p.25 #1The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
DavidBM wrote: freaklikeme wroteDavidBM wroteAnother update to my review: this time to figure out what focussing position is best for across the frame infinity sharpness at f8.
I confirm the earlier finding that focus on the centre gives best results in the centre, but at the cost of poorer corners. And focussing on the corners gives the best corners, but a less good centre.
Focussing on the outer midfield give a centre almost as good as focussing on the centre, and corners almost as good as focussing on the corner.
There are some small crops showing this behaviour.
And just a note to you all: these differences are visible at 100%; less so at 50% and therefore a bit less so on a 24MP and certainly 12MP sensor. And you can only detect them with crops, and focussing by eye and bracketing. The differences in the position of the ring are very hard to see.
(I realise I wrote something earlier which gave the wrong impression: I meant to say that the best results in the centre are towards the 5m mark - it being the next mark - but I think I may have said that it is *near* the 5m mark, which gives the wrong impression!)Curious. I wonder if this lens would perform better on a Kolari modded camera or with a PCX solution.
Thanks for the review, by the way. It's been excellent reading. It would be interesting to see this lens compared to an nFD 50L and plain MD 50/1.2. Those would be my pick of the fast classics to give this one a run for its money.I think the Kolari mod would make it extreme the other way, but I'm not sure. And the FC is mild enough - and, I think, sufficiently confined to the edges, that it would be hard to fix with a spherical profile PCX lens.
But don't make too much of it! It's exactly as bad as the crops show, at 100% and 42MP. And midfield focussing (like on the Loxia 21) pretty much fixes it for practical purposes. Which isn't true of lenses for the M stack that need PCX lens.
Oh, I'm not making too much of it. I'm just curious. Probably curious enough to add it to my rental list when LR gets their stock if sebboh doesn't post away that curiosity first.
p.25 #2The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
sebboh wrote: freaklikeme wroteDavidBM wroteAnother update to my review: this time to figure out what focussing position is best for across the frame infinity sharpness at f8.
I confirm the earlier finding that focus on the centre gives best results in the centre, but at the cost of poorer corners. And focussing on the corners gives the best corners, but a less good centre.
Focussing on the outer midfield give a centre almost as good as focussing on the centre, and corners almost as good as focussing on the corner.
There are some small crops showing this behaviour.
And just a note to you all: these differences are visible at 100%; less so at 50% and therefore a bit less so on a 24MP and certainly 12MP sensor. And you can only detect them with crops, and focussing by eye and bracketing. The differences in the position of the ring are very hard to see.
(I realise I wrote something earlier which gave the wrong impression: I meant to say that the best results in the centre are towards the 5m mark - it being the next mark - but I think I may have said that it is *near* the 5m mark, which gives the wrong impression!)Curious. I wonder if this lens would perform better on a Kolari modded camera or with a PCX solution.doesn't the field curvature go the opposite way of the m-mount lenses?
freaklikeme wroteThanks for the review, by the way. It's been excellent reading. It would be interesting to see this lens compared to an nFD 50L and plain MD 50/1.2. Those would be my pick of the fast classics to give this one a run for its money.how are you liking the MD 50/1.2?
DavidBM wroteDavidBM wrotefreaklikeme wroteDavidBM wroteAnother update to my review: this time to figure out what focussing position is best for across the frame infinity sharpness at f8.
I confirm the earlier finding that focus on the centre gives best results in the centre, but at the cost of poorer corners. And focussing on the corners gives the best corners, but a less good centre.
Focussing on the outer midfield give a centre almost as good as focussing on the centre, and corners almost as good as focussing on the corner.
There are some small crops showing this behaviour.
And just a note to you all: these differences are visible at 100%; less so at 50% and therefore a bit less so on a 24MP and certainly 12MP sensor. And you can only detect them with crops, and focussing by eye and bracketing. The differences in the position of the ring are very hard to see.
(I realise I wrote something earlier which gave the wrong impression: I meant to say that the best results in the centre are towards the 5m mark - it being the next mark - but I think I may have said that it is *near* the 5m mark, which gives the wrong impression!)Curious. I wonder if this lens would perform better on a Kolari modded camera or with a PCX solution.
Thanks for the review, by the way. It's been excellent reading. It would be interesting to see this lens compared to an nFD 50L and plain MD 50/1.2. Those would be my pick of the fast classics to give this one a run for its money.I think the Kolari mod would make it extreme the other way, but I'm not sure. And the FC is mild enough - and, I think, sufficiently confined to the edges, that it would be hard to fix with a spherical profile PCX lens.
But don't make too much of it! It's exactly as bad as the crops show, at 100% and 42MP. And midfield focussing (like on the Loxia 21) pretty much fixes it for practical purposes. Which isn't true of lenses for the M stack that need PCX lens.As for comparison with classic 1.2/50s: I haven't used them all, my own preference is for the OM50 (not 55) but I've tried a few others - including the EF Canon. I hate saying stuff without proof; but it seems to me that this little lens has better, less hazy performance at wide apertures, more contrast, and bokeh is up the with the best of them. (modulo situations in which you get onion rings). But the ashperes that cause the onion rings buy you a lot of goodness in situations where there aren't any onion rings!it certainly seems less hazy on focus than most classic f/1.2 lenses, that doesn't necessarily translate into greater resolving power though. for some lenses there can be very high resolution through the haze while others have neither sharpness nor contrast. unfortunately, it also has less haze in the oof region by the looks of it, which translates into a higher contrast bokeh. the more even correction of SA should make bokeh smoother than most f/1.2 lenses though...
The bokeh is pretty smooth, and when I'm making actual images rather than reviewing, I'm happy to slightly reduce contrast in post in the bokeh when needed. You can losslessly reduce contrast, but can't losslessly increase it.
p.25 #3The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
DavidBM wrote: DavidBM wrotefreaklikeme wroteDavidBM wroteAnother update to my review: this time to figure out what focussing position is best for across the frame infinity sharpness at f8.
I confirm the earlier finding that focus on the centre gives best results in the centre, but at the cost of poorer corners. And focussing on the corners gives the best corners, but a less good centre.
Focussing on the outer midfield give a centre almost as good as focussing on the centre, and corners almost as good as focussing on the corner.
There are some small crops showing this behaviour.
And just a note to you all: these differences are visible at 100%; less so at 50% and therefore a bit less so on a 24MP and certainly 12MP sensor. And you can only detect them with crops, and focussing by eye and bracketing. The differences in the position of the ring are very hard to see.
(I realise I wrote something earlier which gave the wrong impression: I meant to say that the best results in the centre are towards the 5m mark - it being the next mark - but I think I may have said that it is *near* the 5m mark, which gives the wrong impression!)Curious. I wonder if this lens would perform better on a Kolari modded camera or with a PCX solution.
Thanks for the review, by the way. It's been excellent reading. It would be interesting to see this lens compared to an nFD 50L and plain MD 50/1.2. Those would be my pick of the fast classics to give this one a run for its money.I think the Kolari mod would make it extreme the other way, but I'm not sure. And the FC is mild enough - and, I think, sufficiently confined to the edges, that it would be hard to fix with a spherical profile PCX lens.
But don't make too much of it! It's exactly as bad as the crops show, at 100% and 42MP. And midfield focussing (like on the Loxia 21) pretty much fixes it for practical purposes. Which isn't true of lenses for the M stack that need PCX lens.As for comparison with classic 1.2/50s: I haven't used them all, my own preference is for the OM50 (not 55) but I've tried a few others - including the EF Canon. I hate saying stuff without proof; but it seems to me that this little lens has better, less hazy performance at wide apertures, more contrast, and bokeh is up the with the best of them. (modulo situations in which you get onion rings). But the ashperes that cause the onion rings buy you a lot of goodness in situations where there aren't any onion rings!
Yeah, there's no point in speculating without hope of answering the question, and I certainly won't be answering it unless we find a fast normal addict willing to test for us. I'm not sure either of my picks could match it in center resolution, but they are very even tempered lenses across the frame stopped down a bit.
p.25 #4The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
DavidBM wrote: sebboh wrotefreaklikeme wroteDavidBM wroteAnother update to my review: this time to figure out what focussing position is best for across the frame infinity sharpness at f8.
I confirm the earlier finding that focus on the centre gives best results in the centre, but at the cost of poorer corners. And focussing on the corners gives the best corners, but a less good centre.
Focussing on the outer midfield give a centre almost as good as focussing on the centre, and corners almost as good as focussing on the corner.
There are some small crops showing this behaviour.
And just a note to you all: these differences are visible at 100%; less so at 50% and therefore a bit less so on a 24MP and certainly 12MP sensor. And you can only detect them with crops, and focussing by eye and bracketing. The differences in the position of the ring are very hard to see.
(I realise I wrote something earlier which gave the wrong impression: I meant to say that the best results in the centre are towards the 5m mark - it being the next mark - but I think I may have said that it is *near* the 5m mark, which gives the wrong impression!)Curious. I wonder if this lens would perform better on a Kolari modded camera or with a PCX solution.doesn't the field curvature go the opposite way of the m-mount lenses?
freaklikeme wroteThanks for the review, by the way. It's been excellent reading. It would be interesting to see this lens compared to an nFD 50L and plain MD 50/1.2. Those would be my pick of the fast classics to give this one a run for its money.how are you liking the MD 50/1.2?
DavidBM wroteDavidBM wrotefreaklikeme wroteDavidBM wroteAnother update to my review: this time to figure out what focussing position is best for across the frame infinity sharpness at f8.
I confirm the earlier finding that focus on the centre gives best results in the centre, but at the cost of poorer corners. And focussing on the corners gives the best corners, but a less good centre.
Focussing on the outer midfield give a centre almost as good as focussing on the centre, and corners almost as good as focussing on the corner.
There are some small crops showing this behaviour.
And just a note to you all: these differences are visible at 100%; less so at 50% and therefore a bit less so on a 24MP and certainly 12MP sensor. And you can only detect them with crops, and focussing by eye and bracketing. The differences in the position of the ring are very hard to see.
(I realise I wrote something earlier which gave the wrong impression: I meant to say that the best results in the centre are towards the 5m mark - it being the next mark - but I think I may have said that it is *near* the 5m mark, which gives the wrong impression!)Curious. I wonder if this lens would perform better on a Kolari modded camera or with a PCX solution.
Thanks for the review, by the way. It's been excellent reading. It would be interesting to see this lens compared to an nFD 50L and plain MD 50/1.2. Those would be my pick of the fast classics to give this one a run for its money.I think the Kolari mod would make it extreme the other way, but I'm not sure. And the FC is mild enough - and, I think, sufficiently confined to the edges, that it would be hard to fix with a spherical profile PCX lens.
But don't make too much of it! It's exactly as bad as the crops show, at 100% and 42MP. And midfield focussing (like on the Loxia 21) pretty much fixes it for practical purposes. Which isn't true of lenses for the M stack that need PCX lens.As for comparison with classic 1.2/50s: I haven't used them all, my own preference is for the OM50 (not 55) but I've tried a few others - including the EF Canon. I hate saying stuff without proof; but it seems to me that this little lens has better, less hazy performance at wide apertures, more contrast, and bokeh is up the with the best of them. (modulo situations in which you get onion rings). But the ashperes that cause the onion rings buy you a lot of goodness in situations where there aren't any onion rings!it certainly seems less hazy on focus than most classic f/1.2 lenses, that doesn't necessarily translate into greater resolving power though. for some lenses there can be very high resolution through the haze while others have neither sharpness nor contrast. unfortunately, it also has less haze in the oof region by the looks of it, which translates into a higher contrast bokeh. the more even correction of SA should make bokeh smoother than most f/1.2 lenses though...The bokeh is pretty smooth, and when I'm making actual images rather than reviewing, I'm happy to slightly reduce contrast in post in the bokeh when needed. You can losslessly reduce contrast, but can't losslessly increase it.
i'm generally not a fan of fiddling with contrast locally or trying to fix bokeh in post, just tends to do more harm than good imo.
freaklikeme wrote: DavidBM wrotefreaklikeme wroteDavidBM wroteAnother update to my review: this time to figure out what focussing position is best for across the frame infinity sharpness at f8.
I confirm the earlier finding that focus on the centre gives best results in the centre, but at the cost of poorer corners. And focussing on the corners gives the best corners, but a less good centre.
Focussing on the outer midfield give a centre almost as good as focussing on the centre, and corners almost as good as focussing on the corner.
There are some small crops showing this behaviour.
And just a note to you all: these differences are visible at 100%; less so at 50% and therefore a bit less so on a 24MP and certainly 12MP sensor. And you can only detect them with crops, and focussing by eye and bracketing. The differences in the position of the ring are very hard to see.
(I realise I wrote something earlier which gave the wrong impression: I meant to say that the best results in the centre are towards the 5m mark - it being the next mark - but I think I may have said that it is *near* the 5m mark, which gives the wrong impression!)Curious. I wonder if this lens would perform better on a Kolari modded camera or with a PCX solution.
Thanks for the review, by the way. It's been excellent reading. It would be interesting to see this lens compared to an nFD 50L and plain MD 50/1.2. Those would be my pick of the fast classics to give this one a run for its money.I think the Kolari mod would make it extreme the other way, but I'm not sure. And the FC is mild enough - and, I think, sufficiently confined to the edges, that it would be hard to fix with a spherical profile PCX lens.
But don't make too much of it! It's exactly as bad as the crops show, at 100% and 42MP. And midfield focussing (like on the Loxia 21) pretty much fixes it for practical purposes. Which isn't true of lenses for the M stack that need PCX lens.Oh, I'm not making too much of it. I'm just curious. Probably curious enough to add it to my rental list when LR gets their stock if sebboh doesn't post away that curiosity first.
p.25 #5The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
'the onion rings buy you a lot of goodness in situations' - never a truer word, and it's the conclusion the design community has reached as well, if used in moderation. It looks like a lens that works better than it tests.
p.25 #6The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
sebboh wrote:
how are you liking the MD 50/1.2?
I liked it so much, I sold it. If I were picking between it and the FD 50L, the Nikon AIS 50/1.2, and the Oly 50/1.2, I would pick the Minolta. Very nice draw wide open, decent bokeh, best out-of-camera color, decently corrected, and, like I said, very even-tempered stopped down.
Compared to the 58/1.2 and its performance with high-key monochromes, its beautiful landscape draw at wide apertures, and portrait perfection, they all became also-rans. I have a little more hope for 7artisans 50/1.1 because it's an M-mount, which will make it an easy choice to take with an all M-mount kit, but I'm done trying to replace the Rokkor. Like with the Mandler 35 and 90, I don't mind using it for everything, and when I feel like it's right for a shot, there is no substitute.
p.25 #7The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
sebboh wrote:
hey, i'm excited about the lens.
I know. That wasn't intended as a knock against you, or anyone interested in the lens. My lack of interest in ownership has much more to with my contentment with my 35mm combo than anything I've seen in the tests. It's a great focal length, speed, and looks to be a strong performer in many ways. I'm just happy your interest and ownership of a Kolari modded camera will save me a rental to satisfy my stupid curiosity.
p.25 #8The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
freaklikeme wrote: sebboh wrotehow are you liking the MD 50/1.2?I liked it so much, I sold it. If I were picking between it and the FD 50L, the Nikon AIS 50/1.2, and the Oly 50/1.2, I would pick the Minolta. Very nice draw wide open, decent bokeh, best out-of-camera color, decently corrected, and, like I said, very even-tempered stopped down.
Compared to the 58/1.2 and its performance with high-key monochromes, its beautiful landscape draw at wide apertures, and portrait perfection, they all became also-rans. I have a little more hope for 7artisans 50/1.1 because it's an M-mount, which will make it an easy choice to take with an all M-mount kit, but I'm done trying to replace the Rokkor. Like with the Mandler 35 and 90, I don't mind using it for everything, and when I feel like it's right for a shot, there is no substitute....Show more →
yeah, i keep contemplate buying an MD again as i quite like it's look wide open, but i already have a few other f/1.2 lenses laying around that hardly ever see any use compared to the 58/1.2...
freaklikeme wrote: sebboh wrotehey, i'm excited about the lens.I know. That wasn't intended as a knock against you, or anyone interested in the lens. My lack of interest in ownership has much more to with my contentment with my 35mm combo than anything I've seen in the tests. It's a great focal length, speed, and looks to be a strong performer in many ways. I'm just happy your interest and ownership of a Kolari modded camera will save me a rental to satisfy my stupid curiosity.
i'll keep you updated when i try it. might be a little while though, i'm still figuring out the cv 50/1.5. might have to wait for the second time Guy buys it and sells it to buy it off him.
p.25 #9The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
They CV 50 1.5 I really liked but the mid frame falloff killed me as i shot some engagement shots and almost blew it with that lens as a couple shots even at like F4 the mid frame went to soft, but I did cover myself but it threw me for a loop when processing it all out. It does have a really nice look to it
Actually that would be a interesting test the CV 50 1.5 and this 40 1.2 although slower it seems to have the same type of look.
p.25 #10The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
sebboh wrote: freaklikeme wrotesebboh wrotehow are you liking the MD 50/1.2?I liked it so much, I sold it. If I were picking between it and the FD 50L, the Nikon AIS 50/1.2, and the Oly 50/1.2, I would pick the Minolta. Very nice draw wide open, decent bokeh, best out-of-camera color, decently corrected, and, like I said, very even-tempered stopped down.
Compared to the 58/1.2 and its performance with high-key monochromes, its beautiful landscape draw at wide apertures, and portrait perfection, they all became also-rans. I have a little more hope for 7artisans 50/1.1 because it's an M-mount, which will make it an easy choice to take with an all M-mount kit, but I'm done trying to replace the Rokkor. Like with the Mandler 35 and 90, I don't mind using it for everything, and when I feel like it's right for a shot, there is no substitute.yeah, i keep contemplate buying an MD again as i quite like it's look wide open, but i already have a few other f/1.2 lenses laying around that hardly ever see any use compared to the 58/1.2...
freaklikeme wrotesebboh wrotehey, i'm excited about the lens.I know. That wasn't intended as a knock against you, or anyone interested in the lens. My lack of interest in ownership has much more to with my contentment with my 35mm combo than anything I've seen in the tests. It's a great focal length, speed, and looks to be a strong performer in many ways. I'm just happy your interest and ownership of a Kolari modded camera will save me a rental to satisfy my stupid curiosity.i'll keep you updated when i try it. might be a little while though, i'm still figuring out the cv 50/1.5. might have to wait for the second time Guy buys it and sells it to buy it off him.
Lens designers would have a hard time developing a lens for your taste!
Do you like shooting with any modern lens?
p.25 #11The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
Fred Miranda wrote: sebboh wrotefreaklikeme wrotesebboh wrotehow are you liking the MD 50/1.2?I liked it so much, I sold it. If I were picking between it and the FD 50L, the Nikon AIS 50/1.2, and the Oly 50/1.2, I would pick the Minolta. Very nice draw wide open, decent bokeh, best out-of-camera color, decently corrected, and, like I said, very even-tempered stopped down.
Compared to the 58/1.2 and its performance with high-key monochromes, its beautiful landscape draw at wide apertures, and portrait perfection, they all became also-rans. I have a little more hope for 7artisans 50/1.1 because it's an M-mount, which will make it an easy choice to take with an all M-mount kit, but I'm done trying to replace the Rokkor. Like with the Mandler 35 and 90, I don't mind using it for everything, and when I feel like it's right for a shot, there is no substitute.yeah, i keep contemplate buying an MD again as i quite like it's look wide open, but i already have a few other f/1.2 lenses laying around that hardly ever see any use compared to the 58/1.2...
freaklikeme wrotesebboh wrotehey, i'm excited about the lens.I know. That wasn't intended as a knock against you, or anyone interested in the lens. My lack of interest in ownership has much more to with my contentment with my 35mm combo than anything I've seen in the tests. It's a great focal length, speed, and looks to be a strong performer in many ways. I'm just happy your interest and ownership of a Kolari modded camera will save me a rental to satisfy my stupid curiosity.i'll keep you updated when i try it. might be a little while though, i'm still figuring out the cv 50/1.5. might have to wait for the second time Guy buys it and sells it to buy it off him. Lens designers would have a hard time developing a lens for your taste!
Do you like shooting with any modern lens?
the rx1 lens is fantastic (i don't enjoy the ergonomics though). the 50 lux asph, 28 cron, and cv 125/2.5 APO really impressed me when i shot with them. the minolta 85/1.4 limited and ZE 35/1.4 are relatively modern lens that i really like the look of. i like the zm 35/1.4, zm 50/1.5 sonnar, cv 35/1.7, and cv 50/1.5, but they all have things that annoy me about their look.
p.25 #12The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
At the end of last weekend on the blue ridge parkway, I came back from the mountains with a bunch of images from the Loxia 35@f/8 and they are sharp and contrasty from center to all 4 corners, with perfect sunstars.
I really have nothing to complain with that lens at landscape apertures.
I am tempted to try the 40/1.2 at some point, for closeup nature bokeh images, but I definitely don't need to be in any enormous rush to replace the Loxia.
p.25 #13The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
lightskyland wrote:
At the end of last weekend on the blue ridge parkway, I came back from the mountains with a bunch of images from the Loxia 35@f/8 and they are sharp and contrasty from center to all 4 corners, with perfect sunstars.
I really have nothing to complain with that lens at landscape apertures.
I am tempted to try the 40/1.2 at some point, for closeup nature bokeh images, but I definitely don't need to be in any enormous rush to replace the Loxia.
My 2 cents.
How were the fall colors? I am headed to NC next week and hope I don't miss it....
p.25 #14The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
Luvwine wrote: lightskyland wroteAt the end of last weekend on the blue ridge parkway, I came back from the mountains with a bunch of images from the Loxia 35@f/8 and they are sharp and contrasty from center to all 4 corners, with perfect sunstars.
I really have nothing to complain with that lens at landscape apertures.
I am tempted to try the 40/1.2 at some point, for closeup nature bokeh images, but I definitely don't need to be in any enormous rush to replace the Loxia.
My 2 cents.How were the fall colors? I am headed to NC next week and hope I don't miss it....
Colors were very good at Graveyard Fields and the best I've ever seen up at Rough Ridge (on Grandfather Mountain).
Everywhere else was very early, but with a few signs of color starting to show at the lower elevations.
I think next week will be good along the 3000'-4000' areas of the parkway. Probably a couple weeks later for the valleys / waterfall areas.
p.25 #15The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
sebboh wrote: Fred Miranda wrotesebboh wrotefreaklikeme wrotesebboh wrotehow are you liking the MD 50/1.2?I liked it so much, I sold it. If I were picking between it and the FD 50L, the Nikon AIS 50/1.2, and the Oly 50/1.2, I would pick the Minolta. Very nice draw wide open, decent bokeh, best out-of-camera color, decently corrected, and, like I said, very even-tempered stopped down.
Compared to the 58/1.2 and its performance with high-key monochromes, its beautiful landscape draw at wide apertures, and portrait perfection, they all became also-rans. I have a little more hope for 7artisans 50/1.1 because it's an M-mount, which will make it an easy choice to take with an all M-mount kit, but I'm done trying to replace the Rokkor. Like with the Mandler 35 and 90, I don't mind using it for everything, and when I feel like it's right for a shot, there is no substitute.yeah, i keep contemplate buying an MD again as i quite like it's look wide open, but i already have a few other f/1.2 lenses laying around that hardly ever see any use compared to the 58/1.2...
freaklikeme wrotesebboh wrotehey, i'm excited about the lens.I know. That wasn't intended as a knock against you, or anyone interested in the lens. My lack of interest in ownership has much more to with my contentment with my 35mm combo than anything I've seen in the tests. It's a great focal length, speed, and looks to be a strong performer in many ways. I'm just happy your interest and ownership of a Kolari modded camera will save me a rental to satisfy my stupid curiosity.i'll keep you updated when i try it. might be a little while though, i'm still figuring out the cv 50/1.5. might have to wait for the second time Guy buys it and sells it to buy it off him. Lens designers would have a hard time developing a lens for your taste!
Do you like shooting with any modern lens?the rx1 lens is fantastic (i don't enjoy the ergonomics though). the 50 lux asph, 28 cron, and cv 125/2.5 APO really impressed me when i shot with them. the minolta 85/1.4 limited and ZE 35/1.4 are relatively modern lens that i really like the look of. i like the zm 35/1.4, zm 50/1.5 sonnar, cv 35/1.7, and cv 50/1.5, but they all have things that annoy me about their look.
We are very much in-tune. The only lenses I haven't tried yet are the 50 Lux and CV 125 APO. The latter has been a consideration to me but I have a feeling Cosina will release a tele APO for the E-mount soon.
Oct 18, 2017 at 09:27 AM
immortalblue
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.25 #16The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
will have to read all theses pages soon, i love 40mm
p.25 #17The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
Focus-throw issue..
I’d like to report my own observation about this (great)
Voightlander 40mm f1.2, a fact I find absolutely extremely “strange” I don’t remember having read any concern or criticism about anywhere :
Don’t You agree the focus-throw is ridiculously -unpardonably- short (particularly for such a fast lens!) there where it matters most (-to me -but excellent from minimum distance up to around 1m) : namely from 1m to 5m it’s about 2cm only !
So; a portrait at distance between 1.3m and 2m (huge70cm play !) translates into.. guess how much throw on this lens (as you try to focus on one eye with aperture 1.2, 1.4, 1.7, 2..) ? : 5mm !!!
Ok.. so lets say even if Your friendly model stays still within a say 10 or 5cm zone within that distance-range.. you get it ? Do You ? lol : Because than it's down to a matter of not even 1mm rotation on Your lens and You are already off-focus from Your unsharp eye and supposed to focus back, but not past..
At that point its not anymore a question of having a good eye and trained micro-reactivity under your (finger)skin, but luck on top of it. Let’s focus by moving the camera ? lol.
(So there is still good reasons for an Eye-AF compatible G-Master 40mm f1.2)
I like this lens a lot though, just like the 65mm that unfortunately (also totally unpardonably to me -especially for filming witch I do not) lacks the excellent stop-less aperture-ring option I permanently leave on “smooth” on the 40mm.
p.25 #18The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
lacks the excellent stop-less aperture-ring option I permanently leave on “smooth” on the 40mm
I know dismantling a lens you just got should neither be necessary or encouraged, but … how hard would it be to take out the ball bearing under the aperture ring to make it clickless? I know many older manual lenses are dismantlable with just taking out a few screws*, but what about their modern counterparts?
(* OK, maybe taking out a few screws, unscrewing some element groups, taking out a few more screws, etc)
p.25 #19The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
DonQuiPhot wrote:
Focus-throw issue..
I’d like to report my own observation about this (great)
Voightlander 40mm f1.2, a fact I find absolutely extremely “strange” I don’t remember having read any concern or criticism about anywhere :
Don’t You agree the focus-throw is ridiculously -unpardonably- short (particularly for such a fast lens!) there where it matters most (-to me -but excellent from minimum distance up to around 1m) : namely from 1m to 5m it’s about 2cm only !
So; a portrait at distance between 1.3m and 2m (huge70cm play !) translates into.. guess how much throw on this lens (as you try to focus on one eye with aperture 1.2, 1.4, 1.7, 2..) ? : 5mm !!!
Ok.. so lets say even if Your friendly model stays still within a say 10 or 5cm zone within that distance-range.. you get it ? Do You ? lol : Because than it's down to a matter of not even 1mm rotation on Your lens and You are already off-focus from Your unsharp eye and supposed to focus back, but not past..
At that point its not anymore a question of having a good eye and trained micro-reactivity under your (finger)skin, but luck on top of it. Let’s focus by moving the camera ? lol.
(So there is still good reasons for an Eye-AF compatible G-Master 40mm f1.2)
I like this lens a lot though, just like the 65mm that unfortunately (also totally unpardonably to me -especially for filming witch I do not) lacks the excellent stop-less aperture-ring option I permanently leave on “smooth” on the 40mm. ...Show more →
I totally agree that the focus throw is silly short. But, it's not a portrait lens, is it? And yes, you can still shoot portraits with it.
I'm not even interested in portraits, but if your model is sitting still, I don't see a problem at all. At least not at closer than ~3 meter distance. Beyond that, focus can be really tricky.
p.25 #20The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
zaphodm wrote: Earlier quotelacks the excellent stop-less aperture-ring option I permanently leave on “smooth” on the 40mmI know dismantling a lens you just got should neither be necessary or encouraged, but … how hard would it be to take out the ball bearing under the aperture ring to make it clickless? I know many older manual lenses are dismantlable with just taking out a few screws*, but what about their modern counterparts?
(* OK, maybe taking out a few screws, unscrewing some element groups, taking out a few more screws, etc)
--
Good Idea ! I often tend to "tune" my gear but did not consider it at all here with this issue but I now definitely will follow up (carefully) Your idea (perhaps inquire directly at Voightlander) ! Thank You !