fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2017 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2017Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts

  
 
GabrielPhoto
Offline
Details
p.8 #1Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
MrTMan wrote:
I just thought I'd post this shot as an example of how thin the DOF is at f/2.8, at a head-and-shoulders portrait distance. At that distance, who needs f/2?


I want F2 (well 1.8 with my ART) so what is wrong about that?
I just dont understand why you need to post a nice photo and follow up trying to dismiss the idea that a faster lens has any value over yours.
You dont see me posting photos of my Sigma art 1.8 and saying something like: "try getting that with a 2.8!" or similar comment.
.Why? Because, we all have different needs and styles of shooting and just because I prefer the faster lens that can give me more subject isolation does not mean everyone else needs it nor that everyone else choices are silly because they do not follow my own.
I can post a photo to show what a lens can do without having to follow it up with some "derogatory" comment towards other available options in order to validate my purchase decision.
Just saying mate...enjoy your lens and show us what you can do with it and maybe skip the slightly "flaming" comments.
Regards
Aug 06, 2017 at 08:39 AM
MrTMan
Offline
Details
p.8 #2Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
I really wasn't trying to start a flame war and I don't think it's fair to call my comments derogatory. I didn't write "there's no point at all to having an f/1.8 lens" or "you'd have to be dumb to carry around all the weight of a Sigma 135 + adapter".

I was trying to make one very specific point, which is that at head-and-shoulders distance, the DOF at f/2.8 is quite thin -- as shown by the first portrait I posted with the wall in the shot. I thought that would be helpful to people who are considering the Batis.

I 100% agree that a faster lens has its advantages, especially in low-light situations and where the subject distance is greater, such as for full body portraits.
Aug 06, 2017 at 09:04 AM
Steve Spencer
Online
Details
p.8 #3Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
LBJ2 wrote:
MrTMan wrote
peter1219 wroteI also own the Batis 85 and am getting tempted to buy the Batis 135.

Could you post more pics taken with the Batis 135?
Your pics are pushing me towards the "place order" button. Now I am really close to clicking it. .
Here's one where the background is a tad busier. So for this shot, one could argue that f/2 might have been a bit better than f/2.8. But again, even at f/2.8, the background is mostly destroyed.

The bokeh on this lens is noticeably smoother than on the 85, so I'd say that's one of the biggest advantages... not to mention that 135 is a bit more flattering as a focal length than 85.

The total lack of CA is also remarkable... I mean it's not like the 85 has an issue with CA, but this lens has like zero!
The Batis 135 is a true APO design ( hence the well controlled CA). I think there are only four modern Zeiss lenses with the APO design distinction. Bokeh on this lens IMO is more than good enough overall, but yes F2 in some circumstances can and does have its advantages ( with the right lens). Taking it further, I think the Sigma 135 @ F1.8 would take the lead here smooth bokeh wise.


Actually five modern Zeiss lenses have the APO designation. The three Otus lenses and the Milvus 135 (and its ZE/ZF2 predecessor) and now the Batis 135 f/2.8. The Batis is the slowest of these lenses, but it is also the smallest and the only one with AF and Image stabilization.
Aug 06, 2017 at 09:06 AM
LBJ2
Offline
Details
p.8 #4Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
Steve Spencer wrote:
LBJ2 wrote
MrTMan wrote
peter1219 wroteI also own the Batis 85 and am getting tempted to buy the Batis 135.

Could you post more pics taken with the Batis 135?
Your pics are pushing me towards the "place order" button. Now I am really close to clicking it. .
Here's one where the background is a tad busier. So for this shot, one could argue that f/2 might have been a bit better than f/2.8. But again, even at f/2.8, the background is mostly destroyed.

The bokeh on this lens is noticeably smoother than on the 85, so I'd say that's one of the biggest advantages... not to mention that 135 is a bit more flattering as a focal length than 85.

The total lack of CA is also remarkable... I mean it's not like the 85 has an issue with CA, but this lens has like zero!
The Batis 135 is a true APO design ( hence the well controlled CA). I think there are only four modern Zeiss lenses with the APO design distinction. Bokeh on this lens IMO is more than good enough overall, but yes F2 in some circumstances can and does have its advantages ( with the right lens). Taking it further, I think the Sigma 135 @ F1.8 would take the lead here smooth bokeh wise.
Actually five modern Zeiss lenses have the APO designation. The three Otus lenses and the Milvus 135 (and its ZE/ZF2 predecessor) and now the Batis 135 f/2.8. The Batis is the slowest of these lenses, but it is also the smallest and the only one with AF.


Good catch Steve. Thanks for the correction. I should have written four "other" modern Zeiss lenses with the APO design. Also good point about the Batis being the smallest and the only one with AF ( excellent AF IMO). Trade off for the coveted F2.
Aug 06, 2017 at 09:13 AM
LBJ2
Offline
Details
p.8 #5Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
chiron wrote:
LBJ2 wrote
MrTMan wroteI just thought I'd post this shot as an example of how thin the DOF is at f/2.8, at a head-and-shoulders portrait distance. At that distance, who needs f/2?

I've been very pleased with the 135 -- it's replaced my Batis 85 as my go-to portrait lens, and it's made me question whether I even need the 85. Though I think I'll keep the 85 for indoor use, where the extra speed and/or shorter working distance can come in handy.
Good example! As more and more experiment/try this lens, I think many will come to the same conclusion. Once you start using the Batis 135 @ F2.8 you forget all about the fact that it's not F2.

I use both Batis 85 and 135 and find they make for very different applications. IMO, the current Batis system make for a great kit: 18, 25, 85, and 135 not going to miss much with these focal lengths. For those accustomed to the Batis 85, or 85mm in general for portrait should be prepared to step back a few times an then repeat to adjust to the very close frame you'll get with the 135mm. Worse part of the Batis system is getting used to quiet, snappy native AF, along with the light weight of these weather/dust resistant lenses is maybe too easy
I think they need to add something n the 35-45 range with an f/2 aperture. But that would then be five lenses to carry!


I see many asking for a Batis 35/2 and if this is in reference to the Zeiss Distagon T* 35mm f/2, I totally get it. I own the Zeiss Distagon T* 35mm f/2 ZE and that lens is in my eyes probably the very best example of Zeiss pop.
Aug 06, 2017 at 09:18 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.8 #6Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
Steve Spencer wrote:
LBJ2 wrote
MrTMan wrote
peter1219 wroteI also own the Batis 85 and am getting tempted to buy the Batis 135.

Could you post more pics taken with the Batis 135?
Your pics are pushing me towards the "place order" button. Now I am really close to clicking it. .
Here's one where the background is a tad busier. So for this shot, one could argue that f/2 might have been a bit better than f/2.8. But again, even at f/2.8, the background is mostly destroyed.

The bokeh on this lens is noticeably smoother than on the 85, so I'd say that's one of the biggest advantages... not to mention that 135 is a bit more flattering as a focal length than 85.

The total lack of CA is also remarkable... I mean it's not like the 85 has an issue with CA, but this lens has like zero!
The Batis 135 is a true APO design ( hence the well controlled CA). I think there are only four modern Zeiss lenses with the APO design distinction. Bokeh on this lens IMO is more than good enough overall, but yes F2 in some circumstances can and does have its advantages ( with the right lens). Taking it further, I think the Sigma 135 @ F1.8 would take the lead here smooth bokeh wise.
Actually five modern Zeiss lenses have the APO designation. The three Otus lenses and the Milvus 135 (and its ZE/ZF2 predecessor) and now the Batis 135 f/2.8. The Batis is the slowest of these lenses, but it is also the smallest and the only one with AF and Image stabilization.


I compared both Zeiss 135/2 APO and Batis 135/2.8 APO and the latter is a true APO.
May 10, 2018 at 11:00 PM
AGeoJO
Offline
Details
p.8 #7Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
Fred Miranda wrote:
Steve Spencer wrote
LBJ2 wrote
MrTMan wrote
peter1219 wroteI also own the Batis 85 and am getting tempted to buy the Batis 135.

Could you post more pics taken with the Batis 135?
Your pics are pushing me towards the "place order" button. Now I am really close to clicking it. .
Here's one where the background is a tad busier. So for this shot, one could argue that f/2 might have been a bit better than f/2.8. But again, even at f/2.8, the background is mostly destroyed.

The bokeh on this lens is noticeably smoother than on the 85, so I'd say that's one of the biggest advantages... not to mention that 135 is a bit more flattering as a focal length than 85.

The total lack of CA is also remarkable... I mean it's not like the 85 has an issue with CA, but this lens has like zero!
The Batis 135 is a true APO design ( hence the well controlled CA). I think there are only four modern Zeiss lenses with the APO design distinction. Bokeh on this lens IMO is more than good enough overall, but yes F2 in some circumstances can and does have its advantages ( with the right lens). Taking it further, I think the Sigma 135 @ F1.8 would take the lead here smooth bokeh wise.
Actually five modern Zeiss lenses have the APO designation. The three Otus lenses and the Milvus 135 (and its ZE/ZF2 predecessor) and now the Batis 135 f/2.8. The Batis is the slowest of these lenses, but it is also the smallest and the only one with AF and Image stabilization.
I compared both Zeiss 135/2 APO and Batis 135/2.8 APO and the latter is a true APO.


Fred, I see that you sold the Zeiss 135mm ZE lens already . You are keeping the Batis, I assume?
May 10, 2018 at 11:11 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.8 #8Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
AGeoJO wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
LBJ2 wrote
MrTMan wrote
peter1219 wroteI also own the Batis 85 and am getting tempted to buy the Batis 135.

Could you post more pics taken with the Batis 135?
Your pics are pushing me towards the "place order" button. Now I am really close to clicking it. .
Here's one where the background is a tad busier. So for this shot, one could argue that f/2 might have been a bit better than f/2.8. But again, even at f/2.8, the background is mostly destroyed.

The bokeh on this lens is noticeably smoother than on the 85, so I'd say that's one of the biggest advantages... not to mention that 135 is a bit more flattering as a focal length than 85.

The total lack of CA is also remarkable... I mean it's not like the 85 has an issue with CA, but this lens has like zero!
The Batis 135 is a true APO design ( hence the well controlled CA). I think there are only four modern Zeiss lenses with the APO design distinction. Bokeh on this lens IMO is more than good enough overall, but yes F2 in some circumstances can and does have its advantages ( with the right lens). Taking it further, I think the Sigma 135 @ F1.8 would take the lead here smooth bokeh wise.
Actually five modern Zeiss lenses have the APO designation. The three Otus lenses and the Milvus 135 (and its ZE/ZF2 predecessor) and now the Batis 135 f/2.8. The Batis is the slowest of these lenses, but it is also the smallest and the only one with AF and Image stabilization.
I compared both Zeiss 135/2 APO and Batis 135/2.8 APO and the latter is a true APO.
Fred, I see that you sold the Zeiss 135mm ZE lens already . You are keeping the Batis, I assume?


Yes, I kept the Batis. From my testing, they both have pros and cons:

Zeiss 135/2 APO:
Weighs 450 grams more (with MC-11 adapter). it would weigh more with Metabones.
It does not perform as great at infinity distance.
It shows noticeable axial CA despite of being "APO".
Not as flare resistant compared to Batis.
Smooth and pleasant MF feel.
Outstanding resolution at f/2 at close and mid-distances. (same as Batis at f/2.8).
Beautiful rendering: Low contrast OOF and high micro-contrast for the focused area. It renders better than the Batis (both at f/2.8).

Batis 135/2.8 APO:
Amazing axial correction. (The best I've seen)
Outstanding resolution/contrast at all distances. At infinity and wider apertures, it beats the Zeiss 135/2 by a great margin.
Lightweight in comparison.
Fast and accurate AF. (EyeAF works great for portraits)
Great rendering, although OOF area is higher in contrast. (especially towards the corners)
Outstanding flare performance (probably better coating). Very hard to get veiling flare even without the hood.
May 10, 2018 at 11:26 PM
AGeoJO
Offline
Details
p.8 #9Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
Fred, I realize that the Batis 135mm f/2.8 APO is a great lens, is fairly compact and light-weight. Somehow, Zeiss left a bad taste in my mouth when they originally priced the lens for $2K. I know somebody that paid the full price, too and is happy with it. Oh, hi Guy . They ended up lowering the price and you could get it for an even lower price from a certain source, too and yet, it is more me personally that is still somehow resisting getting the lens although the price is now fine. Of course, owning, using and loving a faster alternative lens with now great AF makes it easy to resist the temptation, too .
May 10, 2018 at 11:42 PM
mudlake
Offline
Details
p.8 #10Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts


Fred Miranda wrote:
AGeoJO wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
LBJ2 wrote
MrTMan wroteHere's one where the background is a tad busier. So for this shot, one could argue that f/2 might have been a bit better than f/2.8. But again, even at f/2.8, the background is mostly destroyed.

The bokeh on this lens is noticeably smoother than on the 85, so I'd say that's one of the biggest advantages... not to mention that 135 is a bit more flattering as a focal length than 85.

The total lack of CA is also remarkable... I mean it's not like the 85 has an issue with CA, but this lens has like zero!
The Batis 135 is a true APO design ( hence the well controlled CA). I think there are only four modern Zeiss lenses with the APO design distinction. Bokeh on this lens IMO is more than good enough overall, but yes F2 in some circumstances can and does have its advantages ( with the right lens). Taking it further, I think the Sigma 135 @ F1.8 would take the lead here smooth bokeh wise.
Actually five modern Zeiss lenses have the APO designation. The three Otus lenses and the Milvus 135 (and its ZE/ZF2 predecessor) and now the Batis 135 f/2.8. The Batis is the slowest of these lenses, but it is also the smallest and the only one with AF and Image stabilization.
I compared both Zeiss 135/2 APO and Batis 135/2.8 APO and the latter is a true APO.
Fred, I see that you sold the Zeiss 135mm ZE lens already . You are keeping the Batis, I assume?
Yes, I kept the Batis. From my testing, they both have pros and cons:

Zeiss 135/2 APO:
Weighs 450 grams more (with MC-11 adapter). it would weigh more with Metabones.
It does not perform as great at infinity distance.
It shows noticeable axial CA despite of being "APO".
Not as flare resistant compared to Batis.
Smooth and pleasant MF feel.
Outstanding resolution at f/2 at close and mid-distances. (same as Batis at f/2.8).
Beautiful rendering: Low contrast OOF and high micro-contrast for the focused area. It renders better than the Batis (both at f/2.8).

Batis 135/2.8 APO:
Amazing axial correction. (The best I've seen)
Outstanding resolution/contrast at all distances. At
...Show more →

Great comparison, Fred. I also owned the 135/2 APO but sold it and now adore the Batis 135. You forgot one big plus of the Batis - optical image stabilization. It works very well on the A7RIII and is something no other 135mm has.
May 10, 2018 at 11:54 PM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.8 #11Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
Fred Miranda wrote:
Steve Spencer wrote
LBJ2 wrote
MrTMan wrote
peter1219 wroteI also own the Batis 85 and am getting tempted to buy the Batis 135.

Could you post more pics taken with the Batis 135?
Your pics are pushing me towards the "place order" button. Now I am really close to clicking it. .
Here's one where the background is a tad busier. So for this shot, one could argue that f/2 might have been a bit better than f/2.8. But again, even at f/2.8, the background is mostly destroyed.

The bokeh on this lens is noticeably smoother than on the 85, so I'd say that's one of the biggest advantages... not to mention that 135 is a bit more flattering as a focal length than 85.

The total lack of CA is also remarkable... I mean it's not like the 85 has an issue with CA, but this lens has like zero!
The Batis 135 is a true APO design ( hence the well controlled CA). I think there are only four modern Zeiss lenses with the APO design distinction. Bokeh on this lens IMO is more than good enough overall, but yes F2 in some circumstances can and does have its advantages ( with the right lens). Taking it further, I think the Sigma 135 @ F1.8 would take the lead here smooth bokeh wise.
Actually five modern Zeiss lenses have the APO designation. The three Otus lenses and the Milvus 135 (and its ZE/ZF2 predecessor) and now the Batis 135 f/2.8. The Batis is the slowest of these lenses, but it is also the smallest and the only one with AF and Image stabilization.
I compared both Zeiss 135/2 APO and Batis 135/2.8 APO and the latter is a true APO.


I suspect both are true APO, thought the Batis is better corrected for colour.

I finally discovered a year or so ago, that you can be true APO and still have not great LoCA

Why? To be a true APO requires that three frequencies can come into focus in the same plane.
But that says nothing about the amount of deviation *between* those frequencies.

Some APO lenses will deviate a lot between the frequencies, others will only deviate a little.

I've seen some people describe being good in this way as being Superapochromatic, or Superachromatic.
But that's wrong too: this describes lenses which can be in focus exactly at four frequencies in the same plane.

So a bad Superachromat can have worse LoCA than a good APO, and a not so great (but still true) APO could have worse visible colour correction than a good simple Achromat, which is only in focus at two frequencies, but deviates less between them. (on the whole though, the best guide to how much deviation there is between frequencies that in focus is how many can be in focus, so APOs are usually better than non-APOs, and Superachromats usually better than APOs-especially if you care about frequencies outside the visible spectrum)

May 10, 2018 at 11:56 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.8 #12Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
DavidBM wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
LBJ2 wrote
MrTMan wrote
peter1219 wroteI also own the Batis 85 and am getting tempted to buy the Batis 135.

Could you post more pics taken with the Batis 135?
Your pics are pushing me towards the "place order" button. Now I am really close to clicking it. .
Here's one where the background is a tad busier. So for this shot, one could argue that f/2 might have been a bit better than f/2.8. But again, even at f/2.8, the background is mostly destroyed.

The bokeh on this lens is noticeably smoother than on the 85, so I'd say that's one of the biggest advantages... not to mention that 135 is a bit more flattering as a focal length than 85.

The total lack of CA is also remarkable... I mean it's not like the 85 has an issue with CA, but this lens has like zero!
The Batis 135 is a true APO design ( hence the well controlled CA). I think there are only four modern Zeiss lenses with the APO design distinction. Bokeh on this lens IMO is more than good enough overall, but yes F2 in some circumstances can and does have its advantages ( with the right lens). Taking it further, I think the Sigma 135 @ F1.8 would take the lead here smooth bokeh wise.
Actually five modern Zeiss lenses have the APO designation. The three Otus lenses and the Milvus 135 (and its ZE/ZF2 predecessor) and now the Batis 135 f/2.8. The Batis is the slowest of these lenses, but it is also the smallest and the only one with AF and Image stabilization.
I compared both Zeiss 135/2 APO and Batis 135/2.8 APO and the latter is a true APO.
I suspect both are true APO, thought the Batis is better corrected for colour.

I finally discovered a year or so ago, that you can be true APO and still have not great LoCA

Why? To be a true APO requires that three frequencies can come into focus in the same plane.
But that says nothing about the amount of deviation *between* those frequencies.

Some APO lenses will deviate a lot between the frequencies, others will only deviate a little.

I've seen some people describe being good in this way as being Superapochromatic, or Superachromatic.
But that's wrong too: this describes lenses which can be
...Show more →

I got spoiled by the Batis and started seeing green/magenta color errors in high contrast areas when shooting with the 135/2. I know you own both and I'm sure agree that the Batis is a step above in this regard.
May 11, 2018 at 12:03 AM
Frogfish
Offline
Details
p.8 #13Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
AGeoJO wrote:
GMPhotography wroteI'm out of baseball helmets. I need real protection from that swinging wife bat.
Buy your wife hand bags or shoes and you won't even need any helmet .


That's true - better to be hit with a handbag or kicked with stilettos than hit with a baseball bat
May 11, 2018 at 12:03 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.8 #14Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
mudlake wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
AGeoJO wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
LBJ2 wroteThe Batis 135 is a true APO design ( hence the well controlled CA). I think there are only four modern Zeiss lenses with the APO design distinction. Bokeh on this lens IMO is more than good enough overall, but yes F2 in some circumstances can and does have its advantages ( with the right lens). Taking it further, I think the Sigma 135 @ F1.8 would take the lead here smooth bokeh wise.
Actually five modern Zeiss lenses have the APO designation. The three Otus lenses and the Milvus 135 (and its ZE/ZF2 predecessor) and now the Batis 135 f/2.8. The Batis is the slowest of these lenses, but it is also the smallest and the only one with AF and Image stabilization.
I compared both Zeiss 135/2 APO and Batis 135/2.8 APO and the latter is a true APO.
Fred, I see that you sold the Zeiss 135mm ZE lens already . You are keeping the Batis, I assume?
Yes, I kept the Batis. From my testing, they both have pros and cons:

Zeiss 135/2 APO:
Weighs 450 grams more (with MC-11 adapter). it would weigh more with Metabones.
It does not perform as great at infinity distance.
It shows noticeable axial CA despite of being "APO".
Not as flare resistant compared to Batis.
Smooth and pleasant MF feel.
Outstanding resolution at f/2 at close and mid-distances. (same as Batis at f/2.8).
Beautiful rendering: Low contrast OOF and high micro-contrast for the focused area. It renders better than the Batis (both at f/2.8).

Batis 135/2.8 APO:
Amazing axial correction. (The best I've seen)
Outstanding resolution/contrast at all distances. At infinity and wider apertures, it beats the Zeiss 135/2 by a great margin.
Lightweight in comparison.
Fast and accurate AF. (EyeAF works great for portraits)
Great rendering, although OOF area is higher in contrast. (especially towards the corners)
Outstanding flare performance (probably better coating). Very hard to get veiling flare even without the hood.
Great comparison, Fred. I also owned the 135/2 APO but sold it and now adore the Batis 135. You forgot one big plus of the Batis - optical image stabilization. It works very well on the A7RIII and is something no other 135mm has.


Yes, OOS + IBIS works better at 135mm. The viewfinder is very stabilized and it's possible to capture sharp images at lower shutter speeds. However, the ZE 135/2 + MC-11 adapter and camera's 3-axis IBIS worked great.
May 11, 2018 at 12:12 AM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.8 #15Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
Fred Miranda wrote:
DavidBM wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
LBJ2 wrote
MrTMan wroteHere's one where the background is a tad busier. So for this shot, one could argue that f/2 might have been a bit better than f/2.8. But again, even at f/2.8, the background is mostly destroyed.

The bokeh on this lens is noticeably smoother than on the 85, so I'd say that's one of the biggest advantages... not to mention that 135 is a bit more flattering as a focal length than 85.

The total lack of CA is also remarkable... I mean it's not like the 85 has an issue with CA, but this lens has like zero!
The Batis 135 is a true APO design ( hence the well controlled CA). I think there are only four modern Zeiss lenses with the APO design distinction. Bokeh on this lens IMO is more than good enough overall, but yes F2 in some circumstances can and does have its advantages ( with the right lens). Taking it further, I think the Sigma 135 @ F1.8 would take the lead here smooth bokeh wise.
Actually five modern Zeiss lenses have the APO designation. The three Otus lenses and the Milvus 135 (and its ZE/ZF2 predecessor) and now the Batis 135 f/2.8. The Batis is the slowest of these lenses, but it is also the smallest and the only one with AF and Image stabilization.
I compared both Zeiss 135/2 APO and Batis 135/2.8 APO and the latter is a true APO.
I suspect both are true APO, thought the Batis is better corrected for colour.

I finally discovered a year or so ago, that you can be true APO and still have not great LoCA

Why? To be a true APO requires that three frequencies can come into focus in the same plane.
But that says nothing about the amount of deviation *between* those frequencies.

Some APO lenses will deviate a lot between the frequencies, others will only deviate a little.

I've seen some people describe being good in this way as being Superapochromatic, or Superachromatic.
But that's wrong too: this describes lenses which can be in focus exactly at four frequencies in the same plane.

So a bad Superachromat can have worse LoCA than a good APO, and a not so great (but still true) APO could have worse visible colour correction than a good simple Achromat, which is only in focus at two frequencies, but deviates less between them. (on the whole though, the best guide to how much deviation there is between frequencies that in focus is how many can be in focus, so APOs are usually better than non-APOs, and Superachromats usually better than APOs-especially if you care about frequencies outside the visible spectrum)
I got spoiled by the Batis and started seeing green/magenta color errors in high contrast areas when shooting with the 135/2. I know you own both and I'm sure agree that the Batis is a step above in this regard.


Absolutely the Batis is better in this regard! I was just making a slightly tedious terminological point about how f2 can be both true apo, and still have more colour errors that we'd like. Yeah I find myself doing manual correction on the F2, sometimes, which is a really annoying thing to get right without having side effects.
May 11, 2018 at 12:14 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.8 #16Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
DavidBM wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
DavidBM wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
LBJ2 wroteThe Batis 135 is a true APO design ( hence the well controlled CA). I think there are only four modern Zeiss lenses with the APO design distinction. Bokeh on this lens IMO is more than good enough overall, but yes F2 in some circumstances can and does have its advantages ( with the right lens). Taking it further, I think the Sigma 135 @ F1.8 would take the lead here smooth bokeh wise.
Actually five modern Zeiss lenses have the APO designation. The three Otus lenses and the Milvus 135 (and its ZE/ZF2 predecessor) and now the Batis 135 f/2.8. The Batis is the slowest of these lenses, but it is also the smallest and the only one with AF and Image stabilization.
I compared both Zeiss 135/2 APO and Batis 135/2.8 APO and the latter is a true APO.
I suspect both are true APO, thought the Batis is better corrected for colour.

I finally discovered a year or so ago, that you can be true APO and still have not great LoCA

Why? To be a true APO requires that three frequencies can come into focus in the same plane.
But that says nothing about the amount of deviation *between* those frequencies.

Some APO lenses will deviate a lot between the frequencies, others will only deviate a little.

I've seen some people describe being good in this way as being Superapochromatic, or Superachromatic.
But that's wrong too: this describes lenses which can be in focus exactly at four frequencies in the same plane.

So a bad Superachromat can have worse LoCA than a good APO, and a not so great (but still true) APO could have worse visible colour correction than a good simple Achromat, which is only in focus at two frequencies, but deviates less between them. (on the whole though, the best guide to how much deviation there is between frequencies that in focus is how many can be in focus, so APOs are usually better than non-APOs, and Superachromats usually better than APOs-especially if you care about frequencies outside the visible spectrum)
I got spoiled by the Batis and started seeing green/magenta color errors in high contrast areas when shooting with the 135/2. I know you own both and I'm sure agree that the Batis is a step above in this regard.
Absolutely the Batis is better in this regard! I was just making a slightly tedious terminological point about how f2 can be both true apo, and still have more colour errors that we'd like. Yeah I find myself doing manual correction on the F2, sometimes, which is a really annoying thing to get right without having side effects.


There is something else in favor of the Zeiss 135/2: Higher transmission.
When both are compared at f/2.8 (Manual exposure, same scene), I detected a half stop difference in favor of the Zeiss. So, it gathers more light at same apertures.

It's also worth mentioning that images from the Batis are a bit cooler in comparison. In post, it's possible to match their look by adjusting color temperature, and OOF contrast using masks. Still, to my eyes, the Zeiss f/2 wins in rendering and it's not solely because of the f/2 vs f/2.8 difference.

Over the weekend, I will try posting some crops demonstrating my findings.
May 11, 2018 at 09:43 AM
jakelindsay
Offline
Details
p.8 #17Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
AGeoJO wrote:
Fred, I realize that the Batis 135mm f/2.8 APO is a great lens, is fairly compact and light-weight. Somehow, Zeiss left a bad taste in my mouth when they originally priced the lens for $2K. I know somebody that paid the full price, too and is happy with it. Oh, hi Guy . They ended up lowering the price and you could get it for an even lower price from a certain source, too and yet, it is more me personally that is still somehow resisting getting the lens although the price is now fine. Of course, owning, using and
...Show more →

Incidentally they just raised the price back up to 2K. Ugh.
May 12, 2018 at 04:16 PM
AGeoJO
Offline
Details
p.8 #18Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
gunmetal wrote:
AGeoJO wroteFred, I realize that the Batis 135mm f/2.8 APO is a great lens, is fairly compact and light-weight. Somehow, Zeiss left a bad taste in my mouth when they originally priced the lens for $2K. I know somebody that paid the full price, too and is happy with it. Oh, hi Guy . They ended up lowering the price and you could get it for an even lower price from a certain source, too and yet, it is more me personally that is still somehow resisting getting the lens although the price is now fine. Of course, owning, using and loving a faster alternative lens with now great AF makes it easy to resist the temptation, too .
Incidentally they just raised the price back up to 2K. Ugh.


Yes, I noticed that, too. Well, I hope they sell a lot of that lens at whatever price point they see fit and I mean it.
May 12, 2018 at 05:14 PM
RoseandCharles
Offline
Details
p.8 #19Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
MrTMan wrote:
Alright, I bought the Batis 135.

The size and weight won me over. I only shoot primes, so size matters since I'll typically carry around 3-5 lenses with me. I'm also a big fan of the Zeiss color/contrast (it's why I chose the Batis 85 over the 85 GM), and I'm guessing that the Sony 135 probably won't be a Zony. And, while f/2 would have been nice, the DOF is still pretty shallow at f/2.8 on a 135.

I haven't had time to take many pics, aside for the portrait below. Lighting wasn't great and bokeh isn't very interesting in
...Show more →

Thank you for this comparison!

I would love to see a third comparison with the 85mm f1.4 GM (cropped APSC mode), but I'm guessing you do not have the lens.
May 13, 2018 at 09:46 PM
MrTMan
Offline
Details
p.8 #20Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
RoseandCharles wrote:
Thank you for this comparison!

I would love to see a third comparison with the 85mm f1.4 GM (cropped APSC mode), but I'm guessing you do not have the lens.


I don’t. But incidentally, in the time since I posted that shot, I’ve found there’s a significant improvement in image quality when shooting with the 135, vs. the Batis 85 in crop mode, which probably isn’t readily apparent in the comparison pics I posted. The 135 is just overall a better lens (putting aside the focal length difference).
May 14, 2018 at 01:43 AM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister