EB-1 wrote:
snapsy wrote
He's only had the camera a few days but does make some initial observations in the article about it:
* Better grip than D810
* 40mm f/2.8 STM performs well on it
* AF more customizable and more precise than D810
* VF not good for MF
* DR better than expect but short of the D810EB-1 wrote
Really? It's 2015 not 1975. Canon has only a handful of MF lenses for good reason. The 5D as other EOS series is an AF camera. Why would Canon design new bodies oriented to manual focus as was popular in the 19th-20th centuries?
However, if the AF is not up to par that's a different issue that needs to be addressed.
EBHsnapsy wrote
Because even the best PDAF system available today (5DM3/1DX) doesn't have the precision needed to produce peak MTF focus movement on a consistent basis. For example the 5DM3 has the best PDAF precision I've ever used yet if you lookup Roger C's AF consistency tests you'll see a non-trivial spread of measured MTFs across multiple AF cycles. And that's at only 22MP. Unless the 5DS has made a considerable leap in precision that means it will require even more care in focusing to produce maximum resolution. That's what I'm concerned about. Perhaps the 5Ds/R should have received a new AF module, but that would be the 5D IV and later to market. I think this body needs the lenses set to f/7-8 for best compromise of IQ and not too much diffraction. I never shoot wider than f/4, so I hope the AF is good enough. I expected more AF complaints already, but we'll see. MF is just too unproductive for my limited time on location. Although I focus tracked the running species in the 70s-80s manually, I'm too old for that hassle now.
EBH
Having shot the camera now at a range of apertures, your concern about limiting to f/7-8 is overblown. I got very good results at f/11 and fine results at f/16 in a recent day of landscape shooting. If I'm shooting a subject where depth of field or exposure issues do not compel me to do otherwise, I'll likely shoot at f/8. If I need to shoot at a different aperture I will, and the results are fine.
Maybe instead of guessing how the AF might work, it would be a good idea to wait for some actual evidence.
Dan