fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Nikon 24mm 1.8g beats Sigma 24mm 1.4 Art

  
 
rick2906
Offline

p.1 #1Nikon 24mm 1.8g beats Sigma 24mm 1.4 Art
I was really impressed with the results! The sigma arts are usually the best for sharpness and chromatic aberration but nikon's win this time with a cheaper and lighter lense!! The only good thing going for sigma is a little bit less distorsion.

I was waiting for test between these two lenses!

http://nikonrumors.com/2015/12/08/dxomark-review-of-the-nikon-af-s-nikkor-24mm-f1-8g-ed-lens-superb.aspx/
Dec 09, 2015 at 05:45 AM
Steve Perry
Offline
Details
p.1 #2Nikon 24mm 1.8g beats Sigma 24mm 1.4 Art
Nikon 1.8 G series are all really nice lenses. I think they tend to be underrated, but I personally like / own quite a few. Small, light, affordable, and sharp as heck.
Dec 09, 2015 at 05:59 AM
Danner
Offline
Details
p.1 #3Nikon 24mm 1.8g beats Sigma 24mm 1.4 Art
I'm not surprised. Take a look at the 24/1.8G thread here on FM-Nikon. It appears to be a stella optic, perhaps best of the 1.8G's. It's definitely at the top of my list for next lens purchases.
Dec 09, 2015 at 08:31 AM
BenV
Offline
Details
p.1 #4Nikon 24mm 1.8g beats Sigma 24mm 1.4 Art
rick2906 wrote:
I was really impressed with the results! The sigma arts are usually the best for sharpness and chromatic aberration but nikon's win this time with a cheaper and lighter lense!! The only good thing going for sigma is a little bit less distorsion.

I was waiting for test between these two lenses!

http://nikonrumors.com/2015/12/08/dxomark-review-of-the-nikon-af-s-nikkor-24mm-f1-8g-ed-lens-superb.aspx/


I don't think saying "beats" Sigma is fair to say. It ranks a bit sharper and lighter, but it's also a 2/3rd's stop slower for close to the same price. The Nikon 14-24 'only' gets a score of 30, but I don't think anyone would say that isn't a great lens.

Edited on Dec 09, 2015 at 09:55 AM · View previous versions
Dec 09, 2015 at 09:05 AM
Jason_Brook
Offline
Details
p.1 #5Nikon 24mm 1.8g beats Sigma 24mm 1.4 Art
Meh. Every sample image I've seen appears flat and dull. Bokeh seems non-existent as if it's a fixed 2.8 and not 1.8. I'll stick with the Sigma.
Dec 09, 2015 at 09:22 AM
CastIron
Offline
Details
p.1 #6Nikon 24mm 1.8g beats Sigma 24mm 1.4 Art
BenV wrote:
it's also a stop slower for close to the same price.


Not getting into which is outright better, but for the sake of accuracy, the difference between f/1.4 and f/1.8 is only 2/3 of a stop.

It's also worth noting that the measured transmission is much closer than the advertised apertures; T1.7 vs T1.8.
Dec 09, 2015 at 09:47 AM
BenV
Offline
Details
p.1 #7Nikon 24mm 1.8g beats Sigma 24mm 1.4 Art
CastIron wrote:
BenV wroteit's also a stop slower for close to the same price.
Not getting into which is outright better, but for the sake of accuracy, the difference between f/1.4 and f/1.8 is only 2/3 of a stop.

It's also worth noting that the measured transmission is much closer than the advertised apertures; T1.7 vs T1.8.


Thanks for the correction
Dec 09, 2015 at 09:56 AM
gdsf2
Offline
Details
p.1 #8Nikon 24mm 1.8g beats Sigma 24mm 1.4 Art
Note the Sigma 1.4 is better than the Nikon 1.4 and way cheaper. Those are the correct lenses to compare I think. But if you want lightweight and can do with 1.8, the Nikon prime line-up is second to none technically.

My only issue is I felt the several Nikon 1.8 primes I used to own (50mm, 28mm, 85mm) lacked character. They were technicaly very good (sharp) but the pics looked flat SOOC. Took a lot more post processing to get them to pop. And sometimes, I just could't. YMMV.

Edited on Dec 09, 2015 at 12:18 PM · View previous versions
Dec 09, 2015 at 11:06 AM
Mark_L
Offline
Details
p.1 #9Nikon 24mm 1.8g beats Sigma 24mm 1.4 Art
I think I'll wait for a proper lens review from lenstip and lensrentals. DxO may be ok for bodies but lenses.... not so sure.
Dec 09, 2015 at 11:16 AM
architect7
Offline
Details
p.1 #10Nikon 24mm 1.8g beats Sigma 24mm 1.4 Art
Mark_L wrote:
I think I'll wait for a proper lens review from lenstip and lensrentals. DxO may be ok for bodies but lenses.... not so sure.


Exactly what I'm beginning to think. They can't even acknowledge any of the new super-telezooms which is unacceptable for what DXO is known for.
Dec 09, 2015 at 11:46 AM
gdsf2
Offline
Details
p.1 #11Nikon 24mm 1.8g beats Sigma 24mm 1.4 Art
architect7 wrote:
Mark_L wroteI think I'll wait for a proper lens review from lenstip and lensrentals. DxO may be ok for bodies but lenses.... not so sure.
Exactly what I'm beginning to think. They can't even acknowledge any of the new super-telezooms which is unacceptable for what DXO is known for.


Likely can't afford to get thier hands on them to test $$$$
Dec 09, 2015 at 12:20 PM
Danner
Offline
Details
p.1 #12Nikon 24mm 1.8g beats Sigma 24mm 1.4 Art
I do tend to agree about DXO and lens test. The results seem kind of arbitrary and not in line with my experience. I dunno, maybe subjective tests based on actual use are the better way to evaluate lenses.
Dec 09, 2015 at 12:22 PM
CanadaMark
Offline
Details
p.1 #13Nikon 24mm 1.8g beats Sigma 24mm 1.4 Art
I can't remember off the top of my head, but doesn't DXO measure at infinity and Imatest (eg. LensRentals) closer up? I might have those backwards, but the testing distance can make a significant performance difference depending on how the lens is tuned. I also don't think DXO uses multiple copies.
Dec 09, 2015 at 12:45 PM
curious80
Offline
Details
p.1 #14Nikon 24mm 1.8g beats Sigma 24mm 1.4 Art
rick2906 wrote:
I was really impressed with the results! The sigma arts are usually the best for sharpness and chromatic aberration but nikon's win this time with a cheaper and lighter lense!! The only good thing going for sigma is a little bit less distorsion.

I was waiting for test between these two lenses!

http://nikonrumors.com/2015/12/08/dxomark-review-of-the-nikon-af-s-nikkor-24mm-f1-8g-ed-lens-superb.aspx/


An f1.4 lens is always an extreme design which generally requires very different design compromises than an f1.8 design. It is quite common for f1.8 or f2 lenses to be better than their f1.4 counterparts in the overlapping range. You get an f1.4 lens if you want f1.4, not because you want to compare it to an f1.8 lens
Dec 09, 2015 at 02:22 PM
Aztatlan
Offline
Details
p.1 #15Nikon 24mm 1.8g beats Sigma 24mm 1.4 Art
CanadaMark wrote:
I can't remember off the top of my head, but doesn't DXO measure at infinity and Imatest (eg. LensRentals) closer up? I might have those backwards, but the testing distance can make a significant performance difference depending on how the lens is tuned. I also don't think DXO uses multiple copies.


I don't know about DxO but I am pretty sure LensRentals test at infinity. Personally I prefer reviews based on crops and sample images than measured MTFs but I do appreciate the approach LR use in testing multiple copies and plotting the variances.

Personally I put little credence in DxO lens tests. Frankly I find the idea of boiling a factor like sharpness down to a single Mpix number to be absurd. It's a factor affected by so many variables that I don't see how a single number can possibly provide a true representation of sharpness.

With that said, the 24/1.8 is receiving glowing reviews (at least from a sharpness perspective) all over the web so DxO seem to be backing up what others are already saying.
Dec 09, 2015 at 03:15 PM
CanadaMark
Offline
Details
p.1 #16Nikon 24mm 1.8g beats Sigma 24mm 1.4 Art
^^ I am not a huge fan of DXO lens tests either, but I do think their sensor tests have value, and puts everyone one the same playing field.

With either test method though, if it stands out as exceptional, it probably is above average in the real world as well. I look at many sources, but I do like Roger's tests the best since he has so many copies to play with.
Dec 09, 2015 at 03:35 PM
Gregg Heckler
Offline
Details
p.1 #17Nikon 24mm 1.8g beats Sigma 24mm 1.4 Art
"An f1.4 lens is always an extreme design which generally requires very different design compromises than an f1.8 design. It is quite common for f1.8 or f2 lenses to be better than their f1.4 counterparts in the overlapping range. You get an f1.4 lens if you want f1.4, not because you want to compare it to an f1.8 lens "

Exactly. I can tell you a 1.4 lens is far "better" if you need a faster lens, Nikkor or Sigma.
Dec 09, 2015 at 09:10 PM
rick2906
Offline
Details
p.1 #18Nikon 24mm 1.8g beats Sigma 24mm 1.4 Art
I want the best 24mm lense! I already have fast 1.4 lense and the 200mm F2. I don't really see the big deal here for 2/3 of a stop for a 24mm lense! Dof is already pretty big with 24mm and i'll use it more for landscape anyway. Tell me why you would desperatly need more a 1.4 vs 1.8 for a 24mm lense?

I think it is fair to compare them because they are about the same price and it is both new design lense with ''better'' optics.
Dec 09, 2015 at 10:22 PM
gdsf2
Offline
Details
p.1 #19Nikon 24mm 1.8g beats Sigma 24mm 1.4 Art
rick2906 wrote:
I want the best 24mm lense! I already have fast 1.4 lense and the 200mm F2. I don't really see the big deal here for 2/3 of a stop for a 24mm lense! Dof is already pretty big with 24mm and i'll use it more for landscape anyway. Tell me why you would desperatly need more a 1.4 vs 1.8 for a 24mm lense?

I think it is fair to compare them because they are about the same price and it is both new design lense with ''better'' optics.


Easy there. You don't have to convince us. If you want the lens, buy it, use it, and enjoy it. It is ok. They are different lenses, some will like one, others will like the other, that is good news for all of us.
Dec 09, 2015 at 10:39 PM
jtra
Offline
Details
p.1 #20Nikon 24mm 1.8g beats Sigma 24mm 1.4 Art
rick2906 wrote:
I want the best 24mm lense! I already have fast 1.4 lense and the 200mm F2. I don't really see the big deal here for 2/3 of a stop for a 24mm lense! Dof is already pretty big with 24mm and i'll use it more for landscape anyway. Tell me why you would desperatly need more a 1.4 vs 1.8 for a 24mm lense?

I think it is fair to compare them because they are about the same price and it is both new design lense with ''better'' optics.


DoF is pretty good. With fullframe on my 50mm f/1.4 (older non-art Sigma) and f/1.8G at distances I use it for family photography I often need to stop down to 2.5 or more. And I do it because both DoF is too thin and sharpness wide open is also not great.

Now with Sigma 24/1.4 I got a week ago I don't feel the need to stop down that much. DoF is usable wide open and sharpness is also good wide open.

I compared it briefly in shop with Nikon 24/1.8G and found both to be very similar in sharpness wide open, bokeh was same on complex background (about 1.4m focus distance). I considered getting both to choose better one, but ultimately got just Sigma for now, mostly to just maximize aperture distance between prime and 18-35G which I already have.

Sharpness is not a problem except in corners where it does not matter unless you are attempting landscape photography at f/2.8. For landscape it is slightly better than 18-35G at same apertures (zoom starts at f/4 for 24mm), but it is not a big difference.

Here are some pictures:

f/2.2
http://jtra.cz/foto/201512-sigma24-my-samples/20151205155144_4015.medium.jpg
view full size

f/1.4
http://jtra.cz/foto/201512-sigma24-my-samples/20151205161255_4098.medium.jpg
view full size


f/1.4
http://jtra.cz/foto/201512-sigma24-my-samples/20151205161411_4108.medium.jpg
view full size

f/1.4
http://jtra.cz/foto/201512-sigma24-my-samples/20151205161848_4142.medium.jpg
view full size

If there is any problem with Sigma it is in focus system: on my D610 it works pretty well at all distances with 2400K light using center AF point without any tuning. With 4000K it has some small front focus (actually not big deal, my 50/1.8G does it too, friend's D3 does it too, you can test AF dependency on color of target colored charts I have here: http://jtra.cz/foto/focus-shift-by-color-charts/ ). But peripheral AF points have front focus when center is ok which is bigger deal because focus and recompose does not work that much such wide lens (unlike with 50mm).
So I will perhaps try 24/1.8G too to see how it focuses. In the shop when I compared them I did not feel difference, but I was not using peripheral AF points.

On the other hand I have seen people commenting on AF with Nikon 24/1.4G and they were not happy either.
Dec 10, 2015 at 01:26 AM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister