fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr

  
 
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.15 #1Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
+1 @ 180 shift between DR & stitching.
Aug 10, 2015 at 09:19 AM
mogul
Online
Details
p.15 #2Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
RustyBug wrote:
mttran wroteDon't forget, sony 2 plus stops is a huge range in engineering to collect more lights than canon.
How is the Sony collecting "more light"?

Do you mean that you are increasing your exposure for the lower base ISO, thus reducing noise? Or is there something else that I'm not understanding?


The BSI chip collects more light since its wiring is under the photo sites compared to front side designed chips like Canon uses (and all other sensors in dslr range size except Samsung).
Aug 10, 2015 at 09:23 AM
mttran
Offline
Details
p.15 #3Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
RustyBug wrote:
mttran wroteDon't forget, sony 2 plus stops is a huge range in engineering to collect more lights than canon.
How is the Sony collecting "more light"?

Do you mean that you are increasing your exposure for the lower base ISO, thus reducing noise? Or is there something else that I'm not understanding?


OK, is the room with 3 windows getting more lights than the room with 1 window and yes it is the same fundamental application for any IC.
Aug 10, 2015 at 09:32 AM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.15 #4Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
chez wrote:
jctriguy wrote
chez wrote
RustyBug wrote
mttran wroteExactly. Why buying a brand new 5Ds(r) camera to do that when we can bracket all day long with 5Dc.


13MP vs. 51MP ... essentially a 2^2 delta (+ AA filter variance). i.e. bracketing / DR isn't the only consideration. Essentially a rinse & repeat that there are more considerations than DR alone to the decisions we make.
Rusty...you are conveniently forgetting there is much more to the A7R2 than just DR. I remember you are mainly a manual focus guy...the A7R(2) beats anything Canon has for manual focusing hands down. Let's not get into the IBIS as well.

But Mttran has a point. 5D3 stitched removes any benefits the 5Ds(r) gives you.
So you are now changing your long held view of stitching and bracketing? No point having high DR if you can just bracket. Surprised you've done a full 180 shift here...
Nope...not at all...just saying if Rusty can bracket to get better dynamic range, he can stitch as well...so no need for a high rez, high dynamic range camera.

Me...I'd rather just take one shot and get everything I need in that one image. Hate post processing when I could be out there shooting more.


Strange that you wrote the following "But Mttran has a point. 5D3 stitched removes any benefits the 5Ds(r) gives you."

You would typically be all over that statement with claims of moving trees, water, fading light, etc. just find it funny how your tune changes when it benefits your over zealous attempts to beat people over the head with flimsy Sony cameras.
Aug 10, 2015 at 09:35 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.15 #5Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Okay, the BSI is an advance (sounds good to me)... but, I can't see where it is a more than 4X additional light collection? Unless you are saying that it has the ability collect four times more light, but Sony has chosen to filter it heavily enough that the true system ISO remains lower than other cameras (or ).

Reference documentation that it is a +400% gain in light collection by relocating the wiring?
Aug 10, 2015 at 09:43 AM
chez
Offline
Details
p.15 #6Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
jctriguy wrote:
chez wrote
jctriguy wrote
chez wrote
RustyBug wrote
mttran wroteExactly. Why buying a brand new 5Ds(r) camera to do that when we can bracket all day long with 5Dc.


13MP vs. 51MP ... essentially a 2^2 delta (+ AA filter variance). i.e. bracketing / DR isn't the only consideration. Essentially a rinse & repeat that there are more considerations than DR alone to the decisions we make.
Rusty...you are conveniently forgetting there is much more to the A7R2 than just DR. I remember you are mainly a manual focus guy...the A7R(2) beats anything Canon has for manual focusing hands down. Let's not get into the IBIS as well.

But Mttran has a point. 5D3 stitched removes any benefits the 5Ds(r) gives you.
So you are now changing your long held view of stitching and bracketing? No point having high DR if you can just bracket. Surprised you've done a full 180 shift here...
Nope...not at all...just saying if Rusty can bracket to get better dynamic range, he can stitch as well...so no need for a high rez, high dynamic range camera.

Me...I'd rather just take one shot and get everything I need in that one image. Hate post processing when I could be out there shooting more.
Strange that you wrote the following "But Mttran has a point. 5D3 stitched removes any benefits the 5Ds(r) gives you."

You would typically be all over that statement with claims of moving trees, water, fading light, etc. just find it funny how your tune changes when it benefits your over zealous attempts to beat people over the head with flimsy Sony cameras.


JC...have you read this thread at all. Rusty claims you don't need more DR because you can bracket exposures and merge. Mttran said if that is the case then you don't need high resolution of the 5Ds(r) cameras because you can just stitch images together.

What I'm saying is that if someone claims they can always just merge multiple exposures for better DR, then that same person can just stitch multiple exposures for more pixels.

Hope I don't need to explain again to you.
Aug 10, 2015 at 09:50 AM
chez
Offline
Details
p.15 #7Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
RustyBug wrote:
+1 @ 180 shift between DR & stitching.


Not really...I don't advocate either because things move in real life between shots. Since you advocate shooting multiple exposures and merging...then you can just shoot multiple exposures and stitch...right?
Aug 10, 2015 at 09:52 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.15 #8Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
On Sony's website, they have an image of a field, with mountain backdrop, blue sky. Looks pretty much like a Sunny 16 scene by most accounts.
http://www.sony.net/Products/di_photo_gallery/?mode=body&camera=ilc&mount=E-mount&ilc=%CE%B17R%20II&no=0176


The exif data for the image is ISO 100, f/11, 1/20. By my math, an EV 15 (Sunny 16) scene shot @ f/11 & 1/20 is off by 1 stop for the f/11 and off by 2+ stops for the 1/20 which is 3+ stops off of ISO 100.

Even if we give credence to the scene being only EV 14, or even EV 13 ... well, I'm still not connecting the dots @ 400% more light, yet more than a stop(s) off from stated ISO.

My main point is that if the true ISO is a stop or more lower, then "duh" that noise is lower as we are required to throw more light at it ... which is kinda where this whole thing started in Tim's example raising an eyebrow of consideration to that point.




Edited on Aug 10, 2015 at 11:06 AM · View previous versions
Aug 10, 2015 at 09:57 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.15 #9Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
chez wrote:
RustyBug wrote+1 @ 180 shift between DR & stitching.
Not really...I don't advocate either because things move in real life between shots. Since you advocate shooting multiple exposures and merging...then you can just shoot multiple exposures and stitch...right?


The former point was that bracketing was non-compensable (time) even for still subjects. Now it is being stated that as long as you have the time, it is compensable ... that was the 180 shift.
Aug 10, 2015 at 10:03 AM
chez
Offline
Details
p.15 #10Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
RustyBug wrote:
chez wrote
RustyBug wrote+1 @ 180 shift between DR & stitching.
Not really...I don't advocate either because things move in real life between shots. Since you advocate shooting multiple exposures and merging...then you can just shoot multiple exposures and stitch...right?
The former point was that bracketing was non-compensable (time) even for still subjects. Now it is being stated that as long as you have the time, it is compensable ... that was the 180 shift.


Rusty...you are the one that advocates multiple exposures and blending...which does require time between exposures and does require careful post processing to ensure moving items are not blurry...which is exactly what you can do with stitching. If you can use multiple exposures for DR...you can use multiple exposures for resolution. So if you can bracket...you can stitch. @ no 180 at all...

I don't do either as I make all attempts to get my images with 1 shot.
Aug 10, 2015 at 10:07 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.15 #11Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Chez,

You weren't the one who made the statement that bracketing was non-compensable (time). Nor were you the one who didn't respond when I asked for a clarification to what was meant by non-compensable (time). Until we get a clarification on what was meant by non-compensable (time) ... the repositioning that it can be compensable (preference to do so or not do so notwithstanding), does appear as a 180 shift @ cake & eat it too.

Request for clarification @ original non-compensable (time) stands ... as does the request for evidence of a +400% increase in light collection.

Yes, I'm aware of the apparent correlation regarding taking multiple exposures and registrations / motion variance issues ... you seem to think that folks are rather obtuse about such things. However, when taking multiple exposures for stitching, the time lag between shots is significantly greater because of the care required to reframe and realign for registration Contrast that with ... oh gee, idk a single click of the shutter for a bracketed exposure. And, if you shoot the bracket sequence from slower to faster rather than from faster to slower, the variance between the frames is in fractions of a second, whereas taking multiple exposures for stitching requires a multiple seconds between each exposure for a total variance time even greater.

But, even so ... I can, do, and will stitch. While it is mostly for a panoramic purposes in my case, yes, it can be also for the purpose of resolution stitching (which also requires a coordinating focal length adjustment). Although, I do believe that a wide view of a Red Herring should probably be stitched together here as well. The 180 wasn't between DR and Stitching ... it was between time compensable vs. non-copmensable (even for static subjects as presented).



Edited on Aug 11, 2015 at 07:13 AM · View previous versions
Aug 10, 2015 at 10:11 AM
mttran
Offline
Details
p.15 #12Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
chez wrote:
RustyBug wrote
chez wrote
RustyBug wrote+1 @ 180 shift between DR & stitching.
Not really...I don't advocate either because things move in real life between shots. Since you advocate shooting multiple exposures and merging...then you can just shoot multiple exposures and stitch...right?
The former point was that bracketing was non-compensable (time) even for still subjects. Now it is being stated that as long as you have the time, it is compensable ... that was the 180 shift.
Rusty...you are the one that advocates multiple exposures and blending...which does require time between exposures and does require careful post processing to ensure moving items are not blurry...which is exactly what you can do with stitching. If you can use multiple exposures for DR...you can use multiple exposures for resolution. So if you can bracket...you can stitch. @ no 180 at all...

I don't do either as I make all attempts to get my images with 1 shot.


+1, in canon world: everything is stand still
Aug 10, 2015 at 10:13 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.15 #13Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
mttran wrote:
mogul wrote
RustyBug wrote
mogul wrote
RustyBug wrote
retrofocus wroteI avoid bracketing wherever I can.
I avoid lifting exposures in post +6 stops whenever I can.

There are two primary issues at hand with regard to "movement", as I see it.

A) The registration is not the same between frames.
B) Motion blur of the subject itself as it occurs during a given captured frame.

The dialogue is that the Sony has a two stop advantage. In the case of an EV 8 scene @ ISO 100, the exposure required for an f11 is around 1 second. (EV 8 is 7 stops diff from EV15 @ Sunny 16, f11 is +1 stop, so shutter is +6 stops 100/50/25/13/6/3/1.5. However, if the true ISO if the Sony is say 80 rather than 100, then the exposure adjustments would be 80/40/20/10/5/2.5/1. Allowing for an additional two stop underexposure changes the ss from around 1/2 second in a 100 (true) ISO to around a 1/5 second exposure in an 80 (true) ISO. If the true ISO is closer to 70, 60, 50, 40 ... well, you get the gist (we still don't know what it's true ISO is yet).

If the wind is blowing such that motion blur is a concern WITHIN the single frame, the diff between 1/2 second and 1/5 second is a gain in ss, but it isn't likely to solve such a motion blur issue, in which case you are looking for a lull in the wind to make the capture for your non-stationary subjects anyway. I say this because the dialogue is about achieving max IQ capability of the Sony. If my max IQ is critical, then I'm shooting on the tripod for a 1/5 ss anyway.

By bracketing, I have a couple options, with one being to raise the ISO, so I can raise the shutter speed necessary to avoid motion blur for the EV 8 areas of the scene. So, you say this will incur a hit to the max IQ. Yup, but the diff from ISO to get the the SS to contend with motion blur is a reasonable one ... one that is still going to exceed the two stop advantage in many instances. Are there those occasions where the two stop advantage is in the "sweet spot" of providing a faster SS sufficient to mitigate subject motion blur ... sure, but I'm really not much more happy about shooting 1/5 second than I am 1/2 second if I'm dealing with the wind. Which goes back to my position that I'm still gonna bracket in many instances, even if shooting with the Sony. And once I come off base ISO in the Sony, the advantage of the Sony's base ISO is further reduced.

This is the reason that my response to Tim's exposure variance was rooted in mentioning the true ISO. Is this going to be a full offset to the two stop gain. Not likely, but if we understand what our true ISO is, then we can realize how much gain it is / isn't providing, and where that pragmatically benefits us ... and where it really isn't the holy grail of solutions.

Horses for courses.
Of course, if you want to bracket with the A7rII, it is available up to 9 shots.
I rarely need more than two, three tops. 9 shots sounds more like high fps @ "spray & pray" than a calculated understanding of your scene and light. And, with all the dialogue about how the files of the Sony are the holy grail of lifting shadows ... 9 shots sounds kinda silly if the Sony files are so perfect for lifting without any penalty.

That said ... 9 shots is an advance (props to Sony). Just now too sure when / where I'd need a 9 shot bracket.
It just gives the photographer a choice, 9 is maximum, less can always be used...I haven't bracketed for years though because as you say, a lot of info is available in just one file.
Exactly. Why buying a brand new 5Ds(r) camera to do that when we can bracket all day long with 5Dc. And this is the reason why I added new sony tool along with my older canon for the jobs.


The 5DS(r) is much better than the previous 5D models regarding dynamic range, much thanks to the elimination of fixed pattern noise. Throwing in the ability to do long exposures without LENR or black frame subtraction, which really boosts the number of exposures during the nice light in an evening. The 5DS R is the first Full Frame camera I have owned that is problem free in my use. Something I could not say about the A7r. Yes, the extra 1.5 stops of dynamic range is very welcome, but still my 5DS R is my main camera for manual focus tripod use now, and the A7r is my backup camera. The 5DS R files are that good.
Aug 10, 2015 at 10:13 AM
Monito
Offline
Details
p.15 #14Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
chez wrote:
But Mttran has a point. 5D3 stitched removes any benefits the 5Ds(r) gives you.


Nonsense. It is naive and biased to think that the 5DS offers only extra resolution.
Aug 10, 2015 at 10:13 AM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.15 #15Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
chez wrote:
jctriguy wrote
chez wrote
jctriguy wrote
chez wrote
RustyBug wrote

13MP vs. 51MP ... essentially a 2^2 delta (+ AA filter variance). i.e. bracketing / DR isn't the only consideration. Essentially a rinse & repeat that there are more considerations than DR alone to the decisions we make.
Rusty...you are conveniently forgetting there is much more to the A7R2 than just DR. I remember you are mainly a manual focus guy...the A7R(2) beats anything Canon has for manual focusing hands down. Let's not get into the IBIS as well.

But Mttran has a point. 5D3 stitched removes any benefits the 5Ds(r) gives you.
So you are now changing your long held view of stitching and bracketing? No point having high DR if you can just bracket. Surprised you've done a full 180 shift here...
Nope...not at all...just saying if Rusty can bracket to get better dynamic range, he can stitch as well...so no need for a high rez, high dynamic range camera.

Me...I'd rather just take one shot and get everything I need in that one image. Hate post processing when I could be out there shooting more.
Strange that you wrote the following "But Mttran has a point. 5D3 stitched removes any benefits the 5Ds(r) gives you."

You would typically be all over that statement with claims of moving trees, water, fading light, etc. just find it funny how your tune changes when it benefits your over zealous attempts to beat people over the head with flimsy Sony cameras.
JC...have you read this thread at all. Rusty claims you don't need more DR because you can bracket exposures and merge. Mttran said if that is the case then you don't need high resolution of the 5Ds(r) cameras because you can just stitch images together.

What I'm saying is that if someone claims they can always just merge multiple exposures for better DR, then that same person can just stitch multiple exposures for more pixels.

Hope I don't need to explain again to you.

I would love to know what the last 2 pages have been about. Lots of incomprehensible posts, and a refusal to explain things that don't make sense. You keep on pushing ahead though, no need to understand what people say, just pick reply xx from your standard box and insert here.
Aug 10, 2015 at 10:36 AM
chez
Offline
Details
p.15 #16Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Monito wrote:
chez wroteBut Mttran has a point. 5D3 stitched removes any benefits the 5Ds(r) gives you.
Nonsense. It is naive and biased to think that the 5DS offers only extra resolution.


Elaborate please...compared to the 5D3.
Aug 10, 2015 at 10:36 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.15 #17Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
chez wrote:

does require careful post processing


As does lifting shadows 6+ stops ... choose your poison. Neither is the holy grail.
Aug 10, 2015 at 10:48 AM
Monito
Offline
Details
p.15 #18Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Monito wrote:
Nonsense. It is naive and biased to think that the 5DS offers only extra resolution.


chez wrote:
Elaborate please...compared to the 5D3.


Chez, you are an experienced photographer. I'm not going to take your troll bait and do your homework for you. I will say this shorthand: DR, noise, less shake, intervalometer, and many things tweaked and refined.

If you would like to believe that the 5DS only offers resolution above the 5D3, you are free to do so, but when you express that view, it makes you look much more naive than you are and much more biased than you need to be.
Aug 10, 2015 at 10:49 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.15 #19Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
jctriguy wrote:
explain things that don't make sense.

Would that be anything like it collects 2 stops more light, but you shoot it 1-3 stops below stated ISO?
Aug 10, 2015 at 11:13 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.15 #20Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
chez wrote:
Monito wrote
chez wroteBut Mttran has a point. 5D3 stitched removes any benefits the 5Ds(r) gives you.
Nonsense. It is naive and biased to think that the 5DS offers only extra resolution.
Elaborate please...compared to the 5D3.


We can start with low ISO dynamic range. The 5DS has 2/3 stops higher measured dynamic range than the 5D III (at normalized resolution) and subjectively more due to the character of the noise.
Aug 10, 2015 at 11:22 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister