Last year, I did comparison testing on several lenses for my own use, and discussion in another thread today reminded me that others might find this comparison useful too.
Before I sold my Zony 55/1.8 last year, I wanted to compare the rendering of my other 50/55mm lenses, namely Loxia 50, Zeiss 50/2 makro-planar, and Otus 55. I've uploaded various comparisons: a full-frame overview from each lens, followed by sets of two different full-res clips to examine rendering and bokeh. I have an aperture range series of each lens, but to avoid bogging down this thread too much, I'm posting only the wide-open version of each. If someone wants to see other apertures, let me know and I can post further comparisons.
Focus point for each is just below the main fork of the foreground tree; this area is included in the full res comparisons. All images shot on A7RII in RAW, converted in ACR, with default sharpening applied (25/1/25); ISO 100 with no noise reduction. "Camera Standard" profile applied during conversion. Metabones IV adapter used for the Canon-mount lenses.
I chose this particular scene not only for overall rendering, but also as a torture test for CA and bokeh. In that regard, it shows some nasty-looking areas, even from the Otus.
As much as I do appreciate the Sony 1.8/55 for it's soft bokeh I'm still a little surprised the Sony 1.8/55 beats even the Otus for softness of background bokeh, but it clearly does. Goes to show how formidable the Sony 1.8/55 is in terms of bokeh, but of course it has some faults that are show stoppers for some people.
The Otus 55/1.4 has great aberration control but the 50/1.4 ZA would perform very similarly. (IMO, it's one of the top native lens Sony offers)
The 55/1.8 is just a great lens for Sony shooters. High resolution and smooth bokeh...It's too bad it lacks in micro-contrast and CA is not as well corrected...post-processing helps a lot.
I said this in Fred's review thread on the 50 1.4 Sony and repeat it again. It's the best 50mm in the business, I have no doubts on it. It's the perfect balance of everything.
Except for size and weight. I agree that it's optically amazing (and the bet 50 I've used from an optics standpoint), but I'll stick with the 55/1.8 for my shooting. Especially as the high transmission losses make it only around a 1/3 stop (or less) difference in light transmission, and subject separation is also similar due to the longer FL on the 55.
GMPhotography wrote:
I said this in Fred's review thread on the 50 1.4 Sony and repeat it again. It's the best 50mm in the business, I have no doubts on it. It's the perfect balance of everything.
I love the 50/1.4, but I did feel the need to supplement it with the Loxia 50 for travelling light (just as I supplemented the 35/1.4 FE with the Loxia 35).
When I did my own comparisons between the Loxia 50 and the 55/1.8, I found the difference in image quality and rendering to be less than I'd expected. But the Loxia does have a little more microcontrast and personally that's more important to me than the slightly smoother bokeh from the 55.
While I didn't care for the super-smooth bokeh of the 55/1.8 (I prefer bokeh with a little bite), it was the focus-by-wire that killed it for me. I have one remaining lens with FBW (Batis 25), and it's looking at me nervously, although my impression has been that its FBW isn't nearly as awful as that of the 55. I haven't used it much, however, since I greatly prefer my Loxia 21.
Is my impression correct - are other FBW lenses less obnoxious than the 55?
I don't find the FBW on the 50/1.4 obnoxious. It's certainly no Loxia, when used for MF, but I think it's fine. Maybe the larger focus ring diameter helps?
MrTMan wrote:
I love the 50/1.4, but I did feel the need to supplement it with the Loxia 50 for travelling light (just as I supplemented the 35/1.4 FE with the Loxia 35).
When I did my own comparisons between the Loxia 50 and the 55/1.8, I found the difference in image quality and rendering to be less than I'd expected. But the Loxia does have a little more microcontrast and personally that's more important to me than the slightly smoother bokeh from the 55.
The bokeh smoothness difference between the 55/1.8 and Loxia 50/2 is not small (both at f/2). I do agree with the better color and micro-contrast from the Loxia though. Perfect lens for landscapes at f/5.6 and smaller.
DannyBurkPhoto wrote:
While I didn't care for the super-smooth bokeh of the 55/1.8 (I prefer bokeh with a little bite), it was the focus-by-wire that killed it for me. I have one remaining lens with FBW (Batis 25), and it's looking at me nervously, although my impression has been that its FBW isn't nearly as awful as that of the 55. I haven't used it much, however, since I greatly prefer my Loxia 21.
Is my impression correct - are other FBW lenses less obnoxious than the 55?
It's hard to generalise, because there are different features that make people think that FBW is obnoxious.
I think there are 4 things people hate, one of which I don't mind at all.
(1) delay: agreed that any FBW that has a lag before it starts to work is a complete pain. B25 doesn't seem to have this.
(2) granularity: some FBW lenses seem to have minimum focus change amounts that are a nuisance
(3) lack of repeatable infinity setting. Some allow you to set infinity from the distance gauge accurately, some don't. B25 seems repeatable on this, B85 not so much.
(4) variable throw. Many people HATE this. I like it, done well, it seems to allow greater accuracy (though I would most prefer switchable throw so that you can go to linear like on the 2.8/90
B25 is on the good side of 1-3, and I don't mind 4.
Saw this when you linked recently, Danny. Fair to say there are two classes here, each containing two lenses. Look at focus fade and degree of gentleness and contrast in OOF. This is a feature not a bug, lol.
One of these clips OOF looks like a veritable bubble bath, edgy and harsh. While scaring small children it would take it away from general purpose use where OOF is there to complement the main focus of attention. One of the top features of the 55 is the fast fade and super focal plane IQ (great separation, depth at slightly smaller apertures), and this character strengthens greatly by f2.8.
It's a classic lens (not likely to be repeated) simply because no one else in the major companies makes a medium price lens with this overall quality - instead they are sticking to the two tier approach (cheap/entry -vs- expensive/fast). I see Sony have learned their lesson at 85mm and 50mm, and may not have made the 55 today. Why alienate your new arrivals who are used to the previous deal they had?