takowasa wrote:
All that table did is relate the diameter of the Airy Disk to the pixel size. The only information that would tell us is that if we had a perfect (aberration free) lens, then when stopping down the lens to a point where the diameter of the Airy Disk exceeds one pixel (or, more generally, two pixels for a Bayer CFA), that we will be able to see the effects of diffraction begin to eat into resolution at 100% enlargement for the portions of the scene within the DOF.
AJSJones wrote:
There are no lenses mentioned in the table and I think it's pretty clear what the information is intended to represent (as described in the text on the sites) - some people use the extra pixels to make a larger print and don't want the sharpness of the print limited by diffraction and the aperture in the table tells them what that limit is. They can then struggle to control the other parameters to ensure that it is the limiting cause of unsharpness.
The fact of the matter is that diffraction no more limits a 5Ds at a given aperture than it limits a 5D3, For example, if the sharpest aperture of a lens is f/5.6 on a 5D3, then it will be f/5.6 on a 5Ds. As I demonstrated in my entry into this thread on the first page, the diffraction limited aperture of the Canon 50 / 1.4 on an 8 MP sensor and a 15 MP sensor were the same.
We are clearly not denying that there are other factors that limit sharpness in the final image - we have listed many of them. The table *only* purports to list the effect of diffraction from the aperture on the Airy disc in relation to pixel size and when it begins to limit the sharpness of the image the sensor can potentially record. It goes without saying, in this forum at least, that the lens properties, and a whole range of additional variables, will limit the actual sharpness recorded and printable. The table does not intend to address those other variables - the way your example with specific lenses does. The amount of diffraction does not change from one camera to another for a given lens and aperture, of course. But that's not the issue under discussion.
AJSJones wrote:
We are clearly not denying that there are other factors that limit sharpness in the final image - we have listed many of them. The table *only* purports to list the effect of diffraction from the aperture on the Airy disc in relation to pixel size and when it begins to limit the sharpness of the image the sensor can potentially record. It goes without saying, in this forum at least, that the lens properties, and a whole range of additional variables, will limit the actual sharpness recorded and printable. The table does not intend to address those other variables - the way your example with specific lenses does. The amount of diffraction does not change from one camera to another for a given lens and aperture, of course. But that's not the issue under discussion. ...Show more →
As a photographer, all you want to know is the resolution in the final photo, and thus must include the lens (along with other factors). However, if all you want to know about is diffraction and no other source of blur, then diffraction softening is at its least wide open and gets worse as you stop down. There is no magical point where diffraction suddenly reduces the resolution or suddenly becomes visible.
Now, so long as the diameter of the Airy Disk remains smaller than a pixel (or two pixels for a Bayer CFA), the effects of diffraction softening will be mostly lost in the blur of large pixels. But, in terms of diffraction only, yes, there is more blur at a more narrow aperture than a wider aperture. However, since you cannot separate the blur of diffraction from the blur of lens aberrations when looking at a photo, this information has no practical value to the photographer.
What is practical is at what aperture the blur due to diffraction exceeds the blur due to lens aberrations, and this point is known as the diffraction limited aperture, which, of course, is not only lens specific, but depends on where in the frame you are looking (the edges typically becoming diffraction limited a stop after the center). Pixel size does play a role, but it is a relatively small role, and, as demonstrated earlier, even a doubling in pixel count does not make a noticeable difference.
Using the diameter of the airy disc to describe anything related to "diffraction limited" is bogus from the beginning. There is nothing special that happens when the diameter of the airy disc equals the pixel pitch. Blur from diffraction is present at all apertures, and increases gradually, also past the so-called diffraction limit.
There is a limit to resolution because of diffraction, but that is when two airy discs are so close together that their peaks melt together and there is no contrast to be detected between them. The Rayleigh criterion for limiting resolution is defined as when the contrast between the peaks of two airy discs and the "valley" between them, is 9%.
On top of that, we are talking bayer sensors here, sampling colors at only 50 - 70% of the nominal pixel spacing.
If you are concerned about detail and apertures, the WORST thing you can do is to use a lower pixel density sensor and a wider aperture. That will give less system resolution and more aliasing.
The 5DS / R pixel density is optimal if your required DOF requires apertures around f/8 - f/16. At f/22 there is not much benefit over a 5D III to speak about, but it is not going to be worse either, of course. At apertures below f/8, the 5DS / R has too low pixel density and aliasing occurs.
AJSJones wrote:
We are clearly not denying that there are other factors that limit sharpness in the final image - we have listed many of them. The table *only* purports to list the effect of diffraction from the aperture on the Airy disc in relation to pixel size and when it begins to limit the sharpness of the image the sensor can potentially record. It goes without saying, in this forum at least, that the lens properties, and a whole range of additional variables, will limit the actual sharpness recorded and printable. The table does not intend to address those other variables - the way your example with specific lenses does. The amount of diffraction does not change from one camera to another for a given lens and aperture, of course. But that's not the issue under discussion. ...Show more →
Your post, which I am guessing is meant to "answer" the people (like myself) who are pointing out the misconceptions about higher photo site density and a greater diffraction problem, actually points out precisely why the who kerfuffle over diffraction and high MP sensors is largely nonsense.
You write that "we are clearly not denying that there are other factors that limit sharpness in the final image." Your reference to "final image" is utterly critical and the entire point. (Well, OK, not quite the entire point. More on that in a moment.) In fact, it is the final image that matters, whether that final image is a print or something you view on the screen. The "size of the airy disc" only has significance to photographers in the context of what it means to their photographs.
The second point, and a critical point is is, is that whatever you measure about diffraction, increasing sensor resolution never makes it worse in any way. There are only two possible outcomes when it comes to diffraction and photo site density. One, there is no difference. Two, the higher density sensor is produces a sharper image.
There is no third outcome where (as some imagine) the higher density sensor products "more diffraction" which creates some sort of new diffraction-caused problem in your photographs. Anyone who thinks that such a thing happens needs to accept that fact that they are barking up the wrong tree.
takowasa wrote: AJSJones wroteWe are clearly not denying that there are other factors that limit sharpness in the final image - we have listed many of them. The table *only* purports to list the effect of diffraction from the aperture on the Airy disc in relation to pixel size and when it begins to limit the sharpness of the image the sensor can potentially record. It goes without saying, in this forum at least, that the lens properties, and a whole range of additional variables, will limit the actual sharpness recorded and printable. The table does not intend to address those other variables - the way your example with specific lenses does. The amount of diffraction does not change from one camera to another for a given lens and aperture, of course. But that's not the issue under discussion.... However, if all you want to know about is diffraction and no other source of blur, then diffraction softening is at its least wide open and gets worse as you stop down. There is no magical point where diffraction suddenly reduces the resolution or suddenly becomes visible.
Now, so long as the diameter of the Airy Disk remains smaller than a pixel (or two pixels for a Bayer CFA), the effects of diffraction softening will be mostly lost in the blur of large pixels. But, in terms of diffraction only, yes, there is more blur at a more narrow aperture than a wider aperture. ...Show more →
We are agreed on everything (see the highlighted text in your response.) except, apparently, your distaste for the terminology. My entry into the thread was to indicate that what you called "an error" is only a difference in use of terminology by the folks who created the term in the tables.
*There are many variables that affect the ability of a sensor to record "sharpness" from an incoming image.
*Diffraction by the aperture is only one of them.
*When the aperture is small enough, the Airy disk becomes large enough to cause blur beyond the sensor's ability to record detail and begins to limit the detail that can be recorded.
*The table considers that issue in isolation.
No-one has said it is a "sudden" phenomenon or a hard limit and no-one has said it is the "only" factor - quite the contrary, the other variables have been listed ad nauseam and the sites which use the term are clear on what they mean. (It is conceivable, though, that not everyone reads the "fine print")
How valuable that information is is up to the individual photographer. It is in the same category of "utility" as, for example, knowing the dimension in mm of the circle of confusion when assessing the DoF.
You could start a movement to rename the parameter as something like "detail-limiting aperture caused (only) by diffraction" to distinguish it from "aperture where diffraction effects limit the most detail which can be captured more than the lens imperfections do". (aka the peak in the plot of resolution vs aperture as we have already discussed). Of course, the latter is the most practical number to remember in the field for each lens
(BTW I had the same distaste for the term "resolution" when it started being applied to the number of pixels in a sensor, rather than its original meaning related to the size of those details. However, the single word is now used in both contexts and there is generally no confusion as to its intended meaning and it is no longer regarded by most as "an error". There may be a parallel here)
I warned that the diffraction limited aperture numbers published by The Digital Picture and Cambridge Color were going to cause alarm way back in December or so on this forum, and so here we are. All the discussion here is fine and good, but the very fact an "innocent" photographer will stumble upon these sites, see these numbers posted and think "I can't use any lens on my 5Ds/5Ds-r past F 6.7" is still going to occur. Reacting in a black and white way to a number is very much part of human nature. Perhaps both of these sites need a set of knowledgeable people to persuade them to add in a very clear terms that stopping down past F 6.7 isn't going to make your 5Ds/r files blurry or unusable. And, the numbers posted on these sites DO suggest, despite the explanation here on the contrary, that increasing megapixel density=lowering the f stop number where diffraction becomes a concern. The Digital Picture table probably would be the biggest cause of alarm, since one does not need to "plug in format and sensor size values" into a calculator to see them.
I warned that the diffraction limited aperture numbers published by The Digital Picture and Cambridge Color were going to cause alarm way back in December or so on this forum, and so here we are. All the discussion here is fine and good, but the very fact an "innocent" photographer will stumble upon these sites, see these numbers posted and think "I can't use any lens on my 5Ds/5Ds-r past F 6.7" is still going to occur. Reacting in a black and white way to a number is very much part of human nature. Perhaps both of these sites need a set of knowledgeable people to persuade them to add in a very clear terms that stopping down past F 6.7 isn't going to make your 5Ds/r files blurry or unusable. And, the numbers posted on these sites DO suggest, despite the explanation here on the contrary, that increasing megapixel density=lowering the f stop number where diffraction becomes a concern. The Digital Picture table probably would be the biggest cause of alarm, since one does not need to "plug in format and sensor size values" into a calculator to see them....Show more →
If one reads Cambridge In Color they explain much of what's going on, and why a higher pixel density camera won't be any worse and all thos things.
The main gripe I have with them, is that they mention the Rayleigh criterion, and say that they use it, while they use the diameter of the airy disc, which is entirely different.
At f/16, as an example, the diameter of the airy disc is ca 20 um. That gives a "diffraction limit" of 25 lp/mm in the sensor plane, according to them. The rayleigh criterion, however, gives a resolution limit of 102 lp/mm at f/16. One of the best sources for this:
gdanmitchell wrote:
The second point, and a critical point is is, is that whatever you measure about diffraction, increasing sensor resolution never makes it worse in any way. There are only two possible outcomes when it comes to diffraction and photo site density. One, there is no difference. Two, the higher density sensor is produces a sharper image.
There is no third outcome where (as some imagine) the higher density sensor products "more diffraction" which creates some sort of new diffraction-caused problem in your photographs. Anyone who thinks that such a thing happens needs to accept that fact that they are barking up the wrong tree.
Dan...Show more →
I have been quite clear, I thought, on the intent of my posts. (My response to Talkowasa above should make that intent clearer)
Diffraction effects are nothing new and are independent of what captures the image (even Cassini knew about it and coined the term) . On one end, P&S cameras are limited in aperture for a reason and on the other I ruined the ability to make large prints from my 4x5 on occasion because I stopped down too far for a couple of particular scenes while striving for too much DoF - I mended my ways after that.
Also, bear in mind the two ends of the range of (usually unstated) incoming assumptions about increasing MP on a sensor: 1) I always print at a given szie and assume the other people do that too and 2) I always use the extra pixels to make bigger prints. The discussions of the effects of those extra MP/smaller pixels goes very different ways depending on those viewpoints.
To be clear, I've never said anything resembling "smaller pixels change diffraction" or "smaller pixels make it worse". Of course, the higher pixel density will render a more (i.e. never less) faithful record of the incoming image. The ability of a sensor to record a fine level of detail is determined by its pixel size, Nyquist, Bayer etc. If the incoming image has more detail than the sensor can handle, the sensor is a major factor in limiting recording image resolution (put an Otus on a D30). If the incoming image is very blurry, then the sensor is no longer the major limitation. For example, in OOF areas in a picture, increased resolution means little and more MP will not produce a perceptibly "clearer" image of the blur than that obtained by a sensor with less resolution.
In the scenario I detailed (overtly stating my assumptions), we make a large print at the size limit where the eye (let's say, at a fixed viewing distance) can only barely discern the pixel level details (a soft "limit") from an image captured with an aperture that had an Airy disk smaller than pixel size. Then, if we repeatedly replicate the scenario with everything identical except the taking aperture, at some point we will be able to discern a softening due to the change in aperture - no news there, we all know about diffraction, right? Diffraction softening will not be perceptible until the Airy disk reaches some size. The aperture at which we begin to detect the softening will be influenced by the pixel size (remember, the extra pixels mean the print is bigger to remain at the "pixel level" soft limit - for fine art landscape photographers, people are expected to examine in detail regardless of print size, so the constant viewing distance is realistic).
The smaller the pixel the sooner the Airy disk will exceed it in size and the softening will, under some circumstance such as described above, be perceptible. That's all the table indicates. That's all I've been saying. Not rocket surgery: At some aperture, the blur created by diffraction will be bigger than the smallest detail the sensor can resolve and it is one factor limiting detail capture and may be a limiting factor in printing. The contentious issue seemed to be what that aperture is calledThat's why I posted.
I warned that the diffraction limited aperture numbers published by The Digital Picture and Cambridge Color were going to cause alarm way back in December or so on this forum, and so here we are. All the discussion here is fine and good, but the very fact an "innocent" photographer will stumble upon these sites, see these numbers posted and think "I can't use any lens on my 5Ds/5Ds-r past F 6.7" is still going to occur. Reacting in a black and white way to a number is very much part of human nature. Perhaps both of these sites need a set of knowledgeable people to persuade them to add in a very clear terms that stopping down past F 6.7 isn't going to make your 5Ds/r files blurry or unusable. And, the numbers posted on these sites DO suggest, despite the explanation here on the contrary, that increasing megapixel density=lowering the f stop number where diffraction becomes a concern. The Digital Picture table probably would be the biggest cause of alarm, since one does not need to "plug in format and sensor size values" into a calculator to see them....Show more →
This anxiety has resurfaced every time there has been an increase in MP back to the early days when pixels got small enough* . The Digital Picture has a clear asterisk next to the column heading and footnote in the table. The footnote takes you to the following text. from http://www.the-digital-picture.com/Canon-Cameras/Diffraction-Limited-Aperture.aspx (If someone stumbles on the site and sees the table but does not read the text, caveat emptor)
The digital-Picture wrote
Diffraction Limited Aperture – DLA
You will find "DLA" referenced in many of the DSLR camera reviews on the site. DLA is the acronym for Diffraction Limited Aperture. This aperture value is the result of a mathematical formula that approximates the aperture where diffraction begins to visibly negatively affect image sharpness at the pixel level.
. Diffraction at the DLA is only barely visible when viewed at full-size (100%, 1 pixel = 1 pixel) on a monitor or when output to a very large print. As sensor pixel density increases, the narrowest aperture we can use to get perfectly pixel-sharp images gets wider .
. DLA does not mean that narrower apertures should not be used – it is simply the point where image sharpness begins to be compromised for increased DOF and longer exposures.
. And, higher resolution sensors generally continue to deliver more detail than lower resolution sensors at apertures narrower than the DLA – until the "Diffraction Cutoff Frequency" is reached. The progression from sharp the soft as the aperture narrows beyond DLA is not an abrupt one – and the change from immediately prior camera models to new models is usually not dramatic."
AJSJones wrote:
Not rocket surgery: At some aperture, the blur created by diffraction will be bigger than the smallest detail the sensor can resolve and it is one factor limiting detail capture and may be a limiting factor in printing. The contentious issue seemed to be what that aperture is calledThat's why I posted.
I'll agree that it isn't "rocket surgery." ;-)
I stand by everything else I wrote about the diffraction limited brouhaha.
The message is simple: Anyone who imagines that their higher MP cameras create some additional challenge related to diffraction blur that might degrade their images, negate advantages that accrue from higher sensor resolution, or are otherwise a problem in some way... is barking up the wrong tree.
Wow.... great stuff..... but.... I didn't read about 100% crops. What then?
I am not talking about comparing an equal crops that pull in an eye. I am talking about 100% crop of a 5D MkX vs a 100% crop of a 5DS. One produces an eye, the other a tear duct.
Why care about this inequality? Bird photography. If you do it, you know what I mean. You will try and crop down to 100% to pull in that rare feathered dinosaur. Let's assume your technique is perfect.
All things being equal and perfect technique, wouldn't 100% crops turn blurry sooner as you stop down your lens on a higher pixel count sensor? Therefore, you do need to care. Again, I am talking about 100% crops. No?
Bruce n Philly wrote:
Wow.... great stuff..... but.... I didn't read about 100% crops. What then?
I am not talking about comparing an equal crops that pull in an eye. I am talking about 100% crop of a 5D MkX vs a 100% crop of a 5DS. One produces an eye, the other a tear duct.
Why care about this inequality? Bird photography. If you do it, you know what I mean. You will try and crop down to 100% to pull in that rare feathered dinosaur. Let's assume your technique is perfect.
All things being equal and perfect technique, wouldn't 100% crops turn blurry sooner as you stop down your lens on a higher pixel count sensor? Therefore, you do need to care. Again, I am talking about 100% crops.
I understand what you mean, as long as you don't stop down beyond f/11 with the 5DS, I would let the aperture be dictated by DoF and shutter speed, not diffraction. Sharpening can recover most of the blurring effect.
AJSJones wrote: anscochrome wrote:
.
This anxiety has resurfaced every time there has been an increase in MP back to the early days when pixels got small enough* . The Digital Picture has a clear asterisk next to the column heading and footnote in the table. The footnote takes you to the following text. from http://www.the-digital-picture.com/Canon-Cameras/Diffraction-Limited-Aperture.aspx (If someone stumbles on the site and sees the table but does not read the text, caveat emptor)
The digital-Picture wrote
Diffraction Limited Aperture – DLA
You will find "DLA" referenced in many of the DSLR camera reviews on the site. DLA is the acronym for Diffraction Limited Aperture. This aperture value is the result of a mathematical formula that approximates the aperture where diffraction begins to visibly negatively affect image sharpness at the pixel level.
.
Clear asterisk or not, you should not assume that the average user of these sites that name these DLA are knowledgeable Fred Miranda users. People see a number-they see it is lower than their old camera-they panic. Further reading stops.
Perhaps it is best that they don't even publish these numbers, since it apparently has no influence as far as usable, real world results are concerned.
gdanmitchell wrote:
The message is simple: Anyone who imagines that their higher MP cameras create some additional challenge related to diffraction blur that might degrade their images, negate advantages that accrue from higher sensor resolution, or are otherwise a problem in some way... is barking up the wrong tree.
There is a bit of a perverse relationship between higher MP cameras, DOF, and diffraction, at least when wanting to utilize the full resolution benefit offered vs lower MP cameras. Higher MP means a smaller CoC, which translates into a lower perceptual DOF when utilizing the higher MP ability for larger prints. But higher MP means diffraction becomes observable at larger apertures, again when utilizing the higher MP to print larger. This reduces the envelope by which the photographer can maximize both resolution and DOF.
Before we go any further, remember that Depth of Field depends on seven factors: focal length, sensor size, distance to the subject, f/stop, print size, viewing distance, and visual acuity.
People often neglect print size and viewing distance in these discussions.
Viewing a monitor at 100% is like viewing very large prints (measured in feet) from always the same viewing distance. So when you increase the resolution of the camera (more pixels), you are simply making the virtual print bigger. This reduces the Depth of Field.
Monito wrote:
Before we go any further, remember that Depth of Field depends on seven factors: focal length, sensor size, distance to the subject, f/stop, print size, viewing distance, and visual acuity.
People often neglect print size and viewing distance in these discussions.
Viewing a monitor at 100% is like viewing very large prints (measured in feet) from always the same viewing distance. So when you increase the resolution of the camera (more pixels), you are simply making the virtual print bigger. This reduces the Depth of Field.
And Circle of Confusion, but I suppose that's sort of covered by visual acuity.
This is why I'm (probably) not going up to 50 meg. You can make very big prints at very high sharpness from 20-ish meg, if you don't need to print huge or crop a lot I see no real benefit and a lot of processing overhead, more care and better lenses needed etc.