fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2017 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2017FM members A7R III first impressions

  
 
normie610
Offline
Details
p.7 #1FM members A7R III first impressions

Do you still need to pull back the highlights in post afterwards?

Fred Miranda wrote:
Today I was shooting in 'Metering Mode: Highlight' + 2EV compensation and I think it's a great automated ETTR method.

Dec 02, 2017 at 11:30 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.7 #2FM members A7R III first impressions
Is this continous high and any reading on using the low setting.
Dec 02, 2017 at 11:34 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.7 #3FM members A7R III first impressions
normie610 wrote:
Do you still need to pull back the highlights in post afterwards?

Fred Miranda wroteToday I was shooting in 'Metering Mode: Highlight' + 2EV compensation and I think it's a great automated ETTR method.


It depends if the image was over or underexposed. See, ETTR does not always mean overexposed.
In post, I have to lower exposure for some images, in others just the highlights, and in a few I have to boost the shadows. It depends.
The point is to get shadows as clean as possible.
Dec 03, 2017 at 12:08 AM
Isaacheus
Offline
Details
p.7 #4FM members A7R III first impressions
Fred Miranda wrote:
normie610 wroteDo you still need to pull back the highlights in post afterwards?

Fred Miranda wroteToday I was shooting in 'Metering Mode: Highlight' + 2EV compensation and I think it's a great automated ETTR method.
It depends if the image was over or underexposed. See, ETTR does not always mean overexposed.
In post, I have to lower exposure for some images, in others just the highlights, and in a few I have to boost the shadows. It depends.
The point is to get shadows as clean as possible.


How have you found using zebras to monitor for highlights, if you use them? Very accurate?
Dec 03, 2017 at 12:55 AM
Stoffer
Offline
Details
p.7 #5FM members A7R III first impressions
Fred Miranda wrote:
Today I was shooting in 'Metering Mode: Highlight' + 2EV compensation and I think it's a great automated ETTR method.


Excellent, thanks Fred. Have a nice Sunday.
Dec 03, 2017 at 01:33 AM
tn1krr
Offline
Details
p.7 #6FM members A7R III first impressions
Fred Miranda wrote:
Stoffer wrote
snapsy wroteJim Kasson has started his A7riii measurements. First up is the sensor readout speed for the electronic/silent shutter.

http://blog.kasson.com/a7riii/how-fast-silent-shutter/
Interesting. The readout speed is almost twice as fast, about 1/30 second, IF you set the file format to compressed raw, and the drive mode to continuous (C). Otherwise it is 1/15 second as before and as expected.
So far, based on Jim's latest tests, we could summarize it like this:
  1. Silent shutter + uncompressed raw + single shot = 14-bit precision (1/15 sensor scan time)

  2. Silent shutter + uncompressed raw + continuous-mode = 13-bit precision with same noise level as above (1/15 sensor scan time)

  3. Silent shutter + compressed raw + continuous-mode = 12-bit precision and more noise, but we get 1/30 sensor scan time.


A few new notes/corrections
* all uncompressed RAW (both continuous and single, silent or normal shutter) shot is 14 bit, excluding bulb and Long exposure NR (haven't checked about brackets)
* overall there is no such combination as uncompressed 13-bit, "13 bits" is just 14 bit data after compression has thrown away bits. This is 13 bit in shadows and gets "thinner" the higher the luminance.

Fred Miranda wrote:
How about Silent shutter + compressed + single shot?

"13 bit" with caveats explained above.

But as Jim Kasson noted about these limitations: with A7RII we only had 12-bit single with electronic shutter. No continuous, no 14-bit. The step forward is a big one. Does even the A9 do 14 bit continuous with electronic shutter?

Now if we could only confirm the noise levels between silent and mechanical shutter, specially in 14-bit cases. Would be pretty useful for timelapses etc. to shoot with electronic shutter to save thousands of mechanical shutter actuations per shoot. And there is also 2nd curtain acceleration that can potentially affect sharpness a tiny bit, specially if one is shooting continuous it can upset IBIS/OSS a tiny bit for next frame. We're in ultimate hair-splitting here, but why not get every advantage if it does not cost anything.

Dec 03, 2017 at 02:50 AM
tn1krr
Offline
Details
p.7 #7FM members A7R III first impressions
One more positive finding about A7RIII: flash delay. My Nissin Air radio flashes are super-responsive & 110% reliable whereas with the A7RII I often experienced lag/delay. I can now quite confidently shoot slight movement with TTL.

And since the A7RIII FW separates Wireless Flash toggle from Flash mode (Fill, Rear Sync...) the Nissin Air system can now shoot rear sync etc. too. This was not possible with A7RII.
Dec 03, 2017 at 03:29 AM
Stoffer
Offline
Details
p.7 #8FM members A7R III first impressions
tn1krr wrote:
One more positive finding about A7RIII: flash delay. My Nissin Air radio flashes are super-responsive & 110% reliable whereas with the A7RII I often experienced lag/delay. I can now quite confidently shoot slight movement with TTL.

And since the A7RIII FW separates Wireless Flash toggle from Flash mode (Fill, Rear Sync...) the Nissin Air system can now shoot rear sync etc. too. This was not possible with A7RII.


Wow, that sounds like a very significant improvement when working with flash. I read about this complaint with the a7rII before.
Dec 03, 2017 at 03:37 AM
Viramati
Online
Details
p.7 #9FM members A7R III first impressions
The rIII is indeed a complex beast and even coming form the A7rII it can be quite a challenge getting to grips with all the new functions and menus so I hate to to think what it must be like for a new A7 user. That said the great thing about the Sony's (as is with most cameras now) is that it is so customisable and between the custom buttons, fn button and the new 'my menu' area you can set it up so that you hardly ever need to dive further into the menus etc. it took me a longtime to get the A7rII set up exactly how I wanted it and it will be the same with this as I continue to experiment with it. Now that I have finally managed to import RAW files into Lr and no longer having to also shoot jpeg I feel that I can get more to grips with the camera. I shot a concert event last night and the addition of continuous shooting in silent mode and the better EVF are two of the things I wanted most from this camera and it live up to expectations in this respect. I wasn't seeing any enormous improvements in AF over the rII but it is early days on this and in any case I still often find that it is quicker and more accurate to use a single focus point and then recompose. I think DR in silent mode higher up the iso scale maybe be slightly better but as too IQ in general I am happy to use the rIII and rII together as I feel that for most things the differences will be minimal but obviously for critical work I would choose the rIII. I have started to experiment with touchscreen focus and I can see that this may well be useful for landscape work when using the LCD and having it set to read from a quarter of the screen while using the EVF may also work well when I get used to it and actually be quicker than using the joystick. As to the joystick in some way I prefer the A7rII with the latest firmware where you can activate the focus box and use the control-wheel four-way buttons as when turned on the focus box turns orange and is much easier to see. In fact this is one of the main issues I am having with focusing on the rIII as at times it can be difficult to see the black focus box in darker areas of the screen and I feel there should be an option to change it's colour.
Dec 03, 2017 at 04:04 AM
Chris_88
Offline
Details
p.7 #10FM members A7R III first impressions
I'm still waiting for Adobe to come up with the a7riii support, but I managed to shoot some foliage type shots with mine over the weekend. It wasn't a particularly challenging scenario, as it's sunny, but so far I like what I see: the AF with the 55 1.8 was definitely more responsive, locked on faster and while I don't have my a7rii anymore, I think the shutter sounds more damped. The button responsive is also improved, I think. Being able to "lock" pictures with c3 in default is nice. I like that feature on my D500 quite a bit.

The real test for this cam will be how well it can track BIF with the 100-400 GM. Not sure when I'll be able to check that, though.

Btw, has anybody already gotten their hands on the rss L-bracket? I'm still not sure whether to go with a case or a L-bracket this time, but I've decided to add something to the camera to avoid it taking the same beating as my a7rii.

Edited on Dec 03, 2017 at 04:43 AM · View previous versions
Dec 03, 2017 at 04:38 AM
JonathanP
Offline
Details
p.7 #11FM members A7R III first impressions
JonathanP wrote:
I just wondered if anyone who has moved from the A7rRii to Riii who wears glasses has noticed any improvement with the view into the EVF. I understand it has more resolution, but wondered if the optics have improved for glasses wearers?


Parariss wrote:
I have an a7rii and wear glasses, but I don't shoot with them on - I adjust the diopter and shoot without them. Even so, I find the eye relief to be short on the a7rii (and also the a6300). I got to handle the a7riii today. My impression is that eye relief is improved, but only very slightly.


DavidBM wrote:
You might be right, but my sense is that there is no improvement. So if there is some, it's indeed very small...


Thanks for the feedback, hopefully I’ll get a chance to try one out before too long - will be interesting to see how the higher resolution helps with manual focus.

Jonathan
Dec 03, 2017 at 04:42 AM
mcbroomf
Offline
Details
p.7 #12FM members A7R III first impressions
Pixel Perfect wrote:
Kronologix wroteAfter 17 years of knowing Canon DSLRs blindfolded, this menu system is making the learning curve a bit steeper than I anticipated. I guess once I'm more familiar with the potential of each function (and their menu location) it will get easier to program.

As far as the camera itself, I like the compactness of the body, however I miss the ergonomics of the Canon bodies, I guess things like this just part of the transition process.

Spent the day reading on researching online, I can't wait to try it on the field tomorrow.
Even using a Nikon D500 after being a Canon user for 20 years was a bit of a curve. It's now feeling more intuitive but the Nikon ergonomics aren't quite as good IMO and it definitely takes longer to set-up the camera than a Canon. The Sony reminds me more of the Olympus experience, lot's of customization, but poor menu system and not sure about the Sony manual, it's seems way too short for such an advanced camera at a paltry 96 pages, but the Olympus manual for my E-M5 was a joke.

Is there a more detailed user guide
...Show more →

The Help Guide has all the info in it. The Manual is not so good.. Online and PDF links here
https://esupport.sony.com/US/p/model-home.pl?mdl=ILCE7RM3&template_id=1®ion_id=1&tab=manuals#/manualsTab
Dec 03, 2017 at 04:49 AM
hannes
Offline
Details
p.7 #13FM members A7R III first impressions
for those who want to mix r2 and r3 shots and use capture one be warned you need to process them separatly.
there is a huge white balance difference. the two cameras behave also very different with auto wb. maybe it is the c1 profile for the r3 but I did not see this going from the r1 to the r2.

so it seems I need to get a second one ;-) but this is no problem for me because this is a fantastic camera and the first one which totally convinces me I did the right thing when I moved from canon to sony !
Dec 03, 2017 at 05:30 AM
chiron
Offline
Details
p.7 #14FM members A7R III first impressions
Matt Grum wrote:
virtualrain wroteI don't manual focus... much at all... but I wonder why you would bother now... you can zoom in to where you want to focus and then AF and watch it nail focus. Why would you even try to match that performance manually?
Shooting landscapes, where you want as much in focus as possible. With AF even if you can choose exactly where to focus that doesn't actually help. With MF you can zoom in on something in the distance, start at infinity focus and bring the focus plane forwards until the most distant objects are just starting to soften. That is then your maximum depth of field.


Matt--

In the situation you describe, how much difference do you think there would be between doing what you describe with manual focus versus using the hyperfocal rule-of-thumb and using the AF to focus about a third of the way into the scene?
Dec 03, 2017 at 07:16 AM
chiron
Offline
Details
p.7 #15FM members A7R III first impressions
Mystik wrote:
baltmin wrote
alexands wroteCan someone see if EF lenses via Metabones work better in low light than they did on the A7r2?
There is substantial improvement, they lock more easily without hunting as much and they can focus accurately outside the centre in advanced mode. However still not even close to native performance.
It's better in green mode. I wasn't impressed with AF performance in advance mode.

I think the a9 is still better in terms of adapted AF performance though


I think the Metabones firmware was updated for AF performance on the A9, but has not yet been updated to optimize AF on the A7r3. So, the Metabones performance (and the Sigma MC-11 performance) should get even better with firmware updates.

Given the volume of sales the A7r3 seems to be headed for, and how well it appears to work with adapted lenses, updated firmware by Metabones and Sigma is very likely.
Dec 03, 2017 at 07:43 AM
Parariss
Offline
Details
p.7 #16FM members A7R III first impressions
Anyone using back button focus? Which button? I got to handle an a7riii yesterday and didn't find any of the choices to feel very natural. On the a7rii the AF button forms a very natural grip. Thx
Dec 03, 2017 at 08:45 AM
Mystik
Offline
Details
p.7 #17FM members A7R III first impressions
Parariss wrote:
Anyone using back button focus? Which button? I got to handle an a7riii yesterday and didn't find any of the choices to feel very natural. On the a7rii the AF button forms a very natural grip. Thx


Yup. AEL button is assigned to back button focus. AF-On assigned to eye focus....so two back button focus buttons.
Dec 03, 2017 at 08:58 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.7 #18FM members A7R III first impressions
Mystik wrote:
Parariss wroteAnyone using back button focus? Which button? I got to handle an a7riii yesterday and didn't find any of the choices to feel very natural. On the a7rii the AF button forms a very natural grip. Thx
Yup. AEL button is assigned to back button focus. AF-On assigned to eye focus....so two back button focus buttons.


I also use both buttons for focus but I use the AEL button for EyeAF instead.
Dec 03, 2017 at 10:20 AM
Gary Clennan
Offline
Details
p.7 #19FM members A7R III first impressions
tn1krr wrote:
Now if we could only confirm the noise levels between silent and mechanical shutter, specially in 14-bit cases.


+1
Dec 03, 2017 at 10:23 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.7 #20FM members A7R III first impressions
tn1krr wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
Stoffer wrote
snapsy wroteJim Kasson has started his A7riii measurements. First up is the sensor readout speed for the electronic/silent shutter.

http://blog.kasson.com/a7riii/how-fast-silent-shutter/
Interesting. The readout speed is almost twice as fast, about 1/30 second, IF you set the file format to compressed raw, and the drive mode to continuous (C). Otherwise it is 1/15 second as before and as expected.
So far, based on Jim's latest tests, we could summarize it like this:
  1. Silent shutter + uncompressed raw + single shot = 14-bit precision (1/15 sensor scan time)

  2. Silent shutter + uncompressed raw + continuous-mode = 13-bit precision with same noise level as above (1/15 sensor scan time)

  3. Silent shutter + compressed raw + continuous-mode = 12-bit precision and more noise, but we get 1/30 sensor scan time.
A few new notes/corrections
* all uncompressed RAW (both continuous and single, silent or normal shutter) shot is 14 bit, excluding bulb and Long exposure NR (haven't checked about brackets)
* overall there is no such combination as uncompressed 13-bit, "13 bits" is just 14 bit data after compression has thrown away bits. This is 13 bit in shadows and gets "thinner" the higher the luminance.

Fred Miranda wroteHow about Silent shutter + compressed + single shot?
"13 bit" with caveats explained above.

But as Jim Kasson noted about these limitations: with A7RII we only had 12-bit single with electronic shutter. No continuous, no 14-bit. The step forward is a big one. Does even the
...Show more →

Thanks for the clarification.

So, as long as Uncompressed raw is selected we are getting 14-bits. (except bulb, long exposures and perhaps bracketing)
This goes for Mechanical shutter, Silent shutter, Single or Continuous mode and any other combination.

When using Compressed raw, we can still get 13-bits precision (which means same noise level), by using the Mechanical shutter.

However, when switching from Mechanical shutter to Silent shutter while in Continuous mode and Compressed raw, precision drops to 12 bits. Although this means more noticeable noise in the shadows, it also means sensor scan speed will be 1/30 because of the drop in precision. This is twice as fast and a better combination when using Silent shutter and slow moving subjects.
Dec 03, 2017 at 10:44 AM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister