ben egbert wrote:
I have had similar thoughts but have not sold my 17TSE yet. The big advantage for me is AF, I have a less than 100% focus hit rate with the 17TSE in landscape use. But I have noticed, the 17TSE has better CA than the 11-24, otherwise I have a hard time seeing any sharpness difference, other than the 11-24 has a near 100% hit rate for focus compared to the 17TSe which is mush less for me. By the way, both need to be stopped down to f11 and focused off center to get well focused edges.
I have grown to hate chasing down all the little lens flares the TS-E 17mm produces from every point light source. They're typically small and generally easy to clean up. But, when doing some interior architecture shoots and having to clean up a dozen or so flares in each of a dozen photos I start to get very annoyed. The 11-24mm is remarkably flare resistant and requires minimal clean-up.
Thus far I have made no special efforts towards focusing the 11-24mm and the edges have seemed impressively sharp to me. But, my standards may be too low. I focus via Live View zoomed in 16x and don't use AF except for casual walk-around photography.