fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Nikon 24mm 1.8g beats Sigma 24mm 1.4 Art

  
 
rick2906
Offline
Details
p.2 #1Nikon 24mm 1.8g beats Sigma 24mm 1.4 Art
I didn't mean to sound harsh. I am still not convinced yet which one to buy. I already have the sigma 35 and 50mm 1.4 art. I was just expecting sigma to be better in sharpness.




gdsf2 wrote:
rick2906 wroteI want the best 24mm lense! I already have fast 1.4 lense and the 200mm F2. I don't really see the big deal here for 2/3 of a stop for a 24mm lense! Dof is already pretty big with 24mm and i'll use it more for landscape anyway. Tell me why you would desperatly need more a 1.4 vs 1.8 for a 24mm lense?

I think it is fair to compare them because they are about the same price and it is both new design lense with ''better'' optics.
Easy there. You don't have to convince us. If you want the lens, buy it, use it, and enjoy it. It is ok. They are different lenses, some will like one, others will like the other, that is good news for all of us.




Edited on Dec 10, 2015 at 06:21 AM · View previous versions
Dec 10, 2015 at 05:40 AM
rick2906
Offline
Details
p.2 #2Nikon 24mm 1.8g beats Sigma 24mm 1.4 Art
Thank you!! Let me know if you do compare both later. That is what I want to hear, experience from people who tried both.

jtra wrote:
rick2906 wroteI want the best 24mm lense! I already have fast 1.4 lense and the 200mm F2. I don't really see the big deal here for 2/3 of a stop for a 24mm lense! Dof is already pretty big with 24mm and i'll use it more for landscape anyway. Tell me why you would desperatly need more a 1.4 vs 1.8 for a 24mm lense?

I think it is fair to compare them because they are about the same price and it is both new design lense with ''better'' optics.
DoF is pretty good. With fullframe on my 50mm f/1.4 (older non-art Sigma) and f/1.8G at distances I use it for family photography I often need to stop down to 2.5 or more. And I do it because both DoF is too thin and sharpness wide open is also not great.

Now with Sigma 24/1.4 I got a week ago I don't feel the need to stop down that much. DoF is usable wide open and sharpness is also good wide open.

I compared it briefly in shop with Nikon 24/1.8G and found both to be very similar in sharpness wide open,
...Show more →

Dec 10, 2015 at 05:43 AM
bernardl
Offline
Details
p.2 #3Nikon 24mm 1.8g beats Sigma 24mm 1.4 Art
I currently own the Sigma 35mm f1.4 and the Nikkor 24mm f1.4.

I know they are different focal lengths and therefore difficult to compare, but I prefer the sharpness of the Sigma and the look of the Nikon.

The Nikon 24mm f1.8 seems to be the closest thing to the best of both world. I am considering replacing my Nikon 24mm f1.4 by the f1.8.

Cheers,
Bernard
Dec 10, 2015 at 06:03 AM
gdsf2
Offline
Details
p.2 #4Nikon 24mm 1.8g beats Sigma 24mm 1.4 Art
I think what you wre hearing here is both lenses are great. If what you are after is sharpness at 1.8, and you don't need 1.4, then get the Nikon. But you knew that already, didn't you.
Dec 10, 2015 at 08:36 AM
curious80
Offline
Details
p.2 #5Nikon 24mm 1.8g beats Sigma 24mm 1.4 Art
rick2906 wrote:
I want the best 24mm lense! I already have fast 1.4 lense and the 200mm F2. I don't really see the big deal here for 2/3 of a stop for a 24mm lense! Dof is already pretty big with 24mm and i'll use it more for landscape anyway. Tell me why you would desperatly need more a 1.4 vs 1.8 for a 24mm lense?

I think it is fair to compare them because they are about the same price and it is both new design lense with ''better'' optics.


There is not a single 'best' lens. You have to determine what is better for your specific needs. There are users who need and use 24mm f1.4 lenses because it fits their creative needs (remember Nikon makes a $2K 24mm f1.4 lens). The original Canon 24mm 1.4 was fairly weak wide open and yet people paid a lot of money to buy it since it enabled a style of wide-angle-shallow-DOF shooting which is not possible at that focal-length unless you use an ultra-fast aperture. Another area where fast-wide lenses rule is astrophotography. Though you want better sharpness there which is helped by the modern f1.4 designs such as the ones from Sigma which are better wide-open than the legacy designs. You on the other hand are going to use the lens stopped down so it makes a lot of sense that you should look at the f1.8 version. Right tool for the right job.
Dec 10, 2015 at 01:48 PM
rick2906
Offline
Details
p.2 #6Nikon 24mm 1.8g beats Sigma 24mm 1.4 Art
I will mainly use it for landscape but I like shallow dof too!

curious80 wrote:
rick2906 wroteI want the best 24mm lense! I already have fast 1.4 lense and the 200mm F2. I don't really see the big deal here for 2/3 of a stop for a 24mm lense! Dof is already pretty big with 24mm and i'll use it more for landscape anyway. Tell me why you would desperatly need more a 1.4 vs 1.8 for a 24mm lense?

I think it is fair to compare them because they are about the same price and it is both new design lense with ''better'' optics.
There is not a single 'best' lens. You have to determine what is better for your specific needs. There are users who need and use 24mm f1.4 lenses because it fits their creative needs (remember Nikon makes a $2K 24mm f1.4 lens). The original Canon 24mm 1.4 was fairly weak wide open and yet people paid a lot of money to buy it since it enabled a style of wide-angle-shallow-DOF shooting which is not possible at that focal-length unless you use an ultra-fast aperture. Another area where fast-wide lenses rule is astrophotography. Though you want better sharpness there which is
...Show more →

Dec 10, 2015 at 03:54 PM
gdsf2
Offline
Details
p.2 #7Nikon 24mm 1.8g beats Sigma 24mm 1.4 Art
rick2906 wrote:
I will mainly use it for landscape but I like shallow dof too!

curious80 wrote
rick2906 wroteI want the best 24mm lense! I already have fast 1.4 lense and the 200mm F2. I don't really see the big deal here for 2/3 of a stop for a 24mm lense! Dof is already pretty big with 24mm and i'll use it more for landscape anyway. Tell me why you would desperatly need more a 1.4 vs 1.8 for a 24mm lense?

I think it is fair to compare them because they are about the same price and it is both new design lense with ''better'' optics.
There is not a single 'best' lens. You have to determine what is better for your specific needs. There are users who need and use 24mm f1.4 lenses because it fits their creative needs (remember Nikon makes a $2K 24mm f1.4 lens). The original Canon 24mm 1.4 was fairly weak wide open and yet people paid a lot of money to buy it since it enabled a style of wide-angle-shallow-DOF shooting which is not possible at that focal-length unless you use an ultra-fast aperture. Another area where fast-wide lenses rule is astrophotography. Though you want better sharpness there which is helped by the modern f1.4 designs such as the ones from Sigma which are better wide-open than the legacy designs. You on the other hand are going to use the lens stopped down so it makes a lot of sense that you should look at the f1.8 version. Right tool for the right job.


Then you answered your own question. In case the answer still is not clear, I will help you by answer your question with a question. Answer this, and you will know what to buy:

Which lens is very sharp and also gives most limited dof?
Dec 10, 2015 at 04:10 PM
Russtopher
Offline
Details
p.2 #8Nikon 24mm 1.8g beats Sigma 24mm 1.4 Art
Interesting opinions. I have the chance to acquire the Sigma 24 f/1.4 ART glass, for almost FREE. I guess at that price point, I shouldn’t pass it up. It comes with a “docking port” which I know nothing about. Do I grab it over the Nikon f/1.8 version? How do the docking ports work? Are they a necessity?

Thanks
Jan 13, 2022 at 08:08 AM
Sauseschritt
Offline
Details
p.2 #9Nikon 24mm 1.8g beats Sigma 24mm 1.4 Art
Sigh.

Every lens thread ever:

Hooray, a lens won against another lens in the lab !



I'm love my AF-S 24/1.8, it has more saturated colors than my AF-S 20/1.8, while being otherwise very much the same.

And yes its always sharp and clean, too, but I'd be willing to compromise in that regard if the output would be even more magical.

Another great property of it is that you can focus really close without the lens going soft.
Jan 14, 2022 at 08:25 AM
Joseph.
Offline
Details
p.2 #10Nikon 24mm 1.8g beats Sigma 24mm 1.4 Art
I read the first page and thought BenV and Jason Brook started posting again. Turns out it's just another Walking Dead thread. Sigh indeed.
Jan 14, 2022 at 02:05 PM
elkhornsun
Offline
Details
p.2 #11Nikon 24mm 1.8g beats Sigma 24mm 1.4 Art
These tests are subjective and based on the opinion of one person doing the testing. To evaluate a wide angle lens in this manner is foolish and not to be relied upon. Many people use lenses such as these for astrophotography and so lens aberations are what matters the most.

For example the Canon 28mm f/1.8 has quite bad aberrations when shot wide open at f/1.8 as one is going to do when photographing the night sky.

These tests also do not include autofocus accuracy which is also of critical importance. Canon shooters switched from the 24-70mm f/2.8 L lens to the Tamron 28-75mm f/2.8 lens as the Tamron provided better autofocus accuracy.
Jan 14, 2022 at 04:11 PM
friedrice1212
Offline
Details
p.2 #12Nikon 24mm 1.8g beats Sigma 24mm 1.4 Art
Jason_Brook wrote:
Meh. Every sample image I've seen appears flat and dull. Bokeh seems non-existent as if it's a fixed 2.8 and not 1.8. I'll stick with the Sigma.


Glad to see I'm not the only one who thinks this way. I had it and thought it was just too... plain? My favourite 24 is the Canon 1.4L version 1. Not sharp at all, and vignetted, but it was somehow more exciting to shoot
Jan 14, 2022 at 05:17 PM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.2 #13Nikon 24mm 1.8g beats Sigma 24mm 1.4 Art
I love my 24/1.8G, but I agree it's not a bokeh machine, particularly at environmental portrait distances. The resolution's too even across the frame from wide open to give you the dreamy fall-off toward the edges that you get with most f/1.4 lenses. It's much easier to get some pop on your subject with that performance.

I don't mind the extra structure in the bokeh. I like the low field curvature and mild SA at portrait distances and wide apertures, and I really like the close focus capabilities. While the build's a bit plasticy, it's a nicely light 355g. CA correction's decent, flare correction's excellent, backlit performance is excellent, and the 72mm filter thread allows for a couple of stacked filters without causing mechanical vignetting. The even and strong across the frame resolution make it an easy choice for landscape and architecture. The distortion isn't crazy high, and it's simple barrel, so it corrects easily. The sub-$500 used prices for excellent copies don't hurt. For what I want out of a reasonably fast 24, it's more than enough.
Jan 15, 2022 at 11:32 PM
Russtopher
Offline
Details
p.2 #14Nikon 24mm 1.8g beats Sigma 24mm 1.4 Art
However, the newer generation of primes are as large & heavy as primes. It’s so nice to shoot with the older generation of primes. They are small, compact and sharp.
Jan 19, 2022 at 10:50 AM
reggieb
Offline
Details
p.2 #15Nikon 24mm 1.8g beats Sigma 24mm 1.4 Art

Russtopher wrote:
Interesting opinions. I have the chance to acquire the Sigma 24 f/1.4 ART glass, for almost FREE. I guess at that price point, I shouldn’t pass it up. It comes with a “docking port” which I know nothing about. Do I grab it over the Nikon f/1.8 version? How do the docking ports work? Are they a necessity?

Thanks


The dock allows you to do pretty precise autofocus fine tuning and to update firmware. They're very useful, though not a necessity. If you have a few Global Vision lenses, it's a good idea to have one. The Sigma is a solid lens, though it's my least favorite of the Sigma Art/Sport lenses I've owned, and I've had several (14mm f/1.8, 24mm f/1.4, 28mm f/1.4, 50mm f/1.4, 50-100 f/1.8, and 500mm f/4). But if it's cheap and you like the focal length, you'll be alright.
Jan 19, 2022 at 12:01 PM
Max Power
Offline
Details
p.2 #16Nikon 24mm 1.8g beats Sigma 24mm 1.4 Art
"The newer generation of primes is as large and heavy as primes."

I never would have guessed that.
Jan 20, 2022 at 10:02 AM
Blakehfreeman
Offline
Details
p.2 #17Nikon 24mm 1.8g beats Sigma 24mm 1.4 Art
I've owned all three of these primes and think they're all good performers. My favorite of the 3 is the 24mm 1.8G. The 24mm 1.4g is wonderful for portraits but lacking for landscapes. The sigma is sharp, maybe a hair sharper in the center than the 24mm 1.8g, but the 1.8G is better in the corners.

In the end these are all good lenses, with different strengths. I love my 20mm 1.4ART lens, so not a Nikon only guy, but at 24mm, my preference is the 24mm 1.8G.
Jan 20, 2022 at 10:08 AM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister