fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015landscape gear

  
 
Schlotkins
Offline
Details
p.5 #1landscape gear
If you wanted to replicate a 24mm TSE lens with a normal lens by just keeping the lens level and then cropping in post, you would lose alot of resolution but it would be doable on a 5DsR except for extreme shifts.

For example, if you shifted 6mm, you would need to use a lens that is 50% wider (it would be on both sides) and then crop. So you'd use a 16mm lens and then it would be like using a 1.5x APS-C crop camera - that's 1.5^2 = 2.25 = 51/2.25 = 22.6mpx. You would end up with image quality like the 7DM2.

If you wanted full shift, you would end up with 12mpx and need a 12mm lens. For the 17TSE a 6mm shift would need a 11mm lens.

In other words, you need a 11-24mm canon lens.

Chris
Oct 10, 2015 at 08:49 AM
nntnam
Offline
Details
p.5 #2landscape gear
^ Canon 24 TS-E II is not that wide when fully shifted. A 14mm lens would be enough.
Oct 10, 2015 at 08:55 AM
Schlotkins
Offline
Details
p.5 #3landscape gear
nntnam wrote:
^ Canon 24 TS-E II is not that wide when fully shifted. A 14mm lens would be enough.


I'm talking about using a regular lens, keeping it parallel to the ground, going wide, and then cropping to the 24mm TSE shifted shot.

Oct 10, 2015 at 09:01 AM
nntnam
Offline
Details
p.5 #4landscape gear
Schlotkins wrote:
I'm talking about using a regular lens, keeping it parallel to the ground, going wide, and then cropping to the 24mm TSE shifted shot.



I think I'm talking about same thing too. If I remember correctly, it has image circle of 14 or 16mm lens. I tested my 16-35 @16mm and 24 TS-E horizontal panorama (camera's in landscape position). The 24mm is a wider, but not much. I guess it's around 14.5mm at max.
Oct 10, 2015 at 09:12 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.5 #5landscape gear
Schlotkins wrote:
If you wanted to replicate a 24mm TSE lens with a normal lens by just keeping the lens level and then cropping in post, you would lose alot of resolution but it would be doable on a 5DsR except for extreme shifts.


For whom is the primary point "replicating a 24mm TSE lens with a normal lens," by which I'm guessing you might mean a "normal" 24mm lens? What is magic about 24mm? In what circumstance would "replicating" 24 mm be a concern? And how is it an issue to simply set the zoom to a shorter focal length than 24mm to accomplish this?

In fact, one of the most significant reasons that I and many other photographers choose to shoot with high quality zoom lenses is that focal length becomes a flexible variable, allowing us to crop in camera rather than in post and to use the parameter of focal length with the greatest possible flexibility, not only to control the margins of the composition, but also to control relationships between foreground, background, and subject sizes.

I suppose that from the perspective of a photographer whose primary orientation is or has always been using primes, with their jumps from focal length to focal length — such as between 17mm and 24mm and so forth with the TS lenses — it seems logical to want to replicate 24mm. But for me, that is a complete non issue. It doesn't occur to me to want to "replicate 24mm." I choose the focal length that gives me the composition, camera position, relative sizes of background and foreground that I'm looking for, and I let the focal lengths fall where they may.

And if a 24-xxmm lens isn't wide enough for a photograph, whether because I simply want a larger angle of view or because I intend to alter convergence lines in post, I simply use a wider lens. (In my case that happens to be the 16-25 f/4L IS.)

Unless I'm misunderstanding the concern here, and the idea of using a 24mm prime as a baseline for comparison to 24mm on a zoom isn't the issue that it seems to be, the point eludes me. If I want whatever composition I want once the shifts are completed in post, I simply choose a shorter focal length on my 16-24 zoom.

Right?

I notice that the image quality issue seems to have gone away. That's good.

In the end, YMMV, and anyone is certainly free to use whatever gear they prefer to use — but sometimes the explanations of the reasons for the choices may not make a whole lot of sense to folks with a different perspective.

Dan
Oct 10, 2015 at 10:11 AM
Schlotkins
Offline
Details
p.5 #6landscape gear
There was a comment earlier in the thread about just keeping the camera level and zooming out to end up with a shot with the same perspective as a shifted TSE lens that you could crop to end up with the same picture as the TSE lens shifted.

I'm not advocating that. I am just point out how you would need to accomplish that with a zoom and what the resolution cost is.

Chris
Oct 10, 2015 at 12:32 PM
splathrop
Offline
Details
p.5 #7landscape gear
Two relatively inexpensive lenses I wouldn't be without for landscape:

1. Zeiss 50mm f/2 MP. Otus may beat it at wider apertures. Otherwise, stop it down to f/5.6 and enjoy both great resolution and great contrast—with the right light and subject matter you get an impression of detail which supports very large prints. How large depends also on your camera body.

2. Canon 90mm TS-E. A secret weapon in Canon's lineup. At f/5.6, superb full-frame image quality right to the corners. And the 90mm TS-E is relatively inexpensive, small, and lightweight.

Other than that, my suggestion is that if you want to sell landscapes, plan to print big and buy equipment accordingly. Around the Northeast, anyway, big prints seem to sell better, and to command much higher prices.

Note also that someone planning to print big can get help with the impression of detail by avoiding going too wide. A seascape taken with your 90mm TS-E is going to put more pixels-per-periwinkel into the image than one taken with a wide angle lens.
Oct 10, 2015 at 09:54 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister