p.13 #1Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
+1 @ it has been a pleasure to learn more of Tim as a fellow FM'er. I (for one) feel that he has handled my (fair questions) challenges with respect, dignity and decorum ... even in continued disagreement in some regard. I hope to have afforded him likewise.
p.13 #3Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
RustyBug wrote:
Tim,
I'm still kinda confused by your top two histo's between the A7R and the A7R II. I don't see how those are considered identical or equitable ... maybe, I just don't understand.
Also, I'm not a "histo guru", but one thing I've noticed about Sony cameras for some time now is the "range" at which their histo's read vs. the "range" at which Canon histo's read.
By that, I mean the Sony histo's seem more "compacted", while the Canon's seem more "extracted". I've noticed this in the diff's of controlled test's of color checkers, where the diff between white / black values of the Sony are closer together than the Canon's are.
Your histo's show the same relationship of a "compacted" vs. "extracted" capture. In that regard, it makes me ask the question of the different pro / con that each design might afford for starting out with the different histo profile? Something that's been on my mind for a while, but never asked anyone about.
Sorry rusty, I should have been clearer. I took a set of brackets from which I subsequently chose different exposures to base my results on. The last histogram a posted were actually my 'identical settings' set to show that the light really had changed and so the same settings would have been a really bad choice to make,
p.13 #4Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
RustyBug wrote: chez wroteYes indeed. To publicly call someone out and then run away when challenged is not good form.FYI ... Dan PM'd me a couple days ago about an upcoming outing into the backcountry. I anticipate he'll respond when he returns (assuming that's why the non-response). I've not observed Dan to run away from too many things around here. Suggesting poor form so rapidly after Tim's recent request, seems a bit pre-mature and a bit ad hominem overzealous on your part to do so.
Likewise, I asked for a response from Tim (request for a recap) ... but, oh gee, Tim just might be doing something else in his life besides responding to me at the moment. Imo, it is good form for me to let Tim take all the time he needs / wants to respond (or respect a non-response). He owes me nothing and has other things on his plate. Dan just might have something else on his plate atm, so (imo) good form would be to afford our fellow FM'ers the time to do so....Show more →
p.13 #6Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
RustyBug wrote:
Yup, that's what I wanted to see ... i.e. where it had started from.
Thanks.
So, I obviously know how I got from the second image to the third image. Tim, can you recap how you got from the first (obviously before resize) image (sooc) to the second?
The basic settings are on the screenshot on p9 but on top of that I just did a little dodge and burn on some areas (eg tops of trees in corners were too dark. Grass in ft got a little too bright) and a final highlight recovery brush over hottest highlights.
p.13 #7Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
rdcny wrote:
this is where we need a moderator occasionally to come in and calm things down before they heat up too much.
Tim took a lot of hits from folks - and the way he did his "experiment" or "tests" also got called into question. Reading those comments, I thought some were "over the top" including one from Fred about the tests being a "joke."
What we all came to see through the extended discussion here - and Tim's polite and usually courteous responses - was that very few of us understood completely how he did the tests. Many good (wonderful) issues were raised about methodology (eg., the difference in time between test shots allowing for different lighting conditions) by FM people. I learned a lot.
Anyway, I think we all learned much - and though it was easy to make ad hominen attacks on Tim before he commented here - and continued to answer questions from FM people...I think what I learned most of all is that Tim is a thinking, feeling person just like everyone else on FM. Once we got to know him through his responses it became much more difficult to make personal attacks to discredit his testing methodology/conclusions - and that is good.
p.13 #8Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Just in case it got glossed over, Dan wrote:
gdanmitchell wrote:
I apologize for laying it on a bit too thick, and I have no expectation that you would actually add something like this verbatim. Nonetheless, while there are elements in my post that are over-stated and arguable, I think there are also elements worth considering.
p.13 #9Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
timparkin wrote
The basic settings are on the screenshot on p9 but on top of that I just did a little dodge and burn on some areas (eg tops of trees in corners were too dark. Grass in ft got a little too bright) and a final highlight recovery brush over hottest highlights.
Sorry I didn't see this earlier
No worries ... thanks.
I was trying to emulate in PS from the 50% jpg ... no such luck (go figure). Just wanted a reference, guess I should've taken better notice on my end along the way.
p.13 #10Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Rusty, pardon my deletion earlier. The thread looked to be going in a different props-to-Tim direction, so I deleted my post about bracketing issues of moving tree leaves/branches against a bright sky. You replied succinctly "channel masks". I don't think that works, would you demonstrate that for me? Thanks!
p.13 #11Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Gotcha ...
Two words for the trees against sky ... channel masks.
Although, I do suppose there is a difference between frame vs. frame ... and motion blur of a given frame. In THAT regard, the strategy of intentional underexposure to retain shutter speed has some merit ... which can also be an ISO bump strategy vs. intentional underexposure / lift.
+1 @ Sony sensor. I do dig how clean it seems to be, and am looking forward to learning of what it's true ISO is. I still won't be picking up an A7R II (previous reasons), but I can respect it. Actually, it has given cause to see it compared to the A7R for a "hmmmm" at a niche MF tool in the A7R. Likely, if the right one passes my way, I'll add it to the stable to see how she runs ... but there is a diff between niche vs. workhorse ... depending on ones needs / wants / applications.
Using channel masks can make easy work of separating your treeline from your sky, particularly when your sky is of a different color. Once you have that separation, then instead of chasing moving foliage, move your sky (i.e. clone extra as needed) for the re-alignment.
p.13 #12Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
With the complexities of leaves and branches against a sky, which are not moving linearly, but rather are bending and twisting (changing shape and moving towards/away from the camera) , I cannot imagine how channel masks can work that easily. Cloning? Wow, that sounds painfully tedious.
I can try to post up an example problem if interested.
p.13 #13Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
darbo wrote:
With the complexities of leaves and branches against a sky, which are not moving linearly, but rather are bending and twisting (changing shape and moving towards/away from the camera) , I cannot imagine how channel masks can work that easily. Cloning? Wow, that sounds painfully tedious.
I can try to post up an example problem if interested.
Sure, I'm game ... but maybe another thread / forum (or PM) as a "challenge".
p.13 #15Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Play these couple times and pay attention between A7Rii & 5Ds highlights and shadows transition. It is a whole different world in wider DR imaging. Who said DR is the only thing that counts for landscape:
p.13 #19Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
mttran wrote:
Play these couple times and pay attention between A7Rii & 5Ds highlights and shadows transition. It is a whole different world in wider DR imaging. Who said DR is the only thing that counts for landscape:
Too bad none of them are of the same lighting ... i.e. a repeat shot of the interior industrial (which is likely very repeatable lighting / subject) or some other repeatable "real world" image would be nice.
I had already seen these and while I did like the look of some of the Sony images, there were some @ not so much as well.
Between the variance in lighting conditions and the camera profile setups (I haven't checked them), it is kinda tough to equitably evaluate these. Not sure what the Sony profiles are, but there can be quite a diff between a Faithful / Neutral profile vs. a Landscape profile. I mean, some of the Sony looks just as blocked up as any I've seen (i.e. pine tree shadows), while others look nice with what looks like very large window light as a source or otherwise soft lighting. Not too crazy about a few of the Sony WB choices (but that's an easy adjustment).
I do see a few of the Canon that have harsh transitions (metal work shadow), but given the lighting / specular subject ... I think I'd need to see what the Sony produces in the same condition before I'd use this as telling tale by itself. I mean, the rolloff in the guy doing flips isn't very smooth either in certain aspects. And if you shot the menu with the Canon, you'd probably see much the same rolloff as a condition of the lighting moreover than the camera than the camera being used.
The one that stands out in my mind is the pine tree shadows. While we have seen a diff in noise and extreme underexposure lifting ... those pine tree shadows still look kinda blocked up.