p.4 #1Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 M-mount now available!
zhangyue wrote:
I agree with you 35mm f1.7 is the closet lens to RX1. The reason I prefer 40mm for the cases I mentioned was just like you said: quantity of the bokeh and character. I am sure I will prefer 40mm to RX1 as well for the cases I tested: shooting portrait with subject less than 1M,the background just melt away.
For city or street, I am sure my verdict will reverse. As for those condition, I need bokeh to be smooth but at the same time keep the shape, outline and information of background. (Abosolutly no funky stuff here ) RX1 is definitely the best here out of all 35mm I tested.
I can rate RX1 has smooth and beautiful bokeh, maybe VC35f1.7 as well, but I will not say they have character. ld say VC40 has lots of character. It’s bokeh has some SA build in with oil paint like render, rich but never ugly. And in focus zone is also happen to be sharp with minor SA left. Good design!
What a fun lens it is.
...Show more →Fred Miranda wrotezhangyue wroteMaybe I need use 35mm f1.7 more for other stuffs, but under same condition to maintain the magnification by moving in a little for 35mm for portrait, I prefer 40mm images every single time.
The more I use 40mm, the more I feel its Bokeh special and lovely. I haven't have this kind of impression with any modern lenses since RX1 did it a few years ago on me. but 40mm has its quirk, RX1 almost have none.What's unique about the CV 35/1.7 is the complete absence of onion ring pattern in specular highlights even though this lens has an aspherical element towards the rear. I also like the transition zone and overall rendering. I would say it's the first 35mm lens I liked after shooting with the Sonnar 35/2. However, without the PCX, field curvature is just too high making rendering a bit unpredictable. (So, imo, the 5m front-lens is a must)
Even with all the current 35mm lenses in the market, this is one of my favorites.
The CV 40/1.2 is capable of more subject isolation creating a nice 3d rendering but the excessive LoCA and onion rings ruined many of my images. Still love it though, as there is nothing like it making it a very unique lens.
If you like shooting your subject at 1-1.5m and want sharper results, consider the Leica elpro-4 attached to it. It will give your subject higher resolutioin/contrast since it places the helicoid at lens’ optimum distance. (Closer to infinity)
p.4 #7Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 M-mount now available!
Has anyone compared the VM 40 f/1.2 and the ZM 35 f1.4? The Zeiss is probably the best lens that I have for my SL, and I can hardly bear the thought of selling it or letting it collect dust on a shelf. OTOH, 40mm has always seemed like the ideal all-purpose focal length. I also have the CV 50 f/1.5, which I love dearly. For me, this is clearly a case of too many choices.
p.4 #8Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 M-mount now available!
robgo2 wrote:
Has anyone compared the VM 40 f/1.2 and the ZM 35 f1.4? The Zeiss is probably the best lens that I have for my SL, and I can hardly bear the thought of selling it or letting it collect dust on a shelf. OTOH, 40mm has always seemed like the ideal all-purpose focal length. I also have the CV 50 f/1.5, which I love dearly. For me, this is clearly a case of too many choices.
For an SL? Stick with the Zeiss. A lens the size of the 35 handles better for a camera that size. And it is the better optic
p.4 #9Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 M-mount now available!
I'm still curious to see more empirical testing done with this lens, in both E and M mount. Most of the tests done here - mine included, see Flickr - haven't really been fair or of sound methodology.
I'd like to see some Raw files linked showing a resolution dip at MFD. I have yet to see one, and if we're relying on jpegs out of camera, or focus using a TAP, or in-camera corrections, we're not really getting a clear picture (if you'll excuse the pun.) Especially wide open at close range when we're dealing with an extremely shallow DOF.
I'm loving this lens and it pains me to think that it's not getting its due praise, so please. Indulge me and rise to the challenge. Show me a lack of center sharpness at close range that excludes DOF and focus error as the culprits.
p.4 #10Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 M-mount now available!
imagesfromobjects wrote:
I'm still curious to see more empirical testing done with this lens, in both E and M mount. Most of the tests done here - mine included, see Flickr - haven't really been fair or of sound methodology.
I'd like to see some Raw files linked showing a resolution dip at MFD. I have yet to see one, and if we're relying on jpegs out of camera, or focus using a TAP, or in-camera corrections, we're not really getting a clear picture (if you'll excuse the pun.) Especially wide open at close range when we're dealing with an extremely shallow DOF.
I'm loving this lens and it pains me to think that it's not getting its due praise, so please. Indulge me and rise to the challenge. Show me a lack of center sharpness at close range that excludes DOF and focus error as the culprits.
There are a lot of information to your questions in the review thread. Also some comparisons between E and M or how front lenses improves close up resolution.
But as far as I remember you know this thread and you own the E-mount version. Therefore I'm not sure what empirical tests you want on top? But if I take your last sentence into account it's maybe just a way to tell how happy you are with the lens.
Two things:
1. The lens shows a significant field curve. Using a M-version with a TAP will allow you only focus to the center because you can't reframe after focusing. On top of that the M-version shows slightly worse image quality.
2. It's a great character lens with a very good sharpness in generall. I don't care that much about sharpness. But some see excellent sharpness as a "my way or highway" criteria. On MFD use a front lens. After 1-2m distance even f1.2 can be very sharp in the center and excellent sharpness after f2.8. And it's a really great performer from corner to corner from midzone to infinity at around f5.6-f8.
p.4 #11Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 M-mount now available!
Any thoughts on the 35/1.2 in M and the 40/1.2 in M, which performs better on Sony? I know the E Version is best by far but I like M for a few reasons. Maybe it’s just the difference in M and E versions of the 40, but the 35 seems like it might be better behaved in stock Sony than the M 40?
p.4 #12Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 M-mount now available!
Mathieu18 wrote:
Any thoughts on the 35/1.2 in M and the 40/1.2 in M, which performs better on Sony? I know the E Version is best by far but I like M for a few reasons. Maybe it’s just the difference in M and E versions of the 40, but the 35 seems like it might be better behaved in stock Sony than the M 40?
I would say the M-mount is not inferior to the E-mount when used on a leica.
It looks pretty cool on one too 😎
Unusual?! A leica owner taking a picture of his camera ; )
p.4 #13Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 M-mount now available!
Certainly fair, but I don't have (and probably can't afford) a Leica body. I'm interested in one of the M mount lenses (though the E mount is tempting too) but curious if one or the other (35/1.2 or 40/1.2) works better on a Stock Sony. Thanks for the thoughts regardless.
SharpContrast wrote: Mathieu18 wroteAny thoughts on the 35/1.2 in M and the 40/1.2 in M, which performs better on Sony? I know the E Version is best by far but I like M for a few reasons. Maybe it’s just the difference in M and E versions of the 40, but the 35 seems like it might be better behaved in stock Sony than the M 40?I would say the M-mount is not inferior to the E-mount when used on a leica.
It looks pretty cool on one too 😎
p.4 #15Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 M-mount now available!
How is the auto focus performance with TAP at 1.2? I have an a9 and would love auto focus so my wife could use the camera too. Wanting to make sure having not as close MFD performance and less sharp edges is worth it. Since I also have an a7rii, I'd want to make sure the drop-off in sharpness isn't too bad.
Thanks
p.4 #16Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 M-mount now available!
Howie4life wrote:
How is the auto focus performance with TAP at 1.2? I have an a9 and would love auto focus so my wife could use the camera too. Wanting to make sure having not as close MFD performance and less sharp edges is worth it. Since I also have an a7rii, I'd want to make sure the drop-off in sharpness isn't too bad.
Thanks