p.10 #1Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
retrofocus wrote: gdanmitchell wrotetimparkin wrotep.s. For those of you who have suggested a six stop push is ridiculous, here's an example from my business partner Joe Cornish.
http://static.timparkin.co.uk/onlandscape/SonyLakes/dynamic-range-example.jpgModern digital cameras provide tremendous dynamic range and latitude for adjustment/recovery in post, and being able to significantly push shadows is very useful. I often have to do this — in fact, I often plan on doing so when I make my exposures.
p.10 #2Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
retrofocus wrote: gdanmitchell wrotetimparkin wrotep.s. For those of you who have suggested a six stop push is ridiculous, here's an example from my business partner Joe Cornish.
http://static.timparkin.co.uk/onlandscape/SonyLakes/dynamic-range-example.jpgModern digital cameras provide tremendous dynamic range and latitude for adjustment/recovery in post, and being able to significantly push shadows is very useful. I often have to do this — in fact, I often plan on doing so when I make my exposures.
+1, it was not even one challenge DR in those samples, even my 300D rebel can map that recovery easily. Try meter the tip of the candle light from any canon body in the dark then recover the surrounding shadows and see what you get
p.10 #3Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
timparkin wrote:
p.s. For those of you who have suggested a six stop push is ridiculous, here's an example from my business partner Joe Cornish.
Tim, how do you handle the noise/gain when processing your .ARW's? Noiseware? Solely by eye in LR? I am finding A7 II and A7r files to have a lot of fine chroma and luma noise. True or not, I read one has to really nail exposure to reduce A7 noise. Any thoughts? Thanks.
p.10 #5Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Paul Mo wrote: timparkin wrotep.s. For those of you who have suggested a six stop push is ridiculous, here's an example from my business partner Joe Cornish.Tim, how do you handle the noise/gain when processing your .ARW's? Noiseware? Solely by eye in LR? I am finding A7 II and A7r files to have a lot of fine chroma and luma noise. True or not, I read one has to really nail exposure to reduce A7 noise. Any thoughts? Thanks.
Yes I do like Imagenomic Noiseware for both film scans and digital files. I hate the 'plastic' look that detail protection gives too so avoid that like the plague.
There is typically chroma noise but it smooths out well - I sometimes will use a color layer and manually play with an area if it's a real problem but only rarely.
The biggest problem is usually colour shifts to magenta in the very deep shadows. These involve using a curve with lots of control points on it and injecting green into the shadows (before any shadow recovery!!! if you do shadow recovery first your tonal relationships screwup).
p.10 #6Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Some pp tweaking from where Tim left off. Presented 50% size reduction to "hide" some noise from pixel peeping, yet illustrate even if it would mean a smaller print. Again, bearing in mind where this one started.
Would be curious to see the sooc next to it to see just how far the diff is (vs. reading histo for diff).
p.10 #7Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
timparkin wrote:
The biggest problem is usually colour shifts to magenta in the very deep shadows. These involve using a curve with lots of control points on it and injecting green into the shadows (before any shadow recovery!!! if you do shadow recovery first your tonal relationships screwup).
Tim
I am confused. Would you mind sharing the workflow on that. You don't do the shadow recovery in LR as part of the raw conversion? Or are you saying that you adjust the tone curve in LR prior to adjusting the LR recovery sliders? I would really appreciate any tips on that. Thanks!
p.10 #9Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
gdanmitchell wrote: Fred Miranda wroteSorry guys, pushed images at web resolution don't mean much. Show us the 1:1 crops.I agree. More at the links. The first one includes a scan of a section of a large print. The second includes 100% magnification crops.
Let's stop with this crusade of trying to convince people that differences in DR are "myths" that never show up. We can hand pick examples all day long to support whichever version we choose. We've been down this road many times.
p.10 #10Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
RustyBug wrote:
Some pp tweaking from where Tim left off. Presented 50% size reduction to "hide" some noise from pixel peeping, yet illustrate even if it would mean a smaller print. Again, bearing in mind where this one started.
Would be curious to see the sooc next to it to see just how far the diff is (vs. reading histo for diff).
p.10 #11Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
darbo wrote: timparkin wroteThe biggest problem is usually colour shifts to magenta in the very deep shadows. These involve using a curve with lots of control points on it and injecting green into the shadows (before any shadow recovery!!! if you do shadow recovery first your tonal relationships screwup).
TimI am confused. Would you mind sharing the workflow on that. You don't do the shadow recovery in LR as part of the raw conversion? Or are you saying that you adjust the tone curve in LR prior to adjusting the LR recovery sliders? I would really appreciate any tips on that. Thanks!
David
Hi David,
Yes I definitely do shadow recovery in Lightroom - it does a lot better job than shadow/highlight in photoshop - but I then use curves to tweak the shadow colour balance. What I will sometimes do is add two curve layers, the top one with a big boost so I can see the shadows. I then tweak the lower curve layer to adjust the colour in the shadows (you could do this with luminosity masks if you wanted). The problem you're solving is due to the colour diverging in the deep shadows - it's pretty complex colour shifts so you end up with a lot of points on your curve - typically it's the green layer that needs boosting in the shadows. You can do this in Lightroom using curves but if you touch any of the exposure controls after it means repeating all over again. I adjust luminosity and broad colour in lightroom and then tweak things in photoshop.
p.10 #12Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
timparkin wrote: RustyBug wroteSome pp tweaking from where Tim left off. Presented 50% size reduction to "hide" some noise from pixel peeping, yet illustrate even if it would mean a smaller print. Again, bearing in mind where this one started.
Would be curious to see the sooc next to it to see just how far the diff is (vs. reading histo for diff).here you go ..
p.10 #13Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
artd wrote: gdanmitchell wroteFred Miranda wroteSorry guys, pushed images at web resolution don't mean much. Show us the 1:1 crops.I agree. More at the links. The first one includes a scan of a section of a large print. The second includes 100% magnification crops.Let's stop with this crusade of trying to convince people that differences in DR are "myths" that never show up. We can hand pick examples all day long to support whichever version we choose. We've been down this road many times.
p.10 #14Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
timparkin wrote:
You can do this in Lightroom using curves but if you touch any of the exposure controls after it means repeating all over again.
You're implying something there that just sent me down a google rabbit hole: that order of operations matters in LR.
It seems to be a hot button issue with sentiments leaning towards "order of operations doesn't matter," but I haven't seen any conclusive proof one way or the other.
p.10 #15Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Fast6 wrote: timparkin wroteYou can do this in Lightroom using curves but if you touch any of the exposure controls after it means repeating all over again.You're implying something there that just sent me down a google rabbit hole: that order of operations matters in LR.
It seems to be a hot button issue with sentiments leaning towards "order of operations doesn't matter," but I haven't seen any conclusive proof one way or the other.
Can you elaborate on this at all?
Try putting a small bump in the shadow area of the green channel and then play with exposure or black level. I can do a video if it doesn't work for you
p.10 #16Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
RustyBug wrote: timparkin wroteRustyBug wroteSome pp tweaking from where Tim left off. Presented 50% size reduction to "hide" some noise from pixel peeping, yet illustrate even if it would mean a smaller print. Again, bearing in mind where this one started.
Would be curious to see the sooc next to it to see just how far the diff is (vs. reading histo for diff).here you go ..
I meant the original image sooc portion of the crop (@ 50% to correspond) ... not the histo (that was already in the inset of your 100% crop).
If you just mean the same crop but doc then it's just black but I'll upload anyway. Original histogram was for the whole file. My second histogram was for the crop.
p.10 #17Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
I'd like someone to have a look at the three photos taken from the quarry with the same exposure to tell me if they look like they are the same brightness for me? I'm happy to upload the raw files for someone to look at..
Here's a sample of the A7R and A7Rii frames at the same 1/40th of a second exposure..
p.10 #18Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Fast6 wrote: timparkin wroteYou can do this in Lightroom using curves but if you touch any of the exposure controls after it means repeating all over again.You're implying something there that just sent me down a google rabbit hole: that order of operations matters in LR.
It seems to be a hot button issue with sentiments leaning towards "order of operations doesn't matter," but I haven't seen any conclusive proof one way or the other.
Can you elaborate on this at all?
I'm a little surprised by this as well. The way I understood it, while the order of operations certainly matters for processing, LR is basically setup so that the actual order of operations is somewhat independent of the order of inputs from the user.
p.10 #19Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
whumber wrote:
I'm a little surprised by this as well. The way I understood it, while the order of operations certainly matters for processing, LR is basically setup so that the actual order of operations is somewhat independent of the order of inputs from the user.
p.10 #20Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Fast6 wrote: whumber wroteI'm a little surprised by this as well. The way I understood it, while the order of operations certainly matters for processing, LR is basically setup so that the actual order of operations is somewhat independent of the order of inputs from the user.Also my understanding...at least it was...
Ah sorry I get you, my misunderstanding the question - no it doesn't matter what order you do things in but the curve work on the data after the exposure lumonisoty. So if you use the curve to set colour tweaks to shadow areas and then shift the shadow the colour gets screwed. Plus the if you boost shadows with shadow recovery you can't target the 'low tones' because the tonal relationships have got mixed up.