fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015landscape gear

  
 
melcat
Offline
Details
p.4 #1landscape gear
melcat wrote:
You can say cropping from a superwide zoom on a high resolution camera can substitute for a 24mm shift lens.


gdanmitchell wrote:
What? I didn't write that.


I said that you could argue that, not that you did. If you're not, and you think Canon's 24mm and 17mm TS lenses aren't a good idea because they're not zooms, I'm left wondering how you think perspective correction should be done.

I can't say (and am not saying) that no one uses the brands, models, and types of lenses you lust for when doing landscape.

I don't "lust for" them. I have exactly one EF lens that isn't Canon, because Canon, inexplicably, doesn't make a fast 100mm macro.

But I can say with certainty that the use of such equipment is relatively rare (or, in some cases, highly specialized) by comparison to the use of more prosaic gear like zoom lenses.

I honestly don't know. I regard any such claims with scepticism unless they are supported by statistics. Looking at the serial number on my early production 24 TS-E Mk II, I don't think it's a terribly rare lens.




Edited on Oct 08, 2015 at 09:03 PM · View previous versions
Oct 08, 2015 at 08:51 PM
jcolwell
Online
Details
p.4 #2landscape gear
melcat wrote:
... I have exactly one EF lens that isn't Canon, because Canon, inexplicably, doesn't make a fast 100m macro...


How fast should a fast macro be? Most of mine are f/4, some are faster (at f/2.8 and 2.5), and I use them stopped down.
Oct 08, 2015 at 09:02 PM
melcat
Offline
Details
p.4 #3landscape gear
jcolwell wrote:
melcat wrote... I have exactly one EF lens that isn't Canon, because Canon, inexplicably, doesn't make a fast 100m macro...
How fast should a fast macro be? Most of mine are f/4, some are faster (at f/2.8 and 2.5), and I use them stopped down.


I like the Zeiss because it's f/2. It was a direct replacement for my Olympus 100mm f/2, which, although only semi-macro, focussed close enough for my purposes (I couldn't find a copy of the OM 90mm f/2). Before that, I had the Tamron 90mm f/2.5, which was hugely popular.

All of those lenses are/were completely usable wide open. The Canon 100mm f/2.8 IS, as far as I can tell from test results, is not, due to the vignetting. I wasn't about to waste $1000 finding out with the Zeiss available.
Oct 08, 2015 at 09:09 PM
jcolwell
Online
Details
p.4 #4landscape gear
I've never met a macro lens that I didn't like. That includes the EF 100/2.8L macro.

All of those lenses are/were completely usable wide open. The Canon 100mm f/2.8 IS, as far as I can tell from test results, is not due to the vignetting

I prefer to comment on lenses that I've actually used. Just sayin.
Oct 08, 2015 at 09:16 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.4 #5landscape gear
melcat wrote:
melcat wroteYou can say cropping from a superwide zoom on a high resolution camera can substitute for a 24mm shift lens.
gdanmitchell wroteWhat? I didn't write that.
I said that you could argue that, not that you did. If you're not, and you think Canon's 24mm and 17mm TS lenses aren't a good idea because they're not zooms, I'm left wondering how you think perspective correction should be done.


I think Canon makes fine tilt/shift lenses, and those who need them will be very happy with them. The fact that they are not zooms has no impact on the question of whether they are good lenses — they are good lenses.

The questions are how useful and how necessary these good lenses are they for landscape photography. If you find them useful and necessary for your landscape photography you should consider getting them and using them. There are rare occasions when I could have used a TS in my photography, but not enough that I want to carry them. That's a personal choice, and its one that a lot of (but not all) landscape photographers seem to agree with.

As to how I do perspective correction:
http://www.gdanmitchell.com/2009/02/20/a-test-correcting-perspective-in-post-processing
http://www.gdanmitchell.com/2007/09/16/a-test-correcting-lens-distortion-in-post-processing

(I frequently apply perspective correction to photographs in post, ranging from mostly minor to occasionally rather strong.)

And, yes, I'm fully aware that perspective correction is not the only thing that TS lenses do, and that simulating a tilting plane of focus in post is, uh, tricky.

Regarding some of my personal thoughts about prime lenses for landscape photography:
http://www.gdanmitchell.com/2015/01/10/photographic-myths-and-platitudes-landscape-photography-lenses-part-ii

Dan
Oct 08, 2015 at 11:52 PM
melcat
Offline
Details
p.4 #6landscape gear
gdanmitchell wrote:
As to how I do perspective correction:
http://www.gdanmitchell.com/2009/02/20/a-test-correcting-perspective-in-post-processing


If you correct a building "leaning back" in Photoshop's Lens Correction filter, you end up with an image that has fewer pixels at the bottom. You then need to crop it to be a rectangle, so you lose angle of view at the top of the image. That is why, if you want to end up with something a 24mm shift lens would have shot, you often need to start with an image shot on an even wider lens. That's why I said that to replicate a 24mm shift lens I'd have to carry a 16-35 in addition to the 24-70 zoom, so I wouldn't be ahead weight wise and might as well carry the 24 shift.

If you use Adobe Camera Raw, the situation is worse, because its vertical perspective correction is done wrongly. In Photoshop, you can arrange not to lose pixels at the top by expanding the canvas first, and if you want to crop from the bottom (so it's no longer 3:2 ratio) you can get more of the top in. This is extremely common when shooting in portrait orientation, as the 3:2 ratio often isn't as suitable. ACR can't do this - you always lose all possible pixels at the top. I don't know what Lightroom does, but I'd be surprised if it's different from ACR.

When using this technique, you need to guesstimate in the finder how much of the top you'll be losing. It's a lot more intuitive to just turn a knob on the lens and see the image as it will finally appear; a shift lens is simply easier and more pleasant to use.

A simpler, and older, technique if you don't have a shift lens is not to point the camera up and stretch pixels in post, but to keep the camera level and just crop in post. That was what I was referring to.
Oct 09, 2015 at 02:59 AM
jcolwell
Online
Details
p.4 #7landscape gear
I often use T-S lenses; however, I don't hesitate to use an ordinary lens for photos that are better suited to a T-S lens. I do perspective correction manually in PS CS6. It's tricky, because you have to balance the differences between human perception of perspective with what the camera records. IOW, it's subjective, unless you make everything rectilinear, which is not how it looks to the human observer. Also, whether you expand one end (usually the top) or contract the other end is only part of the process, you also have to adjust the 'height', in order to get the correct aspect ratio.
Oct 09, 2015 at 06:05 AM
Harold Carlson
Offline
Details
p.4 #8landscape gear
I didn't read every word of every reply but I'm surprised no one has mentioned medium format, I think Pentax is pretty affordable. Is medium format obsolete these days or just way too heavy to even think about hiking with?
Oct 09, 2015 at 06:50 AM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.4 #9landscape gear
I know this is a Canon thread...but if I was just doing landscapes, I'd get the A7RII and the Sony FE 16-35 f/4 and the FE 70-200 f/4. That is what I'm personally planning to do once the price drops on the body to a more reasonable (for Sony) level.....
Oct 09, 2015 at 06:56 AM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.4 #10landscape gear
jcolwell wrote:
melcat wrote... I have exactly one EF lens that isn't Canon, because Canon, inexplicably, doesn't make a fast 100m macro...
How fast should a fast macro be? Most of mine are f/4, some are faster (at f/2.8 and 2.5), and I use them stopped down.


The good ones (Zeiss and Zuiko) are all f/2...
Oct 09, 2015 at 07:08 AM
jcolwell
Online
Details
p.4 #11landscape gear
melcat wrote:
... I have exactly one EF lens that isn't Canon, because Canon, inexplicably, doesn't make a fast 100m macro...

jcolwell wrote:
How fast should a fast macro be? Most of mine are f/4, some are faster (at f/2.8 and 2.5), and I use them stopped down.

molson wrote:
The good ones (Zeiss and Zuiko) are all f/2...


My Zeiss MP 50/2 ZE is also f/2, but it's best stopped down.

Besides, some of the very best ones are f/4. Most notably, the SMC Pentax-A* ED 200/4 Macro, which I haven't yet had the pleasure of using.
Oct 09, 2015 at 07:47 AM
dgdg
Offline
Details
p.4 #12landscape gear
Landscape, starting all over again, want to use the 24mm ts-e, money not a big issue.

My preferences may be different from others as I like to take long exposures of the night sky. I often keep the shutter open for 4 minutes consecutively for an hour. The newer sensors seem to have some noise issues and may not fair as well as last year's models. In probably all other ways they truly shine. YMMV.

If I were to do all over again given the main constraint of wanting to use the ts-e lens and take 4 minute exposures with the least noise possible, I'd do the following for landscape.

A7R version 1 with Metabones IV -T adapter.
Canon 5D3 as an all purpose camera backup (I'd prefer the 5DSR but cost not there yet for me)
Tamron 15-30mm f/2.8 - I feel this is the best wide angle fast zoom available for Canon mount.
Canon 24mm ts-e
Cannon 24-70 f/2.8 II
Canon 100-400mm II - a super sharp tele for more distant landscapes and maybe even some large animals you will encounter.

Oct 09, 2015 at 11:15 AM
killersnowman
Offline
Details
p.4 #13landscape gear
If i were to start over i would get:

Alpa TC
Alpagon 5.6/23mm
Alpar 4.0/35mm
Alpagon 5.6/70mm
And just about any modern Phase One back with Live View

A boy can dream
Oct 09, 2015 at 11:23 AM
Schlotkins
Offline
Details
p.4 #14landscape gear
arbitrage wrote:
I know this is a Canon thread...but if I was just doing landscapes, I'd get the A7RII and the Sony FE 16-35 f/4 and the FE 70-200 f/4. That is what I'm personally planning to do once the price drops on the body to a more reasonable (for Sony) level.....


I'd probably go the the D810 + 16-35 and 70+200 Nikon. ISO64 gives you almost another 3/4 stop in DR and Nikon's lenses are better. (If we were going non Nikon)

For me, I love my TSEs, especially for city work. Nikon doesn't have a 17TSE. Plus I have a canon tele so I just use the A7r for high DR landscape images. Finally, I like the Sony for when I want to travel light. the 28-70 isn't terrible and the 55 is great.

Chris
Oct 09, 2015 at 12:03 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.4 #15landscape gear
melcat wrote:
gdanmitchell wroteAs to how I do perspective correction:
http://www.gdanmitchell.com/2009/02/20/a-test-correcting-perspective-in-post-processing
If you correct a building "leaning back" in Photoshop's Lens Correction filter, you end up with an image that has fewer pixels at the bottom. You then need to crop it to be a rectangle, so you lose angle of view at the top of the image. That is why, if you want to end up with something a 24mm shift lens would have shot, you often need to start with an image shot on an even wider lens. That's why I said that to replicate a 24mm shift lens I'd have to carry a 16-35 in addition to the
...Show more →

Your theoretical understanding is correct — when you correct in post you are stretching pixels and effectively beginning with slightly lower resolution image.

Like you, I once presumed that this was a major killer of image quality.

Perhaps unlike you, I decided to try it and see how it works in actual practice — which means making various degrees of adjustment and then both inspecting comparative examples and high magnifications and also making large fine art prints.

It turned out that in almost all cases the difference was literally invisible. As in none.

There is often a tendency in photography, at least from certain perspectives, to give greater consideration to the theoretical concept as a predictor of usability than to give consideration to real world testing. This is odd, since it is so darned easy to do the tests. (If you have a moment, go back and read both of my short articles on this a bit more carefully, and look at the examples that are included. In the case of the small image of grasses, can you see a significant difference in resolution between the two halves of the 100% magnification crops? I can't)

As I pointed out, there are things that cannot be done without the TS lenses. For example you cannot tilt the plane of focus in the way that is sometimes useful with the TS lens. (The alternative of doing focus blending can work in many landscape situations.)

jcolwell wrote:
I often use T-S lenses; however, I don't hesitate to use an ordinary lens for photos that are better suited to a T-S lens. I do perspective correction manually in PS CS6. It's tricky, because you have to balance the differences between human perception of perspective with what the camera records. IOW, it's subjective, unless you make everything rectilinear, which is not how it looks to the human observer. Also, whether you expand one end (usually the top) or contract the other end is only part of the process, you also have to adjust the 'height', in order to get
...Show more →

I'm with you on this. In most cases where I feel that some "correction" is needed I most certainly do not want to make the verticals be perfectly vertical and parallel to one another. To my eyes that looks wrong, and in fact it actually makes in look like the subject is larger at the top than at the bottom, especially if the low camera angle is apparent from other elements in the scene.

What I virtually always to is look for a "just right" compromise between the "distortion" of the capture and the unreality of a "perfect" correction. I move things in the general direction of being less distorted... and I have to use my own judgment to determine where the best point of adjustment lies.

Harold Carlson wrote:
I didn't read every word of every reply but I'm surprised no one has mentioned medium format, I think Pentax is pretty affordable. Is medium format obsolete these days or just way too heavy to even think about hiking with?


It came up on page three of the thread and I wrote a brief message about it. The Pentax mini MF system is quite impressive and could be a perfect choice for some photographers. I considered it myself, but ultimately decided that with 50MP FF bodies and the very large range of lenses available for them, and with the larger size of the camera and the lenses (and more limited lens availability) that it made more sense to work with FF, a format that allows me to make try large and very high quality prints.

Several large format photographers I know who moved the MF film and eventually to MF digital are now working more and more with FF bodies. In most ways, the potential image quality from today's 50MP FF DSLRs surpass that of MF film.

Dan
Oct 09, 2015 at 02:12 PM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.4 #16landscape gear
jcolwell wrote:
I often use T-S lenses; however, I don't hesitate to use an ordinary lens for photos that are better suited to a T-S lens. I do perspective correction manually in PS CS6. It's tricky, because you have to balance the differences between human perception of perspective with what the camera records. IOW, it's subjective, unless you make everything rectilinear, which is not how it looks to the human observer. Also, whether you expand one end (usually the top) or contract the other end is only part of the process, you also have to adjust the 'height', in order to get
...Show more →

I found this a very cumbersome and tedious post processing correction to make it appear coming from a TS lens (and I try to avoid too much post processing in general). I prefer TS any time over a regular lens for landscapes. The only cumbersome thing with TS is the weight and especially with the 24/3.5 TSE II its bulky size. If I need to carry my photo gear for a long time (hikes, travel), I mostly use smaller alternative lenses instead of my TS lenses.
Oct 09, 2015 at 02:30 PM
jcolwell
Online
Details
p.4 #17landscape gear
retrofocus wrote:
I found this a very cumbersome and tedious post processing correction to make it appear coming from a TS lens (and I try to avoid too much post processing in general). I prefer TS any time over a regular lens for landscapes.


Me too. I'm just saying that I don't hesitate to take a photo with perspective distortion that I know I can correct later, just because I don't have my T-S lenses with me.
Oct 09, 2015 at 02:42 PM
Monito
Offline
Details
p.4 #18landscape gear
jcolwell wrote:
Also, whether you expand one end (usually the top) or contract the other end is only part of the process, you also have to adjust the 'height', in order to get the correct aspect ratio.


That's the wrong way to go about it, which is why that way is so difficult: adjusting two variables simultaneously and hoping to get a correct aspect ratio by eye (i.e. subjectively). I know because I used to do it in Photoshop that way myself.

The key is to note that programs like Lightroom do the vertical perspective correction by tilting at the middle, not expanding one end or contracting the other. By tilting in the middle, correct aspect ratio is automatically retained.

In Photoshop, you can tilt the top one way and tilt the bottom the other until the tilt point returns to the middle. The middle point can be objectively measured and in any case is much easier to gauge by eye when doing it this way than gauging aspect ratio by eye. I think it might also be possible to combine one tilt and the height adjustment in a way to achieve the objective tilt-in-the-middle balance and I may have done it that way.

But as far as I can tell the principle is simple: arrange the final tilt correction to swing around the middle of the frame.

Note: the extra pixels of the 5DS come in handy for this kind of work. But if you want to use all the pixels in any given sensor you do have to go to a Tilt-Shift or shifting lens.
Oct 09, 2015 at 04:12 PM
jcolwell
Online
Details
p.4 #19landscape gear
Monito wrote:
That's the wrong way to go about it, which is why that way is so difficult: adjusting two variables simultaneously and hoping to get a correct aspect ratio by eye (i.e. subjectively).


There's nothing wrong about it. It works fine for me, and it's not particularly difficult.
Oct 09, 2015 at 05:08 PM
melcat
Offline
Details
p.4 #20landscape gear
gdanmitchell wrote:
Your theoretical understanding is correct — when you correct in post you are stretching pixels and effectively beginning with slightly lower resolution image.

Like you, I once presumed that this was a major killer of image quality.

Perhaps unlike you, I decided to try it and see how it works in actual practice — which means making various degrees of adjustment and then both inspecting comparative examples and high magnifications and also making large fine art prints.


You completely missed the point of my post, which was not about losing pixels or image quality, but about losing field of view. In general, for a non-trivial perspective correction, you cannot simulate a 24mm shift lens in post with a 24-70mm zoom, no matter what reduction of image quality you are prepared to accept.

I thought last night about fixing the ambiguous first sentence to read "fewer pixels at the bottom than the top" but decided it was OK in context. Of course I was thinking the context included more than the first sentence.

Nor should you assume what I assume. I've used the Photoshop method for almost 10 years. Before I had the 24 TS, I shot with my 16-35 and corrected in post, so much so that I didn't buy a 24-70 until well after I owned the 24 TS. My Flickr stream even includes a couple of images shot with a 100mm lens and perspective corrected in post. I routinely bend images beyond the amount you did in the example on your site.

That said, if I used Nikon cameras I think I'd want their 85mm f/2.8 perspective control macro lens. As has been said several times now by different people, it's just more convenient to do it on the lens.
Oct 09, 2015 at 07:34 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister