p.12 #1Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
EB-1 wrote:
Meanwhile the 5DsR is good enough for >95% of the situations where I need resolution and will also work well enough for wildlife where the Sony is severely hindered. I won't obsess over that <5% of opportunities where the lighting is super contrasty and the Sony would be desirable.
EBH
I, too, choose to work with the 5DS at this time and do not see it handicapping me in my work. But do I wish it had the Sony Exmor sensor instead of the current Canon one in it? Hell yes!
p.12 #2Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
EB-1 wrote:
Meanwhile the 5DsR is good enough for >95% of the situations where I need resolution and will also work well enough for wildlife where the Sony is severely hindered. I won't obsess over that <5% of opportunities where the lighting is super contrasty and the Sony would be desirable.
EBH
Just have a cheap a7R as a convenient accessory to your Canon gear for those 5% of opportunities (it's what I do). Problem solved.
p.12 #3Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
darbo wrote:
Rusty, brackets are not captured instantaneously. The wind is blowing all your foliage around so none of your brackets align.
That sounds good on paper, but ... the areas of extreme DR difference are typically not occurring among various areas of your foliage. Typically, the DR variance is in the fact that you are capturing a direct light source from one direction vs. an indirect subject illumination from a different direction.
If our lighting was uniform, then the scene would readily fit within the range of most any sensor. It is the extreme lighting variance that creates the challenge. So, while you might get movement between frames in your foliage, you likely aren't "splitting" your foliage between frames anyway as they are typically in the same illumination.
I appreciate the fact that subject do have movement, but I find it rare that such movement between frames in the blades of grass in the foreground in extreme DR scenes are really deal breakers. I mean seriously, if the sooc of Tim's had a +3 frame ... how in the world are you going to know that the grass is in a different position than his sooc?
p.12 #4Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
darbo wrote: EB-1 wroteMeanwhile the 5DsR is good enough for >95% of the situations where I need resolution and will also work well enough for wildlife where the Sony is severely hindered. I won't obsess over that <5% of opportunities where the lighting is super contrasty and the Sony would be desirable.
EBHJust have a cheap a7R as a convenient accessory to your Canon gear for those 5% of opportunities (it's what I do). Problem solved.
Yeah, I tried that prior to the 5DsR and it was too much of a PITA. I lost more opportunities than I gained. Having to shoot at ISO 800 with moderate teles due to the shutter shake was intolerable. I was able to use ISO 100 on the Canon.
Anyway, it's time to move on. There will probably be a 5D IV and other new bodies to consider next year. I'm not mental over the Sony vs. Canon thing as seems to be case in many of the forums. At least I tried Sony and am not missing too much.
p.12 #6Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
I like to bracket a lot...and quite frequently the foliage is in different positions in each bracket leading to blending headaches. That's not on paper; it is a regular experience of mine. But, I guess that's just me.
p.12 #7Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
darbo wrote:
I like to bracket a lot...and quite frequently the foliage is in different positions in each bracket leading to blending headaches. That's not on paper; it is a regular experience of mine. But, I guess that's just me.
I'm not saying it is never an issue, but I can usually have sufficient separation (exposure / mask in post) that I don't have to try and match up the foliage even if it has moved between frames.
p.12 #8Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
EB-1 wrote: darbo wroteEB-1 wroteMeanwhile the 5DsR is good enough for >95% of the situations where I need resolution and will also work well enough for wildlife where the Sony is severely hindered. I won't obsess over that <5% of opportunities where the lighting is super contrasty and the Sony would be desirable.
EBHJust have a cheap a7R as a convenient accessory to your Canon gear for those 5% of opportunities (it's what I do). Problem solved. Yeah, I tried that prior to the 5DsR and it was too much of a PITA. I lost more opportunities than I gained. Having to shoot at ISO 800 with moderate teles due to the shutter shake was intolerable. I was able to use ISO 100 on the Canon.
Anyway, it's time to move on. There will probably be a 5D IV and other new bodies to consider next year. I'm not mental over the Sony vs. Canon thing as seems to be case in many of the forums. At least I tried Sony and am not missing too much.
EBH
Cool. The mix works really well for me, and I can't imagine not having one with me any more. It is merely another tool in the bag, like a CPL or GND or speedlite, etc. But, I couldn't agree more with your enthusiasm for the 5DS R as perfectly adequate for the vast majority of situations (actually the primary reason I have an a7R is not so much about DR and more about hand-held manual focusing).
I am really torn over whether to upgrade to the a7R II. I would absolutely love to have one, but I'll reference a good Rusty-ism from a different thread: Glass rules! (or something to that effect) Instead of upgrading my auxilliary camera, I am thinking I should focus on upgrading my lens collection - really want to add that 100-400L II.
p.12 #9Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
RustyBug wrote: EB-1 wroteHaving to shoot at ISO 800 with moderate teles due to the shutter shake was intolerable. I was able to use ISO 100 on the Canon.Interesting point ... but for an extra couple thousand dollars you can have an A7R II instead of an A7R.
AF is not encouraging, especially the 100-400 II. We'll see if there are better adapters later on or if there is an inherent limit in the camera.
p.12 #10Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
gdanmitchell wrote:
So, "adequate" is the most you'll admit to? My examples are no more than "adequate?" ;-)
Stretch a bit, and perhaps you could admit to "more than adequate?" You can even still say that Sony is better if you want and then we'll be in agreement. ;-)
Dan
No, I would not say it is "more than adequate." Canon deep shadow recovery is adequate in some circumstances, and inadequate in others. If I thought Canon deep shadow recovery was "more than adequate" then by definition I would not have use for something that performed better (or was "excellent") in that area. And I do.
Conversely, if you think Canon deep shadow recovery qualifies as "excellent," then does that make Sony "more than excellent"
p.12 #13Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
timparkin wrote: gdanmitchell wroteI apologize for laying it on a bit too thick, and I have no expectation that you would actually add something like this verbatim. Nonetheless, while there are elements in my post that are over-stated and arguable, I think there are also elements worth considering.
Take care,
Dan
timparkin wrotegdanmitchell wroteEarlier quoteLooks like I need to do some reading. Never investigated these color matrices beforeTim, perhaps a preface to your original article, at the top of the page in italic type, should explicitly acknowledge this.
Something along the lines of:
"Thanks to all who have come here to read my original article ostensibly comparing the three cameras. For those of you with a very technical bent, who already understand the complexities of testing things in this way and who will read very carefully may find the following useful. Others who might come here thinking that these test images of captures pushed in all sorts of extreme ways represent what you are actually going to see from any of these cameras, should stop and take a deep breath and study up a bit first. It is extraordinarily unlikely that you will even see a real photograph from any of these cameras that remotely resembles what you see in these extreme test image, and you should not presume that the differences that may be visible in this torture test will be visible in your photographs. In fact, all three of these cameras produce extraordinary high levels of image quality that will satisfy the most careful and discriminating photographers, and those choosing any of the cameras will almost certainly be very happy with the results."
All of us find it useful and informative to test our equipment. However, in this case I relearned important lessons about such testing. It is very hard to do properly. While it was my goal to show an objective test, variables in how the cameras were tested sneaked into the results and they affected the accuracy of my original report. In addition, I now realize that I made unwarranted assumptions about the ways the different cameras are designed and how they work, assumptions that caused me to think that the tests were more comparable then they actually are. I'm currently working to better understand these important factors."
DanAre telling me to post an apology for getting it wrong? I may do if you could show me how it's wrong.
Which assumptions did I get wrong?
Which important lessons did I relearn?
I honestly think it's pretty presumptuous to ask this when you haven't explained how I got it 'wrong' and I don't accept it's wrong in the first place.Seriously though - what do you think I misunderstand or have got wrong? You must think something otherwise you wouldn't post that. At least give me a chance to respond
Hi Dan,
Could you do me a favour and answer these questions. Especially in light of my publication of the rawdigger histograms for the 'same' exposures (and offer of the raw files of those if people would like to see).
Your name is substantially more well known than mine and publicly accusing me of being 'wrong' isn't particularly nice for me. At least do me the justice of a reply...
I'll repeat the links to the 'idential' exposure settings.
p.12 #14Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Rajan Parrikar wrote: RustyBug wroteJust be cautious that you don't allow the crutch of extra DR lure you into the folly of poor technique by the Siren's Song of extreme recovery capabilities.That can be said of any powerful tool that is not used judiciously.
Exactly. Just like AF or Auto exposure...should we be calling these a crutch as well?
What is a crutch is having to use GND filters or merging multiple exposed images in post to tame down the dynamic range in a scene...these are truly crutches.
p.12 #15Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
+1 @ the early reports of the A7R II not playing so nice with the 100-400L II (on the long end, as noted elsewhere).
+1 @ time will tell ... it is SOOOOO early yet.
After seeing (imo) the "heroic" abilities of the new Sony sensor for beyond shadow recovery, my interest in the A7R II was raised. But then, the news of the AF (early) results came out and with 80% of my current AF glass falling on the "NOT WELL" list from Fred. That's quite a bit of a buzz-kill. So that's $4K (camera + multiple adapters + tax) that I'll not be spending on the A7R II at this time.
Had the AF met up with my glass better, I'd be compelled to take it for a spin, but I can't justify $4K for a MF tool, when I can simply set my camera to a three bracket exposure of -1, +2, +5 or +1, -2, -5. Instead of trying to make a "heroic" 6 stop lift of my shadows, I just find it to be better technique to capture an exposure for those areas much closer to where I want their final value to be.
While much is made about the sensor noise and the abilities it offers ... ummm, keeping processing artifacts at bay still remains something to be very attentive to. If you goal is MAX IQ, then I still feel that intentionally underexposing / lifting 6+ stops isn't your best play. If it truly is your only play ... well, then so be it.
However, for landscape use ... it's a tough sell for me to believe that folks are always so restricted that they can't bracket (as the oft argument goes). I mean, the whole wind issue @ moving foliage reminds me of a landscape painter. The wind blows all day long, but it doesn't effect his final product any more or less than he desires for it to be incorporated into his painting.
But, we aren't landscape painters you say. Well, we get to put our tonal values wherever we want them, our hues wherever we want them, our saturation wherever we want them. We heal and clone and sharpen and soften adjust contrast and gamma, etc.
Sure, we start out with a capture, and aspire to stay true to such a capture ... but if the grass blows in the wind, we can put it pretty much anywhere we want it, and it is still a true representation ... not unlike a painter. I mean, we put our WB all over the board and as long as it is plausible, who can say what those changing conditions were when you captured your file. Who can say if your foliage was two pixels to the left or two pixels to the right?
So, to say that you can't bracket because of moving foliage ... I'm of the opinion that some folks prefer to not bracket, while others prefer to make the adjustments as needed. I just think we have choices to make. In this scenario, the choice is do I want to lift shadows 6+ stops, or do I want to bracket. Neither is a perfect option ... which approach one chooses ... horses for courses.
Me, I prefer to get my exposure closer to where I want it in the end, and that may involve bracketing if my goal is truly max IQ. Shooting other scenarios, (event / production volume, etc.) I may prefer the convenience of a single shot at the tradeoff of maximum IQ for good IQ.
p.12 #16Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
chez wrote:
Yes indeed. To publicly call someone out and then run away when challenged is not good form.
FYI ... Dan PM'd me a couple days ago about an upcoming outing into the backcountry. I anticipate he'll respond when he returns (assuming that's why the non-response). I've not observed Dan to run away from too many things around here. Suggesting poor form so rapidly after Tim's recent request, seems a bit pre-mature and a bit ad hominem overzealous on your part to do so.
Likewise, I asked for a response from Tim (request for a recap) ... but, oh gee, Tim just might be doing something else in his life besides responding to me at the moment. Imo, it is good form for me to let Tim take all the time he needs / wants to respond (or respect a non-response). He owes me nothing and has other things on his plate. Dan just might have something else on his plate atm, so (imo) good form would be to afford our fellow FM'ers the time to do so.
p.12 #17Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Tim,
I'm still kinda confused by your top two histo's between the A7R and the A7R II. I don't see how those are considered identical or equitable ... maybe, I just don't understand.
Also, I'm not a "histo guru", but one thing I've noticed about Sony cameras for some time now is the "range" at which their histo's read vs. the "range" at which Canon histo's read.
By that, I mean the Sony histo's seem more "compacted", while the Canon's seem more "extracted". I've noticed this in the diff's of controlled test's of color checkers, where the diff between white / black values of the Sony are closer together than the Canon's are.
Your histo's show the same relationship of a "compacted" vs. "extracted" capture. In that regard, it makes me ask the question of the different pro / con that each design might afford for starting out with the different histo profile? Something that's been on my mind for a while, but never asked anyone about.
p.12 #18Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
RustyBug wrote: chez wroteYes indeed. To publicly call someone out and then run away when challenged is not good form.FYI ... Dan PM'd me a couple days ago about an upcoming outing into the backcountry. I anticipate he'll respond when he returns (assuming that's why the non-response). I've not observed Dan to run away from too many things around here. Suggesting poor form so rapidly after Tim's recent request, seems a bit pre-mature and a bit ad hominem overzealous on your part to do so.
Likewise, I asked for a response from Tim (request for a recap) ... but, oh gee, Tim just might be doing something else in his life besides responding to me at the moment. Imo, it is good form for me to let Tim take all the time he needs / wants to respond (or respect a non-response). He owes me nothing and has other things on his plate. Dan just might have something else on his plate atm, so (imo) good form would be to afford our fellow FM'ers the time to do so....Show more →
I believe Tim has asked Dan on multiple occasions over the last 3 days or so to explain himself. I don't know if you read Dan's post where he basically said that Tim should post an apology to all for purposely misleading people with his tests. All Tim wants is for Dan to point out where Tim's tests are wrong or where he purposely mislead people.
That was a very harsh post by Dan and he owes Tim an explanation. To publicly slam someone and not respond when challenged is telling.
p.12 #19Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Chez ... yeah, I thought Dan's post for the "preface" was a bit over the top. I did understand his point @ disclaimer, though. I took it mostly as "hyperbole", but I can see where others might perceive it differently. I'll leave that to Dan to better explain for himself.
I know that my "hyperbole" gets taken as literal sometimes too. You think that you've written something that folks can't possible take literal because it is so ridiculous (testing tires) ... and then you come to realize you apparently didn't make it ridiculous enough ... go figure.
p.12 #20Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
this is where we need a moderator occasionally to come in and calm things down before they heat up too much.
Tim took a lot of hits from folks - and the way he did his "experiment" or "tests" also got called into question. Reading those comments, I thought some were "over the top" including one from Fred about the tests being a "joke."
What we all came to see through the extended discussion here - and Tim's polite and usually courteous responses - was that very few of us understood completely how he did the tests. Many good (wonderful) issues were raised about methodology (eg., the difference in time between test shots allowing for different lighting conditions) by FM people. I learned a lot.
Anyway, I think we all learned much - and though it was easy to make ad hominen attacks on Tim before he commented here - and continued to answer questions from FM people...I think what I learned most of all is that Tim is a thinking, feeling person just like everyone else on FM. Once we got to know him through his responses it became much more difficult to make personal attacks to discredit his testing methodology/conclusions - and that is good.