness" that I most admire in monochrome photographs made during the 1940s and 1950s. The closest I came was a Yashinon DX 45mm f/1.4 (from a Yashica Lynx 14/14E) converted to Sony E-mount. I finally realised that I already owned the lens I'd been searching for. It was the C-Sonnar 50/1.5.
May 08, 2018 at 05:30 PM
bushwacker
Offline
Details
p.3 #8Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar
genji wrote:
Sorry for the tardy reply. As it happens, now that daylight saving is over, I've become interested in shooting at or near wide open in the late afternoon and early evening. I'll test a variety of lenses before settling on one to use through autumn and winter. The lenses I have in mind include the Sonnar FE 55/1.8, Canon FD 55/1.2 Aspherical, Rokkor MC 58/1.2, Nokton 50/1.5, and C-Sonnar 50/1.5. When I get some satisfactory results, I'll post them here and probably in the main FE Images thread.


thank you
May 08, 2018 at 06:34 PM
Alpha_Geist
Offline
Details
p.3 #9Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar
genji wrote:
Alpha_Geist wroteGenji, it’s never left my M10. It has been on it since I bought it late last year. I will get around to trying it on the A7Rii(m) and A7Riii sometime, but I just love the way it works on the Leica. I am curious of how the 50 APO performs on the A7Rii(m) though, as I sold my M246 before I purchased the APO. If I stilled owned the M246, I strongly feel that the 50 APO would be the only Leica M Lens I would ever use on it.

Also, my 50/1.5 ZM and 7Artisans 50/1.5 haven’t touched my Leica body. I’ve only used those on my A7Rii(m). I don’t plan on using them on the Leica, just the Sony bodies.
That's so interesting. It makes sense to me that, as far as the APO 50 is concerned, the M10 would be supplanted by an M246. Though I'm curious about your choice to restrict the 50/1.5 ZM and 7A lenses to the A7RII(m)...


Hi genji! My apologies for the late reply. I just got back from overseas last evening and I'm currently in the process of unpacking, doing laundry and backing up my photos (M10 & 50 APO) from my stay.

After reviewing and backing up my shots, I'm never left unimpressed with the results from APO. I'm sure it would be a stellar lens on either A7Rii(m) or A7Riii (with greater resolution and file malleability), but for me the overall experience and compact size on the M body feels rewarding. As for using the 50/1.5 ZM and 7artisans 50/1.1 only on my Sony bodies...it comes down to two things. First, focus shift and Second, nailing focus wide open.

I'm aware that the ZM has focus shift when focusing closer vs. mid to further distances. With the Sony EVF, focus shift isn't an issue. Tie that in with shooting wide open with both lenses, and the EVF provides a nice confirmation of where focus is. I just have to be aware of my breathing or any other factor, other than the lens, that may affect nailing focus. It's because of these two points that I choose to use the ZM and 7artisans solely on the Sony bodies. With recent purchases of various ND filters for these lenses, I'm now able to shoot wide open even more in brighter conditions.
May 13, 2018 at 11:53 PM
genji
Offline
Details
p.3 #10Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar
Alpha_Geist wrote:
Hi genji! My apologies for the late reply. I just got back from overseas last evening and I'm currently in the process of unpacking, doing laundry and backing up my photos (M10 & 50 APO) from my stay.

After reviewing and backing up my shots, I'm never left unimpressed with the results from APO. I'm sure it would be a stellar lens on either A7Rii(m) or A7Riii (with greater resolution and file malleability), but for me the overall experience and compact size on the M body feels rewarding. As for using the 50/1.5 ZM and 7artisans 50/1.1 only on my
...Show more →

That makes perfect sense, I should have considered focus shift. I'm not so fond of the 50/1.5 ZM's look wide open so I use it at either f/2 or f/2.8. As for the 50 APO, after reading Thorsten Overgard's interview with Peter Karbe about the lens and looking at hundreds of photos on Flickr, I PMd Steve Spencer to ask him about how it performed on the A7RII. His experience matched yours. Having realised that I "need" a 50 APO, all I have to do now is sell enough stuff to fund the purchase.
May 15, 2018 at 04:49 PM
frezeiss
Offline
Details
p.3 #11Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar
bushwacker wrote:
frezeiss wroteOn the A7 Zony 55 1.8 or 50 1.4 doesnt need help from M lenses.
how is Sony/Zeiss 1.8/55 rendering? very clinical ? and no character? these are the reports I am hearing.



its more like a show off lens high contrast, high sharpness, vignettes quite so, and Sonnar bokeh which is sometimes nice/other time less so (quite different from other planar designs). I use it personally for videos in which the lens really shines (SLOG is very muted compared to photography RAWs), some detailed shots. For general photography I prefer the Zony 50 1.4. Also the extra 5 mm is not to my liking sometimes..
Jun 24, 2018 at 11:52 PM
bushwacker
Offline
Details
p.3 #12Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar
sebboh wrote:
bushwacker wrote
frezeiss wroteOn the A7 Zony 55 1.8 or 50 1.4 doesnt need help from M lenses.
how is Sony/Zeiss 1.8/55 rendering? very clinical ? and no character? these are the reports I am hearing.
it generally has very smooth bokeh and flatter field than the zm 50/1.5, cv 50/1.5, or lux asph. loCA is also a little stronger and the cat's eye effect is very noticeable at mid distance. overall it draws very similar to the rx1 but with stronger cat's eye effect. i quite like it except for the color and that the focus ring is absolutely terrible – much worse than more recent high end sony fbw implementations.

some shots with it (all wide open):
http://c1.staticflickr.com/5/4373/36991303826_368a19e7e5_o.jpg
http://c1.staticflickr.com/5/4245/34531785644_1317fc8322_o.jpg
http://c1.staticflickr.com/5/4198/35436455972_fc122aeda6_o.jpg
http://c1.staticflickr.com/5/4332/36991303346_e0013294e6_o.jpg
http://c1.staticflickr.com/5/4163/35218318260_307fee8642_o.jpg
http://c1.staticflickr.com/5/4120/35604858425_6be78a2bc3_o.jpg
sorry no deer shot.


thanks man for all these samples...


So now.... I am dropping the Sony A7 series body combo with 50C sonnar., I decided to stay with Canon bodies mainly with the purchase of EOS R. I am now eyeing EOS R + 1.5/50C Sonnar combo in terms of 3D rendering compared to CV 50/1.5 and 7artisan 50/1.1.... how close are these two to the sonnar?

again many thanks...

Jan 12, 2019 at 06:44 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.3 #13Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar
genji wrote:
Alpha_Geist wroteI’ve owned the Voigt 50/1.5, Leica 50 Lux ASPH, but now I have the Sonnar 50/1.5, Leica 50 APO and 7Artisans 50/1.1.

My thoughts, I wish I never sold the Voigt 50/1.5 for the Lux, as I wouldn’t have spent the unnecessary money on the Lux. While the Lux was a great lens, I never felt like it was truly worth the money I paid for it. I just never clicked with it on my Leica M bodies (240/246/262) and on the Sony A7II. While it was smaller than an adapted setup, I liked the results with my 50/1.4 ZF, 50/2 Makro ZE and 50/2 Cron-R more so. I guess I’m just weird. Anyways, I sold the Lux to fund the 50 APO, and couldn’t be happier. The Sonnar 50/1.5 and 7Artisans 50/1.1 were originally purchased with the intent of keeping one, but not both. I ended up keeping both as I like their individual renderings, flaws and all, enough to remain in my stable. The 7Artisans is a real deal for the money! I need more time with the Sonnar, but I absolutely love the results I get with it. YMMV
I'm curious as to whether you're using the 50 APO on an M10, an A7R II that Daniel has converted to monochrome, or both? Ever since phillip_pj linked to the Thorsten Overgaard interview with Peter Karbe, I can't seem to get the 50 APO out of my mind. I can't imagine it behaves as well on a stock A7R II as it would on either a Kolari UT or a monochrome body with a thin cover glass.


The 50 cron AA performs very well on the A7r II with almost the same performance it has on an M10 in my experience. I did like it better on the M10 and you could notice it especially if you used the macro adapter for extension, but it worked very well on the A7r II. I am posting some samples with it below. Unfortunately, but that lens and my M10 were stolen before I got around to doing side by side comparisons, but I loved the 50 cron AA on my stock A7r II. Some samples:



















Jan 12, 2019 at 07:51 PM
rscheffler
Offline
Details
p.3 #14Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar

bushwacker wrote:
thanks man for all these samples...

So now.... I am dropping the Sony A7 series body combo with 50C sonnar., I decided to stay with Canon bodies mainly with the purchase of EOS R. I am now eyeing EOS R + 1.5/50C Sonnar combo in terms of 3D rendering compared to CV 50/1.5 and 7artisan 50/1.1.... how close are these two to the sonnar?

again many thanks...


I recently got the 7artisans and used to own the CV50/1.5. The 7artisans exhibits Sonnar rendering whereas the 50/1.5 is not a Sonnar design and I found it to be very close to the 50 Lux ASPH-M, if slightly less gaussian in its background rendering.

I haven't shot enough with the 7artisans to get an impression relative to other Sonnar lenses, such as the 50/1.5 Zeiss Opton also in my collection, or to really comment on 3D rendering. I think 3D rendering is due to a range of variables, including the speed of transition from sharp to soft. Given the SA of the 50/1.1 wide open, I find it somewhat forgiving with focus placement, because it's not that super well defined. It'll probably be more glowy wide open than the ZM 50/1.5 but it does cut down SA glow significantly by f/2. Again, I haven't used it enough, but until I do, I'd guess it probably won't be as snappy/saturated as the ZM and its T* coatings. Overall, I'm impressed with the 50/1.1 and also their 35/2, given their price points, but I also didn't buy the 50 looking for 3D rendering. I got hooked by the Sonnar classification and a good price.

The CV50/1.5 never really grew on me. It was very sharp centrally and as mentioned, similar rendering to the 50 Lux ASPH, though lower contrast/saturation. It also didn't hold sharpness across the frame. That was the older version. The current version apparently has revised coatings and somewhat better contrast/saturation against backlighting. Therefore it might be a touch snappier looking. But it won't have Sonnar style rendering.
Jan 13, 2019 at 08:31 PM
bushwacker
Offline
Details
p.3 #15Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar
rscheffler wrote:
bushwacker wrotethanks man for all these samples...

So now.... I am dropping the Sony A7 series body combo with 50C sonnar., I decided to stay with Canon bodies mainly with the purchase of EOS R. I am now eyeing EOS R + 1.5/50C Sonnar combo in terms of 3D rendering compared to CV 50/1.5 and 7artisan 50/1.1.... how close are these two to the sonnar?

again many thanks...
I recently got the 7artisans and used to own the CV50/1.5. The 7artisans exhibits Sonnar rendering whereas the 50/1.5 is not a Sonnar design and I found it to be very close to the 50 Lux ASPH-M, if slightly less gaussian in its background rendering.

I haven't shot enough with the 7artisans to get an impression relative to other Sonnar lenses, such as the 50/1.5 Zeiss Opton also in my collection, or to really comment on 3D rendering. I think 3D rendering is due to a range of variables, including the speed of transition from sharp to soft. Given the
...Show more →


thanks man....


so when is the 7artisan starts to get really sharp with smooth bokeh around f/2 or somewhere? f/2.8?

Actually I am looking for 1.5/50c sonnar or the leica 1.4/50 summilux asph “LOOK” for cheap or atleast almost the same rendering.

Again tnx man.



Edited on Jan 14, 2019 at 11:39 AM · View previous versions
Jan 14, 2019 at 04:11 AM
krug
Offline
Details
p.3 #16Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar
This is a very interesting thread and strongly demonstrates one of the great strengths of FM - the quiet considered sharing of experience of a number of people offered free to colleagues.
Well now we have the new Voigtlander 50 1.2 which in my experience so far ranks with the best of those considered here though still does not totally displace my Contax rf 50/1.5 in my heart - although quite different. the nice thing is the particular characteristics of each of my half dozen or so 50's - often the favourite is the one that I have been using most often most recently !
Jan 14, 2019 at 10:00 AM
LBJ2
Offline
Details
p.3 #17Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar
IMO, having used both on the M10:

#1 Summilux (some very good used copies out there w/ some patience)
#2 Very well priced Voigtlander VM 50 F1.2 ( close runner up to Summilux).
Jan 14, 2019 at 10:27 AM
LBJ2
Offline
Details
p.3 #18Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar
genji wrote:
bushwacker wrotehow is Sony/Zeiss 1.8/55 rendering? very clinical ? and no character? these are the reports I am hearing.
I've struggled mightily to use legacy lenses such as the G 45/2, ZM 50/1.5 ZM, and CV 50/1.5 to make the kinds of pictures that currently fascinate me: close-up portraits taken at waist level of strangers on the street. I'm not interested in standing off with an 85mm/100mm/135mm lens because I'm looking for a greater sense of engagement and I want more than mush in the background. The Techart PRO is useless when either I, or my subject, or both of us are in motion. So I've reluctantly had to accept that only the FE 55/1.8 can do the job.
...Show more →

Point the camera at a subject(s) with character and there it is...Excellent example of what the FE 55/1.8 can do 👏👏

I'll never give up my FE 55/1.8. Same for the FE 35 F2.8. Both make for excellent IQ ( but not perfect), compact/lightweight, get up and go kit for Sony alpha FF.
Jan 14, 2019 at 10:34 AM
sebboh
Offline
Details
Jan 14, 2019 at 04:51 PM
Desmolicious
Offline
Details
p.3 #20Leica 50mm ASPH Summilux vs. Zeiss 50mm f/1.5 Sonnar
sebboh wrote:
i don't have anything to say about the 7artisans 50/1.1 since i haven't shot it, but figured i ought to post some summilux asph shots since i posted cv 50/1.5, zm 50/1.5, and FE 55/1.8 shots:
http://farm2.staticflickr.com/1751/40895072840_e3263b7246_o.jpg
http://farm2.staticflickr.com/1725/27629926437_1f6a7484a3_o.jpg
http://farm2.staticflickr.com/1732/28485202058_63a54b89f1_o.jpg
http://farm2.staticflickr.com/1729/41786760115_b2de98096c_b.jpg
http://farm2.staticflickr.com/1755/27629926617_9e72330132_o.jpg
http://farm2.staticflickr.com/1721/41729395685_a8661219a1_o.jpg


My Summilux 50 asph looks nothing like that! I assume u heavily edited the images? The vignette (especially on the chicken photo) is not native to the lens.
Jan 14, 2019 at 06:48 PM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister