Andrew Gough wrote:
Wife: "Is that a new lens on your camera?"
Me: "Are those new shoes?"
True story, I swear.
There is a simple solution - collecting tons of cheap lenses until she gets used to and lose reckoning It works perfect for me
But on the other hand I'm a little jealous - mine wife is not interested in 'all this photo stuff'...
ikit wrote: Andrew Gough wroteWife: "Is that a new lens on your camera?"
Me: "Are those new shoes?"
True story, I swear.
There is a simple solution - collecting tons of cheap lenses until she gets used to and lose reckoning It works perfect for me
But on the other hand I'm a little jealous - mine wife is not interested in 'all this photo stuff'...
Yes, my wife doesn't seem to care about the equipment I use - pays no attention to anything new in my hand - it all looks the same to her. However she does realize that she really likes the results with the gear I have.
jhinkey wrote: ikit wroteAndrew Gough wroteWife: "Is that a new lens on your camera?"
Me: "Are those new shoes?"
True story, I swear.
There is a simple solution - collecting tons of cheap lenses until she gets used to and lose reckoning It works perfect for me
But on the other hand I'm a little jealous - mine wife is not interested in 'all this photo stuff'...Yes, my wife doesn't seem to care about the equipment I use - pays no attention to anything new in my hand - it all looks the same to her. However she does realize that she really likes the results with the gear I have.
jhinkey wrote: DannyBurkPhoto wroteIt can be reversed on the other Loxias, so I imagine it's the same in this case...That'd be cool. That's my one complaint with my 85ZM is that the stupid hood doesn't reverse mount on the bayonet - really Zeiss? I force it to with some ingenuity, but I shouldn't have to resort to such measures.
Would you please describe the method you used? I might want to try it.
JerryFusselman wrote: jhinkey wroteDannyBurkPhoto wroteIt can be reversed on the other Loxias, so I imagine it's the same in this case...That'd be cool. That's my one complaint with my 85ZM is that the stupid hood doesn't reverse mount on the bayonet - really Zeiss? I force it to with some ingenuity, but I shouldn't have to resort to such measures.Would you please describe the method you used? I might want to try it.
It's really stupid, but it works.
I bought a third party cap that has a leash hole in it which I connected to a leash with an elastic band that goes around the Leitax adapter. With the cap and leash in place I then reverse the hood and the leash is just the right diameter to make the lens cap need to be pushed on and it stays on fairly securely both to slight interference from the leash that gets squished between the hood and body and the felt lining of the lens hood.
I need to take a picture of it which I will tonight.
If anyone is still skeptical about the price, remember there is the similarly spec'd HandeVision Iberit 90mm 2.4 that will eventually come out. Optically not as complex, but has 10 aperture blades
Much tidier MTF than the Otus 85mm too, no midfield fall-off. Gotta love these Sonnars that peak where you want it - mid apertures, rather than f4. L85 is optimised almost certainly for infinity, letting the short focal distances reduce acuity for close work - the intended purpose being travel and portraiture:
"..Loxia 2.4/85..is particularly well suited for portrait photography,” said Christophe Casenave.
220 degree focus ring turn is a little more than the CY 100/3.5, which works great for 3-5m distances. It is also a bigger deal than it sounds, since the ring diameter is so small = faster focus acquisition, with just a little wiggle. Diameter is the same as the CY 100/3.5 as well (62.5mm), and length is about 1/4in shorter than that lens mounted on Sony's LA-EA3.
See LC's photo to see how large the gap is between infinity and 10m (bottom of page):
Reports indicate a super smooth focus action - a heavy duty manual lens in a small solid body. Metal hood is nice, large hood as CZ really want to avoid extraneous light these days, esp for video. It's just larger enough in diameter than the barrel to suggest it mounts in reverse. Read 3-4 'reviews' and it was not mentioned..it would be the first thing any travel guy would check. Will still need to be careful doing aperture brackets, as the focus ring is very close to the aperture ring; I would have preferred a larger gap, for gloved hands.
trogdon wrote:
If anyone is still skeptical about the price, remember there is the similarly spec'd HandeVision Iberit 90mm 2.4 that will eventually come out. Optically not as complex, but has 10 aperture blades
Probably best to wait for some user reviews on that one, however, Phillip Reeve & Co. were at Photokina and had a look at this lens, along with all other manual focus lens offerings at the show... Phillip's casual impressions of the Iberit 90/2.4 are not reassuring... See his blog post.
I can't get this lens off of my mind. After the Fuji announcement, I thought the GFX would be my obsession, but I have a surprisingly calm wait-and-see attitude about it. This lens, however, has me pouring over the limited samples available like they contain the secrets to life, the universe, and everything. So far, the only thing I've determined is that it should be an excellent performance-to-size compromise for landscape. I just wish I could figure out what it is about the close-to-mid distance performance that bugs me.
In the meantime, a friend borrowed one of my lenses and loaned me his Elmarit-M 90. It's a real sweetheart of an all-arounder. Wide open, it's got enough of the Summicron's mojo to make a good portrait, and by f/5.6, it's keeping up with the ZM 85/4 across the frame. it's 2cm shorter than the ZM and almost exactly 100g heavier, but it does have a built it hood. It's headed out on a road trip to LA with me in a couple of weeks, so I'm excited to see how it does in the mountains and in Utah and Arizona.
Cross system and format comparison, I know, but it would be interesting to see wide-open image comparison between the Loxia 85/2.4 on a7 and the Panasonic-Leica 42.5/1.2 on Oly EM1. DoF characteristics should be identical but light gathering of the latter will be two stops better.
waterden wrote:
Cross system and format comparison, I know, but it would be interesting to see wide-open image comparison between the Loxia 85/2.4 on a7 and the Panasonic-Leica 42.5/1.2 on Oly EM1. DoF characteristics should be identical but light gathering of the latter will be two stops better.
An old debate and I don't want to beat a dead horse, but maybe just a few lashes. Light gathering is not better in this instance for the m4/3rds set because you can turn up the ISO without adding as much noise on the Sony cameras--particularly the A7r II or A7s, or A7sII that all have excellent high ISO performance. Also the depth of field isn't exactly the same because of the difference in formats. So, if you crop to 4 X 3 or squarer the m4/3rds camera will have a bit shallower depth of field, but if you crop to 3 X 2 or wider then the Sony A7 seres camera will have a bit shallower depth of field. They will be pretty close, however.
I don't think your logic is correct - once you apply equivalence your 42.5 f1.2 becomes an 85mm f2.4 in full frame. I'm also not sure why you think 1600 ISO would be acceptable on the EM1 and you would need 6400 ISO on the Sony A7 - doesn't make sense.
Physics and the semiconductor processes used means the Sony a7 would win everytime. In any case, I also don't think that many people will be using the Loxia 85 on an Sony A7 - most likely on the A7R II, which micro 4/3 cannot hope to match performance wise.
I'll buy one when BH get them in stock, estimated late Dec at the moment. Much as I dislike heavy lenses, this one has the endearing characteristics that it is superbly made, small and well-balanced for the bodies. Easy to buy a shorter ebay hood too. I never thought they would do this again, this design could have come straight from the Contax range with the addition of the APD glass, which gave them degrees of latitude for the faster max stop than f2.8. Another indication Zeiss will not sacrifice quality for lens size.
Also, I have found that manual focus is not much of an onerous task for my street style, which is to banter and be playful while getting ready. Auto EVF-On will help greatly. Add to that a certain guilty pleasure that the lens will be unpopular, truly a stealth lens for use by outsider photographers.
Apart from wide open portraits, 85mm is also a terrific big country focal length. With Zeiss's DOF data (using f8 and 5 micron CoC), infinity focus gets you 30m to infinity, whereas a 10m focus delivers a DOF of just 7.6m to 15m. They will have factored that into the helicoil ratio, no doubt.
We are getting to the point where say, the mighty Milvus 85mm - the only 85mm lens verifiably as good across most of the frame as this Loxia at infinity (because even the Otus 85 is a 'super center' lens not as strong out wide, plus curvature and asph artifacts) - is attracting comments from pros that the best cameras to use the 1200 gram Milvus on are..EVF Sonys! We have reached the point where you actually NEED an EVF for this class of optic, at least in the great outdoors.
I just tried out my CY 100-300 on the a7r and wow, it goes past infinity so easily (by design) but the EVF sorts it very effectively indeed. Of course we all know what past infinity focus does for picture quality...on the a900 (despite fine OVF) this lens was simply unmanageable for this reason, in different temps. Now it's back, and it comes along next (mostly car) trip.
The A7 has an older technology full frame sensor so not it is not two stops better than even the EM1. The A7r II and the A7s both have a bit better than 2 stop ISO advantage over the EM1. With those cameras, I have both and I had an EM1, I would say ISO 6400 is better than ISO 1600 on the EM1. I also had the A7 II and it had about a stop and a half advantage over the EM1. I would say ISO 4000 or so was pretty similar to ISO 1600 on the EM1. The EM1 was a great camera, but high ISO shooting is not its strength.
Agreed on all points but maybe the MkII EM1 will up the ante. I use both an A7R II and EM1, the former mainly for landscape and portraiture (where I tend to use it in crop mode because the full 42mp shows up everything - not always popular with women) and the latter for travel and wildlife, but not yet BIF. However, my portrait work is largely with studio flash where lens speed is unimportant and AF is. So a fast portrait lens would be for low light use, hence my original question. That said, MF is very difficult in low light, particularly with a fast lens wide open where DoF can be very thin, so I suspect the Batis would trump the Loxia at this focal length. But the PL 42.5/1.2 on the new EM1 mk2? That's another question!
waterden wrote:
Agreed on all points but maybe the MkII EM1 will up the ante. I use both an A7R II and EM1, the former mainly for landscape and portraiture (where I tend to use it in crop mode because the full 42mp shows up everything - not always popular with women) and the latter for travel and wildlife, but not yet BIF. However, my portrait work is largely with studio flash where lens speed is unimportant and AF is. So a fast portrait lens would be for low light use, hence my original question. That said, MF is very difficult in low light, particularly with a fast lens wide open where DoF can be very thin, so I suspect the Batis would trump the Loxia at this focal length. But the PL 42.5/1.2 on the new EM1 mk2? That's another question!...Show more →
For me, one of the things I love about an EVF camera is the ability to manual focus in low light. I don't have trouble with that at all, but YMMV. I also much prefer MF with thin depth of field than AF, but again YMMV. So, if I was just going to AF with thin depth of field and low light, then a DSLR would become much more attractive. It is exactly this situation, in which I think and EVF camera has a huge advantage. So obviously our shooting styles are very different.
With regard to the Batis vs. Loxia vs. Noctitron, I would say they are all very nice lenses (I have the first two and I have always admired the Noctitron). Personally, I would probably prefer the Loxia as I like to MF, but given your shooting style I think that would be your last choice. If you don't like MF for low light, then I think the Loxia would just be a landscape lens for you and it does look excellent for that but there are many excellent options for landscapes at 85mm.
I think there is a simple solution to your concern about 42mp for portraits. It is downsizing. You can do this lots of different ways so that you show exactly what you you want to show. This would give you a lot more control than shooting in crop mode. Unless you hate post processing, I would recommend shooting in 42mp and developing a routine for downsizing. This is a very simple bit of post processing and will give you a lot more control of the outcome.
I also don't think the EM1 II will up the ante much in low ISO performance. I expect the same sensor as the EM5 MK II, and that was just a modest improvement and the A7r II remains about 2 stops better in high ISO performance.