fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2017 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2017Canon NFD 2.8/300L

  
 
dog rocket
Offline
Details
p.4 #1Canon NFD 2.8/300L
In response to other comments, the focus ring on mine is also extremely lightly damped... no looseness, but it almost feels that way. I do wish it were damped heavier like all my other MF lenses. Anyone have a trick to add resistance?
Feb 05, 2018 at 07:59 PM
SoundHound
Offline
Details
p.4 #2Canon NFD 2.8/300L
Well it looks like the price of FD lenses is going up. I bought a 300mm F2.8 EF “L” for the AF. It is well used and not so pretty but the IQ goes head to head with my EF 200 mm F2.0. With the lighter weight of the battery gripped A9 the combo is eminently hand holdable (A9 IBIS!).
Feb 05, 2018 at 09:25 PM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.4 #3Canon NFD 2.8/300L
dog rocket wrote:
In response to other comments, the focus ring on mine is also extremely lightly damped... no looseness, but it almost feels that way. I do wish it were damped heavier like all my other MF lenses. Anyone have a trick to add resistance?


No it was deliberate, to allow manual follow focus before AF.
I can’t think of any way to damp it, and I don’t think it would be an advantage except to make it feel more like a heavy unit focusing lens...
Feb 05, 2018 at 11:38 PM
dog rocket
Offline
Details
p.4 #4Canon NFD 2.8/300L


DavidBM wrote:
dog rocket wroteIn response to other comments, the focus ring on mine is also extremely lightly damped... no looseness, but it almost feels that way. I do wish it were damped heavier like all my other MF lenses. Anyone have a trick to add resistance?
No it was deliberate, to allow manual follow focus before AF.
I can’t think of any way to damp it, and I don’t think it would be an advantage except to make it feel more like a heavy unit focusing lens...


Oh, I completely understand that and wasn’t questioning that. That’s not how I use it though. And probably not how anyone else uses it today either unless they are gluttons for punishment. Haha. Kidding... much respect for those who can capture BIF or sports with MF!

I do find it challenging to get precise focus with it so lightly damped. Perhaps I can design my own adapter ring for it... that would be a nice little design project...
Feb 06, 2018 at 08:26 AM
mjm6
Offline
Details
p.4 #5Canon NFD 2.8/300L
Anyone using the FD 500 f4.5 lens on the a7 or similar cameras? I have a need for a super telephoto, and am interested in what I can do with a lens like that.

If you were going to also look at TC's for these old FD lenses, would it make more sense to get the old FD TC's or get the new Sony TC's? Anyone know how the old compare to the new Sony ones performance-wise?

I'm assuming you can even mount the new TC's with a FD-FE adapter, which may not be correct.


---Michael
Feb 06, 2018 at 10:58 AM
Paul_100A
Offline
Details
p.4 #6Canon NFD 2.8/300L
genji wrote:
DavidBM wroteWow I'm like a kid in a toyshop. The 300 f2.8 has a look that I've lusted after for a long long time, and while no doubt recent ones are better, this is still amazingly good.

But -- Drumroll -- TAP works!! It's incredible. It works really well (I guess the lens has good contrast for focussing and is fast enough). I have the lens on a monopod taking pics of the dogs, and manual focus was really tricky - the tiniest movement of the fairly loose (for manual follow focus) ring and things are off. But if you focus as well as you can manually, TAP will then keep sharp focus on eyes (if you have the point there of course - no Eye AF)

Of course TAP is moving the camera not the lens, so you have to be careful to let the camera move.
Impressive! Score another one for the mighty TAP. Were you about 3 meters away from Annie?


what is TAP?
I have a nFD 4/300 L.

Edited on Apr 06, 2018 at 11:50 PM · View previous versions
Feb 06, 2018 at 12:57 PM
dog rocket
Offline
Details
p.4 #7Canon NFD 2.8/300L
mjm6 wrote:
Anyone using the FD 500 f4.5 lens on the a7 or similar cameras? I have a need for a super telephoto, and am interested in what I can do with a lens like that.

If you were going to also look at TC's for these old FD lenses, would it make more sense to get the old FD TC's or get the new Sony TC's? Anyone know how the old compare to the new Sony ones performance-wise?

I'm assuming you can even mount the new TC's with a FD-FE adapter, which may not be correct.

---Michael


I can't answer for the Sony extenders but the FD 1.4x extender on the 300/2.8 is superb. I have not done any extensive tests but that combo on my setup is nearly as sharp as the 300/2.8 alone (and I say almost because I know if I said equal I'd get slammed since that's likely not possible with the tolerances involved... let's just say it's about as close as I can see and I'm pretty picky for sharpness)



In case you missed it, the moon shot was with that combo and was shot offhand. It is a 1:1 crop straight from the RAW without any sharpening. Obviously 420mm at the moon hardly makes a dent in the middle of 42MP.
Feb 06, 2018 at 02:44 PM
bluloo
Offline
Details
p.4 #8Canon NFD 2.8/300L
mjm6 wrote:
Anyone using the FD 500 f4.5 lens on the a7 or similar cameras? I have a need for a super telephoto, and am interested in what I can do with a lens like that.

If you were going to also look at TC's for these old FD lenses, would it make more sense to get the old FD TC's or get the new Sony TC's? Anyone know how the old compare to the new Sony ones performance-wise?

I'm assuming you can even mount the new TC's with a FD-FE adapter, which may not be correct.

---Michael


I have an FD 300 F/4, with a 2X-A TC (for 300mm or longer lenses) and the IQ is excellent. Not sure if or how well, a Sony TC would work, but the Canon FD tele extenders are very good, IME.

YMMV, of course.
Feb 06, 2018 at 03:38 PM
dog rocket
Offline
Details
p.4 #9Canon NFD 2.8/300L
Well, you guys caught me at good time. I had a few hours to kill. I designed an adjustable damper. I will like this because not only is the focus ring too light for my liking, this will help it stay focused which has also been a challenge for me with the feather touch damping. I'll let you know if it works... probably not if it doesn't! lol!

It's a challenge because there's very little surface area to clamp on...


Edited on Feb 27, 2018 at 06:16 PM · View previous versions
Feb 07, 2018 at 02:57 PM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.4 #10Canon NFD 2.8/300L
I'm coming back around to this lens. I think this time I'm going to try an Ed Mika conversion on it and use it with more modern extenders to see if I can pick up better performance at longer distances. I need to look at getting a lighter adapter, though. No sense in using the MBIV if I don't need the electronics.
Feb 17, 2018 at 04:44 PM
JimBuchanan
Offline
Details
p.4 #11Canon NFD 2.8/300L
dog rocket wrote:
... not only is the focus ring too light for my liking, this will help it stay focused which has also been a challenge for me with the feather touch damping. . .


Too light focusing, Huh? If I had that problem, I suppose I would try putting some "dampening" grease on the inside focusing ring. That stuff is used on things like stereo knobs, and is like glue. Its also very expensive. Maybe the Chinese grease they use on lathes and mills is another option, as its also like glue.

As far as extenders, I think I would try a crop camera first.
Feb 17, 2018 at 05:43 PM
dog rocket
Offline
Details
p.4 #12Canon NFD 2.8/300L
JimBuchanan wrote:
dog rocket wrote... not only is the focus ring too light for my liking, this will help it stay focused which has also been a challenge for me with the feather touch damping. . .
Too light focusing, Huh? If I had that problem, I suppose I would try putting some "dampening" grease on the inside focusing ring. That stuff is used on things like stereo knobs, and is like glue. Its also very expensive. Maybe the Chinese grease they use on lathes and mills is another option, as its also like glue.

As far as extenders, I think I would try a crop camera first.


I finished assembling my external damper... It works great! I'll put up images if anyone cares... the nice thing about this as opposed to grease is it is adjustable. I am able to dial it in to exactly the damping I am looking for. The thread on the ball set screw is extremely fine. Hell, it even looks good. I haven't shot any images with it yet, but I'm hoping it will allow me to dial the focus in one direction rather than back and forth, and back and forth... which is what I was doing due to the light dampening prior to this mod.
Feb 26, 2018 at 10:18 PM
dog rocket
Offline
Details
p.4 #13Canon NFD 2.8/300L
freaklikeme wrote:
I'm coming back around to this lens. I think this time I'm going to try an Ed Mika conversion on it and use it with more modern extenders to see if I can pick up better performance at longer distances. I need to look at getting a lighter adapter, though. No sense in using the MBIV if I don't need the electronics.


Have you tried the FD extenders with this lens? Frankly, I don't know how it can be any better...

EDIT: I just downloaded the full scale duck shot you linked to here:
https://www.flickr.com/photos/102985582@N02/14009252467/in/dateposted-public/

I can tell you that is not representative of my FD 1.4X extender of which the sharpness is almost indiscernible from the 300/2.8 alone. Maybe I have a lucky combo...but what I will tell you is the 300/2.8 + 1.4x images from the person I bought the set from went a long way in convincing me to trade for it.

Feb 26, 2018 at 10:20 PM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.4 #14Canon NFD 2.8/300L
dog rocket wrote:
freaklikeme wroteI'm coming back around to this lens. I think this time I'm going to try an Ed Mika conversion on it and use it with more modern extenders to see if I can pick up better performance at longer distances. I need to look at getting a lighter adapter, though. No sense in using the MBIV if I don't need the electronics.
Have you tried the FD extenders with this lens? Frankly, I don't know how it can be any better...



The FD 1.4x is the same optical design at the EF vI 1.4x. So, yeah, I think it can get better. As did Canon. Twice.
Feb 27, 2018 at 05:34 PM
dog rocket
Offline
Details
p.4 #15Canon NFD 2.8/300L
Alrighty then, have at it!

And eventually Canon will have a thrice... and then a frice... (while my once will suffice)
Feb 27, 2018 at 06:14 PM
mjm6
Offline
Details
p.4 #16Canon NFD 2.8/300L
I am about to do some testing of the FD teleconverters and Mark II of the EF teleconverters with a 500 f4.5, so I may be able to provide some insight on the performance of them once I have that testing done.

I will be using an Ed Mika mount conversion for the EF adaption, and then to Sony with an EF to FE adapter.

I’ll report back with some better info once I have done the testing.
Feb 28, 2018 at 12:26 AM
dog rocket
Offline
Details
p.4 #17Canon NFD 2.8/300L
The mechanical engineer in me is interested in your results. We are starting with lenses and teleconverters that are decades old and using adapters on them for Sony mounts. That’s already two strikes even with teleconverters designed for those very lenses.

Taking that lens, removing the mount and replacing with an EOS 3rd party mount, adding a teleconverter designed for later generation lenses (optical formulas notwithstanding) and finally the addition of the obligatory Sony adapter will be an interesting endeavor from a tolerance stackup POV. Of course, height tolerances should be correctable, but planar or other non-linear irregularities... not so much.

I assume plenty of Ed Mika mount users have tried the different EOS teleconverter versions. Anyone heard reports of those?

I think sharpness from corner to corner in a landscape image will be much more revealing than wide open shots, although both will be fun to observe.

Edited on Feb 28, 2018 at 01:24 PM · View previous versions
Feb 28, 2018 at 09:19 AM
mjm6
Offline
Details
p.4 #18Canon NFD 2.8/300L
No, I have seen very little on this anywhere, but I'm sure that there are people using them.

The Ed Mika mount is a complete mount conversion, so it shouldn't lose precision compared to the original, unlike a mount adapter.

I figure there are a few benefits to this approach (hypothetically speaking, at this point):
1. The EOS mount can have a chip put on it to report some EXIF info to the camera.
2. I can use the newer EOS teleconverters, which may be a higher level of performance (we'll see)
3. I can also use the Sony teleconverters...

My hypothesis is that the newer EOS TCs are going to be better than the FD ones, but as the lenses have changed (adding IS internally, etc.) the optics have as well, so I suspect that the Mk III ones could feasibly be worse than the MkII ones on these older lenses because they are designed to work with different optical formulas in the most current lenses.

Plus, they are considerably more expensive, and I'm trying to do this on the cheap.

I also figure that using the Canon TCs should be better than the Sony ones because they are actually in the right position for the lens whereas the Sony TCs are considerably farther back. I've seen results from a few people using both TCs with a Canon lens and they seem to indicate that the performance is approximately equal, so there may not be any real performance difference there.

All of this is completely theoretical at this point. I'm waiting on the EdMika mount, and still don't have the 2x EF TC MkII in hand. I do have the two FD TCs waiting.
Feb 28, 2018 at 11:25 AM
dog rocket
Offline
Details
p.4 #19Canon NFD 2.8/300L
OK, so this is probably of very little interest here, but this is the focus damper I came up with. The ball point set screws (4) have 3/16-100 threads which results in extreme fine tuning of the focus ring damping. It works great and I can't wait to try it out on the next deer that walks through the yard...

http://www.bertuccelli.com/assembled.jpg
http://www.bertuccelli.com/exploded.jpg
http://www.bertuccelli.com/DSC02895.jpg
http://www.bertuccelli.com/DSC02901.jpg
Feb 28, 2018 at 01:18 PM
roboticspro
Offline
Details
p.4 #20Canon NFD 2.8/300L
Good Morning,

Dog rocket: very nice design; was it 3D printed, and can you share the STL file if so?

I normally have the 300mm f4L with my A7II gear (very portable), and the 300mm f2.8L stays on a gimbal head with 1D, 5D, or 7D series bodies. At f4, the 300mm f2.8 is sharper, but not by much. At f5.6 to f11, it is pretty much a coin toss; I am so glad that I did not dump my FD glass (30+) when I got into digital.

Regards,

Edd



© roboticspro 2018

FDn 300mm f2.8L





© roboticspro 2018

Glassware going back to the early 80's



Edited on Mar 03, 2018 at 12:59 PM · View previous versions
Mar 03, 2018 at 11:08 AM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister