Bruce n Philly wrote: gdanmitchell wroteYet again (he drones on) the news is somewhere between neutral and good for you.
There is no downside.
DanThanx Dan, but edumacate me (as if I can't read!)
Go with me on this.....
You take a picture black on the left, white on the right and an infinity perfect line/transition between.
You have a 5D Mk II...... you crop a pic to 100%..... diffraction sets in at f/11.... You look at the pixels along the b/w line and there is some diffraction blurring. Let's say for arguments sake that the "transition" pixels are 10 pixels wide.
Now swap the body for a 5Ds... because you have more/density pixels, you now crop again down to 100%..... but you are now way deeper. The blurry zone covers more pixel, now 20 pioxels, than the other camera. More pixels are in the blur zone... therefore the need to open up a stop to get the same number of pixels in the blurr zone back to 10.
Remember, my objective is to crop a small part of the pic down to 100%
I'd say that's a pretty good description of the scenario where the "DLA" applies because you are looking at actual pixels and reacting to how many pixels are affected by the diffraction blur. If you are hoping to use the high pixel density in lieu of a longer FL lens, and will be viewing at 100% then both DoF and diffraction need to use the pixel size as their basis.
AJSJones wrote: Bruce n Philly wrotegdanmitchell wroteYet again (he drones on) the news is somewhere between neutral and good for you.
There is no downside.
DanThanx Dan, but edumacate me (as if I can't read!)
Go with me on this.....
You take a picture black on the left, white on the right and an infinity perfect line/transition between.
You have a 5D Mk II...... you crop a pic to 100%..... diffraction sets in at f/11.... You look at the pixels along the b/w line and there is some diffraction blurring. Let's say for arguments sake that the "transition" pixels are 10 pixels wide.
Now swap the body for a 5Ds... because you have more/density pixels, you now crop again down to 100%..... but you are now way deeper. The blurry zone covers more pixel, now 20 pioxels, than the other camera. More pixels are in the blur zone... therefore the need to open up a stop to get the same number of pixels in the blurr zone back to 10.
Remember, my objective is to crop a small part of the pic down to 100%
Peace
Bruce in PhillyI'd say that's a pretty good description of the scenario where the "DLA" applies because you are looking at actual pixels and reacting to how many pixels are affected by the diffraction blur. If you are hoping to use the high pixel density in lieu of a longer FL lens, and will be viewing at 100% then both DoF and diffraction need to use the pixel size as their basis.
I have no problem following that approach. Still I would say that if you are focal length limited and concerned about detail, you are barking up the wrong tree if you are concerned about diffraction, because increasing the pixel density is what really helps with getting more detail.
Your first error is in thinking that "diffraction sets in" at some aperture. It is always there — though its "size" varies with aperture (and format).
Your other error is in basing everything on 100% crops. On the high MP image you are looking at a smaller portion of the overall image — essentially "looking more closely" at a smaller area, this falsely convincing yourself that the diffraction at a given aperture is larger on the higher MP system.*
If you look at the same area of the full image (let's say 10% of its width), the amount of diffraction blue will be exactly the same in the two image shot on different cameras at the same aperture.
Your scenario does not demonstrate "more diffraction" on one system than the other. It demonstrates that blur gets bigger when you look closer... which has nothing to do with diffraction itself. ;-)
A potential advantage of the higher MP system is that if you have great lenses and are very careful you may be able to resolve a bit more detail on the higher MP system if you open up slightly from what you regarded as your optimum resolution aperture on the lower MP system. (But don't forget that what constitutes "best resolution" is not necessarily "highest lp/mm in the center of the frame.")
Dan
*Your goal of getting to 100% magnification on both systems is an interesting clinical exercise, but we are concerned here about the effect of aperture choice and photo site density on actual photographs — and those are virtually never displayed at so-called 100% magnification nor are they compared in the way you describe.
Bruce n Philly wrote: gdanmitchell wroteYet again (he drones on) the news is somewhere between neutral and good for you.
There is no downside.
DanThanx Dan, but edumacate me (as if I can't read!)
Go with me on this.....
You take a picture black on the left, white on the right and an infinity perfect line/transition between.
You have a 5D Mk II...... you crop a pic to 100%..... diffraction sets in at f/11.... You look at the pixels along the b/w line and there is some diffraction blurring. Let's say for arguments sake that the "transition" pixels are 10 pixels wide.
Now swap the body for a 5Ds... because you have more/density pixels, you now crop again down to 100%..... but you are now way deeper. The blurry zone covers more pixel, now 20 pioxels, than the other camera. More pixels are in the blur zone... therefore the need to open up a stop to get the same number of pixels in the blurr zone back to 10.
Remember, my objective is to crop a small part of the pic down to 100%
alundeb wrote: AJSJones wroteBruce n Philly wrotegdanmitchell wroteYet again (he drones on) the news is somewhere between neutral and good for you.
There is no downside.
DanThanx Dan, but edumacate me (as if I can't read!)
Go with me on this.....
You take a picture black on the left, white on the right and an infinity perfect line/transition between.
You have a 5D Mk II...... you crop a pic to 100%..... diffraction sets in at f/11.... You look at the pixels along the b/w line and there is some diffraction blurring. Let's say for arguments sake that the "transition" pixels are 10 pixels wide.
Now swap the body for a 5Ds... because you have more/density pixels, you now crop again down to 100%..... but you are now way deeper. The blurry zone covers more pixel, now 20 pioxels, than the other camera. More pixels are in the blur zone... therefore the need to open up a stop to get the same number of pixels in the blurr zone back to 10.
Remember, my objective is to crop a small part of the pic down to 100%
Peace
Bruce in PhillyI'd say that's a pretty good description of the scenario where the "DLA" applies because you are looking at actual pixels and reacting to how many pixels are affected by the diffraction blur. If you are hoping to use the high pixel density in lieu of a longer FL lens, and will be viewing at 100% then both DoF and diffraction need to use the pixel size as their basis.I have no problem following that approach. Still I would say that if you are focal length limited and concerned about detail, you are barking up the wrong tree if you are concerned about diffraction, because increasing the pixel density is what really helps with getting more detail.
Agreed. But now Bruce seems to be asking specifically about where he is FL limited and also pixel density limited (at least for the available lenses - unless he adapts the optically superb - possibly diffraction limited - FF supertele to a P&S density sensor, like you tested) so the next limitation, on how much/small detail can be captured and displayed at 100%, is diffraction. Then it becomes "how much diffraction blur is acceptable?" and that's where he will determine his "personal DLA" Pretty rarefied air up here, but that's what the diffraction brouhaha has always been about.
AJSJones wrote: alundeb wroteAJSJones wroteBruce n Philly wrotegdanmitchell wroteYet again (he drones on) the news is somewhere between neutral and good for you.
There is no downside.
DanThanx Dan, but edumacate me (as if I can't read!)
Go with me on this.....
You take a picture black on the left, white on the right and an infinity perfect line/transition between.
You have a 5D Mk II...... you crop a pic to 100%..... diffraction sets in at f/11.... You look at the pixels along the b/w line and there is some diffraction blurring. Let's say for arguments sake that the "transition" pixels are 10 pixels wide.
Now swap the body for a 5Ds... because you have more/density pixels, you now crop again down to 100%..... but you are now way deeper. The blurry zone covers more pixel, now 20 pioxels, than the other camera. More pixels are in the blur zone... therefore the need to open up a stop to get the same number of pixels in the blurr zone back to 10.
Remember, my objective is to crop a small part of the pic down to 100%
Peace
Bruce in PhillyI'd say that's a pretty good description of the scenario where the "DLA" applies because you are looking at actual pixels and reacting to how many pixels are affected by the diffraction blur. If you are hoping to use the high pixel density in lieu of a longer FL lens, and will be viewing at 100% then both DoF and diffraction need to use the pixel size as their basis.I have no problem following that approach. Still I would say that if you are focal length limited and concerned about detail, you are barking up the wrong tree if you are concerned about diffraction, because increasing the pixel density is what really helps with getting more detail.Agreed. But now Bruce seems to be asking specifically about where he is FL limited and also pixel density limited (at least for the available lenses - unless he adapts the optically superb - possibly diffraction limited - FF supertele to a P&S density sensor, like you tested) so the next limitation, on how much/small detail can be captured and displayed at 100%, is diffraction. Then it becomes "how much diffraction blur is acceptable?" and that's where he will determine his "personal DLA" Pretty rarefied air up here, but that's what the diffraction brouhaha has always been about.
Agreed again.
I just want to repeat myself, and say that there IS a diffraction limit on resolution, where it is no longer a question of acceptable levels of sharpening, but a hard limit on resolution. The Rayleigh criterion is a bit conservative, it is possible to get slightly above. For the 5DS pixel density, the hard limit is around f/13.
alundeb wrote: snapsy wroteWhat limits the resolution on the smaller sensor with the higher pixel density with that lens, diffraction or LP/mm resolving ability of that specific optic?Do we actually know, at the wider apertures? Isn't the sensor still the limiting factor at f/4 anyway?
Not sure we can assume that, esp for such a small sensor like the Q that requires a high LP/mm optic. But putting that aside, when I look at the Q images (bottom) I see evidence of diffraction starting @ f/8, based on the disappearance of the aliasing that appears at f/4 and f/5.6. I don't see that aliasing disappearing on the D800 image (top) until f/22. This would seem to support the notion that a diffraction impacts a higher-density sensor sooner in terms of aperture. Was the example meant to demonstrate otherwise?
snapsy wrote: alundeb wrotesnapsy wroteWhat limits the resolution on the smaller sensor with the higher pixel density with that lens, diffraction or LP/mm resolving ability of that specific optic?Do we actually know, at the wider apertures? Isn't the sensor still the limiting factor at f/4 anyway?Not sure we can assume that, esp for such a small sensor like the Q that requires a high LP/mm optic. But putting that aside, when I look at the Q images (bottom) I see evidence of diffraction starting @ f/8, based on the disappearance of the aliasing that appears at f/4 and f/5.6. I don't see that aliasing disappearing on the D800 image (top) until f/22. This would seem to support the notion that a diffraction impacts a higher-density sensor sooner in terms of aperture. Was the example meant to demonstrate otherwise?
It was not meant to demonstrate otherwise It was meant to provide a visual comparison instead of numbers. And to illustrate that the aperture where the size of the airy disc equals the pixel size, has nothing to do with any diffraction limit.
Monito wrote:
Before we go any further, remember that Depth of Field depends on seven factors: focal length, sensor size, distance to the subject, f/stop, print size, viewing distance, and visual acuity.
People often neglect print size and viewing distance in these discussions.
Viewing a monitor at 100% is like viewing very large prints (measured in feet) from always the same viewing distance. So when you increase the resolution of the camera (more pixels), you are simply making the virtual print bigger. This reduces the Depth of Field.
The lens sharpness also effects the DOF. Sharpness is related to the circle of confusion and a sharper lens has a smaller CoC and a greater DOF. I was amazed that my Digiron had greater DOF than my Mamiya lens but when you consider how much sharper the Rodie was and the CoC connection then it makes sense.
Here is a good read.
gdanmitchell wrote:
1. Diffraction is an optical thing, not something that is related to sensor resolution. Imagine taking a 12MP camera and a 50MP camera, putting the same lens on both, setting it to the same focal length and aperture, and making a pair of test exposures. Now make prints from both images at the same print size (whatever print size you wish). The images in the two prints will have exactly the same amount of diffraction. So, using a sensor with higher resolution does not increase the amount of diffraction blur at any f-stop.
Dan
+1 @ diffraction is a product of the optically projected image, not the capture media.
Monito wrote:
Before we go any further, remember that Depth of Field depends on seven factors: focal length, sensor size, distance to the subject, f/stop, print size, viewing distance, and visual acuity.
People often neglect print size and viewing distance in these discussions.
Viewing a monitor at 100% is like viewing very large prints (measured in feet) from always the same viewing distance. So when you increase the resolution of the camera (more pixels), you are simply making the virtual print bigger. This reduces the Depth of Field.
plateaulight wrote:
The lens sharpness also effects the DOF.
No, it does not.
Sharpness is related to the circle of confusion and a sharper lens has a smaller CoC and a greater DOF.
No, it is not.
I was amazed that my Digiron had greater DOF than my Mamiya lens...
Not for the same perspective, framing, aperture diameter, display size, viewing distance, and visual acuity it didn't.
...but when you consider how much sharper the Rodie was and the CoC connection then it makes sense.
There is no connection, whatsoever, between the lens resolution (or pixel count) and the CoC.
plateaulight wrote:
The lens sharpness also effects the DOF.
No
plateaulight wrote:
Sharpness is related to the circle of confusion
Yes
plateaulight wrote:
and a sharper lens has a smaller CoC
Yes, but only at the plane of focus.
plateaulight wrote:
and a greater DOF.
No. The smaller CoC at the plane of focus, which is where it is smaller, does not affect Depth of Field, because it is well inside the Depth of Field already. A sharper lens is sharper at the plane of focus.
Depth of field is defined by the region that is limited by the Just Noticeable Difference (JND) between what seems like a point and what seems like a blur disk (observed at the viewing distance with a given sized print/image). The JND blur disk at the edge of DoF is controlled by the aperture and distance to the lens. At the edge of depth of field the image thrown by the lens is already out of focus and a sharper lens does not make it more in focus there.
takowasa wrote: plateaulight wroteThe lens sharpness also effects the DOF.No, it does not.
Lens sharpness is a vague term, but it is well known that certain lens aberrations affect the depth of field. As an extreme example, we could consider a lens that is so soft that the viewer perceives nothing in the image as sharp. The DOF is then zero, whereas a 'sharp lens' would have given a DOF greater than 0.
plateaulight wrote:
The problem is that you are using formulas and ray tracing based on an IDEAL or perfect lens and not accounting for the intrinsic variable of different lens/sensor combinations. [...]
In practice the sharper lens approaches the "perfect" lens whereas the poorer optic does not fit into models well.
Good points and good discussion.
plateaulight wrote:
As the pixel size decreases so does the blur radius and you will get to a point that many optics will not meet even the minimum blur radius and have little DOF whereas a perfect lens will have a clearly defined and fixed point of infinite sharpness and an acceptable tightly defined DOF envelope that is considerably larger than the optic that can't even meet the minimum blur at the plane of focus.
That case applies only if you are examining the image at 100% closeup on the monitor. For the vast majority of displayed images this does not apply.
In the real world, the effect of general lens sharpness differences on DOF is so tiny as to be insignificant. Aperture (along with subjective parameters such as print size and viewing distance and more) will be the things to care about.
plateaulight wrote:
The lens sharpness also effects the DOF.
takowasa wrote:
No, it does not.
Toothwalker wrote:
Lens sharpness is a vague term, but it is well known that certain lens aberrations affect the depth of field. As an extreme example, we could consider a lens that is so soft that the viewer perceives nothing in the image as sharp. The DOF is then zero, whereas a 'sharp lens' would have given a DOF greater than 0.
Resolution is affected by lens aberrations and DOF (as well as diffraction, motion blur, camera shake, pixel count, etc). However, the DOF itself (the blur associated due to the focus being progressively further off as elements of the scene are further from the focal plane), is not affected by lens aberrations.
Uhh, all this discussion is making my head spin, and I didn't even read anything on the last page!
Technical points aside, diffraction is something you need to consider for yourself in your use cases, just shoot a number of images at various apertures and print the crops to see if you can notice the difference. More often than not, an increased depth of field will give a greater impression of sharpness than an image that's technically sharper.
How big do you print? how do you sharpen your images? what's you criteria for sharpness? can your print medium even display fine details?
I don't understand the race for maximum detail for the sake of it, people will only see your images in one of two ways, online as a small compressed jpeg, which any camera is decently capable of capturing, or as a print on quality paper, with print size being the point on which your expensive camera can stretch it's legs.
Counting pixels is a good thing to do if you intend to make a 2 x 1.5m large print that you can also put your nose up to and inspect the details... but most of the people I know that do so probably wouldn't consider a Canon DSLR as their first choice, even if it does have 50MP.
plateaulight wrote:
Well I am printing BIG and in the gallery have sold mostly 40x60 or larger so it really does matter to me.
I have to understand that most people are doing web rez or A3.
I met several dozen photographers in Palouse this spring and very few even did prints.
It all makes me wonder why so many people are chasing these ultra rez cameras.
the lengths I go to are extraordinary to get the max from a combo.
I'm not a photographer, and I suspect the same is true for some other buyers. My expectations are that a print be sharp enough at 10-12" viewing distance, regardless if the print is 12" or 48".
As well, the advantage of additional pixels is substantial when cropping from long tele images.
takowasa wrote:
Resolution is affected by lens aberrations and DOF (as well as diffraction, motion blur, camera shake, pixel count, etc). However, the DOF itself (the blur associated due to the focus being progressively further off as elements of the scene are further from the focal plane), is not affected by lens aberrations.
Which part of Dr. Nasse's document did you not understand?