Schlotkins wrote:
If you wanted to replicate a 24mm TSE lens with a normal lens by just keeping the lens level and then cropping in post, you would lose alot of resolution but it would be doable on a 5DsR except for extreme shifts.
For whom is the primary point "replicating a 24mm TSE lens with a normal lens," by which I'm guessing you might mean a "normal" 24mm lens? What is magic about 24mm? In what circumstance would "replicating" 24 mm be a concern? And how is it an issue to simply set the zoom to a shorter focal length than 24mm to accomplish this?
In fact, one of the most significant reasons that I and many other photographers choose to shoot with high quality zoom lenses is that focal length becomes a flexible variable, allowing us to crop in camera rather than in post and to use the parameter of focal length with the greatest possible flexibility, not only to control the margins of the composition, but also to control relationships between foreground, background, and subject sizes.
I suppose that from the perspective of a photographer whose primary orientation is or has always been using primes, with their jumps from focal length to focal length — such as between 17mm and 24mm and so forth with the TS lenses — it seems logical to want to replicate 24mm. But for me, that is a complete non issue. It doesn't occur to me to want to "replicate 24mm." I choose the focal length that gives me the composition, camera position, relative sizes of background and foreground that I'm looking for, and I let the focal lengths fall where they may.
And if a 24-xxmm lens isn't wide enough for a photograph, whether because I simply want a larger angle of view or because I intend to alter convergence lines in post, I simply use a wider lens. (In my case that happens to be the 16-25 f/4L IS.)
Unless I'm misunderstanding the concern here, and the idea of using a 24mm prime as a baseline for comparison to 24mm on a zoom isn't the issue that it seems to be, the point eludes me. If I want whatever composition I want once the shifts are completed in post, I simply choose a shorter focal length on my 16-24 zoom.
Right?
I notice that the image quality issue seems to have gone away. That's good.
In the end, YMMV, and anyone is certainly free to use whatever gear they prefer to use — but sometimes the explanations of the reasons for the choices may not make a whole lot of sense to folks with a different perspective.
Dan