fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2017 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2017Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts

  
 
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.9 #1Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
MrTMan wrote:
RoseandCharles wroteThank you for this comparison!

I would love to see a third comparison with the 85mm f1.4 GM (cropped APSC mode), but I'm guessing you do not have the lens.
I don’t. But incidentally, in the time since I posted that shot, I’ve found there’s a significant improvement in image quality when shooting with the 135, vs. the Batis 85 in crop mode, which probably isn’t readily apparent in the comparison pics I posted. The 135 is just overall a better lens (putting aside the focal length difference).


It would be shocking if a good 135 were not quite a lot better than an equally good 85 with a more than 1.5x crop! It’s a tribute to the Loxia how usable it is at that crop level, even though off course 18mp behind a cropped portion of it can’t match 42mp spread over the whole ff area of a 135mm lens.
May 14, 2018 at 02:58 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.9 #2Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
MrTMan wrote:
RoseandCharles wroteThank you for this comparison!

I would love to see a third comparison with the 85mm f1.4 GM (cropped APSC mode), but I'm guessing you do not have the lens.
I don’t. But incidentally, in the time since I posted that shot, I’ve found there’s a significant improvement in image quality when shooting with the 135, vs. the Batis 85 in crop mode, which probably isn’t readily apparent in the comparison pics I posted. The 135 is just overall a better lens (putting aside the focal length difference).


For me, crop mode is very useful but I mostly use it for emergencies only.
May 15, 2018 at 10:41 PM
KarmaKramer
Offline
Details
p.9 #3Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
I don't have time to post them now but I took the same photo using the same camera with Sigma 135art at 2.8 and Batis 135 at 2.8 and they were exactly the same. Just a photo of my son's bear outside in the sun. Obviously the Sigma goes to 1.8 but after all I heard about the Batis I expected a color difference at least. Kind of surprising.
May 19, 2018 at 09:42 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.9 #4Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
KarmaKramer wrote:
I don't have time to post them now but I took the same photo using the same camera with Sigma 135art at 2.8 and Batis 135 at 2.8 and they were exactly the same. Just a photo of my son's bear outside in the sun. Obviously the Sigma goes to 1.8 but after all I heard about the Batis I expected a color difference at least. Kind of surprising.


Now you have to post that comparison!
May 23, 2018 at 10:22 PM
stevesanacore
Offline
Details
p.9 #5Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
Fred Miranda wrote:
AGeoJO wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
LBJ2 wrote
MrTMan wroteHere's one where the background is a tad busier. So for this shot, one could argue that f/2 might have been a bit better than f/2.8. But again, even at f/2.8, the background is mostly destroyed.

The bokeh on this lens is noticeably smoother than on the 85, so I'd say that's one of the biggest advantages... not to mention that 135 is a bit more flattering as a focal length than 85.

The total lack of CA is also remarkable... I mean it's not like the 85 has an issue with CA, but this lens has like zero!
The Batis 135 is a true APO design ( hence the well controlled CA). I think there are only four modern Zeiss lenses with the APO design distinction. Bokeh on this lens IMO is more than good enough overall, but yes F2 in some circumstances can and does have its advantages ( with the right lens). Taking it further, I think the Sigma 135 @ F1.8 would take the lead here smooth bokeh wise.
Actually five modern Zeiss lenses have the APO designation. The three Otus lenses and the Milvus 135 (and its ZE/ZF2 predecessor) and now the Batis 135 f/2.8. The Batis is the slowest of these lenses, but it is also the smallest and the only one with AF and Image stabilization.
I compared both Zeiss 135/2 APO and Batis 135/2.8 APO and the latter is a true APO.
Fred, I see that you sold the Zeiss 135mm ZE lens already . You are keeping the Batis, I assume?
Yes, I kept the Batis. From my testing, they both have pros and cons:

Zeiss 135/2 APO:
Weighs 450 grams more (with MC-11 adapter). it would weigh more with Metabones.
It does not perform as great at infinity distance.
It shows noticeable axial CA despite of being "APO".
Not as flare resistant compared to Batis.
Smooth and pleasant MF feel.
Outstanding resolution at f/2 at close and mid-distances. (same as Batis at f/2.8).
Beautiful rendering: Low contrast OOF and high micro-contrast for the focused area. It renders better than the Batis (both at f/2.8).

Batis 135/2.8 APO:
Amazing axial correction. (The best I've seen)
Outstanding resolution/contrast at all distances. At
...Show more →

Thanks Fred, that's very good info. Even though I'm a fan of manual focus lenses, when it comes to tele's, AF is much more usable and more relevant for me. Looks like the Batis is the best bet at the moment for me.
Jun 18, 2018 at 05:00 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.9 #6Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
Batis 135/2.8 APO @f/4




Jun 23, 2018 at 06:37 AM
chiron
Offline
Details
p.9 #7Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
DavidBM wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
LBJ2 wrote
MrTMan wrote
peter1219 wroteI also own the Batis 85 and am getting tempted to buy the Batis 135.

Could you post more pics taken with the Batis 135?
Your pics are pushing me towards the "place order" button. Now I am really close to clicking it. .
Here's one where the background is a tad busier. So for this shot, one could argue that f/2 might have been a bit better than f/2.8. But again, even at f/2.8, the background is mostly destroyed.

The bokeh on this lens is noticeably smoother than on the 85, so I'd say that's one of the biggest advantages... not to mention that 135 is a bit more flattering as a focal length than 85.

The total lack of CA is also remarkable... I mean it's not like the 85 has an issue with CA, but this lens has like zero!
The Batis 135 is a true APO design ( hence the well controlled CA). I think there are only four modern Zeiss lenses with the APO design distinction. Bokeh on this lens IMO is more than good enough overall, but yes F2 in some circumstances can and does have its advantages ( with the right lens). Taking it further, I think the Sigma 135 @ F1.8 would take the lead here smooth bokeh wise.
Actually five modern Zeiss lenses have the APO designation. The three Otus lenses and the Milvus 135 (and its ZE/ZF2 predecessor) and now the Batis 135 f/2.8. The Batis is the slowest of these lenses, but it is also the smallest and the only one with AF and Image stabilization.
I compared both Zeiss 135/2 APO and Batis 135/2.8 APO and the latter is a true APO.
I suspect both are true APO, thought the Batis is better corrected for colour.

I finally discovered a year or so ago, that you can be true APO and still have not great LoCA

Why? To be a true APO requires that three frequencies can come into focus in the same plane.
But that says nothing about the amount of deviation *between* those frequencies.

Some APO lenses will deviate a lot between the frequencies, others will only deviate a little.

I've seen some people describe being good in this way as being Superapochromatic, or Superachromatic.
But that's wrong too: this describes lenses which can be
...Show more →


Hi David.

Can you explain what you mean by "deviate" in the sentence "Some APO lenses will deviate a lot between the frequencies, others will only deviate a little."

If they are focusing in the same plane, in what sense do they deviate?

Thanks!

Jun 23, 2018 at 07:39 AM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.9 #8Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
chiron wrote:
DavidBM wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
LBJ2 wrote
MrTMan wroteHere's one where the background is a tad busier. So for this shot, one could argue that f/2 might have been a bit better than f/2.8. But again, even at f/2.8, the background is mostly destroyed.

The bokeh on this lens is noticeably smoother than on the 85, so I'd say that's one of the biggest advantages... not to mention that 135 is a bit more flattering as a focal length than 85.

The total lack of CA is also remarkable... I mean it's not like the 85 has an issue with CA, but this lens has like zero!
The Batis 135 is a true APO design ( hence the well controlled CA). I think there are only four modern Zeiss lenses with the APO design distinction. Bokeh on this lens IMO is more than good enough overall, but yes F2 in some circumstances can and does have its advantages ( with the right lens). Taking it further, I think the Sigma 135 @ F1.8 would take the lead here smooth bokeh wise.
Actually five modern Zeiss lenses have the APO designation. The three Otus lenses and the Milvus 135 (and its ZE/ZF2 predecessor) and now the Batis 135 f/2.8. The Batis is the slowest of these lenses, but it is also the smallest and the only one with AF and Image stabilization.
I compared both Zeiss 135/2 APO and Batis 135/2.8 APO and the latter is a true APO.
I suspect both are true APO, thought the Batis is better corrected for colour.

I finally discovered a year or so ago, that you can be true APO and still have not great LoCA

Why? To be a true APO requires that three frequencies can come into focus in the same plane.
But that says nothing about the amount of deviation *between* those frequencies.

Some APO lenses will deviate a lot between the frequencies, others will only deviate a little.

I've seen some people describe being good in this way as being Superapochromatic, or Superachromatic.
But that's wrong too: this describes lenses which can be in focus exactly at four frequencies in the same plane.

So a bad Superachromat can have worse LoCA than a good APO, and a not so great (but still true) APO could have worse visible colour correction than a good simple Achromat, which is only in focus at two frequencies, but deviates less between them. (on the whole though, the best guide to how much deviation there is between frequencies that in focus is how many can be in focus, so APOs are usually better than non-APOs, and Superachromats usually better than APOs-especially if you care about frequencies outside the visible spectrum)
Hi David.

Can you explain what you mean by "deviate" in the sentence "Some APO lenses will deviate a lot between the frequencies, others will only deviate a little."

If they are focusing in the same plane, in what sense do they deviate?

Thanks!



Sure.
An APO lens focuses in the same plane at three frequencies in the visible spectrum.
At every other frequency (ie most of them) it does not focus at that plane!
So the performance of the lens as a whole depends on how far in front or behind the focus plane all those other frequencies are focused. That difference is what I was calling deviation. A regular achromat only focuses two frequencies, but to the extent that it’s worse than an apo lens it’s because usually the deviation of the frequencies other than the two is greater than the deviation in the APO case.
Jun 23, 2018 at 05:08 PM
chiron
Offline
Details
p.9 #9Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
DavidBM wrote:
chiron wrote
DavidBM wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
LBJ2 wroteThe Batis 135 is a true APO design ( hence the well controlled CA). I think there are only four modern Zeiss lenses with the APO design distinction. Bokeh on this lens IMO is more than good enough overall, but yes F2 in some circumstances can and does have its advantages ( with the right lens). Taking it further, I think the Sigma 135 @ F1.8 would take the lead here smooth bokeh wise.
Actually five modern Zeiss lenses have the APO designation. The three Otus lenses and the Milvus 135 (and its ZE/ZF2 predecessor) and now the Batis 135 f/2.8. The Batis is the slowest of these lenses, but it is also the smallest and the only one with AF and Image stabilization.
I compared both Zeiss 135/2 APO and Batis 135/2.8 APO and the latter is a true APO.
I suspect both are true APO, thought the Batis is better corrected for colour.

I finally discovered a year or so ago, that you can be true APO and still have not great LoCA

Why? To be a true APO requires that three frequencies can come into focus in the same plane.
But that says nothing about the amount of deviation *between* those frequencies.

Some APO lenses will deviate a lot between the frequencies, others will only deviate a little.

I've seen some people describe being good in this way as being Superapochromatic, or Superachromatic.
But that's wrong too: this describes lenses which can be in focus exactly at four frequencies in the same plane.

So a bad Superachromat can have worse LoCA than a good APO, and a not so great (but still true) APO could have worse visible colour correction than a good simple Achromat, which is only in focus at two frequencies, but deviates less between them. (on the whole though, the best guide to how much deviation there is between frequencies that in focus is how many can be in focus, so APOs are usually better than non-APOs, and Superachromats usually better than APOs-especially if you care about frequencies outside the visible spectrum)
Hi David.

Can you explain what you mean by "deviate" in the sentence "Some APO lenses will deviate a lot between the frequencies, others will only deviate a little."

If they are focusing in the same plane, in what sense do they deviate?

Thanks!
Sure.
An APO lens focuses in the same plane at three frequencies in the visible spectrum.
At every other frequency (ie most of them) it does not focus at that plane!
So the performance of the lens as a whole depends on how far in front or behind the focus plane all those other frequencies are focused. That difference is what I was calling deviation. A regular achromat only focuses two frequencies, but to the extent that it’s worse than an apo lens it’s because usually the deviation of the frequencies other than the two is greater than the deviation in the APO
...Show more →

Thanks for the explanation.

In terms of the characteristics of the lens's images, it must also matter a great deal exactly which three of the visible frequencies are focused in the same plane? How much variation is there among APO lenses in which three visible frequencies are focused in the same plane?
Jun 23, 2018 at 07:26 PM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.9 #10Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
chiron wrote:
DavidBM wrote
chiron wrote
DavidBM wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
Steve Spencer wroteActually five modern Zeiss lenses have the APO designation. The three Otus lenses and the Milvus 135 (and its ZE/ZF2 predecessor) and now the Batis 135 f/2.8. The Batis is the slowest of these lenses, but it is also the smallest and the only one with AF and Image stabilization.
I compared both Zeiss 135/2 APO and Batis 135/2.8 APO and the latter is a true APO.
I suspect both are true APO, thought the Batis is better corrected for colour.

I finally discovered a year or so ago, that you can be true APO and still have not great LoCA

Why? To be a true APO requires that three frequencies can come into focus in the same plane.
But that says nothing about the amount of deviation *between* those frequencies.

Some APO lenses will deviate a lot between the frequencies, others will only deviate a little.

I've seen some people describe being good in this way as being Superapochromatic, or Superachromatic.
But that's wrong too: this describes lenses which can be in focus exactly at four frequencies in the same plane.

So a bad Superachromat can have worse LoCA than a good APO, and a not so great (but still true) APO could have worse visible colour correction than a good simple Achromat, which is only in focus at two frequencies, but deviates less between them. (on the whole though, the best guide to how much deviation there is between frequencies that in focus is how many can be in focus, so APOs are usually better than non-APOs, and Superachromats usually better than APOs-especially if you care about frequencies outside the visible spectrum)
Hi David.

Can you explain what you mean by "deviate" in the sentence "Some APO lenses will deviate a lot between the frequencies, others will only deviate a little."

If they are focusing in the same plane, in what sense do they deviate?

Thanks!
Sure.
An APO lens focuses in the same plane at three frequencies in the visible spectrum.
At every other frequency (ie most of them) it does not focus at that plane!
So the performance of the lens as a whole depends on how far in front or behind the focus plane all those other frequencies are focused. That difference is what I was calling deviation. A regular achromat only focuses two frequencies, but to the extent that it’s worse than an apo lens it’s because usually the deviation of the frequencies other than the two is greater than the deviation in the APO case.
Thanks for the explanation.

In terms of the characteristics of the lens's images, it must also matter a great deal exactly which three of the visible frequencies are focused in the same plane? How much variation is there among APO lenses in which three visible frequencies are focused in the same plane?


Indeed. There is some variation, but I don't know how much. I think the principal source of variation is how much the frequencies that aren't focussed on the same plane deviate.

Being APO is a good thing, but people talk about it as though APO = no chromatic aberration. This is just sadly not true. And APOness doesn't come in degrees either: It's either APO or not (roughly). But of course LoCA comes in degrees. So one shouldn't be surprised if some, especially older APO lenses have imperfect corruption of LoCA.

Even superachromats can have some CA left! (they focus four frequencies in the same plane, one usually but not always being out of the visible band). But some recent APOs (like the Batis 135) really do have almost no visible LoCA. And can be better in this respect than some superachromats, just as some ordinary achromats appear to have better LoCA than the worst APO lenses.
Jun 24, 2018 at 03:05 AM
bjornthun
Offline
Details
p.9 #11Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
DavidBM wrote:
chiron wrote
DavidBM wrote
chiron wrote
DavidBM wrote
Fred Miranda wroteI compared both Zeiss 135/2 APO and Batis 135/2.8 APO and the latter is a true APO.
I suspect both are true APO, thought the Batis is better corrected for colour.

I finally discovered a year or so ago, that you can be true APO and still have not great LoCA

Why? To be a true APO requires that three frequencies can come into focus in the same plane.
But that says nothing about the amount of deviation *between* those frequencies.

Some APO lenses will deviate a lot between the frequencies, others will only deviate a little.

I've seen some people describe being good in this way as being Superapochromatic, or Superachromatic.
But that's wrong too: this describes lenses which can be in focus exactly at four frequencies in the same plane.

So a bad Superachromat can have worse LoCA than a good APO, and a not so great (but still true) APO could have worse visible colour correction than a good simple Achromat, which is only in focus at two frequencies, but deviates less between them. (on the whole though, the best guide to how much deviation there is between frequencies that in focus is how many can be in focus, so APOs are usually better than non-APOs, and Superachromats usually better than APOs-especially if you care about frequencies outside the visible spectrum)
Hi David.

Can you explain what you mean by "deviate" in the sentence "Some APO lenses will deviate a lot between the frequencies, others will only deviate a little."

If they are focusing in the same plane, in what sense do they deviate?

Thanks!
Sure.
An APO lens focuses in the same plane at three frequencies in the visible spectrum.
At every other frequency (ie most of them) it does not focus at that plane!
So the performance of the lens as a whole depends on how far in front or behind the focus plane all those other frequencies are focused. That difference is what I was calling deviation. A regular achromat only focuses two frequencies, but to the extent that it’s worse than an apo lens it’s because usually the deviation of the frequencies other than the two is greater than the deviation in the APO case.
Thanks for the explanation.

In terms of the characteristics of the lens's images, it must also matter a great deal exactly which three of the visible frequencies are focused in the same plane? How much variation is there among APO lenses in which three visible frequencies are focused in the same plane?
Indeed. There is some variation, but I don't know how much. I think the principal source of variation is how much the frequencies that aren't focussed on the same plane deviate.

Being APO is a good thing, but people talk about it as though APO = no chromatic aberration. This is just sadly not true. And APOness doesn't come in degrees either: It's either APO or not (roughly). But of course LoCA comes in degrees. So one shouldn't be surprised if some, especially older APO lenses have imperfect corruption of LoCA.

Even superachromats can have some CA left! (they focus four
...Show more →

Mathematically it is easy to think that a lens is either apo or not. Due to the physical nature of light, I think it is much harder. You will need to settle for a definition where red, green and blue light converges to within a small radius r from the desired convergence point, i.e. a small sphere. This has to hold in the focus surface, and if you want to account for loCA also behind and in front of it. For the application at hand you will need to define the radius of the sphere within which red, green and blue light should converge. Second you will need to define just how far in front of, and behind the focus surface there should be no colour fringing to account for loCA.

Here I say focus surface instead of focus plane, since all lenses will display some curvature of field.

The radius r of a sphere will have a positive, non-zero value due to the physical (quantum) nature of light, think about diffraction. Red, green and blue light, will have slightly different diffraction properties, since they have different wavelengths. A definitive apo-ness will elude us, but for practical photography it's no problem.

The definition I did will account for older "apo" lenses being apo on film but not on a high res digital sensor, as it is designed according to the requirement of the appplication and technical feasibility at the time.

Will the lenses we think of as apo now, be apo, when Sony some time in the future introduces a 150mpix sensor in a hypothetical A7Rx?
Jun 24, 2018 at 05:22 AM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.9 #12Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
bjornthun wrote:
DavidBM wrote
chiron wrote
DavidBM wrote
chiron wrote
DavidBM wroteI suspect both are true APO, thought the Batis is better corrected for colour.

I finally discovered a year or so ago, that you can be true APO and still have not great LoCA

Why? To be a true APO requires that three frequencies can come into focus in the same plane.
But that says nothing about the amount of deviation *between* those frequencies.

Some APO lenses will deviate a lot between the frequencies, others will only deviate a little.

I've seen some people describe being good in this way as being Superapochromatic, or Superachromatic.
But that's wrong too: this describes lenses which can be in focus exactly at four frequencies in the same plane.

So a bad Superachromat can have worse LoCA than a good APO, and a not so great (but still true) APO could have worse visible colour correction than a good simple Achromat, which is only in focus at two frequencies, but deviates less between them. (on the whole though, the best guide to how much deviation there is between frequencies that in focus is how many can be in focus, so APOs are usually better than non-APOs, and Superachromats usually better than APOs-especially if you care about frequencies outside the visible spectrum)
Hi David.

Can you explain what you mean by "deviate" in the sentence "Some APO lenses will deviate a lot between the frequencies, others will only deviate a little."

If they are focusing in the same plane, in what sense do they deviate?

Thanks!
Sure.
An APO lens focuses in the same plane at three frequencies in the visible spectrum.
At every other frequency (ie most of them) it does not focus at that plane!
So the performance of the lens as a whole depends on how far in front or behind the focus plane all those other frequencies are focused. That difference is what I was calling deviation. A regular achromat only focuses two frequencies, but to the extent that it’s worse than an apo lens it’s because usually the deviation of the frequencies other than the two is greater than the deviation in the APO case.
Thanks for the explanation.

In terms of the characteristics of the lens's images, it must also matter a great deal exactly which three of the visible frequencies are focused in the same plane? How much variation is there among APO lenses in which three visible frequencies are focused in the same plane?
Indeed. There is some variation, but I don't know how much. I think the principal source of variation is how much the frequencies that aren't focussed on the same plane deviate.

Being APO is a good thing, but people talk about it as though APO = no chromatic aberration. This is just sadly not true. And APOness doesn't come in degrees either: It's either APO or not (roughly). But of course LoCA comes in degrees. So one shouldn't be surprised if some, especially older APO lenses have imperfect corruption of LoCA.

Even superachromats can have some CA left! (they focus four frequencies in the same plane, one usually but not always being out of the visible band). But some recent APOs (like the Batis 135) really do have almost no visible LoCA. And can be better in this respect than some superachromats, just as some ordinary achromats appear to have better LoCA than the worst APO lenses.
Mathematically it is easy to think that a lens is either apo or not. Due to the physical nature of light, I think it is much harder. You will need to settle for a definition where red, green and blue light converges to within a small radius r from the desired convergence point, i.e. a small sphere. This has to hold in the focus surface, and if you want to account for loCA also behind and in front of it. For the application at hand you will need to define the radius of the sphere within which red, green and
...Show more →

Indeed, That's why I said it's either apo or not, "roughly"
But the important point is that it's typically not the extent to which a lens labelled APO fails to be APO that is relevant to poorer than expected LoCA performance; rather its the deviations in focus in the other frequencies which are quite compatible with being APO.
Jun 24, 2018 at 07:01 AM
bjornthun
Offline
Details
p.9 #13Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
DavidBM wrote:
bjornthun wrote
DavidBM wrote
chiron wrote
DavidBM wrote
chiron wroteHi David.

Can you explain what you mean by "deviate" in the sentence "Some APO lenses will deviate a lot between the frequencies, others will only deviate a little."

If they are focusing in the same plane, in what sense do they deviate?

Thanks!
Sure.
An APO lens focuses in the same plane at three frequencies in the visible spectrum.
At every other frequency (ie most of them) it does not focus at that plane!
So the performance of the lens as a whole depends on how far in front or behind the focus plane all those other frequencies are focused. That difference is what I was calling deviation. A regular achromat only focuses two frequencies, but to the extent that it’s worse than an apo lens it’s because usually the deviation of the frequencies other than the two is greater than the deviation in the APO case.
Thanks for the explanation.

In terms of the characteristics of the lens's images, it must also matter a great deal exactly which three of the visible frequencies are focused in the same plane? How much variation is there among APO lenses in which three visible frequencies are focused in the same plane?
Indeed. There is some variation, but I don't know how much. I think the principal source of variation is how much the frequencies that aren't focussed on the same plane deviate.

Being APO is a good thing, but people talk about it as though APO = no chromatic aberration. This is just sadly not true. And APOness doesn't come in degrees either: It's either APO or not (roughly). But of course LoCA comes in degrees. So one shouldn't be surprised if some, especially older APO lenses have imperfect corruption of LoCA.

Even superachromats can have some CA left! (they focus four frequencies in the same plane, one usually but not always being out of the visible band). But some recent APOs (like the Batis 135) really do have almost no visible LoCA. And can be better in this respect than some superachromats, just as some ordinary achromats appear to have better LoCA than the worst APO lenses.
Mathematically it is easy to think that a lens is either apo or not. Due to the physical nature of light, I think it is much harder. You will need to settle for a definition where red, green and blue light converges to within a small radius r from the desired convergence point, i.e. a small sphere. This has to hold in the focus surface, and if you want to account for loCA also behind and in front of it. For the application at hand you will need to define the radius of the sphere within which red, green and blue light should converge. Second you will need to define just how far in front of, and behind the focus surface there should be no colour fringing to account for loCA.

Here I say focus surface instead of focus plane, since all lenses will display some curvature of field.

The radius r of a sphere will have a positive, non-zero value due to the physical (quantum) nature of light, think about diffraction. Red, green and blue light, will have slightly different diffraction properties, since they have different wavelengths. A definitive apo-ness will elude us, but for practical photography it's no problem.

The definition I did will account for older "apo" lenses being apo on film but not on a high res digital sensor, as it is designed according to the requirement of the appplication and technical feasibility at the time.

Will the lenses we think of as apo now, be apo, when Sony some time in the future introduces a 150mpix sensor in a hypothetical A7Rx?
Indeed, That's why I said it's either apo or not, "roughly"
But the important point is that it's typically not the extent to which a lens labelled APO fails to be APO that is relevant to poorer than expected LoCA performance; rather its the deviations in focus in the other frequencies which are quite compatible with being APO.


Agree.
Jun 24, 2018 at 07:33 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.9 #14Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
I was looking through my pictures and was very impressed by the Batis 135. Repurchased and just received it.
Here are a couple test shots. I forgot how superb this lens is.









Oct 21, 2020 at 04:45 PM
ShootPDX
Offline
Details
p.9 #15Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
The Batis 25 is one of my favorite lenses, and in betting the 85/135 have very similar rendering.
Oct 21, 2020 at 05:37 PM
Dave Sanders
Offline
Details
p.9 #16Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
My father has the B135 and a while back I 'borrowed' it for a weekend trip and didn't give it back for a month. Terrible son, I know. But I was really impressed by the image quality. A near perfect lens, optically. Less impressed by the AF, though, but optically it's brilliant. I like build of the Batii in general but I do miss having an aperture ring and an AF/MF button/switch.
Oct 21, 2020 at 05:40 PM
wdshuck
Offline
Details
p.9 #17Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
I have the Batis 40 and 85, with a Loxia 25 on the wide end. I've been tempted by this lens for a while. I keep telling myself a zoom is more practical on the long end, but really enjoy the rendering of the Batis primes a lot more.
Oct 21, 2020 at 05:51 PM
Dave Sanders
Offline
Details
p.9 #18Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
wdshuck wrote:
I have the Batis 40 and 85, with a Loxia 25 on the wide end. I've been tempted by this lens for a while. I keep telling myself a zoom is more practical on the long end, but really enjoy the rendering of the Batis primes a lot more.


You almost have my ideal kit. I have the Loxia 25 and 85 for landscapes but I would like the 40/85 combo for AF and general wandering about. The B135 is a winner and I'm happy my dad doesn't use it that often so he's quite generous with lending it out. I'd love a L25/85, B40/85/135 and GM24/100 set. I lack the funds to make that a reality, of course, so I'll continue to dream...
Oct 21, 2020 at 06:03 PM
MikeEvangelist
Offline
Details
p.9 #19Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
Fred Miranda wrote:
Repurchased it and just received it. Here are a couple test shots. I forgot how superb this lens is.


I just repurchased the Batis too (after selling my 135mm GM). Love the image quality and the size. The fact that it's stabilized is a nice bonus.

Plus, used the 'extra' cash for a nice set of Minolta lenses.
Oct 21, 2020 at 06:05 PM
AGeoJO
Offline
Details
p.9 #20Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
All Batis lenses are actually superb performers but they just fall out of favor with most users and their prices have tanked. I am sure it has a lot to do with the original pricing Zeiss came up with, and the abundance lenses from other manufacturers that are priced more competitively.

I thought I scored well when I bought a mint Batis 135mm lens for $1,200 but now, the going price is around $900. Ouch!

Edited on Oct 21, 2020 at 06:47 PM · View previous versions
Oct 21, 2020 at 06:21 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister