fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 20155DS - Diffraction earlier at wider stop?

  
 
Bruce n Philly
Offline

p.1 #15DS - Diffraction earlier at wider stop?
Given the increased pixel density of the 5DS, wouldn't diffraction appear at an earlier f/stop that say other cameras?

This guy denotes this at the end of his blog. He is a PHD student in applied mathematics and a photographer. https://fstoppers.com/education/5ds-f11-and-confusing-circles-68177

Besides, possibly, earlier diffraction issue, are there other disadvantages to this high pixel density/count sensor?

Peace
Bruce in Philly
TravelThroughPictures.com
Jun 20, 2015 at 07:38 PM
dhachey
Offline
Details
p.1 #25DS - Diffraction earlier at wider stop?
He's correct, DLA is about f7 for this pixel size, but use what you must to get the shot.

Check this out: http://www.cambridgeincolour.com/tutorials/diffraction-photography.htm

Jun 20, 2015 at 07:55 PM
EB-1
Offline
Details
p.1 #35DS - Diffraction earlier at wider stop?
It's the same diffraction as when using a 20 MP Rebel or 7D series. What aperture do you use there with a fine lens, f/6.3 or 7.1 and stop down a bit more if you really need the DOF? It's nothing new, really.

EBH
Jun 20, 2015 at 07:58 PM
takowasa
Offline
Details
p.1 #45DS - Diffraction earlier at wider stop?
Diffraction softening is there right from wide open and increase as you stop down. Lens aberrations exist right from wide open and lessen as you stop down. The point where increasing diffraction outweighs lessening lens aberrations is called the "diffraction limited aperture" and usually lags a stop later in the edges than the center.

The diffraction limited aperture is largely independent of pixel size. Consider, for example, the 50 / 1.8 on an 8 MP sensor compared to a 15 MP sensor. Even doubling the pixel count is not enough to change the diffraction limited aperture.

Regardless, at the same aperture, the sensor with more pixels will *always* resolve more than the sensor with fewer pixels, all else equal. How much more depends on a great number of factors, but the maximum possible increase is the square root of the ratio of the pixel counts. For example, the 5Ds will resolve at most sqrt (50/22) = 51% more than the 5D3, where I use half the max possible as a back-of-the-note estimate for "usual" situations. The 5DsR may resolve better still due to its cancelled AA filter, but that violates the "all else equal" clause due to trading increased resolution for increased artifacts.

In other words, if you take a photo of a scene with the 5D3 and either of the 5Ds cameras, using the same lens and settings, the 5Ds will resolve more detail. Whether or not the additional detail is "significant" or not, however, is another matter all together and dependent on a great number of factors. But there is no need to fear stopping the 5Ds down more any more than there is to have stopped down the 5D3 -- the 5Ds will come out on top every time, or, at worst, be no worse off than the 5D3.
Jun 20, 2015 at 08:06 PM
trumpet_guy
Offline
Details
p.1 #55DS - Diffraction earlier at wider stop?
The extra pixels aren't a disadvantage. Resize your 5Ds image down to 5D3 size and it should look just as sharp.
Jun 20, 2015 at 11:51 PM
takowasa
Offline
Details
p.1 #65DS - Diffraction earlier at wider stop?
trumpet_guy wrote:
The extra pixels aren't a disadvantage. Resize your 5Ds image down to 5D3 size and it should look just as sharp.


Sharper, actually, although not as much sharper as upsampling the 5D3 photo to the same dimensions as the 5Ds photo.
Jun 20, 2015 at 11:55 PM
EB-1
Offline
Details
p.1 #75DS - Diffraction earlier at wider stop?
trumpet_guy wrote:
The extra pixels aren't a disadvantage. Resize your 5Ds image down to 5D3 size and it should look just as sharp.


More pixels can be a disadvantage if at least a good portion of the extra resolution is not utilized due to excessively small apertures. For example, the buffer and framing rate are worse, the noise is worse, files are larger, etc. on the 5Ds/R compared to the standard 5D III.

EBH
Jun 21, 2015 at 12:16 AM
EB-1
Offline
Details
p.1 #85DS - Diffraction earlier at wider stop?
trumpet_guy wrote:
The extra pixels aren't a disadvantage. Resize your 5Ds image down to 5D3 size and it should look just as sharp.


More pixels can be a disadvantage if at least a good portion of the extra resolution is not utilized due to excessively small apertures. For example, the buffer and framing rate are worse, the noise is worse, files are larger, etc. on the 5Ds/R compared to the standard 5D III.

EBH
Jun 21, 2015 at 12:16 AM
EB-1
Offline
Details
p.1 #95DS - Diffraction earlier at wider stop?
trumpet_guy wrote:
The extra pixels aren't a disadvantage. Resize your 5Ds image down to 5D3 size and it should look just as sharp.


More pixels can be a disadvantage if at least a good portion of the extra resolution is not utilized due to excessively small apertures. For example, the buffer and framing rate are worse, the noise is worse, files are larger, etc. on the 5Ds/R compared to the standard 5D III.

EBH
Jun 21, 2015 at 12:16 AM
EB-1
Offline
Details
p.1 #105DS - Diffraction earlier at wider stop?
trumpet_guy wrote:
The extra pixels aren't a disadvantage. Resize your 5Ds image down to 5D3 size and it should look just as sharp.


More pixels can be a disadvantage if at least a good portion of the extra resolution is not utilized due to excessively small apertures. For example, the buffer and framing rate are worse, the noise is worse, files are larger, etc. on the 5Ds/R compared to the standard 5D III.

EBH
Jun 21, 2015 at 12:16 AM
Ian.Dobinson
Offline
Details
p.1 #115DS - Diffraction earlier at wider stop?
EBH at some point your going to have to either get a new mouse or learn that you can delete ALL your double posts
Jun 21, 2015 at 03:21 AM
Kolor-Pikker
Offline
Details
p.1 #125DS - Diffraction earlier at wider stop?
Higher resolution always has benefits, remember that each pixel only stores information for one color, and you also raise the limit of nyquist frequency for all your lenses, meaning that all lenses that could potentially resolve above the 22MP of the 5D3 will be sharper on the 5DSR - even if you sample back down to 22MP.

Pixel-per-pixel, the 5DSR is of course worse than the 5D3, but when equalized to identical image size (such as a print), I think you'd be hard-pressed to tell the difference.

EB-1 wrote:
More pixels can be a disadvantage if at least a good portion of the extra resolution is not utilized due to excessively small apertures. For example, the buffer and framing rate are worse, the noise is worse, files are larger, etc. on the 5Ds/R compared to the standard 5D III.

EBH


It's up to you to know how to utilize the camera's capabilities, ultimately this camera is no replacement to the 5D3, and I suspect that people who buy it will be shooting it in a manner that optimizes resolution; after all, they paid $4000 for the privilege.


...I also want to point that the Cambridge site shouldn't be taken religiously, everything there is based on photographic theory, and the CoC of the sensor pixels is hardly representative of usable aperture. They define the CoC as the width of two pixels, but in practice details are almost never that fine and you won't notice softening at 100% magnification by at least one stop above their stated value. For instance, my camera is said to be diffraction limited at around f/9~10, but I can easily shoot at f/14 with no discernible diffraction, which I specifically tested for.
Jun 21, 2015 at 04:07 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.1 #135DS - Diffraction earlier at wider stop?
Bruce n Philly wrote:
Given the increased pixel density of the 5DS, wouldn't diffraction appear at an earlier f/stop that say other cameras?


The answer to your question is actually simple, but depending on how you word it things can end up skewing out of control very quickly.

In terms of overall image resolution, having more MP is never a disadvantage and it can be an advantage in some real situations.

There are two ways to think about it.

1. Diffraction is an optical thing, not something that is related to sensor resolution. Imagine taking a 12MP camera and a 50MP camera, putting the same lens on both, setting it to the same focal length and aperture, and making a pair of test exposures. Now make prints from both images at the same print size (whatever print size you wish). The images in the two prints will have exactly the same amount of diffraction. So, using a sensor with higher resolution does not increase the amount of diffraction blur at any f-stop.

2. If you are pushing the upper boundaries of large print size and you want to get even better overall image resolution and you are using excellent lenses and technique, in some cases you may be able to get even better resolution with the higher MP camera by using a slightly larger aperture (the "diffraction limited aperture") than that which was ideal in diffraction terms on the lower MP camera. The difference will be small but it will be an improvement over what was possible with the lower MP system.

In other words, the differences ranges (depending on how you look at it) from none to a slight potential improvement with the high MP system.

As to the mythology that "you must shoot at smaller apertures on higher MP systems in order to get sharp photos..." that is misleading. Basically, in situations where you might have made your aperture selection based solely on "sharpest aperture" in the past, you might now choose a slightly larger aperture than you used with a lower MP camera. In all the cases you will select your aperture using the same criteria you used before and you will be fine. (The definition of "fine" is more than I want to go into here, but it is a Good Thing.)

Dan

Edited on Jun 21, 2015 at 03:36 PM · View previous versions
Jun 21, 2015 at 08:13 AM
Kolor-Pikker
Offline
Details
p.1 #145DS - Diffraction earlier at wider stop?
One thing's for sure, the importance of using tilt-shift lenses and aligning the focal plane with the subject is increased, since one can't compensate with a smaller aperture anymore. Or maybe utilize focus stacking for those shots where tilting the field of focus wouldn't help. High resolution imaging comes with new problems.
Jun 21, 2015 at 08:32 AM
takowasa
Offline
Details
p.1 #155DS - Diffraction earlier at wider stop?
Sneakyracer wrote:
The Digital Picture posts the "DLA" (Diffraction Limited Aperture) in their camera reviews. Here is a table they made:


The table, of course, is in error. As I noted above, diffraction softening is there right from wide open and increase as you stop down. Lens aberrations exist right from wide open and lessen as you stop down. The point where increasing diffraction outweighs lessening lens aberrations is called the "diffraction limited aperture" and usually lags a stop later in the edges than the center. Thus, the diffraction limited aperture is a function of the lens and where in the frame you are looking, not the sensor size.

That said, the size of the Airy Disk (the disk over which a point source of light is spread, which is what results in diffraction softening) will be the same on all systems for the same DOF.
Jun 21, 2015 at 01:48 PM
RobDickinson
Offline
Details
p.1 #165DS - Diffraction earlier at wider stop?
Regardless of diffreaction limits if you need to stop down for DOF ( and cant tilt or stack) then stop down for DOF. You wont get a worse overall print with a 5dsr than with a 5d or whatever.
Jun 21, 2015 at 02:40 PM
howard
Offline
Details
p.1 #175DS - Diffraction earlier at wider stop?
gdanmitchell wrote:
Bruce n Philly wroteGiven the increased pixel density of the 5DS, wouldn't diffraction appear at an earlier f/stop that say other cameras?
The answer to your question is actually simple, but depending on how you word it thing can end up skewing out of control very quickly.

In terms of overall image resolution, having more MP is never a disadvantage and it can be an advantage in some real situations.

There are two ways to think about it.

1. Diffraction is an optical thing, not something that is related to sensor resolution. Imagine taking a 12MP camera and a 50MP camera, putting the same lens on both, setting it to the same focal length and aperture, and making a pair of test exposures.
...Show more →

+1

More pixel density does not CREATE more diffraction. You will see it more clearly at pixel level, but it does not degrade overall image quality.
Jun 21, 2015 at 02:43 PM
AJSJones
Offline
Details
p.1 #185DS - Diffraction earlier at wider stop?
takowasa wrote:
Sneakyracer wroteThe Digital Picture posts the "DLA" (Diffraction Limited Aperture) in their camera reviews. Here is a table they made:
The table, of course, is in error. As I noted above, diffraction softening is there right from wide open and increase as you stop down. Lens aberrations exist right from wide open and lessen as you stop down. The point where increasing diffraction outweighs lessening lens aberrations is called the "diffraction limited aperture" and usually lags a stop later in the edges than the center. Thus, the diffraction limited aperture is a function of the lens and where in the frame you are looking, not the sensor size.

That said, the size of the Airy Disk (the disk over which a
...Show more →

The error, of course, is in the definition Lens designers talk of "diffraction limted lenses" where the lens imperfections are below the limitation imposed by the laws of optics and diffraction of light. However, The Digital Picture and, to pick another good educational site, Cambridge in Colour, both define and discuss the DLA solely in terms of the effect of diffraction, not the combination of lens properties and diffraction combined. It is estimated by relating the size of the Airy disk to the size of the sensels (easily seen in the chart). At some point during the printing and viewing process the Airy disk from a certain aperture can exceed the size of the sharpest feature that the sensor can record (for the sake of argument, let's call that one pixel) and that the eye can perceive as "sharp" and "diffraction softening" will (in theory) be detectable (this would be where the CoC is the ~ size of a pixel and we have pixel-size limited DoF). If you are actually in a situation where your print allows you to resolve individual sensor pixels, then having an Airy disk bigger than that will become noticeable. That is the condition they calculate for and call DLA.* Of course, you may already have enough blur from a variety of sources where you cannot resolve those pixels (subject motion, camera motion, OOF, lens imperfections etc) so whether you notice the extra softening due to diffraction will vary. Both sites discuss the caveats about when this might be seen and the gradual nature of its impact. It's quite rare for people to get to the situation I described (requiring good lenses, good technique, large print and/or closeviewing etc), so it is often the case that stopping down (quite a bit) further will not result in detectable extra softening.

*It's a lot easier to describe and quantify than the "lens imperfection and diffraction limit balanced optimal aperture" which is what is typically seen as the peak in a resolution vs aperture plot, which is what I think you mean when you say "diffraction limited aperture" and obviously varies from lens to lens - different terminology
Jun 21, 2015 at 03:32 PM
takowasa
Offline
Details
p.1 #195DS - Diffraction earlier at wider stop?
Sneakyracer wrote:
The Digital Picture posts the "DLA" (Diffraction Limited Aperture) in their camera reviews. Here is a table they made:


takowasa wrote:
The table, of course, is in error. As I noted above, diffraction softening is there right from wide open and increase as you stop down. Lens aberrations exist right from wide open and lessen as you stop down. The point where increasing diffraction outweighs lessening lens aberrations is called the "diffraction limited aperture" and usually lags a stop later in the edges than the center. Thus, the diffraction limited aperture is a function of the lens and where in the frame you are looking, not the sensor size.

That said, the size of the Airy Disk (the disk over which a
...Show more →

AJSJones wrote:
The error, of course, is in the definition Lens designers talk of "diffraction limted lenses" where the lens imperfections are below the limitation imposed by the laws of optics and diffraction of light. However, The Digital Picture and, to pick another good educational site, Cambridge in Colour, both define and discuss the DLA solely in terms of the effect of diffraction, not the combination of lens properties and diffraction combined. It is estimated by relating the size of the Airy disk to the size of the sensels (easily seen in the chart). At some point during the printing and viewing
...Show more →

All that table did is relate the diameter of the Airy Disk to the pixel size. The only information that would tell us is that if we had a perfect (aberration free) lens, then when stopping down the lens to a point where the diameter of the Airy Disk exceeds one pixel (or, more generally, two pixels for a Bayer CFA), that we will be able to see the effects of diffraction begin to eat into resolution at 100% enlargement for the portions of the scene within the DOF.

*It's a lot easier to describe and quantify than the "lens imperfection and diffraction limit balanced optimal aperture" which is what is typically seen as the peak in a resolution vs aperture plot, which is what I think you mean when you say "diffraction limited aperture" and obviously varies from lens to lens - different terminology

To use the term "diffraction limited" to apply to a situation when the resolution is not diffraction limited at all, but aberration limited, because the lens has been ignored, is not the best use of terminology. In fact, if we were to take that line of thought, all lenses would be "diffraction limited" right from wide open. The reason being that the Airy Disk is not a hard limit of the area over which light is spread, but simply the first ring of an infinite set of concentric rings. Granted, 88% of the light is contained in that first ring, but 12% is not, so wider apertures in an aberration free lens will have a smaller spread of light than more narrow apertures.

Regardless, the important thing when discussing diffraction in the context of photography, is to relate the effects of diffraction to the visual properties of the photo. To that end, we need to consider both the lens aberrations when discussing the diffraction limited aperture, and we must also include DOF in terms of the overall sharpness of the photo. For example, while f/16 may result in noticeable diffraction softening for the portions of the scene within the DOF for a large print, that may well be preferable to shooting at a diffraction limited aperture of, say, f/5.6 at the cost of having more of the photo outside the DOF.

As impairments to IQ go, however, diffraction is one of the least except for macro photography, where techniques such as focus stacking become serious considerations (although for landscape photos that require a DOF from inches away to infinity will also benefit from focus stacking).

Jun 21, 2015 at 06:48 PM
AJSJones
Offline
Details
p.1 #205DS - Diffraction earlier at wider stop?
takowasa wrote:
All that table did is relate the diameter of the Airy Disk to the pixel size. The only information that would tell us is that if we had a perfect (aberration free) lens, then when stopping down the lens to a point where the diameter of the Airy Disk exceeds one pixel (or, more generally, two pixels for a Bayer CFA), that we will be able to see the effects of diffraction begin to eat into resolution at 100% enlargement for the portions of the scene within the DOF.
There are no lenses mentioned in the table and I think it's pretty clear what the information is intended to represent (as described in the text on the sites) - some people use the extra pixels to make a larger print and don't want the sharpness of the print limited by diffraction and the aperture in the table tells them what that limit is. They can then struggle to control the other parameters to ensure that it is the limiting cause of unsharpness.
Jun 21, 2015 at 08:30 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister