p.20 #3The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
baltmin wrote:
I was planning to buy the voigtlander 35mm f1.2 II with the Techart Pro for my a7rII but since the 40 was announced I decided to wait. The 40 sounded like more versatile, smaller and lighter, optimized for Sony and of course a newer lens, which was expected to be better.
Now I am confused. Both lenses have a character, both have their strengths and weaknesses, but what I can’t “forgive” is this bad corner to corner sharpness of the 40 even stopped down. The confusion gets bigger because I think there is no infinity test of the 35 with 100% crops in the web so I can’t say how good (or bad) is this lens for landscapes.
Of course there is also the Ultron option but I would rather go for an f1.2-1.4 lens as I already own the sigma 24-35 f2 which is excellent for landscapes. The combination of the 24-35 for landscapes and the 40 f1.2 for environmental portraits and more “artistic” low depth of field photography would sound ideal but if the voigtlander 35 f1.2 is better in corner to corner sharpness maybe it is still the choice for me.
Any opinions? A comparison between the voigtlander 35 and 40 would be very interesting. ...Show more →
First, my past experience of the 1.2/35 makes me doubt that it’s better than the 40.
Second, I don’t think the 40 has bad corner to corner sharpness. It’s just not in the same league as slower modern lenses, as you might expect. There’s no free lunch. If you opinion is based on my crops, you only see a bit of the extreme corner. Look at Juhas samples (in this thread) to get a whole frame perspective on 24MP. It’s really pretty good.
But there are only three possibilities if you want speed and ultimate sharpness.
(1) buy an Otus and you can have both, for the price of a car and a kilo of weight.
(2) Buy two lenses - a high end moderate speed one ultimate resolution and a fast one for thin DOF with good centres
(3) decide which is more important, and put up with a little less speed (get the ulton) if you prioritize corners, or get a faster one, and accept slightly less corner resolution (but remember in this case it really is just the corners, and they are god stopped down)
p.20 #4The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
Thanks for your response. I appreciate your opinion. I’m looking forward to seeing your off-centre focusing tests so as to have an overview about sharpness.
To be honest I didn’t find Juhas’ samples too bad, however those are 24mp. What I noticed in his samples is that the mid frame is actually worse than the borders/corners in wide apertures, which makes me believe that focusing in the mid frame might make things a lot better. Just a hunch as you said.
p.20 #5The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
Ok, I just completed my testing, and implemented this lens in my processing workflow (specifically created a custom profile in DXO Optics). I was able to deal with the LoCa easily (even at f1.2), and am completely happy with this lens.
I do have an option to send the lens back within 30 days for a full refund, but I'm keeping it.
It does everything I wanted from it. Comparing this f1.2 lens with the Loxia 35mm f2 is ridiculous, because they're different beasts for different purposes. Try shooting the Loxia 35mm at f1.2, oh sorry, you can't!!!
Other's criticise this lens for not being sharp at wider apertures (really?, surprise surprise a lens that is softer wide open), turning up unsharp mask a little in DXO fixed that. The Loxia 35mm might be a little sharper at f2 (WGAF), but the Loxia also has to be stopped down to get the best out of it. Onion ring bokeh is barely noticeable wide open, it's just like smooth butter. The rendering is so "special" with this lens, I absolutely love it 👍
Voigtlander did a great job making a native FE mount f1.2 lens this light and compact. Don't listen to the naysayers folks, just try this lens for yourself, you might be surprised.
J
p.20 #7The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
baltmin wrote:
Thanks for your response. I appreciate your opinion. I’m looking forward to seeing your off-centre focusing tests so as to have an overview about sharpness.
To be honest I didn’t find Juhas’ samples too bad, however those are 24mp. What I noticed in his samples is that the mid frame is actually worse than the borders/corners in wide apertures, which makes me believe that focusing in the mid frame might make things a lot better. Just a hunch as you said.
I think there’s a bit more evidence for the FC hypothesis; the curved field can be clearly seen in some non infinity samples I saw. Also, there are some frames I took at infinity where the corners are no worse than the ones I posted, but the centre is terrible! An obvious explanation might be that this is focused at the other end of the acceptability range for the corners (which is right out of range for the centre). This sipuggests (but doesn’t prove) there may be a position better for the corners, with a smaller cost in the centre.
p.20 #8The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
jaybr wrote:
The Loxia 35mm might be a little sharper at f2 (WGAF), but the Loxia also has oodles of LoCa at this aperture, that's why I never considered it
Oodles of LoCa?
I would say there are other lenses that fit this description, like the ZF.2 Distagon 35mm f1.4, but the Loxia 35mm seems quite ok. regarding LoCa
p.20 #10The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
You are correct,
I must apologise, I mistakenly referred to the Loxia 35mm as having "oodles of LoCa". It is the Loxia 50mm I confused it with. I have edited this reference out of my previous post.
J
p.20 #11The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
After looking more thoroughly at the samples we have so far I'm pretty sure that there is a lot of field curvature, which explains the mid frame/corner softness.
Here is an example from Juha's samples (converted from raw with ACR, vignetting corrected),
The blue sign on the left bottom corner looks focused and reasonably sharp, even at f1.2 (compared to f2.2) whereas the mid frame background is blurred and out of focus (gets better at f2.2).
Mid frame infinity focus test will be very useful for conclusions.
p.20 #12The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
baltmin wrote:
After looking more thoroughly at the samples we have so far I'm pretty sure that there is a lot of field curvature, which explains the mid frame/corner softness.
Here is an example from Juha's samples (converted from raw with ACR, vignetting corrected),
The blue sign on the left bottom corner looks focused and reasonably sharp, even at f1.2 (compared to f2.2) whereas the mid frame background is blurred and out of focus (gets better at f2.2).
Mid frame infinity focus test will be very useful for conclusions.
One should not forget that mechanical vignetting makes the effective aperture smaller towards the corners. This doesn't change very much when stopping down just ~1 stop, so some very fast lenses can have reasonably sharp corners wide open because of that.
p.20 #13The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
baltmin wrote:
After looking more thoroughly at the samples we have so far I'm pretty sure that there is a lot of field curvature, which explains the mid frame/corner softness.
Here is an example from Juha's samples (converted from raw with ACR, vignetting corrected),
The blue sign on the left bottom corner looks focused and reasonably sharp, even at f1.2 (compared to f2.2) whereas the mid frame background is blurred and out of focus (gets better at f2.2).
Mid frame infinity focus test will be very useful for conclusions.
Hmm . . . not sure where the intended focus point is in that picture - the mid-frame background better be out of focus if the sign is the intended focus plane.
p.20 #14The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
jhinkey wrote: baltmin wroteAfter looking more thoroughly at the samples we have so far I'm pretty sure that there is a lot of field curvature, which explains the mid frame/corner softness.
Here is an example from Juha's samples (converted from raw with ACR, vignetting corrected),
The blue sign on the left bottom corner looks focused and reasonably sharp, even at f1.2 (compared to f2.2) whereas the mid frame background is blurred and out of focus (gets better at f2.2).
Mid frame infinity focus test will be very useful for conclusions.Hmm . . . not sure where the intended focus point is in that picture - the mid-frame background better be out of focus if the sign is the intended focus plane.
Sorry I should have posted the photo from where the crops are taken.
p.20 #15The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
jaybr wrote:
You are correct,
I must apologise, I mistakenly referred to the Loxia 35mm as having "oodles of LoCa". It is the Loxia 50mm I confused it with. I have edited this reference out of my previous post.
J
p.20 #16The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
davewolfs wrote: jaybr wroteYou are correct,
I must apologise, I mistakenly referred to the Loxia 35mm as having "oodles of LoCa". It is the Loxia 50mm I confused it with. I have edited this reference out of my previous post.
JThe 50 has oodles of Loca?
At large apertures it does have a fair amount. Whether the amount of CA qualifies as “oodles” I will refrain from stating an opinion. Oodles is obviously a technical term I cannot quantify. 😜
p.20 #17The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
I've used the Loxia 50 a lot, though mostly at wider apertures I choose another lens. CA has never bothered me with it. However it can be provoked. Phillip's fountain torture test is horrible with the Loxia 50 (at phillipreeve.net) if I'm remembering correctly.
p.20 #18The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
Luvwine wrote: davewolfs wrotejaybr wroteYou are correct,
I must apologise, I mistakenly referred to the Loxia 35mm as having "oodles of LoCa". It is the Loxia 50mm I confused it with. I have edited this reference out of my previous post.
JThe 50 has oodles of Loca?At large apertures it does have a fair amount. Whether the amount of CA qualifies as “oodles” I will refrain from staying an opinion. Oodles is obviously a technical term I cannot quantify. 😜
Pretty happy with it. Oodles and all. How often are you shooting fountains, spoons and chrome on cars wide open in broad daylight lol.
p.20 #19The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
"Pretty happy with it. Oodles and all. How often are you shooting fountains, spoons and chrome on cars wide open in broad daylight lol"
.
Same could be said about the Voigtlander FE 40mm f1.2
J
p.20 #20The Voigtlander Nokton 40mm f/1.2 FE is coming!
jaybr wrote:
"Pretty happy with it. Oodles and all. How often are you shooting fountains, spoons and chrome on cars wide open in broad daylight lol"
.
Same could be said about the Voigtlander FE 40mm f1.2
J
I agree and I’m looking forward to trying this lens out. It seems to be a nice compromise especially for its size.