fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2018 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2018FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender

  
 
davev
Offline
Details
p.11 #1FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
pizdets17 wrote:
I have a question having just got this setup today. When you twist the lens onto the extender, are you hearing a click and having it lock? Mine seems like i have to move the lens about 1mm backwards and then manually click the little extender button to lock it in place. Thoughts?


That doesn't seem right.

Mine clicks in. The click isn't a loud "click", but you can hear it.
You can visually see the tc's button move away from the lens as you start to put it on, as you get to the end of the twist,
the button pops into place towards the lens.
The 2x tc works in exactly the same way.

There's a small pin that's attached to the button. That's the lock.
If you press it, you should be able to tell if the button's spring is doing it's job.
You can feel the pin/lock coming out from the flange under the button.

No messing around with it.
Feb 26, 2019 at 11:56 PM
pizdets17
Offline
Details
p.11 #2FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
It seems that the spring is not “springy”. It operates like a switch. Looks like RMA inbound....
Feb 27, 2019 at 12:25 AM
Douglas L
Online
Details
p.11 #3FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
Frogfish wrote:
kdrk888 wroteThis is not one person had to say there was a problem. After seeing the samples posted in those threads, are you not convinced at least some of the TCs have problems?
I'll be honest though Douglas and say that I'd imagine for most people some vignetting isn't much of an issue for two reasons :

a) most people don't shoot at 800mm/560mm because they are interested in the whole frame scene (atmospheric conditions/interference at those FLs mean you are highly unlikely to get the best out of any TC-lens combination), it's for wildlife/birds/safari and you are going to crop out the corners anyway (at least I always do) and ....

b) PP will remove most / all of the vignetting

I'll admit the reflection of the interior 'corner edges' of the TC is
...Show more →

Kevin, I totally see your point in terms of how little this vignetting issue would affect most of the shots because of cropping and correction. However, I got some shots of fighter jets that fill most of the frame, so cropping is not ideal, LR profile correction didn't make it go away completely, I tried some other crude method to lessen the impact.

As I learned a couple days ago (and posted results here a couple pages back), leaving the camera' lens comp./shading to auto, and correcting it again in LR pretty much eliminates the vignetting. I went out yesterday to photograph some swans and snow geese from long distance, with the lens shading at auto in the camera, I see very little vignetting. So I can live with that.

What puzzles me most is that from my conversation with the Sony CS last year, Sony seemed to know some TCs are affected, and some owners do show theirs don't have the problem, yet they want $230 to "repair" Fred's? What exactly are they repairing? I think they should issue a recall on the affected ones like they did with the 24-105.




Feb 27, 2019 at 05:35 AM
naturephoto1
Offline
Details
p.11 #4FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
kdrk888 wrote:
Frogfish wrote
kdrk888 wroteThis is not one person had to say there was a problem. After seeing the samples posted in those threads, are you not convinced at least some of the TCs have problems?
I'll be honest though Douglas and say that I'd imagine for most people some vignetting isn't much of an issue for two reasons :

a) most people don't shoot at 800mm/560mm because they are interested in the whole frame scene (atmospheric conditions/interference at those FLs mean you are highly unlikely to get the best out of any TC-lens combination), it's for wildlife/birds/safari and you are going to crop out the corners anyway (at least I always do) and ....

b) PP will remove most / all of the vignetting

I'll admit the reflection of the interior 'corner edges' of the TC is potentially more of an issue.

Basically this is just to say it isn't an issue for me personally because I don't need those corners (even though I accept a few, and generally only very few, will). This isn't to absolve Sony from blame but just saying I don't see this is a 'in real world use' problem per se. Just as the FC of the VC 35/1.7 has been commented on here by a few as a reason not to buy it, however it has 'never' been an issue for me and has never stopped me printing/selling shots from it. Most issues on FM/DPR etc. tend to be blown out of all proportion as people seek perfection.

EDIT. For the purposes of this post I'm assuming the vignetting is not repairable.
Kevin, I totally see your point in terms of how little this vignetting issue would affect most of the shots because of cropping and correction. However, I got some shots of fighter jets that fill most of the frame, so cropping is not ideal, LR profile correction didn't make it go away completely, I tried some other crude method to lessen the impact.

As I learned a couple days ago (and posted results here a couple pages back), leaving the camera' lens comp./shading to auto, and correcting it again in LR pretty much eliminates the vignetting. I went out yesterday to
...Show more →

I do not consider below as acceptable at this point, though I would not normally expect 4 corners like this (but it could be possible), but 1 or 2 is certainly not unlikely if I included blue sky in these images at f8 and 560mm. This would require a lot of cropping if I were unable to remove most of this vignetting with the using the LR profile on and additional vignetting adjustment.

Rich





© naturephoto1 2019


Lens Compensation off, and right out of camera.





© naturephoto1 2019


Lens Compensation on, and right out of camera.

Feb 27, 2019 at 06:33 AM
Douglas L
Online
Details
p.11 #5FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
naturephoto1 wrote:
kdrk888 wrote
Frogfish wrote
kdrk888 wroteThis is not one person had to say there was a problem. After seeing the samples posted in those threads, are you not convinced at least some of the TCs have problems?
I'll be honest though Douglas and say that I'd imagine for most people some vignetting isn't much of an issue for two reasons :

a) most people don't shoot at 800mm/560mm because they are interested in the whole frame scene (atmospheric conditions/interference at those FLs mean you are highly unlikely to get the best out of any TC-lens combination), it's for wildlife/birds/safari and you are going to crop out the corners anyway (at least I always do) and ....

b) PP will remove most / all of the vignetting

I'll admit the reflection of the interior 'corner edges' of the TC is potentially more of an issue.

Basically this is just to say it isn't an issue for me personally because I don't need those corners (even though I accept a few, and generally only very few, will). This isn't to absolve Sony from blame but just saying I don't see this is a 'in real world use' problem per se. Just as the FC of the VC 35/1.7 has been commented on here by a few as a reason not to buy it, however it has 'never' been an issue for me and has never stopped me printing/selling shots from it. Most issues on FM/DPR etc. tend to be blown out of all proportion as people seek perfection.

EDIT. For the purposes of this post I'm assuming the vignetting is not repairable.
Kevin, I totally see your point in terms of how little this vignetting issue would affect most of the shots because of cropping and correction. However, I got some shots of fighter jets that fill most of the frame, so cropping is not ideal, LR profile correction didn't make it go away completely, I tried some other crude method to lessen the impact.

As I learned a couple days ago (and posted results here a couple pages back), leaving the camera' lens comp./shading to auto, and correcting it again in LR pretty much eliminates the vignetting. I went out yesterday to photograph some swans and snow geese from long distance, with the lens shading at auto in the camera, I see very little vignetting. So I can live with that.

What puzzles me most is that from my conversation with the Sony CS last year, Sony seemed to know some TCs are affected, and some owners do show theirs don't have the problem, yet they want $230 to "repair" Fred's? What exactly are they repairing? I think they should issue a recall on the affected ones like they did with the 24-105.
I do not consider below as acceptable at this point, though I would not normally expect 4 corners like this (but it could be possible), but 1 or 2 is certainly not unlikely if I included blue sky in these images at f8 and 560mm. This would require a lot of cropping if I were unable to remove most of this vignetting with the using the LR profile on and additional vignetting adjustment.

Rich



This is not looking good, Rich. I am guessing solely cropping away these corners would lose 30% of the frame?

Like I said in the previous post, if you have a subject that fills most of the frame, cropping the 4 corners at this level may not be the ideal solution. I will continue to experiment by keeping the camera's lens comp. shading at auto, and correcting again in LR. So basically double correction.
Feb 27, 2019 at 07:07 AM
naturephoto1
Offline
Details
p.11 #6FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
kdrk888 wrote:
naturephoto1 wrote
kdrk888 wrote
Frogfish wrote
kdrk888 wroteThis is not one person had to say there was a problem. After seeing the samples posted in those threads, are you not convinced at least some of the TCs have problems?
I'll be honest though Douglas and say that I'd imagine for most people some vignetting isn't much of an issue for two reasons :

a) most people don't shoot at 800mm/560mm because they are interested in the whole frame scene (atmospheric conditions/interference at those FLs mean you are highly unlikely to get the best out of any TC-lens combination), it's for wildlife/birds/safari and you are going to crop out the corners anyway (at least I always do) and ....

b) PP will remove most / all of the vignetting

I'll admit the reflection of the interior 'corner edges' of the TC is potentially more of an issue.

Basically this is just to say it isn't an issue for me personally because I don't need those corners (even though I accept a few, and generally only very few, will). This isn't to absolve Sony from blame but just saying I don't see this is a 'in real world use' problem per se. Just as the FC of the VC 35/1.7 has been commented on here by a few as a reason not to buy it, however it has 'never' been an issue for me and has never stopped me printing/selling shots from it. Most issues on FM/DPR etc. tend to be blown out of all proportion as people seek perfection.

EDIT. For the purposes of this post I'm assuming the vignetting is not repairable.
Kevin, I totally see your point in terms of how little this vignetting issue would affect most of the shots because of cropping and correction. However, I got some shots of fighter jets that fill most of the frame, so cropping is not ideal, LR profile correction didn't make it go away completely, I tried some other crude method to lessen the impact.

As I learned a couple days ago (and posted results here a couple pages back), leaving the camera' lens comp./shading to auto, and correcting it again in LR pretty much eliminates the vignetting. I went out yesterday to photograph some swans and snow geese from long distance, with the lens shading at auto in the camera, I see very little vignetting. So I can live with that.

What puzzles me most is that from my conversation with the Sony CS last year, Sony seemed to know some TCs are affected, and some owners do show theirs don't have the problem, yet they want $230 to "repair" Fred's? What exactly are they repairing? I think they should issue a recall on the affected ones like they did with the 24-105.
I do not consider below as acceptable at this point, though I would not normally expect 4 corners like this (but it could be possible), but 1 or 2 is certainly not unlikely if I included blue sky in these images at f8 and 560mm. This would require a lot of cropping if I were unable to remove most of this vignetting with the using the LR profile on and additional vignetting adjustment.

Rich
This is not looking good, Rich. I am guessing solely cropping away these corners would lose 30% of the frame?

Like I said in the previous post, if you have a subject that fills most of the frame, cropping the 4 corners at this level may not be the ideal solution. I will continue to experiment by keeping the camera's lens comp. shading at auto, and correcting again in LR. So basically double correction.


Hi Douglas,

This looks interesting. I just checked the Precision Camera Repair website for my teleconverter and the website indicates:
"Delay. Repair on hold, waiting for parts. Parts Ordered." So maybe there is a fix and Precision will actually fix the problem with my teleconverter. I will keep my fingers crossed and report updates.

Rich
Feb 27, 2019 at 07:14 AM
bluloo
Offline
Details
p.11 #7FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
naturephoto1 wrote:
This looks interesting. I just checked the Precision Camera Repair website for my teleconverter and the website indicates:
"Delay. Repair on hold, waiting for parts. Parts Ordered." So maybe there is a fix and Precision will actually fix the problem with my teleconverter. I will keep my fingers crossed and report updates.

Rich


Good to hear. You must be pretty happy. Hopefully it's an actual fix for the issue.
Feb 27, 2019 at 01:34 PM
davev
Offline
Details
p.11 #8FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
I have to ask, what can go wrong with a teleconverter?

Pretty much no moving parts, most of the contacts I would think are just pass throughs to power the lens.
There must be a board in it to tell the camera that it's there, but I can't see how that a would cause the vignetting.
Misaligned lenses? That would cause focusing issues.

I'm just having a hard time grasping what could go wrong to cause this in so many copies.
Feb 27, 2019 at 08:54 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.11 #9FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
naturephoto1 wrote:
kdrk888 wrote
naturephoto1 wrote
kdrk888 wrote
Frogfish wrote
kdrk888 wroteThis is not one person had to say there was a problem. After seeing the samples posted in those threads, are you not convinced at least some of the TCs have problems?
I'll be honest though Douglas and say that I'd imagine for most people some vignetting isn't much of an issue for two reasons :

a) most people don't shoot at 800mm/560mm because they are interested in the whole frame scene (atmospheric conditions/interference at those FLs mean you are highly unlikely to get the best out of any TC-lens combination), it's for wildlife/birds/safari and you are going to crop out the corners anyway (at least I always do) and ....

b) PP will remove most / all of the vignetting

I'll admit the reflection of the interior 'corner edges' of the TC is potentially more of an issue.

Basically this is just to say it isn't an issue for me personally because I don't need those corners (even though I accept a few, and generally only very few, will). This isn't to absolve Sony from blame but just saying I don't see this is a 'in real world use' problem per se. Just as the FC of the VC 35/1.7 has been commented on here by a few as a reason not to buy it, however it has 'never' been an issue for me and has never stopped me printing/selling shots from it. Most issues on FM/DPR etc. tend to be blown out of all proportion as people seek perfection.

EDIT. For the purposes of this post I'm assuming the vignetting is not repairable.
Kevin, I totally see your point in terms of how little this vignetting issue would affect most of the shots because of cropping and correction. However, I got some shots of fighter jets that fill most of the frame, so cropping is not ideal, LR profile correction didn't make it go away completely, I tried some other crude method to lessen the impact.

As I learned a couple days ago (and posted results here a couple pages back), leaving the camera' lens comp./shading to auto, and correcting it again in LR pretty much eliminates the vignetting. I went out yesterday to photograph some swans and snow geese from long distance, with the lens shading at auto in the camera, I see very little vignetting. So I can live with that.

What puzzles me most is that from my conversation with the Sony CS last year, Sony seemed to know some TCs are affected, and some owners do show theirs don't have the problem, yet they want $230 to "repair" Fred's? What exactly are they repairing? I think they should issue a recall on the affected ones like they did with the 24-105.
I do not consider below as acceptable at this point, though I would not normally expect 4 corners like this (but it could be possible), but 1 or 2 is certainly not unlikely if I included blue sky in these images at f8 and 560mm. This would require a lot of cropping if I were unable to remove most of this vignetting with the using the LR profile on and additional vignetting adjustment.

Rich
This is not looking good, Rich. I am guessing solely cropping away these corners would lose 30% of the frame?

Like I said in the previous post, if you have a subject that fills most of the frame, cropping the 4 corners at this level may not be the ideal solution. I will continue to experiment by keeping the camera's lens comp. shading at auto, and correcting again in LR. So basically double correction.
Hi Douglas,

This looks interesting. I just checked the Precision Camera Repair website for my teleconverter and the website indicates:
"Delay. Repair on hold, waiting for parts. Parts Ordered." So maybe there is a fix and Precision will actually fix the problem with my teleconverter. I will keep my fingers crossed and report updates.

Rich


Keep us updated. CameraQuest told me they will ask Sony to ship me a few teleconverters and see which one has better vingetting when combined to the 100-400GM.
Feb 27, 2019 at 08:59 PM
jhinkey
Offline
Details
p.11 #10FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
davev wrote:
I have to ask, what can go wrong with a teleconverter?

Pretty much no moving parts, most of the contacts I would think are just pass throughs to power the lens.
There must be a board in it to tell the camera that it's there, but I can't see how that a would cause the vignetting.
Misaligned lenses? That would cause focusing issues.

I'm just having a hard time grasping what could go wrong to cause this in so many copies.


It was designed or manufactured incorrectly . . . .
Feb 27, 2019 at 09:25 PM
bluloo
Offline
Details
p.11 #11FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
davev wrote:
I have to ask, what can go wrong with a teleconverter?

Pretty much no moving parts, most of the contacts I would think are just pass throughs to power the lens.
There must be a board in it to tell the camera that it's there, but I can't see how that a would cause the vignetting.
Misaligned lenses? That would cause focusing issues.

I'm just having a hard time grasping what could go wrong to cause this in so many copies.


A parts supplier can change their production process, and produce a product that they think meets their delivery specs but may result in more OOS parts for Sony's needs, without notifying Sony. Or a supplier can have a change that produces more variation in a part.
Or they can inadvertently change a part, to cut costs, without assigning a new product number to it, or notifying Sony.

Or Sony might have intentionally changed suppliers and there was an unintended change in the output of the TC. Or perhaps a part was added, or omitted on some units.

If the lens assembly was too close to the sensor, couldn't it throw the corners of the image too far inside of the sensor in the corner areas, for example?
If so. an omitted spacer or a too-tall spacer could do it (or vise versa).

Maybe it's too close or too far from the baffle on some units. Too far and the baffle will start interfering with the image circle, I think.

Not suggesting any of those things occurred, but they're not uncommon in large-scale manufacturing operations.

I worked as a Quality Engineer for a biotech company, and those sorts of "hidden" changes can really play havoc with your process and product, when they occur.
Feb 27, 2019 at 11:58 PM
davev
Offline
Details
p.11 #12FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
bluloo wrote:
A parts supplier can change their production process, and produce a product that they think meets their delivery specs but may result in more OOS parts for Sony's needs, without notifying Sony. Or a supplier can have a change that produces more variation in a part.
Or they can inadvertently change a part, to cut costs, without assigning a new product number to it, or notifying Sony.

Or Sony might have intentionally changed suppliers and there was an unintended change in the output of the TC. Or perhaps a part was added, or omitted on some units.

If the lens assembly was
...Show more →

Ok, I understand what you're saying.

I hope on the repair sheet they list what parts were changed.


Feb 28, 2019 at 01:12 AM
rattlebonez
Offline
Details
p.11 #13FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
Save up for a longer lens. possibly a Tamron or Sigma 150-600 in native FE mount when released.

I don't think any teleconveryers are worthwhile. It was the same with Canaon cameras and TC's. The F8 of a 100-400 with TC is the culprit I believe.

Sometimes TC's give good images, but more often not. Usually the impact on focus making it a bit off, or too slow.

But that is just what I have seen with multiple TC's and camera and lens combinations. I prefer to use my 100-400 GM with no TC now.

Your results may vary ...


A high megapixel full frame or a 24 MP APSC might make a better TC - Sony A7000 if released



Edited on Mar 01, 2019 at 08:39 AM · View previous versions
Feb 28, 2019 at 06:47 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.11 #14FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
I just got informed that Sony will send me a new teleconverter to test against mine. Let's see if the new batch one performs differently. They seem interested in finding out the results.
Feb 28, 2019 at 06:52 PM
Frogfish
Offline
Details
p.11 #15FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
rattlebonez wrote:
Save up for a longer lens. possibly a Tamron or Sigma 150-600 in native FE mount when released.

I don't think any teleconveryers are worthwhile. It was the same with Canaon cameras and TC's. The F8 of a 100-400 with TC is the culprit I believe.

Sometimes TC's give good images, but more often not. Usually the impact on focus making it a bit off, or too slow.

But that is just what I have seen with multiple TC's and camera and lens combinations. I prefer to use my 100-400 GM with no TC now.

Your Results may vary ...


Pentax 300/4 + x1.7
Nikon 300/2.8 + x1.4 and x2.0 (I have thousands of very good bird images with this combo at 600mm, and more often than not rather than vice versa)
Sony 100-400 + x2.0 (still has superb AF and Eye-AF in good light)

Against
Nikon 200-500
Sigma 550
Tokina 300/2.8
and all of the lenses above sans TC.

Although the AF can sometimes suffer somewhat give me the TC and lens over bare lens and cropping *almost* every time (TCs didn't work well with the Nikon 200-500). An added benefit is also being able to not use the TC at all in very low light, where f2.8 or sometimes f4 is essential and I also use them (400mm or sub teles) as long portrait lenses (I love the compression in portraits+long teles).

YMMV depending on your needs though and that's fine too !
Mar 01, 2019 at 06:01 AM
jschn372
Offline
Details
p.11 #16FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
If it does are they going to do a recall? 😂

Fred Miranda wrote:
I just got informed that Sony will send me a new teleconverter to test against mine. Let's see if the new batch one performs differently. They seem interested in finding out the results.

Mar 01, 2019 at 08:11 AM
bluloo
Offline
Details
p.11 #17FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
Fred Miranda wrote:
I just got informed that Sony will send me a new teleconverter to test against mine. Let's see if the new batch one performs differently. They seem interested in finding out the results.


Great to hear!

Sony received mine today. Hopefully it will be replaced in the next week or two.
Mar 01, 2019 at 04:57 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.11 #18FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
Just got the latest production batch of the 1.4x tele directly from Sony and will test it out today.
Basically I just want to compare the vignetting against my own teleconverter. (old serial number)
Mar 04, 2019 at 12:18 PM
davev
Offline
Details
p.11 #19FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
Fred Miranda wrote:
Just got the latest production batch of the 1.4x tele directly from Sony and will test it out today.
Basically I just want to compare the vignetting against my own teleconverter. (old serial number)


What's the new serial number?
Might give me some idea how old mine is.
Mar 04, 2019 at 12:53 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.11 #20FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
davev wrote:
Fred Miranda wroteJust got the latest production batch of the 1.4x tele directly from Sony and will test it out today.
Basically I just want to compare the vignetting against my own teleconverter. (old serial number)
What's the new serial number?
Might give me some idea how old mine is.


I think that the 1.4x replacement serial number that Sony gave me is not the latest one. It's "18076XX"
However, it's higher than my personal one which has serial number "18039XX".

Here is a quick test showing them side by side. The one provided by Sony with a higher serial number has lower vignetting when used on the same 100-400GM lens.




Mar 04, 2019 at 01:55 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister