I think if you had presented the vertical first it would have broader acceptance between the two. The vertical gets closer to what I feel is the subject, which is the meandering creek and the Sierras/Sky in the distance, the mist helps with the mood, helps hide the trail fence but also adds to the dead area in the horizontal. I also like more of the FG in the second. I would clone out the "No Swimming" signs as well.
Great view Fred...