p.1 #5Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 M-mount now available!
timerickson wrote:
Same lens design as the FE mount version? Any differences other than presumably being shaved back a bit for M mount?
One FMer has both, and the edge/corner performance on a Sony is definitively worse using the M version. So, it appears to be a different optical formula.
p.1 #7Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 M-mount now available!
But... the aperture blades aren't rounded. As we are in this forum it would be interesting to know the weight with the auto-focus adapter included. EDIT: OK, we seem to be in ALT and Sony forums.
p.1 #8Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 M-mount now available!
timerickson wrote:
Same lens design as the FE mount version? Any differences other than presumably being shaved back a bit for M mount?
Same approximate design: nothing different at the level of the block diagram.
But there must be small differences is spacing or surface geometry to compensate for the different filter stacks, as we have seen the the M version performs well on M but not as well at wider apertures on Sony.
So it's rather like 2/35ZM and Loxia 2/35. Roughly the same formula, but you do want the version optimised for your mount.
p.1 #9Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 M-mount now available!
DavidBM wrote: timerickson wroteSame lens design as the FE mount version? Any differences other than presumably being shaved back a bit for M mount?Same approximate design: nothing different at the level of the block diagram.
But there must be small differences is spacing or surface geometry to compensate for the different filter stacks, as we have seen the the M version performs well on M but not as well at wider apertures on Sony.
So it's rather like 2/35ZM and Loxia 2/35. Roughly the same formula, but you do want the version optimised for your mount.
Yes, and I think the images posted by SharpContrast shows this. (Crops at page 40 in the review thread and more posts on the subject at other pages.)
p.1 #10Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 M-mount now available!
DavidBM wrote: timerickson wroteSame lens design as the FE mount version? Any differences other than presumably being shaved back a bit for M mount?Same approximate design: nothing different at the level of the block diagram.
But there must be small differences is spacing or surface geometry to compensate for the different filter stacks, as we have seen the the M version performs well on M but not as well at wider apertures on Sony.
So it's rather like 2/35ZM and Loxia 2/35. Roughly the same formula, but you do want the version optimised for your mount.
I would certainly want the one optimized for the mount I was using, but for people who are using Sony and are willing to make the trade off in corner performance to be able to use an AF adapter I can see an argument for the approach. On a Leica camera you of course can only use the M mount version and there wouldn't be much sense in doing anything different anyway.
p.1 #11Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 M-mount now available!
Steve Spencer wrote:
I would certainly want the one optimized for the mount I was using, but for people who are using Sony and are willing to make the trade off in corner performance to be able to use an AF adapter I can see an argument for the approach. (...)
The problem is that the comparisons shown it's not only the corners that suffer. This far it seems as the M-mount version used on a Sony camera is quite a bit worse than the E-mount version everywhere but in the center. Maybe further investigations will show something else.
p.1 #13Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 M-mount now available!
Jonas B wrote: Steve Spencer wroteI would certainly want the one optimized for the mount I was using, but for people who are using Sony and are willing to make the trade off in corner performance to be able to use an AF adapter I can see an argument for the approach. (...)The problem is that the comparisons shown it's not only the corners that suffer. This far it seems as the M-mount version used on a Sony camera is quite a bit worse than the E-mount version everywhere but in the center. Maybe further investigations will show something else.
I'm not disagree Jonas, but for some people they are willing to make that trade in performance for autofocus. I certainly wouldn't make that trade off, but who am I to say what other's priorities should be. I would say if you are going to use the M lens, you probably should see if there is a front filter that can improve its performance. A front filter even seems to help the E mount version for close distance as you know and have provided some evidence for.
p.1 #14Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 M-mount now available!
Steve Spencer wrote: Jonas B wroteSteve Spencer wroteI would certainly want the one optimized for the mount I was using, but for people who are using Sony and are willing to make the trade off in corner performance to be able to use an AF adapter I can see an argument for the approach. (...)The problem is that the comparisons shown it's not only the corners that suffer. This far it seems as the M-mount version used on a Sony camera is quite a bit worse than the E-mount version everywhere but in the center. Maybe further investigations will show something else.I'm not disagree Jonas, but for some people they are willing to make that trade in performance for autofocus. I certainly wouldn't make that trade off, but who am I to say what other's priorities should be. I would say if you are going to use the M lens, you probably should see if there is a front filter that can improve its performance. A front filter even seems to help the E mount version for close distance as you know and have provided some evidence for.
Oh Steve, it was only your way to say "the corners" instead of "midzone and corners" which I think is more correct.
About front end addons... well, "some evidence" is right: My conclusion is that I will bother with the Elpro very seldom, if ever.
I can't really see anyone switching between the Elpro (or any other close-up lens) and the a PCX filter to help with the rest.
p.1 #15Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 M-mount now available!
JasonEdwardPho wrote:
I was about to pick up the 35 1.2, but this could be fantastic.
Anyone’s compare the two of them yet?
The review thread, page 44 post 13 and 14, page 45 post 4 - no direct comparisons though - only comments from us having owned both. EDIT: Came to think about it...For what camera?
p.1 #17Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 M-mount now available!
For the M240
Jonas B wrote: JasonEdwardPho wroteI was about to pick up the 35 1.2, but this could be fantastic.
Anyone’s compare the two of them yet?The review thread, page 44 post 13 and 14, page 45 post 4 - no direct comparisons though - only comments from us having owned both. EDIT: Came to think about it...For what camera?
p.1 #18Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 M-mount now available!
Please let us know! Finally got to review SharpContrast’s shots and it looked substantial...
linnil wrote:
B&H offers very good return policy. I will test if the quality drop (compared to E Mount) bothers me much, if it does, I will return it. I am hopeful.
p.1 #19Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 M-mount now available!
Ordered with FM link! 300g is sweat for f1.2 lens. It seems a lens I was always talking about Leica should make. Small size, Character WO, sharp slow down. A Well engineered photographer lens it is.
Even slightly lighter than 35lux ASPH, i also ordered heliopan 52-58mm step ring (best brass quality) to use my 58mm filter set for Leica. Also serve as small hood that cover chrome ring to avoid flare.
Finger crossed.
p.1 #20Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 M-mount now available!
Looking forward to your thoughts on it.
zhangyue wrote:
Ordered with FM link! 300g is sweat for f1.2 lens. It seems a lens I was always talking about Leica should make. Small size, Character WO, sharp slow down. A Well engineered photographer lens it is.
Even slightly lighter than 35lux ASPH, i also ordered heliopan 52-58mm step ring (best brass quality) to use my 58mm filter set for Leica. Also serve as small hood that cover chrome ring to avoid flare.
Finger crossed.