fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr

  
 
Monito
Offline
Details
p.2 #1Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
One and a third stops less light is a little like starving a race horse and then expecting it to win the Kentucky Derby.
Aug 04, 2015 at 07:52 PM
Rajan Parrikar
Offline
Details
p.2 #2Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Monito wrote:
Rajan, Dan has written the most measured notes in this thread. He is the least "bent out of shape" of anyone. Dan always emphasizes that Sony makes excellent cameras for some purposes (as do the other brands for other purposes).


Aka repeating ad nauseum the obvious and the unremarkable.

I am still looking for the guy in this thread who has attempted to "make the "other brand" look bad." After all, I am in the "other brand" camp.


Aug 04, 2015 at 07:58 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.2 #3Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Monito wrote:
One and a third stops less light is a little like starving a race horse and then expecting it to win the Kentucky Derby.


... and pointing him in the wrong direction in the starting gate (skewed color balance).

Edited on Aug 04, 2015 at 08:01 PM · View previous versions
Aug 04, 2015 at 07:59 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.2 #4Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
snapsy wrote:
2ndviolinman wroteThe link is to a test that compares what the cameras can do when a particular area of the scene is exposed to the right, not a test of what the results are when the cameras are set to the same shutter speed, aperture and ISO. As long as one knows what the test is, it is what it. It is only bogus if you want it to be some other test.
The images were exposed to the left - the sky is -6EV below highlight clipping. Any test that endeavors to compare noise between cameras must use the same absolute exposure - if there are nominal ISO differences between cameras that would risk clipping on one vs another then the exposure must be adjusted so that all cameras remain below clipping but still using the same absolute exposure.


Agree. Even using identical camera settings don't assure fair results in many cases. Cameras lie about their true ISO settings and slight changes in exposure from camera to camera may benefit one over the other.
This test is a complete joke. However I do expect the A7RII to do substantially better when recovering deep shadows.
Aug 04, 2015 at 08:01 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.2 #5Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Monito wrote:
Rajan, Dan has written...


Monito, don't worry about it. Nothing to worry about. Let it go. :-)

Fred Miranda wrote:
This test is a complete joke. However I do expect the A7RII to do substantially better when recovering deep shadows.


I expect that the Sony sensor in the A7rII will continue to have more dynamic range than the current Canon sensor, too.

Take care,

Dan, a.k.a. "hen on a hot griddle" ;-)

Edited on Aug 05, 2015 at 01:32 PM · View previous versions
Aug 04, 2015 at 08:02 PM
Rajan Parrikar
Offline
Details
p.2 #6Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
gdanmitchell wrote:
Monito wroteRajan, Dan has written...
Monito, don't worry about it. He has said nothing but negative and personal things about me for at least a year now. Nothing to worry about. Let it go. :-)

Take care,

Dan


False. I know nothing personal about you nor am I interested. I comment based on what you write.
Aug 04, 2015 at 08:03 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.2 #7Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Fred Miranda wrote:
snapsy wrote
2ndviolinman wroteThe link is to a test that compares what the cameras can do when a particular area of the scene is exposed to the right, not a test of what the results are when the cameras are set to the same shutter speed, aperture and ISO. As long as one knows what the test is, it is what it. It is only bogus if you want it to be some other test.
The images were exposed to the left - the sky is -6EV below highlight clipping. Any test that endeavors to compare noise between cameras must use the same absolute exposure - if there are nominal ISO differences between cameras that would risk clipping on one vs another then the exposure must be adjusted so that all cameras remain below clipping but still using the same absolute exposure.
Agree. Even using identical camera settings don't assure fair results in many cases. Cameras lie about their true ISO settings and slight changes in exposure from camera to camera may benefit one over the other.
This test is a complete joke. However I do expect the A7RII to do substantially better when recovering deep shadows.


+1 @ Fred ... I also expect the true base ISO of the A7R II to be lower than the true base ISO of the Canon. Historically, Sony tends to cheat their ISO a bit more than Canon (who also shaves it a bit) does.
Aug 04, 2015 at 08:05 PM
zlatko
Offline
Details
p.2 #8Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
It's obvious the Sony sensor is better for these extreme scenarios -- I don't doubt that. But why would someone choose to base their camera comparison on this one extreme test (and then rig the comparison by underexposing the Canon an additional 1.3 stops)? Is 5-stop underexposure recovery the new standard for camera comparisons? The author may as rationally have chosen some other extreme comparisons:
- comparison of viewfinder lag
- comparison of battery life in the Arctic
- comparison of image stabilization at 800mm
- comparison of speed of manual selection of autofocus points
- comparison of reliability of recording to dual cards
- comparison of durability when getting trampled by wildebeest
- etc.
Aug 04, 2015 at 08:17 PM
zlatko
Offline
Details
p.2 #9Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
gdanmitchell wrote:
Well, dang. I guess that in all of my 5DsR photographs where I pushed blacks, shadows, and exposure and thought I got beautiful results (and prints) that I was just hallucinating. Actually the camera sucks. Just look at that horrible noise!

Because the internet. ;-)

Here you go, excerpted from my link above with a wide dynamic range scene ETTR, an objective example of just how terribly, awfully, horrible things get when you push a 5DsR file. Oh, the shame!.

The unprocessed raw shot at base ISO...

http://i0.wp.com/www.gdanmitchell.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/07/02DarkestExposure.jpg

Then edited...

Exposure was pushed to +2.00
Contrast was increased to +47
Highlights was reduced to -44 to compensate
...Show more →

Thank you for that post -- that is very instructive.

I think the author of the linked article reveals his bias by choosing to highlight just one extreme situation where the Sony is known to have an advantage, i.e. 5-stop exposure push with +100 shadow recovery, and then rigging the test with different exposures. I will venture to guess that of all of the great photographs published in the last two centuries, absolutely *none* have required a 5-stop exposure push with +100 shadow recovery (or the film equivalent) such as the author has done.
Aug 04, 2015 at 08:40 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.2 #10Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
zlatko wrote:
It's obvious the Sony sensor is better for these extreme scenarios -- I don't doubt that. But why would someone choose to base their camera comparison on this one extreme test (and then rig the comparison by underexposing the Canon an additional 1.3 stops)? Is 5-stop underexposure recovery the new standard for camera comparisons? The author may as rationally have chosen some other extreme comparisons:
- comparison of viewfinder lag
- comparison of battery life in the Arctic
- comparison of image stabilization at 800mm
- comparison of speed of manual selection of autofocus points
- comparison of reliability of recording to dual cards
- comparison
...Show more →

You are being too rational. Once DXOMark posts the overall score for the A7RII, that is the magical number the media will focus on...and it's meaningless.
Aug 04, 2015 at 08:42 PM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.2 #11Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Rajan Parrikar wrote:
Monito wroteRajan, Dan has written the most measured notes in this thread. He is the least "bent out of shape" of anyone. Dan always emphasizes that Sony makes excellent cameras for some purposes (as do the other brands for other purposes).
Aka repeating ad nauseum the obvious and the unremarkable.

I am still looking for the guy in this thread who has attempted to "make the "other brand" look bad." After all, I am in the "other brand" camp.


Start with the guy who 'liked' your post. Rational thought has rapidly left some on the forum.
Aug 04, 2015 at 08:49 PM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.2 #12Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Fred Miranda wrote:
zlatko wroteIt's obvious the Sony sensor is better for these extreme scenarios -- I don't doubt that. But why would someone choose to base their camera comparison on this one extreme test (and then rig the comparison by underexposing the Canon an additional 1.3 stops)? Is 5-stop underexposure recovery the new standard for camera comparisons? The author may as rationally have chosen some other extreme comparisons:
- comparison of viewfinder lag
- comparison of battery life in the Arctic
- comparison of image stabilization at 800mm
- comparison of speed of manual selection of autofocus points
- comparison of reliability of recording to dual cards
- comparison of durability when getting trampled by wildebeest
- etc.
You are being too rational. Once DXOMark posts the overall score for the A7RII, that is the magical number the media will focus on...and it's meaningless.


Not sure I would say it is meaningless - problem is that the algorithm how this number is calculated for each camera is not known. But I suspect that all cameras of the same category like full frame are determined by the same calculation method. Of course we can argue one feature should have a higher or lower weight - for example DR. Seeing the recent rating of the 5Ds(R) series, it appears that DR is more heavily weighted in this score - not a bad thing for newer FF camera models IMO.
Aug 04, 2015 at 08:52 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.2 #13Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
retrofocus wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
zlatko wroteIt's obvious the Sony sensor is better for these extreme scenarios -- I don't doubt that. But why would someone choose to base their camera comparison on this one extreme test (and then rig the comparison by underexposing the Canon an additional 1.3 stops)? Is 5-stop underexposure recovery the new standard for camera comparisons? The author may as rationally have chosen some other extreme comparisons:
- comparison of viewfinder lag
- comparison of battery life in the Arctic
- comparison of image stabilization at 800mm
- comparison of speed of manual selection of autofocus points
- comparison of reliability of recording to dual cards
- comparison of durability when getting trampled by wildebeest
- etc.
You are being too rational. Once DXOMark posts the overall score for the A7RII, that is the magical number the media will focus on...and it's meaningless.
Not sure I would say it is meaningless - problem is that the algorithm how this number is calculated for each camera is not known. But I suspect that all cameras of the same category like full frame are determined by the same calculation method. Of course we can argue one feature should have a higher or lower weight - for example DR. Seeing the recent rating of the 5Ds(R) series, it appears that DR is more heavily weighted in this score - not a bad thing for newer FF camera models IMO.


I say meaningless because it's subjective to what the tester believes is important.
For example, you mentioned DR. A sport shooter or wildlife photographer would not care about base ISO dynamic range. If that carries too much weight to calculate the overall score number, it would be misleading for that type of photography.
Aug 04, 2015 at 09:14 PM
zlatko
Offline
Details
p.2 #14Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
The Canon has anti-flicker reduction. That feature is amazing for shooting in fluorescent light -- a common scenario for some photographers. Interesting how the author didn't compare that. I can cherry-pick scenarios for "testing" as well as he can.
Aug 04, 2015 at 09:16 PM
Scott Stoness
Offline
Details
p.2 #15Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
retrofocus wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
zlatko wroteIt's obvious the Sony sensor is better for these extreme scenarios -- I don't doubt that. But why would someone choose to base their camera comparison on this one extreme test (and then rig the comparison by underexposing the Canon an additional 1.3 stops)? Is 5-stop underexposure recovery the new standard for camera comparisons? The author may as rationally have chosen some other extreme comparisons:
- comparison of viewfinder lag
- comparison of battery life in the Arctic
- comparison of image stabilization at 800mm
- comparison of speed of manual selection of autofocus points
- comparison of reliability of recording to dual cards
- comparison of durability when getting trampled by wildebeest
- etc.
You are being too rational. Once DXOMark posts the overall score for the A7RII, that is the magical number the media will focus on...and it's meaningless.
Not sure I would say it is meaningless - problem is that the algorithm how this number is calculated for each camera is not known. But I suspect that all cameras of the same category like full frame are determined by the same calculation method. Of course we can argue one feature should have a higher or lower weight - for example DR. Seeing the recent rating of the 5Ds(R) series, it appears that DR is more heavily weighted in this score - not a bad thing for newer FF camera models IMO.


Its not weighting dynamic range but dynamic range at 17% noise at iso 100. There is no doubt that a narrow measure of dynamic range is indicative but so are lots of other things like shutter noise, camera features, selection of lens by brand.... Too much is made of dynamic range below iso 800 when the sony pushed to use the dynamic range yields ugly results and still needs aeb and blending.

Sony has a good sensor but I like the package of 5dsr better than the package of a7r (and likely a7rii).
Aug 04, 2015 at 09:30 PM
KKFung
Offline
Details
p.2 #16Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Negative film have much better DR than positive film (slide), why people still using positive film nowaday?
Aug 04, 2015 at 09:39 PM
howard
Offline
Details
p.2 #17Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
Fred Miranda wrote:
This test is a complete joke.


^^^ this

Aug 04, 2015 at 09:40 PM
darbo
Offline
Details
p.2 #18Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
I like that my 5DS not only doesn't produce lesser 12-bit images (with lossy compressed raws) in bulb mode, but it's even got a built-in bulb timer to help me get time the shot with even better timing precision.

Not super-happy to learn about the various shooting modes that limit my a7R's color output to only 12-bit raw files.

Aug 04, 2015 at 09:44 PM
timparkin
Offline
Details
p.2 #19Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr


RustyBug wrote:
Okay, so one is shot at 1/2500s (5DsR) and the other 1/1000s (A7R II) ... one is shot @ -2 Tint (A7R II) and one is shot at -24 Tint (5DsR) (temps @ 5754 & 5800 are close enough). Do you not think that this is going to have a difference in the outcomes when you ratchet to the max. How about doing a test that has let the same amount of light in, and one that is equitably balanced BEFORE you start cranking on sliders.

I mean, the really smart folks around here have made it clear how noise is
...Show more →

The base exposure was calculated using raw digger to ettr (ie not affected by tint). The exposure was then dialed down 6 stops. So the test is on 6 stops below typical ETTR practise.
Aug 04, 2015 at 10:08 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.2 #20Sony A7Rii compared with Sony A7R and Canon 5DSr
It sounds like they were equitably dialed down 6 stops ... but they were NOT equitably given the same amount of light (which has a direct influence on noise, iirc) @ capture to achieve that (same) ETTR.

Essentially, you are saying that a 50 ISO film has better noise characteristics than a 125 ISO film. In order to achieve a "correct" exposure in each, you are applying more light to the 50 ISO film than you are to the 125 ISO film and thus get less noise. Gee, where is the surprise in that.

Despite both cameras (A7R II & 5DsR) being rated at 100 ISO ... IF one requires more light to achieve the same level of exposure (the ETTR referenced in the test), then the actual ISO is lower.

If anything, this suggests (to me) that the Sony ISO may be even more of a "stretch" than their previous stretching.

As to the tint being "not effected" ... hmmm, -24 tint means a reduction in the green channel. Given that the green channel carries half of the weight in a bayer array, you really think that it would have no effect in producing additional underexposure, nor account for the color noise amplification we see after all the ratcheting is complete.

Maybe I'm off here, but whenever I use the Color Balance and take my green channel -24, things tend to get darker (and magenta) as the green channel moves left.
Aug 04, 2015 at 10:29 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister