snapsy wrote:
He's only had the camera a few days but does make some initial observations in the article about it:
* VF not good for MF
About this he wrote (in total, as far as I can see): "Manual focus is a disaster on both cameras; the finders are completely useless and we’ve got to resort to live view for anything critical."
That is one strange comment.
To me it is kind of like complaining that the film advance lever is missing from your DSLR.
On one hand, if he is referring to manual focus through the viewfinder — as we used to do back in the days of split prisms and so forth — I guess he has a point, one that is true of essentially all modern DSLR cameras. These cameras are not designed for manual focus, viewfinder shooting. There is good reason for this. Modern AF systems generally provide more accuracy and more speed than manually focusing through the viewfinder. For the most part, the best reason I can think of for wanting to look through the viewfinder, turn off AF, and manually focus would be that you did it that way back in the old days. (If that is your thing... DSLRs are probably not your best tool, anyway.)
On the other hand, if he refers to the range of ways in which these modern cameras implement manual focus, the "disaster" reference is nonsense. On the tripod, using live view and manually focusing, the experience is far more accurate and far more flexible that what we had available to us on older manually focusing SLR cameras. Yes, I used to use them. Let's review:
On those older cameras we did have focusing assistance from split prisms and the like in the viewfinder. They helped, and we could find focus relatively quickly that way — far faster than simply trying to manually focus on ground glass in the small SLR viewfinder. However, the result was generally far less accurate than today's AF systems and it was also a lot slower. Good AF is virtually instantaneous, but even skillful manual focusers took some time and a bit of rocking the focus ring back and forth.
But beyond that, once we got into more critical focus issues, the old manual system was far worse. If you wanted to check the effect of aperture on DOF you could (as you still can) press a DOF preview button. The viewfinder became very dark, making it harder to see the already small and somewhat dim image, and our ability to accurately gauge DOF was quite limited. However, with live view and exposure simulation, even in very dim light (including multiple stop ND filters!) we can hit the DOF preview button and still see a bright image of the scene... and we can zoom in to 16X (on the 5Ds) magnification and scroll around the screen to carefully inspect any element of the scene.
I've used both systems and I can tell you with absolute certainty that what we have today is most certainly nothing like a "disaster," and it is certainly much better and more flexible than what we had in the "good old days" of manually focusing on ground glass.
Dan