fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?

  
 
CanadaMark
Offline
Details
p.2 #1Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
The Cameralabs link tests all 4 of the big zooms (Nikon, Sigma C, Sigma S, Tamron) on the D810. It's been the most useful test so far for side-by-side comparisons of those I've seen.
Oct 27, 2015 at 01:12 PM
elkhornsun
Offline
Details
p.2 #2Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
You did not specify which lens you used only showing "500mm".
Oct 27, 2015 at 03:04 PM
trenchmonkey
Offline
Details
p.2 #3Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
elkhornsun wrote:
You did not specify which lens you used only showing "500mm".


If you're referring to my post...
The exif provided tells you the lens
Only the Nikon is f5.6 at 500mm, the Sig is f6.3
Oct 27, 2015 at 03:14 PM
elkhornsun
Offline
Details
p.2 #4Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
It could also have been the 500mm f4 lens at f5.6 which is why I asked. Nice shot with lots of detail.

I find that comparisons of same subject/scene with same camera provide me with the information I need to decide on the best lens. Too often subjects are used that make the test worthless or like the Cameralabs test provide no indication of color rendition and absence of CA and loss of contrast with a particular lens. "Sharpness" in an image is as much determined by the contrast as resolution and the camera is very much a part of the equation.

To me the Tamron and Sigma S lenses provided superior IQ to the Nikon at 400mm and 500mm focal lengths based on the test images presented on the cameralabs website.

Even more important is the speed and accuracy of autofocus with the lenses and this was not tested or evaluated which is why I am interested in getting my own Sigma S to test alongside the Nikon 200-500mm lens.
Oct 27, 2015 at 03:25 PM
Lauchlan Toal
Offline
Details
p.2 #5Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
Comparing the 150-600 to the 200-500 is apples and oranges. Clearly, the new Nikon needs to be compared to something more equivalent - Will, I don't suppose you bought that Sigma 200-500 f2.8 that was on the B&S?

In all seriousness, good to see some comparisons of both lenses. Look like they both have advantages.
Oct 27, 2015 at 03:42 PM
trenchmonkey
Offline
Details
p.2 #6Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
It could also have been the 500mm f4 lens at f5.6 which is why I asked. Nice shot with lots of detail.
That's cool, didn't realize primes were part of the discussion.
All things being equal, I knew in the first 5 minutes the Nikon AF
would pale by comparison to the Sig Sport...but I bought the 200-500
because a buddy has been blowin' me away with captures at 500 wide open.
The S is close @f7.1/500mm, big difference. There are enough plusses to each
that I'll be keeping 'em both. Glad you liked the shot, after the swallow captures
he went back in the water and gave me a butt op. When I get home I'll post it too.
Oct 27, 2015 at 03:45 PM
Lance B
Offline
Details
p.2 #7Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
Ephotozione has done a test on the 200-500 but have used a new scoring system. They now use actual LW/PH rather than using descriptors such as "Excellent", "Good", "Fair" etc.

I contacted Ephotozine asking them how their new scoring scale using actual LW/PH numbers corresponds to the old "Excellent", "Good", "Fair" scale. Here is their response:

"As a rough guide, Excellent would be around 2500, and Outstanding would be 3000+. However, this number changes depending on the camera / sensor used, with higher resolution sensors giving higher results."

This seems to be correct when you look at the results in the new system and compare that to the old.

So, looking at the 200-500 results and comparing them to say the Sigma 150-600 Sports it would seem that they are very close. Wide open the 200-500 is a tad better, then it seems that the Sigma is better at f8 and then at f11 the 200-500 is ahead again. Like others, I am a little perplexed at their wide open results as the 200-500 from Camera Labs seems to show that it is almost as sharp wide open as it is stopped down, but this is not what it is showing at Ephotozine. Anyway, the differences between the two lenses are so minimal according to the test that it would be imperciptible in real world shooting.

This is one reason why I like LenScore as they test the lenses at 5 different camera to subject distances thus giving a more accurate evaluation of the lens' performance. Ephotozine, like just about every other lens test site only uses one camera to subject distance which may or may not be the lens' weak or strong point.

Anyway, as with all things, let your eyes be the judge and look at as many samples and reputable test sites as possible to glean an overall idea of the lens' performance.

Also, looking at the 80-400G's results, it is a lot better than people make out, scoring just as well if not better than bth the 200-500 and the Sigma Sports.

Here are the tests of both of the Sigma 150-600's, the Tamron 150-600, the Nikon 200-500 and the Nikon 80-400. Sorry about the way I linked them, but using the normal hyper link didn't seem to work for some reason:

Sigma 150-600 C:
https://www.ephotozine.com/article/sigma-150-600mm-f-5-6-3-dg-os-hsm-contemporary-review-27247

Sigma 150-600 S:
https://www.ephotozine.com/article/sigma-150-600mm-f-5-6-3-dg-os-hsm-sports-lens-review-26786

Nikon 200-500:
https://www.ephotozine.com/article/nikon-af-s-nikkor-200-500mm-f-5-6e-ed-vr-review-28326

Tamron 150-600:
https://www.ephotozine.com/article/tamron-sp-150-600mm-f-5-6-3-di-vc-usd-lens-review-23866

Nikon 80-400G:
https://www.ephotozine.com/article/nikon-nikkor-80-400mm-f-4-5-5-6g-ed-vr-ii-review-22065

Edited on Oct 27, 2015 at 04:03 PM · View previous versions
Oct 27, 2015 at 03:58 PM
elkhornsun
Offline
Details
p.2 #8Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
Good write-up by someone using the Sigma S and Nikon lenses in the field, on land and from a boat. Interesting analysis of keepers when using the two lenses on two different cameras while shooting from a boat.

http://www.naturalart.ca/voice/blog.html

Oct 27, 2015 at 04:01 PM
blutch
Offline
Details
p.2 #9Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
I just got my Sigma Sport yesterday and am incredibly impressed. Will, I haven't used the honkin' big lens hood on it or my 120-300 sport either. What advantage is there to using it other than protecting the glass? (I use UV filters.)

Here's one of my first shots with it.. handheld, no tuning.. it is a fairly heavy crop.

B



© blutch 2015

Oct 27, 2015 at 08:26 PM
trenchmonkey
Offline
Details
p.2 #10Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
What advantage is there to using it (hood) other than protecting the glass? (I use UV filters.)
Seriously?? Keeping out extraneous light for more saturated colors/ ^contrast.
Man, I wouldn't use a UV filter on fine glass if you paid me. Over 50 yrs of lens
purchases and I've never scratched an element. Congrats on the lens, work it

You'll wan't more SS handholdin' 900mm FOV I started out 1/2000th then went to 1/1600th
After 2 weeks use I'm down to 1/1250th with ~90% in focus humpin' this gem. GL
Oct 27, 2015 at 08:47 PM
blutch
Offline
Details
p.2 #11Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
Thanks for the advice TM. It will take me awhile to get it down. I will work on using the hoods on my big lenses more. What do you have against UV filters? Not as sharp? Having the big hood on would make me feel better.. I am a bit clumsy sometimes.

B
Oct 27, 2015 at 08:55 PM
trenchmonkey
Offline
Details
p.2 #12Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
UV serves no purpose in the digital age, can screw up AF, and
lead to weird flaring in backlit or toward light source shooting.
Think about it, extremely well engineered glass you're adding
another element. If you HAVE to "protect" the front of the lens.
get a high quality clear multi-coated filter to lessen the effect. HTH.
Oct 27, 2015 at 09:03 PM
blutch
Offline
Details
p.2 #13Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
I see.. well, I bought a high quality B+W filter, so I thought I bought a high quality clear multi-coated filter....

B
Oct 27, 2015 at 09:06 PM
trenchmonkey
Offline
Details
p.2 #14Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
@ Lance: you DO realize that tester used a CANON 5DmkIII for the Sig Sport
You want the very best results, no less than a D810 will do.
Oct 27, 2015 at 09:07 PM
blutch
Offline
Details
p.2 #15Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
Oct 27, 2015 at 09:11 PM
trenchmonkey
Offline
Details
p.2 #16Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
blutch wrote:
I see.. well, I bought a high quality B+W filter, so I thought I bought a high quality clear multi-coated filter....

B


That'll do ya fine. "UV" is the unnecessary element (no pun intended)
A retailers highest profit margin item is filters. Just sayin'
Oct 27, 2015 at 09:14 PM
elkhornsun
Offline
Details
p.2 #17Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
I have the 200-500mm lens and used it for a few weeks in the Southwest and just received the Sigma Sport lens. I will be doing my own testing over the next several days.

Right out of the box I have a problem with the Sport version of the lens as the collar and foot cannot be removed from the lens. With the 200-500mm lens I shot with it hand held 100% of the time and left the collar and foot off the lens after doing the autofocus fine tuning with my cameras. Easier to hold the lens without the collar and gets the foot completely out of the way. It also takes up less space in my backpack without the collar and foot and mounting plate. A bit lighter as well which does not hurt either.

I bought the 150-600mm Sport to use hand held the majority of the time and not being able to remove the collar and foot may be a deal breaker. I did not realize this was the case. Evidently the Sigma Contemporary and Tamron 150-600mm lenses do allow for removal of the collar and foot. Seems odd to me that with the heavier Sport version that one is stuck with the extra weight of the collar and its foot and plate.

The worst part of the Sport lens' design is that the collar and foot do not slant forward as with the Nikon 200-500mm, Tamron 150-600mm, and Sigma Contemporary lenses. If I mount the lens on a gimbal head then the foot blocks the lens controls on the left or the camera controls (grip, function button, preview button) with the foot on the right side of the lens.

The Sigma folks also in an effort to make up for having the collar and foot permanently in place reduced the distance between the foot and the lens. I don't have huge hands but I cannot get them between the foot and the lens barrel and I need to do this to support the lens when attaching or detaching it from the gimbal head. They also made a very large knurled knob for tightening the collar that is so big that it gets in the way when the lens is attached to the camera.

I like every aspect of the lens except the collar and foot design that gets in the way when trying to hand hold the lens or use it with a gimbal head on a tripod. For me the collar and foot design is a flaw I don't intend to live with and I am sending the lens back to B&H.

I thought I was going to be deciding between the Nikon 200-500mm and the Sigma Sport but now it looks like I will be comparing the Nikon to the Sigma Contemporary instead.

Oct 29, 2015 at 11:51 PM
blutch
Offline
Details
p.2 #18Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
I hope you'll shoot with it before making the collar and foot design a deal breaker. I have normal sized hands and have no problem holding he barrel of the lens to put it on the camera. Also, I rotate the foot out of the way to handhold and it is never a factor.

I do wish there were a little more room, but I've been able to adjust to these tiny annoyances, no problem. It really does seem to be a shame that the collar can't be removed. That makes no sense whatsoever.

B
Oct 30, 2015 at 06:43 AM
trenchmonkey
Offline
Details
p.2 #19Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
The foot comes off if that ounce or so is killing y'all
Oct 30, 2015 at 06:59 AM
johnctharp
Online
Details
p.2 #20Any reviews comparing Nikon 200-500 to Sigma 150-600 S?
trenchmonkey wrote:
The foot comes off if that ounce or so is killing y'all


That, and RRS etc. should come up with a replacement foot that addresses these issues- wish the foot on my Contemporary came off, it only has one screw position!
Oct 30, 2015 at 09:42 AM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister