fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Quick S-007 review/thoughts..

  
 
rscheffler
Offline
Details
p.3 #1Quick S-007 review/thoughts..
Michael, thanks for the reply! I agree, I'll stick with AF lenses for DSLR event work. The two new primes from Tamron sound interesting!

adamdewilde wrote:
I'm getting too skinny though, so it's a good idea for me to use the S-system once and a while. Since I don't really have time to exercise.

Gary Clennan wrote:
Adam - a steady (Canadian) diet of bacon and donuts will solve that little problem....

adamdewilde wrote:
Gary - I miss French Cruller donuts from Tim Hortons so much!


Adam, you've been out of Canada too long. It's Honey Cruller (also one of my faves, other than Old Fashioned Plain and Sour Cream Plain)... Here's the nutritional breakdown. I'm sure it would wreak havoc with your diet (carbs and sugar galore)!

Grade: D-

Calories 310
Calories from Fat 162
Total Fat 18g 28%
Saturated Fat 9g 45%
Cholesterol 50mg 17%
Sodium 200mg 8%
Carbohydrates 37g 12%
Dietary Fiber 0g 0%
Sugars 22g
Protein 2g

Sep 07, 2015 at 07:31 PM
Dpedraza
Offline
Details
p.3 #2Quick S-007 review/thoughts..
Michael over at luminous landscapes has a first look review of the 007.

https://luminous-landscape.com/leica-s007-first-impressions-review/
Sep 08, 2015 at 06:02 AM
ryankarr
Offline
Details
p.3 #3Quick S-007 review/thoughts..
rscheffler wrote:
Adam, you've been out of Canada too long. It's Honey Cruller (also one of my faves, other than Old Fashioned Plain and Sour Cream Plain)... Here's the nutritional breakdown. I'm sure it would wreak havoc with your diet (carbs and sugar galore)!

Grade: D-

Calories 310
Calories from Fat 162
Total Fat 18g 28%
Saturated Fat 9g 45%
Cholesterol 50mg 17%
Sodium 200mg 8%
Carbohydrates 37g 12%
Dietary Fiber 0g 0%
Sugars 22g
Protein 2g



I want one so bad. I'm also off carbs at the moment
Sep 08, 2015 at 07:40 AM
Gary Clennan
Offline
Details
p.3 #4Quick S-007 review/thoughts..
Yeah, what's up with the misquote Adam?!?! You knew us Canadians would call you out on it! Me, I'm sipping a Timmies at the moment but no Cruller.
Sep 08, 2015 at 08:16 AM
adamdewilde
Offline
Details
p.3 #5Quick S-007 review/thoughts..
rscheffler wrote:
Michael, thanks for the reply! I agree, I'll stick with AF lenses for DSLR event work. The two new primes from Tamron sound interesting!

adamdewilde wroteI'm getting too skinny though, so it's a good idea for me to use the S-system once and a while. Since I don't really have time to exercise.
Gary Clennan wroteAdam - a steady (Canadian) diet of bacon and donuts will solve that little problem....
adamdewilde wroteGary - I miss French Cruller donuts from Tim Hortons so much!
Adam, you've been out of Canada too long. It's Honey Cruller (also one of my faves, other than Old Fashioned Plain and Sour Cream Plain)... Here's the nutritional breakdown. I'm sure it would wreak havoc with your diet (carbs and sugar galore)!

Grade: D-

Calories 310
Calories from Fat 162
Total Fat 18g 28%
Saturated Fat 9g 45%
Cholesterol 50mg 17%
Sodium 200mg 8%
Carbohydrates 37g 12%
Dietary Fiber 0g 0%
Sugars 22g
Protein 2g



Yeah FAT is good.. But ONLY if you're eating ZERO Carbohydrates.
Donuts = Epic fail.

And yeah, I'm Retro Canadian. I haven't been there for 8 years, and I haven't lived there for 13 years. Obviously at some point in the last 13 years Timmy's started hating on the French. Their French Crullers are now in fact called Honey Crullers.. What a strange world we live in. I wonder if they taste the same!
Sep 08, 2015 at 07:02 PM
adamdewilde
Offline
Details
p.3 #6Quick S-007 review/thoughts..
ryankarr wrote:
rscheffler wroteAdam, you've been out of Canada too long. It's Honey Cruller (also one of my faves, other than Old Fashioned Plain and Sour Cream Plain)... Here's the nutritional breakdown. I'm sure it would wreak havoc with your diet (carbs and sugar galore)!

Grade: D-

Calories 310
Calories from Fat 162
Total Fat 18g 28%
Saturated Fat 9g 45%
Cholesterol 50mg 17%
Sodium 200mg 8%
Carbohydrates 37g 12%
Dietary Fiber 0g 0%
Sugars 22g
Protein 2g

I want one so bad. I'm also off carbs at the moment


.. I just landed in L.A. and did the obligatory In-N-Out run (not carb free, since I don't diet while in transit on long flights). Now I'm going to try to take a nap while my bedsheets are in the wash.
Sep 08, 2015 at 07:05 PM
adamdewilde
Offline
Details
p.3 #7Quick S-007 review/thoughts..
Gary Clennan wrote:
Yeah, what's up with the misquote Adam?!?! You knew us Canadians would call you out on it! Me, I'm sipping a Timmies at the moment but no Cruller.



Ask them when they changed the name of the donut from French Cruller to Honey Cruller.. And also ask what the French did wrong to get their named donut rights revoked.
Sep 08, 2015 at 07:05 PM
Gary Clennan
Offline
Details
p.3 #8Quick S-007 review/thoughts..
adamdewilde wrote:
Gary Clennan wroteYeah, what's up with the misquote Adam?!?! You knew us Canadians would call you out on it! Me, I'm sipping a Timmies at the moment but no Cruller.
Ask them when they changed the name of the donut from French Cruller to Honey Cruller.. And also ask what the French did wrong to get their named donut rights revoked.


Haha... The French wanted to separate from Canada so maybe Mr. Horton got upset and changed the donut name?

Fun fact - did you know that the first ever Tim Hortons store opened in 1964 in Mr. Scheffler's home town?
Sep 09, 2015 at 07:56 AM
adamdewilde
Offline
Details
p.3 #9Quick S-007 review/thoughts..
Gary Clennan wrote:
adamdewilde wrote
Gary Clennan wroteYeah, what's up with the misquote Adam?!?! You knew us Canadians would call you out on it! Me, I'm sipping a Timmies at the moment but no Cruller.
Ask them when they changed the name of the donut from French Cruller to Honey Cruller.. And also ask what the French did wrong to get their named donut rights revoked.
Haha... The French wanted to separate from Canada so maybe Mr. Horton got upset and changed the donut name?

Fun fact - did you know that the first ever Tim Hortons store opened in 1964 in Mr. Scheffler's home town?


, he was a hockey player right? Now it's a billion dollar donut & coffee company.
(In all fairness Hockey is a safe guess.)
Sep 09, 2015 at 10:57 AM
joakim
Offline
Details
p.3 #10Quick S-007 review/thoughts..
Bringing off-topic to an all new level, well done gentlemen
Sep 09, 2015 at 12:32 PM
rscheffler
Offline
Details
p.3 #11Quick S-007 review/thoughts..
Gary Clennan wrote:
Yeah, what's up with the misquote Adam?!?! You knew us Canadians would call you out on it! Me, I'm sipping a Timmies at the moment but no Cruller.

adamdewilde wrote:
Ask them when they changed the name of the donut from French Cruller to Honey Cruller.. And also ask what the French did wrong to get their named donut rights revoked.


20 years ago I worked in a camera shop several doors down from the original Tim Hortons in Hamilton (perhaps Hamilton's greatest export?). I don't ever remember it being called anything other than Honey Cruller. On the other hand, Dunkin' Donuts does have a French Cruller. Maybe my memory is going...

Gary, next time you're in Hamilton, we'll have to do a Hortons pilgrimage. BTW, the camera shop is still there, too. And they're now a bit of a Leica dealer, though not lots of inventory.

Gary Clennan wrote:
Haha... The French wanted to separate from Canada so maybe Mr. Horton got upset and changed the donut name?

Fun fact - did you know that the first ever Tim Hortons store opened in 1964 in Mr. Scheffler's home town?

adamdewilde wrote:
, he was a hockey player right? Now it's a billion dollar donut & coffee company.
(In all fairness Hockey is a safe guess.)


Yes, hockey player. Then died in a car accident. His franchisee, a Hamilton cop named Ron Joyce, bought out his widow, IIRC, built up the Tim Hortons empire, and is now the one who is the billionaire (or close to it). Nice guy, see him at some McMaster University events I work...
Sep 09, 2015 at 01:25 PM
joakim
Offline
Details
p.3 #12Quick S-007 review/thoughts..
Red Dot Forum has posted a review today, S 007 review

And Sean Reid has a new article with some studio tests which he ends with saying that if he had $20,000 free for another system he would be very tempted by the S-007, me too

No news on the donut front though.
Sep 10, 2015 at 07:20 AM
zhangyue
Online
Details
p.3 #13Quick S-007 review/thoughts..
His review is very good and persuasive It cover almost all the topic. but the thing is if you read his S2 or S006 review a few years back, you will feel those are prefect camera as well.

No disrespect for David, I like his review. very detail cover lots of corner. just make sure try the camera first, buy camera based on your experience but not glowing review from internet.
Sep 10, 2015 at 10:23 AM
adamdewilde
Offline
Details
p.3 #14Quick S-007 review/thoughts..
Hahha... Someone in Canada needs to go take some S-007 + 120 Macro shots of FRENCH *ahem* Honey Crullers to tie this all back together for joakim
Sep 10, 2015 at 10:33 AM
joakim
Offline
Details
p.3 #15Quick S-007 review/thoughts..
Ha ha, yeah that's the missing link
Sep 10, 2015 at 10:36 AM
zhangyue
Online
Details
p.3 #16Quick S-007 review/thoughts..
Adam, I'd like to bump your thread since I now tried S007 at Leica Store SF yesterday. I haven't even look the file I took with it yet.

During briefly visit in two hour, I tested SL and 24mm S, 100mm S, 30-90mm Zoom. 24mm is mul function that can't AF. I can hear the motor sound trying to focus but link seems broken. They are now sending the lens for repair. S007 during middle of shooting, it give nasty blotch color spots all over the frame. They capture a picture of LCD screen and send to Leica at that time. I was told the firmware is latest. They don't know what happened. I havent look the files on my computer yet, I hope it only corrupted on JPEG but not raw, I shoot both.

Since I haven't play the file. I will not comment on IQ, but I must say the camera undergone a good overhaul for GOOD. the shutter is brilliant, means almost as good as Canikon. The mirror is also a lot snapper as well. The focusing is 2~3 times faster and also quieter even with same lens, weird. S2 and 006 AFC are un usable given shutter delay and miserable AFC focus speed. S007 seems improved and usable. checking result from LCD, (I use it around SF street outside of Leica Store ) the focus accuracy under AFC does not impress me, TBH. (and I know what I am talking about. I understand how AF works perfectly)

I also play SL with 50lux R I brought. The first thing I notice is the black frame of first shot. Adam, your SL report help me to understand what is going on here. It didn't happen during rest of shooting. I will comment that later once had more time.

Given I also interested in a few S lens myself, I put them on my S006 body as well. I will hold my judgement since I haven't look the file yet and I know Leica's JPEG are waste of time compare to what camera capable doing. My feeling about this visit is very mixed.

The store is highly recommended, very courtesy and patient about customer request. they have a nice selection of M lens and camera, the lowest price on MM is about $3500. too pity I am not in M mind right now.

I will post more comments later.
Dec 30, 2015 at 05:14 PM
adamdewilde
Offline
Details
p.3 #17Quick S-007 review/thoughts..
zhangyue wrote:
Adam, I'd like to bump your thread since I now tried S007 at Leica Store SF yesterday. I haven't even look the file I took with it yet.

During briefly visit in two hour, I tested SL and 24mm S, 100mm S, 30-90mm Zoom. 24mm is mul function that can't AF. I can hear the motor sound trying to focus but link seems broken. They are now sending the lens for repair. S007 during middle of shooting, it give nasty blotch color spots all over the frame. They capture a picture of LCD screen and send to Leica at that
...Show more →


Good to hear your thoughts. I agree with you on the S-007 points you listed. Especially the focusing accuracy issue.

As for the SL + Black frame. I exchanged my M-T adapter and I have only seen the black frame twice since (and I've been using that adapter now for weeks). The old adapter was doing a black frame every time I mounted a new lens or switched the camera off and on. So it was definitely an adapter problem.

I've not seen the image spots that you mention. And as for S lenses not working.. It's typical, and is a result of two issues AFAIK. One, the firmware in camera and on lens are separate, so sometimes they get confused and AF ceases to work. And second, Leica was having issues with a part. Mostly in the 120S, but it did affect a good number of other lenses from what I was told.

The S007 really does feel a lot more like a Canikon DSLR. But for a while now, my work has been very slow paced and I have no problems shooting with the S-006. And I even prefer it, as I'm more use to the colors it produces. That and any spare chance I get, I'm fooling around with the SL and various M lenses


Anyway, would love to hear your thoughts once you process the files!
Jan 01, 2016 at 03:07 PM
zhangyue
Online
Details
p.3 #18Quick S-007 review/thoughts..
adamdewilde wrote:
zhangyue wroteAdam, I'd like to bump your thread since I now tried S007 at Leica Store SF yesterday. I haven't even look the file I took with it yet.

During briefly visit in two hour, I tested SL and 24mm S, 100mm S, 30-90mm Zoom. 24mm is mul function that can't AF. I can hear the motor sound trying to focus but link seems broken. They are now sending the lens for repair. S007 during middle of shooting, it give nasty blotch color spots all over the frame. They capture a picture of LCD screen and send to Leica at that time. I was told the firmware is latest. They don't know what happened. I havent look the files on my computer yet, I hope it only corrupted on JPEG but not raw, I shoot both.

Since I haven't play the file. I will not comment on IQ, but I must say the camera undergone a good overhaul for GOOD. the shutter is brilliant, means almost as good as Canikon. The mirror is also a lot snapper as well. The focusing is 2~3 times faster and also quieter even with same lens, weird. S2 and 006 AFC are un usable given shutter delay and miserable AFC focus speed. S007 seems improved and usable. checking result from LCD, (I use it around SF street outside of Leica Store ) the focus accuracy under AFC does not impress me, TBH. (and I know what I am talking about. I understand how AF works perfectly)

I also play SL with 50lux R I brought. The first thing I notice is the black frame of first shot. Adam, your SL report help me to understand what is going on here. It didn't happen during rest of shooting. I will comment that later once had more time.

Given I also interested in a few S lens myself, I put them on my S006 body as well. I will hold my judgement since I haven't look the file yet and I know Leica's JPEG are waste of time compare to what camera capable doing. My feeling about this visit is very mixed.

The store is highly recommended, very courtesy and patient about customer request. they have a nice selection of M lens and camera, the lowest price on MM is about $3500. too pity I am not in M mind right now.

I will post more comments later.
Good to hear your thoughts. I agree with you on the S-007 points you listed. Especially the focusing accuracy issue.

As for the SL + Black frame. I exchanged my M-T adapter and I have only seen the black frame twice since (and I've been using that adapter now for weeks). The old adapter was doing a black frame every time I mounted a new lens or switched the camera off and on. So it was definitely an adapter problem.

I've not seen the image spots that you mention. And as for S lenses not working.. It's typical, and is
...Show more →

Adam, No time for process the photo yet. But seems the problem I saw from S007 are real. All corrupted RAW files like sample below.

https://farm2.staticflickr.com/1650/24004685721_ee9e6526c5_b.jpg

SL in hand is quite heavy and dense, feel even more so than S somehow. I tried a few frame for zoom and mostly 50lux R. The EVF is better than my A7R for sure but not fundamentally different to me. I think most likely because I am biased on this. I am a hardcore fan of OVF, not just S's big one, even with "small" D810/D700's OVF. Instead of looking through a small TV, I am now looking through a bigger one.

S007 is good in many way, but for me the main point to get it if I am willing to get it is not shutter, AFc or frame per sec but LV, a important feature for landscape use. I don't trust S2/S006 AF, and won't trust S007 as well from what I see. the big center AF spot is designed by someone having brain damage IMO, and I am not exact sure how its AF implemented, which part of its big circle is taking action. I do know there is some hyper focus implement in its AF engine when I shoot stop down, but I hate this and hate anything computer doing things for me, I don't trust it. And it complicate my shooting process because of this.

The improvement over S2/S006 doesn't make it equivalent to D810, not even close. IQ is really hard to judge by such a short term of use, I will hold my judgement for now. So, even I process the file carefully, I don't think I can draw any conclusion. I need spend time with camera to fully understand its potential.

One thing I can say for sure is S2/S006 indeed have some specialty in color to my eyes, S007 is TBD for now.

The short visit reveal so many problems of Leica system is bugging me. I absolutely love my S results. But My both S body require a German visit, and each time 3 month. Leica service is impressive that cover shipping and even loan body if you are eligible. but how can I trust it if I am in some trip in Africa or I am professional need bring food on table. How many people can afford to have back up M body not to say a back up S body.

Jan 01, 2016 at 10:39 PM
adamdewilde
Offline
Details
p.3 #19Quick S-007 review/thoughts..
zhangyue wrote:
adamdewilde wrote
zhangyue wroteAdam, I'd like to bump your thread since I now tried S007 at Leica Store SF yesterday. I haven't even look the file I took with it yet.

During briefly visit in two hour, I tested SL and 24mm S, 100mm S, 30-90mm Zoom. 24mm is mul function that can't AF. I can hear the motor sound trying to focus but link seems broken. They are now sending the lens for repair. S007 during middle of shooting, it give nasty blotch color spots all over the frame. They capture a picture of LCD screen and send to Leica at that time. I was told the firmware is latest. They don't know what happened. I havent look the files on my computer yet, I hope it only corrupted on JPEG but not raw, I shoot both.

Since I haven't play the file. I will not comment on IQ, but I must say the camera undergone a good overhaul for GOOD. the shutter is brilliant, means almost as good as Canikon. The mirror is also a lot snapper as well. The focusing is 2~3 times faster and also quieter even with same lens, weird. S2 and 006 AFC are un usable given shutter delay and miserable AFC focus speed. S007 seems improved and usable. checking result from LCD, (I use it around SF street outside of Leica Store ) the focus accuracy under AFC does not impress me, TBH. (and I know what I am talking about. I understand how AF works perfectly)

I also play SL with 50lux R I brought. The first thing I notice is the black frame of first shot. Adam, your SL report help me to understand what is going on here. It didn't happen during rest of shooting. I will comment that later once had more time.

Given I also interested in a few S lens myself, I put them on my S006 body as well. I will hold my judgement since I haven't look the file yet and I know Leica's JPEG are waste of time compare to what camera capable doing. My feeling about this visit is very mixed.

The store is highly recommended, very courtesy and patient about customer request. they have a nice selection of M lens and camera, the lowest price on MM is about $3500. too pity I am not in M mind right now.

I will post more comments later.
Good to hear your thoughts. I agree with you on the S-007 points you listed. Especially the focusing accuracy issue.

As for the SL + Black frame. I exchanged my M-T adapter and I have only seen the black frame twice since (and I've been using that adapter now for weeks). The old adapter was doing a black frame every time I mounted a new lens or switched the camera off and on. So it was definitely an adapter problem.

I've not seen the image spots that you mention. And as for S lenses not working.. It's typical, and is a result of two issues AFAIK. One, the firmware in camera and on lens are separate, so sometimes they get confused and AF ceases to work. And second, Leica was having issues with a part. Mostly in the 120S, but it did affect a good number of other lenses from what I was told.

The S007 really does feel a lot more like a Canikon DSLR. But for a while now, my work has been very slow paced and I have no problems shooting with the S-006. And I even prefer it, as I'm more use to the colors it produces. That and any spare chance I get, I'm fooling around with the SL and various M lenses

Anyway, would love to hear your thoughts once you process the files!
Adam, No time for process the photo yet. But seems the problem I saw from S007 are real. All corrupted RAW files like sample below.

SL in hand is quite heavy and dense, feel even more so than S somehow. I tried a few frame for zoom and mostly 50lux R. The EVF is better than my A7R for sure but not fundamentally different to me. I think most likely because I am biased on this. I am a hardcore fan of OVF, not just S's big one, even with "small" D810/D700's OVF. Instead of looking through a small TV,
...Show more →

I share a lot of the same feelings as you do. And sometimes I even wonder myself as a professional, why should I have to buy three of every body Leica makes, just for security purposes. When they're priced so high, you'd expect them to work without major failures. BTW, I have never seen what you're seeing (coloured dots).. I'm sure it'll happen to a lot of people now that it's happened to one camera.

I understand your love for OVF. And I believe that the way the SL is priced. You're better off sticking with your D810 and having a A7II if you want to travel light.
I think although the adaptability of the SL is cool. And although the ergonomics are great. From the tests I've done, there is almost no difference between the SL sensor and the A7II sensor. So the real reason I'd own the camera is for the excellent AF lenses that Leica has yet to put out into the world

All of 2015 has been a very convincing argument to get out of the gear buying game. And to just stick with a few lenses that make me happy. And a few cameras that'll allow me to get my work done.

I will buy the 50 Summilux-L (I hope it doesn't disappoint) and then we'll see if my opinion changes on the SL.
Jan 01, 2016 at 11:52 PM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister