fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 20155DS - Diffraction earlier at wider stop?

  
 
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.5 #15DS - Diffraction earlier at wider stop?
Toothwalker wrote:
takowasa wroteResolution is affected by lens aberrations and DOF (as well as diffraction, motion blur, camera shake, pixel count, etc). However, the DOF itself (the blur associated due to the focus being progressively further off as elements of the scene are further from the focal plane), is not affected by lens aberrations.
Which part of Dr. Nasse's document did you not understand?


Which part of non sequitur do you not understand? ;-)

YMMV,

Dan
Jun 26, 2015 at 09:50 AM
takowasa
Offline
Details
p.5 #25DS - Diffraction earlier at wider stop?
takowasa wrote:
Resolution is affected by lens aberrations and DOF (as well as diffraction, motion blur, camera shake, pixel count, etc). However, the DOF itself (the blur associated due to the focus being progressively further off as elements of the scene are further from the focal plane), is not affected by lens aberrations.


Toothwalker wrote:
Which part of Dr. Nasse's document did you not understand?


Why don't you be a little more polite and helpful, and quote the portion from Dr. Nasse's 45 page PDF document that you feel I didn't understand.



Edited on Jun 26, 2015 at 11:00 PM · View previous versions
Jun 26, 2015 at 06:05 PM
EB-1
Offline
Details
p.5 #35DS - Diffraction earlier at wider stop?
Toothwalker wrote:
takowasa wroteResolution is affected by lens aberrations and DOF (as well as diffraction, motion blur, camera shake, pixel count, etc). However, the DOF itself (the blur associated due to the focus being progressively further off as elements of the scene are further from the focal plane), is not affected by lens aberrations.
Which part of Dr. Nasse's document did you not understand?



Who is Dr. Nasen?

EBH
Jun 26, 2015 at 07:27 PM
takowasa
Offline
Details
p.5 #45DS - Diffraction earlier at wider stop?
takowasa wrote:
Resolution is affected by lens aberrations and DOF (as well as diffraction, motion blur, camera shake, pixel count, etc). However, the DOF itself (the blur associated due to the focus being progressively further off as elements of the scene are further from the focal plane), is not affected by lens aberrations.


Toothwalker wrote:
Which part of Dr. Nasse's document did you not understand?


EB-1 wrote:
Who is Dr. Nasen?


The author of this document.
Jun 26, 2015 at 11:01 PM
Toothwalker
Offline
Details
p.5 #55DS - Diffraction earlier at wider stop?
takowasa wrote:
Why don't you be a little more polite and helpful, and quote the portion from Dr. Nasse's 45 page PDF document that you feel I didn't understand.


The fun starts on page 20.

Jun 27, 2015 at 03:28 AM
anscochrome
Offline
Details
p.5 #65DS - Diffraction earlier at wider stop?
All of this discussion about diffraction on the 5Ds for five + pages, and I will bet a dollar to a doughnut there are STILL 5Ds owners fearful of stopping down past F 6.7.
Jun 27, 2015 at 07:54 AM
EB-1
Offline
Details
p.5 #75DS - Diffraction earlier at wider stop?
takowasa wrote:
Resolution is affected by lens aberrations and DOF (as well as diffraction, motion blur, camera shake, pixel count, etc). However, the DOF itself (the blur associated due to the focus being progressively further off as elements of the scene are further from the focal plane), is not affected by lens aberrations.

Toothwalker wrote:
Which part of Dr. Nasse's document did you not understand?

EB-1 wrote:
Who is Dr. Nasen?

takowasa wrote:
The author of this document.


I'm not sure where that came from not, since this thread has been all over the place.
It's a useful primer and I have someone in mind (outside FM).

EBH
Jun 27, 2015 at 08:03 AM
EB-1
Offline
Details
p.5 #85DS - Diffraction earlier at wider stop?
anscochrome wrote:
All of this discussion about diffraction on the 5Ds for five + pages, and I will bet a dollar to a doughnut there are STILL 5Ds owners fearful of stopping down past F 6.7.


Yet it has same damned pixel density as the 70D from years ago.

EBH
Jun 27, 2015 at 08:08 AM
Jeff Fenske
Offline
Details
p.5 #95DS - Diffraction earlier at wider stop?
anscochrome wrote:
All of this discussion about diffraction on the 5Ds for five + pages, and I will bet a dollar to a doughnut there are STILL 5Ds owners fearful of stopping down past F 6.7.


And some will probably not even buy the 5DsR, because of Cambridge in Colour's world famous, diffraction limit calculator, based on a mathematical theory instead of actual testing.

Here is an actual test, comparing a 12MP full frame sensor with a 36MP full frame sensor, and he didn't find the smaller pixels to cause diffraction sooner. The results are always better with the higher pixeled sensor.

http://www.scantips.com/lights/diffraction.html
Jun 27, 2015 at 09:06 AM
anscochrome
Offline
Details
p.5 #105DS - Diffraction earlier at wider stop?
Jeff Fenske wrote:
anscochrome wroteAll of this discussion about diffraction on the 5Ds for five + pages, and I will bet a dollar to a doughnut there are STILL 5Ds owners fearful of stopping down past F 6.7.
And some will probably not even buy the 5DsR, because of Cambridge in Colour's world famous, diffraction limit calculator, based on a mathematical theory instead of actual testing.

l


Which is exactly my point in earlier posts that get glossed over-if Cambridge in Color and The Digital picture numbers bear no relation to usability in the real world (as has been asserted in this thread), they should not be published in the first place.
Jun 27, 2015 at 10:50 AM
takowasa
Offline
Details
p.5 #115DS - Diffraction earlier at wider stop?
Jeff Fenske wrote:
anscochrome wroteAll of this discussion about diffraction on the 5Ds for five + pages, and I will bet a dollar to a doughnut there are STILL 5Ds owners fearful of stopping down past F 6.7.
And some will probably not even buy the 5DsR, because of Cambridge in Colour's world famous, diffraction limit calculator, based on a mathematical theory instead of actual testing.

Here is an actual test, comparing a 12MP full frame sensor with a 36MP full frame sensor, and he didn't find the smaller pixels to cause diffraction sooner. The results are always better with the higher pixeled sensor.

http://www.scantips.com/lights/diffraction.html


Smaller pixels can shift the diffraction limited aperture sooner, as the links in my earlier post demonstrated, but it requires a large difference in pixels to produce a small shift in the diffraction limited aperture. Regardless, for any given aperture, more pixels will still resolve more, although how much more resolution depends greatly on not only how sharp the lens is, but also the scene and camera settings. That said, the advantage of more pixels is constrained by diminishing returns. That is, you'll see more benefit going from 12 MP to 24 MP than going from 24 MP to 48 MP.
Jun 27, 2015 at 11:28 AM
takowasa
Offline
Details
p.5 #125DS - Diffraction earlier at wider stop?
takowasa wrote:
Why don't you be a little more polite and helpful, and quote the portion from Dr. Nasse's 45 page PDF document that you feel I didn't understand.


Toothwalker wrote:
The fun starts on page 20.


For example this quote: "All types of aberrations from real lenses cause a series of deviations from the geometric model". With regards to resolution, this is absolutely true. But, as I said, DOF and lens aberrations (as well as diffraction and any other source of blur) are all independent measures of blur. The total blur for any particular portion of the photo is the product of all sources of blur.
Jun 27, 2015 at 11:36 AM
Toothwalker
Offline
Details
p.5 #135DS - Diffraction earlier at wider stop?
takowasa wrote:
For example this quote: "All types of aberrations from real lenses cause a series of deviations from the geometric model".


And then he goes on with a description of how aberrations can influence the depth of field.

With regards to resolution, this is absolutely true. But, as I said, DOF and lens aberrations (as well as diffraction and any other source of blur) are all independent measures of blur. The total blur for any particular portion of the photo is the product of all sources of blur.

Aberrations and diffraction are not measures of blur, but causes of blur. DOF is a measure of blur, and is thus affected by aberrations and diffraction.




Jun 27, 2015 at 12:03 PM
takowasa
Offline
Details
p.5 #145DS - Diffraction earlier at wider stop?
takowasa wrote:
For example this quote: "All types of aberrations from real lenses cause a series of deviations from the geometric model".


Toothwalker wrote:
And then he goes on with a description of how aberrations can influence the depth of field.


Can you quote where he says that it influences DOF and not the resolution in the photo?

takowasa wrote:
With regards to resolution, this is absolutely true. But, as I said, DOF and lens aberrations (as well as diffraction and any other source of blur) are all independent measures of blur. The total blur for any particular portion of the photo is the product of all sources of blur.


Toothwalker wrote:
Aberrations and diffraction are not measures of blur, but causes of blur.


Quite right. My bad on that.

DOF is a measure of blur, and is thus affected by aberrations and diffraction.

DOF is a measure of blur as a function of distance from the focal plane, and thus is not affected by lens aberrations or diffraction. However, the total blur is a function of DOF, lens aberrations, diffraction, motion, etc.

Jun 27, 2015 at 12:20 PM
Toothwalker
Offline
Details
p.5 #155DS - Diffraction earlier at wider stop?
takowasa wrote:
Can you quote where he says that it influences DOF and not the resolution in the photo?


What about the bullets immediately following the sentence which you quoted?
Jun 27, 2015 at 01:04 PM
takowasa
Offline
Details
p.5 #165DS - Diffraction earlier at wider stop?
takowasa wrote:
Can you quote where he says that it influences DOF and not the resolution in the photo?


Toothwalker wrote:
What about the bullets immediately following the sentence which you quoted?



Did you mean this bullet?

Depending on the lens aberration, the type of blurriness can be different in front of and behind the focal plane.

I have no argument with that. If you are referring to a different bullet or bullets, please quote them.
Jun 27, 2015 at 01:19 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister