fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2017 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2017The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!

  
 
jaybr
Offline
Details
p.21 #1The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
I'm happy with it 👍
J
Oct 07, 2017 at 06:52 PM
jhinkey
Offline
Details
p.21 #2The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
baltmin wrote:
jhinkey wrote
baltmin wroteAfter looking more thoroughly at the samples we have so far I'm pretty sure that there is a lot of field curvature, which explains the mid frame/corner softness.
Here is an example from Juha's samples (converted from raw with ACR, vignetting corrected),

https://www.flickr.com/photos/41555552@N00/37502412006/in/dateposted-public/ (copy and paste the entire link to make it work)

The blue sign on the left bottom corner looks focused and reasonably sharp, even at f1.2 (compared to f2.2) whereas the mid frame background is blurred and out of focus (gets better at f2.2).

Mid frame infinity focus test will be very useful for conclusions.
Hmm . . . not sure where the intended focus point is in that picture - the mid-frame background better be out of focus if the sign is the intended focus plane.
Sorry I should have posted the photo from where the crops are taken.

It's from Juha Kannisto's album, and the photo according to his words is focused in the centre, in the most distant building: https://photos.google.com/share/AF1QipP4yNWPOJPWIVWuT84t-_I942VGjts51StpD12SDfJelD0HRw1lzueaVEeLauHEpA?key=NkZBUXkyVlhPb1Y0UzBhOVhCTVNyX1FwX1NUdHh3

He has also shared with us the raw files, which I used to support my comment.


I downloaded the raw files and it appears to be focused far away and has a lot of backward FC? The very 3D subject of those test images makes it hard to tell what FC, focus point, etc.
I must say, stopped down to f/2.8 it looks pretty good all over.

Does the A9 have a LPF? The images seem to look that way to me.
Oct 07, 2017 at 07:15 PM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.21 #3The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
Ok I have confirmed that the relative corner unsharpness is definitely field curvature related, and have updated my review at https://phillipreeve.net/blog/voigtlander-40mm-f1-2-nokton-aspherical-rolling-review/

Please look, but I won't make you click if you don't want to: check out these crops:





Oct 07, 2017 at 07:34 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.21 #4The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
DavidBM wrote:
Ok I have confirmed that the relative corner unsharpness is definitely field curvature related, and have updated my review at https://phillipreeve.net/blog/voigtlander-40mm-f1-2-nokton-aspherical-rolling-review/

Please look, but I won't make you click if you don't want to: check out these crops:

Very important update David! It shows it's sharp towards the edges (like we saw in other samples posted on this thread) but the lens is not flat-field at infinity distance.
Oct 07, 2017 at 07:41 PM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.21 #5The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
Fred Miranda wrote:
DavidBM wroteOk I have confirmed that the relative corner unsharpness is definitely field curvature related, and have updated my review at https://phillipreeve.net/blog/voigtlander-40mm-f1-2-nokton-aspherical-rolling-review/

Please look, but I won't make you click if you don't want to: check out these crops:
Very important update David! It shows it's sharp towards the edges (like we saw in other samples posted on this thread) but the lens is not flat-field at infinity distance.


Far from flat field, Fred.
And the odd thing is the shape of the curvature is strange.
It seems that corner focus gives good results in the corner (obviously) surprisingly good results in the midfield, and it's a relatively small central area where the plane of focus bulges forward. So focussing on the midfield would likely have given good results in the corners, as in some crops.

At least that's how it seems. So the big question for landscape use is whether there is a compromise focus position that gives good results across the field. I hope so, but the difference is large enough that I worry...

Here's the difference between the centre focussed for corner and then focussed for centre, wide open.











Edited on Oct 07, 2017 at 07:52 PM · View previous versions
Oct 07, 2017 at 07:47 PM
davewolfs
Offline
Details
p.21 #6The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
Not sure If these samples were already posted.

http://mypace.hatenablog.com

The author states that an ND was used. Also confirms some of the other comments softer at 1.2-1.4 sharpens up nicely at f/2 and CA when wide open which can be removed in LR.

Edited on Oct 07, 2017 at 08:14 PM · View previous versions
Oct 07, 2017 at 07:52 PM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.21 #7The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
Fred Miranda wrote:
DavidBM wroteOk I have confirmed that the relative corner unsharpness is definitely field curvature related, and have updated my review at https://phillipreeve.net/blog/voigtlander-40mm-f1-2-nokton-aspherical-rolling-review/

Please look, but I won't make you click if you don't want to: check out these crops:
Very important update David! It shows it's sharp towards the edges (like we saw in other samples posted on this thread) but the lens is not flat-field at infinity distance.


Incidentally the corners are good close to the hard stop, the centre much closer - more like 5m - so anyone focussing at infinity taking the hard stop as a guide would end up with good corners!
Oct 07, 2017 at 07:53 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.21 #8The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
DavidBM wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
DavidBM wroteOk I have confirmed that the relative corner unsharpness is definitely field curvature related, and have updated my review at https://phillipreeve.net/blog/voigtlander-40mm-f1-2-nokton-aspherical-rolling-review/

Please look, but I won't make you click if you don't want to: check out these crops:
Very important update David! It shows it's sharp towards the edges (like we saw in other samples posted on this thread) but the lens is not flat-field at infinity distance.
Incidentally the corners are good close to the hard stop, the centre much closer - more like 5m - so anyone focussing at infinity taking the hard stop as a guide would end up with good corners!


If that's the case, the FC shape could be similar to Loxia 21's where the hard stop gives perfect corners and a small tad before it, perfect center. However from your description of "going towards 5m for the center", FC seems to be a little more pronounced in comparison.
I knew there was FC when checking some samples showing the OOF rendering wide open and now you've confirmed its intensity at infinity. (Not too bad)
Oct 07, 2017 at 08:00 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.21 #9The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
DavidBM wrote:
Ok I have confirmed that the relative corner unsharpness is definitely field curvature related, and have updated my review at https://phillipreeve.net/blog/voigtlander-40mm-f1-2-nokton-aspherical-rolling-review/

Please look, but I won't make you click if you don't want to: check out these crops:


It doesn't look severe, but there is a bit of field curvature. Perhaps a mid zone focus could get sharpness across the frame at least at smaller apertures.
Oct 07, 2017 at 08:01 PM
jhinkey
Offline
Details
p.21 #10The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
davewolfs wrote:
Not sure If these were posted more samples.

http://mypace.hatenablog.com


Nice.

Those images are a great reminder of what kind of images can be made with a technically non-perfect lens such as the 40/1.2.
Oct 07, 2017 at 08:04 PM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.21 #11The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
Fred Miranda wrote:
DavidBM wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
DavidBM wroteOk I have confirmed that the relative corner unsharpness is definitely field curvature related, and have updated my review at https://phillipreeve.net/blog/voigtlander-40mm-f1-2-nokton-aspherical-rolling-review/

Please look, but I won't make you click if you don't want to: check out these crops:
Very important update David! It shows it's sharp towards the edges (like we saw in other samples posted on this thread) but the lens is not flat-field at infinity distance.
Incidentally the corners are good close to the hard stop, the centre much closer - more like 5m - so anyone focussing at infinity taking the hard stop as a guide would end up with good corners!
If that's the case, the FC shape could be similar to Loxia 21's where the hard stop gives perfect corners and a small tad before it perfect center. However from your description of "going towards 5m for the center", FC seems to be a little more pronounced in comparison.
I knew there was FC when checking some samples showing the OOF rendering wide open and now you've confirmed its intensity at infinity. (Not too bad)


Yes that sounds about right, just two differences with the Lox

(1) a little more than a tad
(2) the part of the frame that is better with centre focus is a smaller area than with Lox.

But knowing this behaviour makes a huge difference: if you wanted this lens for its rendering, you should be able to get excellent landscape quality with it as well with a bit of care and attention.
Oct 07, 2017 at 08:13 PM
Juha Kannisto
Offline
Details
p.21 #12The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
For me with my A9 and the 40/1.2, the center is actually best very close to hard infinity, around the middle of the first loop of the infinity symbol. On my long distance shots I always focused on the center area by checking with magnified view and it was always just before hard infinity and the corners get very good at the same distance from f2.8. So maybe there is some variation, don't know why A7rII and A9 would make a difference here.

I used the same focusing position many times later on as well with other long distance photos, after reconfirming with magnified view on the center area.
Oct 07, 2017 at 08:47 PM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.21 #13The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
Juha Kannisto wrote:
For me with my A9 and the 40/1.2, the center is actually best very close to hard infinity, around the middle of the first loop of the infinity symbol. On my long distance shots I always focused on the center area by checking with magnified view and it was always just before hard infinity and the corners get very good at the same distance from f2.8. So maybe there is some variation, don't know why A7rII and A9 would make a difference here.

I used the same focusing position many times later on as well with other long distance photos,
...Show more →

Interesting, and a bit odd.
I guess A7rII crops will make the differences more obvious.

As for variation, variation in the calibration of the focussing ring is very likely, which could explain where best central focus is for you.

But variation in the actual amount of field curvature would be a bit surprising, except perhaps in a tilted or decentred lens, which neither of ours seem to be...
Oct 07, 2017 at 09:01 PM
Juha Kannisto
Offline
Details
p.21 #14The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
Yes a bit strange. I fully trust your results of course but I'm also sure that for me the center infinity is very close to hard infinity. I'll try to take some shots with my A7r (v1) today as well and see if it works differently there than on my A9. The camera hasn't seen any use since February or so
Oct 07, 2017 at 09:27 PM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.21 #15The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
Juha Kannisto wrote:
Yes a bit strange. I fully trust your results of course but I'm also sure that for me the center infinity is very close to hard infinity. I'll try to take some shots with my A7r (v1) today as well and see if it works differently there than on my A9. The camera hasn't seen any use since February or so


And I yours! If it is variation in the calibration of the hard stop, and centre focus on your lens is very close indeed to the hard stop, then I wonder if it's possible to focus to the best corner position, since that might then be *behind* the hard stop?
Oct 07, 2017 at 09:34 PM
Juha Kannisto
Offline
Details
p.21 #16The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!


DavidBM wrote:
Juha Kannisto wroteYes a bit strange. I fully trust your results of course but I'm also sure that for me the center infinity is very close to hard infinity. I'll try to take some shots with my A7r (v1) today as well and see if it works differently there than on my A9. The camera hasn't seen any use since February or so
And I yours! If it is variation in the calibration of the hard stop, and centre focus on your lens is very close indeed to the hard stop, then I wonder if it's possible to focus to the best corner position, since that might then be *behind* the hard stop?


I'll try focusing on the corners as well to see if the best infinity focus appears at a different position than it does for center, I haven't actually tried that yet as the corners looked good with center based focusing.

My lens has a hard stop a hair after midpoint of infinity symbol. My 65/2 goes a bit further than that.
Oct 07, 2017 at 09:48 PM
Juha Kannisto
Offline
Details
p.21 #17The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
A quick focusing test outdoors with my A9 and 40/1.2:
I'm getting best infinity for center as well as left extreme edge and corners at the same point where focus mark is in the middle of the first loop of the infinity symbol. Confirmed visually and with peaking (set to Low) in magnified view. Camera shows focus distance as infinity at that position as well (seems to be one step before hard end on the focusing distance bar shown on viewfinder). I wonder if camera's focus distance info can be found in EXIF somewhere, that could be a useful reference as well...

This was tested at f1.2.
Oct 07, 2017 at 11:06 PM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.21 #18The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
Juha Kannisto wrote:
A quick focusing test outdoors with my A9 and 40/1.2:
I'm getting best infinity for center as well as left extreme edge and corners at the same point where focus mark is in the middle of the first loop of the infinity symbol. Confirmed visually and with peaking (set to Low) in magnified view. Camera shows focus distance as infinity at that position as well (seems to be one step before hard end on the focusing distance bar shown on viewfinder). I wonder if camera's focus distance info can be found in EXIF somewhere, that could be a useful reference
...Show more →

That's astonishing.

Before we assume there is sample variation, perhaps you could do some 100% tripod mounted samples
(I don't think I could have spotted this effect through the viewfinder or with peaking)
It's especially hard to tell because best you really need to focus open, but at f1.2, corner resolution there is so low that it's quite hard to focus.

But as you saw from my crops the difference is very real:

The corner focused crops are much better in the corners, and the effect is confirmed by the fact that the corner focus crops are much worse in the centre.

So what we'd need to see to be sure that another copy is significantly different in this respect is:

An aperture series of wide open to f8 focussed on the extreme corner (it's best to do it three times and choose the one that is best in the corner)

An aperture series of the same apertures focussed in the centre (again, do it three times and choose the one this time best in the centre).

Then compare the two series in the extreme corner, and in the centre.

If your lens is like mine, the corner focussed series will always be visibly better than the centre focussed series in the corners (getting close at f8)
The centre focused series will be much better than the corner focussed series in the centre, though getting almost the same by f8.

If they look exactly the same, then there is substantial variation in the field curvature of these lenses.

Don't think I'm putting pressure on to do this slightly tedious comparison! Maybe you've tested yours enough to be sure that it's fine at 24 MP and that focussing just off infinity works for you across the field. On my copy, I'd focus close to infinity rather than where it's best for the centre, to get best overall results.


Oct 07, 2017 at 11:25 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.21 #19The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
Just a thought folks focusing at 1.2 maybe very hard to do as its so dang paper thin. Maybe try at 1.7 or f2 that you maybe more used too and easier to nail the correct spot when focusing. You maybe getting thrown off by the fast speed. You don't want to stop down anymore than this as DOF could throw you off but try 1.7 and see if your nailing it better.
Oct 07, 2017 at 11:40 PM
Juha Kannisto
Offline
Details
p.21 #20The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
I'll try to do some more aperture series today with a tripod, probably not the full test but something in that direction with both A9 and A7r (got some batteries charged now).

It's true that corner and edge resolution at f1.2 is not good but the peaking differences were obvious (my targets were street side buildings far away) , with best peaking at similar point where I get the best center.
Oct 07, 2017 at 11:43 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister