fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Quick S-007 review/thoughts..

  
 
edwardkaraa
Offline
Details
p.2 #1Quick S-007 review/thoughts..


aly324 wrote:
The non-CS 35/70/120 combo is actually very reasonably priced on the used market. I picked all three up for under $7k.

The others are a different story...


But that's what you would ever need. 28/50/90 equivalent FL. I also found this trio for a very good price in Bangkok with a used S2, and was very tempted, but I really couldn't convince myself about the weight
Aug 29, 2015 at 03:57 AM
adamdewilde
Offline
Details
p.2 #2Quick S-007 review/thoughts..
aly324 wrote:
The non-CS 35/70/120 combo is actually very reasonably priced on the used market. I picked all three up for under $7k.

The others are a different story...


Actually these 3 lenses are FANTASTIC.. Just what I look for in lenses.
Aug 29, 2015 at 04:31 AM
adamdewilde
Offline
Details
p.2 #3Quick S-007 review/thoughts..
edwardkaraa wrote:
aly324 wroteThe non-CS 35/70/120 combo is actually very reasonably priced on the used market. I picked all three up for under $7k.

The others are a different story...
But that's what you would ever need. 28/50/90 equivalent FL. I also found this trio for a very good price in Bangkok with a used S2, and was very tempted, but I really couldn't convince myself about the weight


Totally agree with that. BTW I'd love to see you shooting with the S-system, it would be interesting to see how you process your work since I'm a fan of your ZM work currently.


My thoughts waver between 35/70/120 or 45/100. I haven't tried the 45 yet, but I'm tempted.
Aug 29, 2015 at 04:35 AM
edwardkaraa
Offline
Details
p.2 #4Quick S-007 review/thoughts..
Thank you Adam for the kind words

I would love to shoot with the S too, but I remember my days with the 1Ds and I don't think I will ever go back there
Aug 29, 2015 at 05:10 AM
adamdewilde
Offline
Details
p.2 #5Quick S-007 review/thoughts..
edwardkaraa wrote:
Thank you Adam for the kind words

I would love to shoot with the S too, but I remember my days with the 1Ds and I don't think I will ever go back there


I know how you feel. It's one of the reasons I switched from the 1Dx / D4 bodies.

I'm getting too skinny though, so it's a good idea for me to use the S-system once and a while. Since I don't really have time to exercise.
Aug 29, 2015 at 05:34 AM
edwardkaraa
Offline
Details
p.2 #6Quick S-007 review/thoughts..


adamdewilde wrote:
edwardkaraa wroteThank you Adam for the kind words

I would love to shoot with the S too, but I remember my days with the 1Ds and I don't think I will ever go back there
I know how you feel. It's one of the reasons I switched from the 1Dx / D4 bodies.

I'm getting too skinny though, so it's a good idea for me to use the S-system once and a while. Since I don't really have time to exercise.


Aug 29, 2015 at 06:01 AM
rscheffler
Offline
Details
p.2 #7Quick S-007 review/thoughts..
Adam, enjoyed the review and images! Love the colours and don't see any problems with the white shirt (am I missing something?).

A question/comment about the Otus option… I thought one of the big complaints of those on DSLRs is that the crappy focusing screens make them difficult to focus by eye. So to be sure, you end up in live view much of the time working off the back display, which can be a hassle in itself at times, or impractical. Maybe an EVF camera would be better, but at the moment the only option is really one of the Sonys, with the compromise there being the UI. It would seem one of the selling points of the S system is the OVF that can actually be used for precise manual focusing.

I'm curious what your hit rate is with MF and how often you switch to it.

The biggest MF problem I had with DSLRs, other than the crappy screens, was trying to get wide angle lenses in focus (perhaps related to the poor screen/OVF design). It was a primary reason I decided to try, and stuck with, the M system.

I've contemplated the Otus option, but the MF/DSLR hassle has kept me away, as well as the size and weight. And I'm still not entirely convinced by Sony, though the a7RII seems their best effort so far.

I had a brief look at a friend's S system last year. I could see myself liking it, though like Edward am turned off by the size, particularly of the lenses. Still, who knows… Maybe in a few more years and even lower used prices…

Would also be interested in Michael's take on some of the above.

BTW, lost about 10kg the last few months after making the effort to restrict my carbs intake, though would not classify myself as too skinny, yet. But nice to drop a pants size.
Aug 29, 2015 at 07:51 AM
aly324
Offline
Details
p.2 #8Quick S-007 review/thoughts..
I suspect if I shot primarily outdoors in a tropical environment like Singapore or Bangkok, I'd be worn out by the bulk and weight of the S system. I wilt in humid heat. At this time up north in Beijing, I am quite comfortable carrying my S2 and two lenses around town. The S lenses are so well-behaved that I skip the hoods. Then they don't look or feel quite as unwieldy.

I think the 35/70/120 combo is optically wonderful and relatively affordable, but I am not really bonding with the 35. I am too attached to the 35mm-equivalent perspective. Rather than 28/50/90, I think I'm more a 24/35/60 kind of person. I'd try the S45 if it weren't even more ginormous (why? it's not even f/2.5) and also exorbitant. A new copy costs almost the same as my three used ones combined. I'm wondering about the Contax 645 45/2.8 and 80/2...
Aug 29, 2015 at 08:57 AM
Lee Saxon
Offline
Details
p.2 #9Quick S-007 review/thoughts..
adamdewilde wrote:
And yes, you probably know what the camera is before reading my review. Unless you stumble upon it randomly while looking for photos of Daniel Craig



+5 for this line

Aug 29, 2015 at 11:03 AM
adamdewilde
Offline
Details
p.2 #10Quick S-007 review/thoughts..
rscheffler wrote:
Adam, enjoyed the review and images! Love the colours and don't see any problems with the white shirt (am I missing something?).

A question/comment about the Otus option… I thought one of the big complaints of those on DSLRs is that the crappy focusing screens make them difficult to focus by eye. So to be sure, you end up in live view much of the time working off the back display, which can be a hassle in itself at times, or impractical. Maybe an EVF camera would be better, but at the moment the only option is really one of the
...Show more →


Thanks Ron.

I agree, the A7 series bodies are wonderful for manually focusing lenses (pity the shape/button placement and UI + sensor-dislike). I found it frustrating at times to accurately hit focus using a DSLR and stock screen. You need a good screen. Like anything practice also helps!
I actually never bothered to discuss the OVF as it's the same as what you'd get on the S-006. Since you asked, yes it's better than DSLRs by a large margin. It's far from my mind, because of my RF gear. I find RF focusing to be the quickest way for me to grab a MF shot. I'm just use to it.

Reflecting on this, I suppose my current DSLR gear serves two functions.
1) Quick AF shots.
2) Ability to use a fuss free on camera flash.

If the above two aren't necessary, I pack my M-system. It wasn't always this way, I did use ZE lenses for a long while. And with the right focusing screen, I was able to get a good number of reasonably in-focus shots, after a lot of practice. And as mentioned above, it was frustrating at times. I haven't used the S-006 much in MF mode, but the few times I've done it, I didn't feel the need to run out and buy the $400 split screen. I loved my cheap Pentax film camera specifically for the split screen, so I am slightly tempted by the idea of it. Maybe I'll buy one if the price is right!

The Contax645 system was similarly slow with AF. I found myself shooting a lot of manually focused fast paced shots with it. The times I used it professionally, everything was within an acceptable level of focus (for film). I've had the S-006 three times now by right. Owned it twice, borrowed and used it extensively once. My initial feeling of the OVF was that it was inferior to the Contax645. After continuous S-system use (even in AF mode), my eyes have grown accustom to the magnification. Now when I pick up my last remaining Contax645, I feel it's unfamiliar, almost inferior. Funny how our brains work.

To sum it up (), critical focus rate is higher then I'd have expected after not using a DSLR OVF to MF for a couple of years. And yes, it's superior to other DSLRs.

On vacation I much prefer my M-P + 50APO and the odd time I'll toss on the 35FLE (evenings in cities). I try to bring my S-system along, but often find myself out for full days and the S just becomes a burden. Unless I've got something specific planned, or am working, it stays at home. Once I move to the states, my mentality might change. Besides, the wife likes it for her "beauty journal" shots that I take indoors.

Awesome about the 10kg drop! Yea carbs/sugars seem ridiculous once you cut them out of your life.
Save for the odd cheat day. I've been completely sugar free (includes carbs/fruits/etc) for a few years. I feel great, but my body doesn't store the copious amounts of fat I ingest.. Just burns it all up for energy. So I got skinny. It would be great if I worked out, but no time for that I'm afraid So yeah, gonna have to bring the S-system out more (exercise). Maybe after using the S I'll buy a Sigmonster for my D750 and take up birding or something.

Anyway, off to bed.. I'm working for the next few days on a last minute job, but will try to get online a bit more. Maybe put up some backlogged photos if I can.
Aug 29, 2015 at 12:09 PM
adamdewilde
Offline
Details
p.2 #11Quick S-007 review/thoughts..
aly324 wrote:
I suspect if I shot primarily outdoors in a tropical environment like Singapore or Bangkok, I'd be worn out by the bulk and weight of the S system. I wilt in humid heat. At this time up north in Beijing, I am quite comfortable carrying my S2 and two lenses around town. The S lenses are so well-behaved that I skip the hoods. Then they don't look or feel quite as unwieldy.

I think the 35/70/120 combo is optically wonderful and relatively affordable, but I am not really bonding with the 35. I am too attached to the 35mm-equivalent perspective. Rather
...Show more →

YEP. I find it easier to tote heavy gear in cooler/drier weather.

The C45/2.8 is a decent lens. I've used it on film quite a bit, liked my results. From what I've been told, the 45S is superior, not surprising considering the age difference. The C80/2 is really just too hyped. But is still a great lens for film use. The more I see images taken with this lens, and the more I analyse my images taken with this lens. The more I realise it's just not worth me buying a $2,000 adapter for it. It's "unique" but very retro/harsh and that gets amplified on digital. I'm not pimping the 100S or anything. There are a lot of good older medium format portrait lenses. Pentax 105/2.4 is one. Zeiss has a long history of good lenses. The 110/2FE comes to mind. But I'm just over the 80/2 look. And the few shots I've seen with it adapted to digital confirmed it for me. I had a Mamiya 80 1.9 a long time ago. I was thinking of buying another one, along with a cheap S adapter. In the end, I decided against it as I don't love the look enough to hassle with eBay.

Personally I feel the 70S is great. As is the 120S. I know what you mean about the 35.. It's just a bit to wide coming in at 28mm FOV. I'm more partial to 35mm FOV lenses myself. So I'm curious about the 45/2.8 but the speed has me hesitating. For the size, I'd have expected a f/2 lens

Aug 29, 2015 at 01:30 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.2 #12Quick S-007 review/thoughts..
Adam, thanks for the review. I hadn't thought much of the system, but your review and photos have me longing for even the 006 with the 70 and 120. They look like fabulous lenses. It is too expensive for me now, but in time I would love to build a studio and then the S system for studio, portraits, and macro (with the lovely 120 f/2.5) would be a dream.

I like very much the non-standard review style of your blog. It was easy and fun to read and I loved how the pictures told the story.
Aug 29, 2015 at 02:20 PM
Gary Clennan
Offline
Details
p.2 #13Quick S-007 review/thoughts..
adamdewilde wrote:
edwardkaraa wroteThank you Adam for the kind words

I would love to shoot with the S too, but I remember my days with the 1Ds and I don't think I will ever go back there
I know how you feel. It's one of the reasons I switched from the 1Dx / D4 bodies.

I'm getting too skinny though, so it's a good idea for me to use the S-system once and a while. Since I don't really have time to exercise.


Adam - a steady (Canadian) diet of bacon and donuts will solve that little problem....
Aug 29, 2015 at 05:02 PM
Gary Clennan
Offline
Details
p.2 #14Quick S-007 review/thoughts..
Steve Spencer wrote:
Adam, thanks for the review. I hadn't thought much of the system, but your review and photos have me longing for even the 006 with the 70 and 120. They look like fabulous lenses. It is too expensive for me now, but in time I would love to build a studio and then the S system for studio, portraits, and macro (with the lovely 120 f/2.5) would be a dream.

I like very much the non-standard review style of your blog. It was easy and fun to read and I loved how the pictures told the story.


X2
Aug 29, 2015 at 05:03 PM
adamdewilde
Offline
Details
p.2 #15Quick S-007 review/thoughts..
Steve Spencer wrote:
Adam, thanks for the review. I hadn't thought much of the system, but your review and photos have me longing for even the 006 with the 70 and 120. They look like fabulous lenses. It is too expensive for me now, but in time I would love to build a studio and then the S system for studio, portraits, and macro (with the lovely 120 f/2.5) would be a dream.

I like very much the non-standard review style of your blog. It was easy and fun to read and I loved how the pictures told the story.


Thanks!
Yes, the 120 would be an amazing portrait and beauty lens. Prefect for studio work. It's a bit slower to focus in daily life, but would be fine in a controlled environment. Prices will continue to come down I'm sure. But building a small studio can get costly
Aug 29, 2015 at 11:40 PM
adamdewilde
Offline
Details
p.2 #16Quick S-007 review/thoughts..
Gary Clennan wrote:
adamdewilde wrote
edwardkaraa wroteThank you Adam for the kind words

I would love to shoot with the S too, but I remember my days with the 1Ds and I don't think I will ever go back there
I know how you feel. It's one of the reasons I switched from the 1Dx / D4 bodies.

I'm getting too skinny though, so it's a good idea for me to use the S-system once and a while. Since I don't really have time to exercise.
Adam - a steady (Canadian) diet of bacon and donuts will solve that little problem....


Gary - I miss French Cruller donuts from Tim Hortons so much!
Aug 29, 2015 at 11:46 PM
zhangyue
Online
Details
p.2 #17Quick S-007 review/thoughts..
rscheffler wrote:
Adam, enjoyed the review and images! Love the colours and don't see any problems with the white shirt (am I missing something?).

A question/comment about the Otus option… I thought one of the big complaints of those on DSLRs is that the crappy focusing screens make them difficult to focus by eye. So to be sure, you end up in live view much of the time working off the back display, which can be a hassle in itself at times, or impractical. Maybe an EVF camera would be better, but at the moment the only option is really one of the
...Show more →

Hi, Ron, Sorry for late reply you as I am travelling to southwest US.

If you plan use OTUS for your professional work meaning fast pace shooting, then I'd say forget it even with Canon S-type of screen. It is not un-usable but just you can not take full advantage of its glass performance. Due to minor focusing error you will not see benefit of it say compare other decent fast glass...

The lens suit for slow pace shooting like landscape, cityscape, or amateur like me that can tolerant missing focus during shooting. Again, It does not mean it is not good for manual focus, just won't bring extra compare to any other fast glass most of the time because very minor focus error can ruin its last 5% performance difference. Given the weight and size, I am not sure it make financial sense for professional for event shooting. (That is why I love R lens as they are very tolerant for slightly focus error.)

I do like use OTUS for close range portrait that show its specialty as I can really see focus by eyes with very thin DOF, none of AF work as good to me in that case. and performance advantage is really show up.

BTW, keep in mind here I am only discuss shooting WO.

As for S, it is in very similar situation with OTUS, beautiful rendering, beautiful file, great glass and then again, not very practical for general photography. It takes a lot of weight and space budget for my bag and require extra shooting discipline to get sharp photo do its lens and sensor justice. Its AF is workable and accurate for most case but again and AF delay and shutter delay is noticeable. This will make freeze 'moment' difficult. Canikon is way better. However, once you nail it, the result is very rewarding. In term of MF, I can nail focus manually much easier due to its huge VF compare to any 35mm system. I tend to use AF most of the time though, as I feel the lens size and focus ring location is awkward to MF.

Hope it helps.

Sep 01, 2015 at 12:44 PM
trogdon
Offline
Details
p.2 #18Quick S-007 review/thoughts..
Not even interested in the camera, but this was a nice review! Great photos and covered aspects that seemed relevant to actually know if you were going to purchase one. I'd recommend including one photo though of the camera, had no idea what it was until I looked it up then I remembered the S system. Great read though, thanks for sharing
Sep 01, 2015 at 05:46 PM
adamdewilde
Offline
Details
p.2 #19Quick S-007 review/thoughts..
Totally forgot to mention the DOF scale/calculator.

When you're using the camera it does that Batis thing.. But since the screen has more space, it gives you the readout in a easier to see/use way. I wouldn't use the feature often, but it's nice for group shots, and I don't think anyone has mentioned it yet.
Sep 03, 2015 at 03:40 AM
reggieb
Offline
Details
p.2 #20Quick S-007 review/thoughts..
adamdewilde wrote:
Hi guys,

Posted some thoughts and images from the S-007. If you care to take a look:
http://www.jupitersnake.com/review/leica-s-typ-007-s-007/

Best,
Adam


Quick question, I had a chance to play with the S-E/70 in London, comparing it to my D800/Sigma 50A. One thing that really shocked me was the difference in fine detail. The crop that really showed it was a group of buildings, just under a window there was some paint peeling. I could see the individual pieces of it, from great distance, when I cropped in with the Leica. Just wondering if the CMOS sensor in this would produce the same level of low-ISO detail - have you had a chance to compare?
Sep 07, 2015 at 07:08 PM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister