Fred Miranda wrote:
The Otus 55/1.4 has great aberration control but the 50/1.4 ZA would perform very similarly. (IMO, it's one of the top native lens Sony offers)
The 55/1.8 is just a great lens for Sony shooters. High resolution and smooth bokeh...It's too bad it lacks in micro-contrast and CA is not as well corrected...post-processing helps a lot.
My eyes tell me that the 50 planar and 50 loxia have the best micro contrast here, so my question, does the 50 1.4 equal them or better ? Also from the samples above, what does the 50 1.4 render the closest with regards to bokeh ?
To my eye, the Loxia and 50/2 MP are very close in rendering.
Since there is a interest in seeing the Zony 50/1.4 in comparison....I don't have one, but if someone would like to loan one for comparison later in the year, I wouldn't object to re-running the tests with it included. (Or, if you are not too far from South Bend and would like to visit for a couple hours.)
I still have access to the 55/1.8, so it's possible to redo the tests with it included. Just for kicks, I could also include the "classic" 50/1.4 Zeiss Planar and a Voigtlander 50/1.1 (M-mount), which I didn't include in this test last year.
From my side by side tests, the Loxia 50 was very similar to the 50/1.4 ZA in terms of global and micro contrast. Both did better than the 55/1.8. (out of the camera, with no post-processing)
However, higher contrast also affects OOF rendering and contributes to the 55/1.8's flatter/smoother wide-open rendering, which is a plus. The 55/1.8's contrast can be increased whenever needed in post. (globally and/or localized)
From the three, I thought the Loxia 50/2 had the harsher rendering at mid-distance, followed by the 50/1.4 (which is actually quite smooth) and then the 55/1.8 which imo has the smoothest background bokeh to my eyes.
DannyBurkPhoto wrote:
To my eye, the Loxia and 50/2 MP are very close in rendering.
Since there is a interest in seeing the Zony 50/1.4 in comparison....I don't have one, but if someone would like to loan one for comparison later in the year, I wouldn't object to re-running the tests with it included. (Or, if you are not too far from South Bend and would like to visit for a couple hours.)
I still have access to the 55/1.8, so it's possible to redo the tests with it included. Just for kicks, I could also include the "classic" 50/1.4 Zeiss Planar and a Voigtlander 50/1.1 (M-mount), which I didn't include in this test last year....Show more →
Danny, I agree that the Loxia 50 and the Milvus/ZE/ZF 50 f/2 MP have very similar renderings in these shots. Having shot both lenses I would expect the Loxia to be better in the far corners especially stopped down as the MP never really sharpens up in the last few pixels in the corners. If you do reshoot this series, send my a PM. I will try to come up to South Bend and I could add my Leica M 50 f/2 APO to the mix. I also have the Otus 55, FE 55, and Loxia 50, but I think the FE is the only one you don't have. I also plan to pick up the Oly OM 50 f/2 macro before too long too and I have an E55 Leica R 50 f/1.4 as well. Thanks for the test. It was very well done and quite informative.
Rereading the old posts, I see that someone requested to see the f/5.6 versions of these, and I forgot to post them. I've prepared them this afternoon and will post them below; I have a full aperture series from each lens, wide open to f/16.
Again, these are at f/5.6. Same lens order as before, but I'll note it with each photo too. First 4 are the full frame; next two sets of 4 are clips from middle-left and upper left corner. First in each set is Zony 55/1.8; then Loxia 50; then Zeiss 50/2 makro-planar "classic"; then Zeiss Otus 55.
Steve Spencer wrote:
Danny, I agree that the Loxia 50 and the Milvus/ZE/ZF 50 f/2 MP have very similar renderings in these shots. Having shot both lenses I would expect the Loxia to be better in the far corners especially stopped down as the MP never really sharpens up in the last few pixels in the corners. If you do reshoot this series, send my a PM. I will try to come up to South Bend and I could add my Leica M 50 f/2 APO to the mix. I also have the Otus 55, FE 55, and Loxia 50, but I think the FE is the only one you don't have. I also plan to pick up the Oly OM 50 f/2 macro before too long too and I have an E55 Leica R 50 f/1.4 as well. Thanks for the test. It was very well done and quite informative....Show more →
Thanks, Steve. Likewise, I agree with your thought that the MP will remain a bit soft in the corners when stopped down. In the f/5.6 series that I just posted, the results are more similar to one another as you would expect, with the Otus standing apart from the others by its smoother background bokeh.
OK, I'll let you know if another series works out. Even without a Zony 50/1.4, it would be nice to add your Leica 50/2 APO to the test. Yes, I have the Otus 55, Loxia 50, and Zeiss 50/2 MP, and I can re-borrow my old Zony 55/1.8 for testing if need be. I don't have the Oly OM 50/2 nor the Leica R 50/1.4 that you mention, but I could add a Voigtlander 50/1.1 and a Zeiss 50/1.4 Planar ZE to the mix too. I have more 50s than anything, but it could be instructional to do tests with other focal lengths too!