fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Does M4/3 have a viable future?

  
 
johnvanr
Online
Details
p.2 #1Does M4/3 have a viable future?
sflxn wrote:
at all the m43 fans saying APS-C is getting squeezed. It's ironic since m43 is losing marketshare faster than Canon and Nikon. Unfortunately for them, they are so wrong. APS-C is the single biggest interchangeable lens mount there is. Yes, Sony is not currently paying much attention to their APS-C lenses, but it hasn't had an effect on sales. In fact, that also holds true for Canon and Nikon, whose APS-C lineup (each) still dwarfs the mirrorless market. Even Sony's APS-C mirrorless is bigger than all of m43.

Having said that, I don't think either m43 nor APS-C have great
...Show more →

You might be right overall, but as a MFT user, I can say you're wriong about just everything you assume about my photographic needs. I think you're forgetting about the user experience when you think phones or a RX100 are comparable to MFT.
Jun 15, 2015 at 07:33 AM
twelveish
Offline
Details
p.2 #2Does M4/3 have a viable future?
Worth remembering, and I know this point always comes up, is that we here are a tiny minority. Most people/consumers don't buy sensor sizes, they buy cameras. I'd wager a lot of m4/3 cameras are being sold on the promise that it will give you photos as nice as "that other bulky" camera, as pointed out by the sales person. They see a smaller camera, a couple of much smaller lenses, and coupled with brief info like imagined above, I'm sure for most people, that's all the info they need to make a purchase.

I don't use m4/3 myself but like tobicus said, people like options. Don't over-analyse it; a smaller system for travel will always make sense to most people not content with using the camera on their phone alone.

At the same time, APS-C is too established to go away any time soon. Too many heavily invested players. Again, a lot of people buy cameras/camera systems with little regard to the sensor inside. Brand recognition and some reassuring words from the sales person matter so much more, IMO. Also, being in the middle of two popular options, it provides a next-in-line alternative to two other product categories. Anyone with knowledge in consumer marketing will tell you about the critical importance of a middle option.

Personally, I am currently shooting with Canon FF as my workhorse and a Fujifilm X for more creative use. I chose neither primarily for sensor size, especially the Fuji. I'd follow them to m4/3 or FF alike, as long as they stay strong in the areas I chose them for.

Edit: The discussion regarding the shape of this or that company or smartphone camera use is, imo, a different type of speculation altogether.
Jun 15, 2015 at 07:34 AM
kwalsh
Offline
Details
p.2 #3Does M4/3 have a viable future?
twelveish wrote:
I'd wager a lot of m4/3 cameras are being sold on the promise that it will give you photos as nice as "that other bulky" camera, as pointed out by the sales person.


There are sales people that can point at a m4/3 camera in the US That's the weird thing about m43 in the US, it is impossible to find except online. Really the system should have no sales at all in the US given how it is marketed (as in not marketed or available in retail at all).

Certainly APS-C as a whole is here to stay. The larger question though is APS-C mirrorless. Canikon refuse to make any serious effort in APS-C mirrorless. Sony never developed much of a APS-C mirrorless system and appears to have moved on to FF. Samsung an also ran in the market even if they've got some innovative cameras. Really Fuji is the only one making a committed push for APS-C mirrorless but I wonder about their market being to small a niche.

The real question for m43 is will Panasonic and Olympus continue to accept losses in their camera divisions, neither have been profitable in forever. That isn't a problem unique to those two companies though, but it seems worse with them than Sony for sure.
Jun 15, 2015 at 07:55 AM
twelveish
Offline
Details
p.2 #4Does M4/3 have a viable future?
kwalsh wrote:
twelveish wroteI'd wager a lot of m4/3 cameras are being sold on the promise that it will give you photos as nice as "that other bulky" camera, as pointed out by the sales person.
There are sales people that can point at a m4/3 camera in the US That's the weird thing about m43 in the US, it is impossible to find except online.


Interesting, I didn't know that. However, from what I understand, m4/3 is doing very well in many parts of Asia for example. And it takes more than low sales in the US to make a format extinct.

Jun 15, 2015 at 08:01 AM
howard
Offline
Details
p.2 #5Does M4/3 have a viable future?
rattymouse wrote:
howard wroteOlympus as a company is not in good shape at all.
Factually incorrect. Olympus as a company is doing very well. They are the industry leader in medical imaging. 80% of their business is in this field. Their share price has gone up almost 1000 yen in the past 12 months.

http://www.olympus-global.com/en/ir/summary/segment/5year/index.jsp


I stand corrected, and thanks for the info.

A few yeas back Olympus had a huge restatement and nearly got their stock delisted, which etched into my mind:
http://www.digitaltrends.com/photography/olympus-restates-finances-in-bid-to-keep-stock-listed/

Plus, did you look at the (negative) earning from their imaging division?

But we are off topic now; I wish these companies well and keep producing top-quality products.
Jun 15, 2015 at 08:18 AM
rattymouse
Offline
Details
p.2 #6Does M4/3 have a viable future?
howard wrote:
rattymouse wrote
howard wroteOlympus as a company is not in good shape at all.
Factually incorrect. Olympus as a company is doing very well. They are the industry leader in medical imaging. 80% of their business is in this field. Their share price has gone up almost 1000 yen in the past 12 months.

http://www.olympus-global.com/en/ir/summary/segment/5year/index.jsp
I stand corrected, and thanks for the info.

A few yeas back Olympus had a huge restatement and nearly got their stock delisted, which etched into my mind:
http://www.digitaltrends.com/photography/olympus-restates-finances-in-bid-to-keep-stock-listed/

Plus, did you look at the (negative) earning from their imaging division?

But we are off topic now; I wish these companies well and keep producing top-quality products.


Yes, Olympus is losing a lot of cash making cameras. All mirrorless companies are except for Sony, who might be eeking out a profit.

Olympus' medical division is what got them through the huge accounting scandal of several years ago.

Jun 15, 2015 at 08:30 AM
darrellc
Offline
Details
p.2 #7Does M4/3 have a viable future?
I have FF and an extensive m4/3 lineup. I am divesting m4/3 partially to focus on where it excels for me - small kit with great user experience and sufficient IQ, and tele where I rarely shoot and will not carry a big 70-200 FF zoom or any longer tele primes for my occasional use.

The divestiture is driven by Sony FF stepping up with video performance (my GH4 will soon be sold), a lens lineup that now has stellar lenses at the focal lengths I want, with some very compact options if I include some of the manual focus and legacy glass (which I am fine with).

I never saw the point in aps-c in a Canon Nikon Sony world. I don't shoot birds or wildlife and am not budget constrained. Fuji is interesting but that has nothing to do with sensor size.

M4/3 was historically the sweet spot for me in the balance between size and IQ and system completeness. Sony is shifting the balance but I'll be keeping a GM5 with the small primes and small 35-100 zoom and the bigger Pany 2.8 zooms and a couple other lenses to use with the GM5.

Edited on Jun 15, 2015 at 11:50 AM · View previous versions
Jun 15, 2015 at 09:59 AM
kwalsh
Offline
Details
p.2 #8Does M4/3 have a viable future?
twelveish wrote:
kwalsh wrote
twelveish wroteI'd wager a lot of m4/3 cameras are being sold on the promise that it will give you photos as nice as "that other bulky" camera, as pointed out by the sales person.
There are sales people that can point at a m4/3 camera in the US That's the weird thing about m43 in the US, it is impossible to find except online.
Interesting, I didn't know that. However, from what I understand, m4/3 is doing very well in many parts of Asia for example. And it takes more than low sales in the US to make a format extinct.



I think m43 is doing quite well in Europe as well. But certainly Asia, and especially Japan is where it is doing the best and where the gained a lot of market share early on. It is just so odd that they don't even try here in the US. Or perhaps they would do poorly here even if they did try so they don't bother trying! Anyway, the US still seems to be a DLSR by default kind of market as far as bricks and mortar retail goes - though you do see the Sony APS-C at places like Best Buy.

Jun 15, 2015 at 09:59 AM
kwalsh
Offline
Details
p.2 #9Does M4/3 have a viable future?
darrellc wrote:
M4/3 was historically the sweet spot for me in the balance between size and IQ and system completeness. Sony is shifting the balance but I'll be keeping a GM5 with the small primes and small 35-100 zoom and the bigger Pany 2.8 zooms and a couple other lenses to use with the GM5.


The GM1/5 paired with some of the nicer tiny primes is really a pretty amazing kit for out and about with our daughter - love it with the 15/1.7 especially. And the GM1/5 paired with the surprisingly good 12-32 and 35-100 is a bang up hiking kit that can still do a great job tripod mounted for twilight landscapes. None of the other mirrorless systems have anything like the wee little GM1/5 nor the super small but high quality primes to go with it.

I'm seriously watching the A7RII for a landscape kit though. I've been very happy with m43 for landscape for a number of years now compared with the Canon APS-C I came from. I was hoping the E-M5II 40MP mode with something like the 12-40 would stave off FF but user reports from people trying it out for landscape work have made it seem a bit too fussy and unreliable for field work. The A7RII seems to have fixed everything that concerned me about the A7R and so why wallet is getting very nervous Will still keep m43 for all the kid photography - it is the killer system for kids I feel as the single shot AF is wicked fast and accurate not to mention way more functional with face/eye detect than a DLSR PDAF system.

I think I'll end up m43 + A7 by the end of the year. No space for APS-C for me...
Jun 15, 2015 at 10:08 AM
KaaX
Offline
Details
p.2 #10Does M4/3 have a viable future?
I, like many other people, run a FF system and a m4/3 system. I decided to bypass APS-C as being an unsatisfying compromise.

Size (with good lenses!) is still a crucial advantage is certain areas -- e.g. for a camera to carry with you at all times or to attach to a drone.

m4/3 will never replace FF for things like large prints of fine-detail landscapes, but for something like street shooting it's perfectly fine already.

Jun 15, 2015 at 11:28 AM
bjornthun
Offline
Details
p.2 #11Does M4/3 have a viable future?
Kwalsh: I can verify that the E-M5 II high res mode is suited for studio and still life. An advantage of the high res mode is that you completely svoid Bayer srtifacts for fine details and fabrics.

Curently I have a combination of Sony "full frame" mirrorless and m43. In some cases m43 can't be beaten for size.

Compare size and weight of the three Olympus 7-14/2.8, 12-40/2.8 and 40-150/2.8 to the Sony FE lenses 16-35/4, 24-70/4 and the 70-200/4 and you will see that they are pretty close. As far as zooms go, I'm not sure if m43 has an advantage, but for prime lenses m43 is still ahead when low weight is needed. I have also tried to compare Fuji X vs. Sony E mount lenses and cameras, and I find the difference not to be that great, in terms of size and weight. So for me Sony and m43 best compliment each other, as they are sufficiently different from one another.
Jun 15, 2015 at 12:25 PM
curious80
Offline
Details
p.2 #12Does M4/3 have a viable future?
Paul Mo wrote:
I have never seriously considered M4/3 - it's just too small. As soon as the light drops those small sensors become challenged. Nice idea though, just not for me.
....


Look at the following low light comparison from dpreview (E-PL5 against 7D, 7DII, A6000) and see what you think:

http://www.dpreview.com/reviews/image-comparison?attr18=lowlight&attr13_0=canon_eos7d&attr13_1=oly_epl5&attr13_2=canon_eos7dii&attr13_3=sony_a6000&attr15_0=raw&attr15_1=raw&attr15_2=raw&attr15_3=raw&attr16_0=1600&attr16_1=1600&attr16_2=1600&attr16_3=1600&normalization=compare&widget=1&x=-0.8918214619804892&y=0.18625999000998994

In this comparison the E-PL5 is clearly better than the 7D (I), and about the same as A6000 (which is actually a surprise for me).
Jun 15, 2015 at 02:01 PM
bobbytan
Offline
Details
p.2 #13Does M4/3 have a viable future?
curious80 wrote:
Paul Mo wroteI have never seriously considered M4/3 - it's just too small. As soon as the light drops those small sensors become challenged. Nice idea though, just not for me.
....
Look at the following low light comparison from dpreview (E-PL5 against 7D, 7DII, A6000) and see what you think:

http://www.dpreview.com/reviews/image-comparison?attr18=lowlight&attr13_0=canon_eos7d&attr13_1=oly_epl5&attr13_2=canon_eos7dii&attr13_3=sony_a6000&attr15_0=raw&attr15_1=raw&attr15_2=raw&attr15_3=raw&attr16_0=1600&attr16_1=1600&attr16_2=1600&attr16_3=1600&normalization=compare&widget=1&x=-0.8918214619804892&y=0.18625999000998994

In this comparison the E-PL5 is clearly better than the 7D (I), and about the same as A6000 (which is actually a surprise for me).


I think the Olympus RAW files are more malleable than the Sony files, so you can do a lot of tweaking in LR or PS. Also, I have found that the color balance on the A7 II is all over the place - sometimes it's on the cool side and sometimes it's on the warm side. The AWB on the Olympus is generally very consistent and reliable.

Check out these 2 sets of images - the recorded settings/exposure and time captured are exactly the same - meaning the images were shot only seconds apart of each other.





















Jun 15, 2015 at 02:40 PM
curious80
Offline
Details
p.2 #14Does M4/3 have a viable future?
bobbytan wrote:
curious80 wrote
Paul Mo wroteI have never seriously considered M4/3 - it's just too small. As soon as the light drops those small sensors become challenged. Nice idea though, just not for me.
....
Look at the following low light comparison from dpreview (E-PL5 against 7D, 7DII, A6000) and see what you think:

http://www.dpreview.com/reviews/image-comparison?attr18=lowlight&attr13_0=canon_eos7d&attr13_1=oly_epl5&attr13_2=canon_eos7dii&attr13_3=sony_a6000&attr15_0=raw&attr15_1=raw&attr15_2=raw&attr15_3=raw&attr16_0=1600&attr16_1=1600&attr16_2=1600&attr16_3=1600&normalization=compare&widget=1&x=-0.8918214619804892&y=0.18625999000998994

In this comparison the E-PL5 is clearly better than the 7D (I), and about the same as A6000 (which is actually a surprise for me).
I think the Olympus RAW files are more malleable than the Sony files, so you can do a lot of tweaking in LR or PS. Also, I have found that the color balance on the A7 II is all over the place - sometimes it's on the cool side and sometimes it's on the warm side. The AWB on the Olympus is generally very consistent and reliable.

Check out these 2 sets of images - the recorded settings/exposure and time captured are exactly the same - meaning the images were shot only seconds apart of each other.

I have certainly not been as happy with the performance of my A6000 in low light high ISO situations as I was expecting given the reputation of the sensor. Also in terms of color and overall tonal rendition in low light I definitely preferred my lowly EOS-M over the A6000. I wasn't a fan of my previous Sony RX100 in these conditions either. On the other hand I had no such complaints in my Sony alpha days with A580 + minolta glass.
Jun 15, 2015 at 03:40 PM
kwalsh
Offline
Details
p.2 #15Does M4/3 have a viable future?
bjornthun wrote:
Kwalsh: I can verify that the E-M5 II high res mode is suited for studio and still life. An advantage of the high res mode is that you completely svoid Bayer srtifacts for fine details and fabrics.


Yeah, I've definitely seen it works great for studio/still life. And that's exactly what Olympus said, they never claimed it would do well at landscape. But a few hopefuls like myself thought maybe with careful technique it would serve for landscape. That is probably still true, but having talked with people who have tried they found it rather difficult to get consistent results in the field. I'll likely still pick up a E-M5II in the coming year as my at home camera for shooting family stuff.


Curently I have a combination of Sony "full frame" mirrorless and m43. In some cases m43 can't be beaten for size.

Compare size and weight of the three Olympus 7-14/2.8, 12-40/2.8 and 40-150/2.8 to the Sony FE lenses 16-35/4, 24-70/4 and the 70-200/4 and you will see that they are pretty close. As far as zooms go, I'm not sure if m43 has an advantage, but for prime lenses m43 is still ahead when low weight is needed. I have also tried to compare Fuji X vs. Sony E mount lenses and cameras, and I find the difference not to be
...Show more →

Yes, for the "quality" zooms the Sony FE vs. Olympus Pro is not that big a difference. One of the reasons I'm considering A7RII for my dedicated landscape setup while keeping m43 for family shots and day hikes.

Thanks for sharing your experience with a Sony FF + m43 kit! I'm seriously considering it...
Jun 15, 2015 at 07:33 PM
Massimo Foti
Offline
Details
p.2 #16Does M4/3 have a viable future?
KaaX wrote:
I, like many other people, run a FF system and a m4/3 system. I decided to bypass APS-C as being an unsatisfying compromise.

Same for me. Still I can see that if I had more budget constrains I could consider APS-C, as my only system.

Jun 15, 2015 at 09:48 PM
cputeq
Offline
Details
p.2 #17Does M4/3 have a viable future?
howard wrote:
. Sure, they are still larger and heavier than comparable M4/3 counterparts, but then again they have larger sensors.


Therein lies the flaw in your argument. m43 shooters have obviously valued size and weight more then the size of the sensor.

In other words, let me take your argument to its next logical step -- Why don't we shoot medium format? Sure they are larger and heavier than FF, but then again they have larger sensors

For me, quite frankly APS-C just isn't enough of a size / weight savings to shoot it over mirrorless FF. Not that I think APS-C is a bad system, it's pretty good, but I still prefer m43



Jun 15, 2015 at 11:10 PM
Paul Mo
Offline
Details
p.2 #18Does M4/3 have a viable future?
Many of us are still waiting Nikon, Canon and Fuji to join Sony in building compact fullframe cameras - they are taking their time about it. From what I know Fuji could more or less drop a fullframe sensor into existing bodies.

Meaning, excuses aside, they could release powerful fullframe cameras in smaller bodies which could come close to some M4/3 in size.
Jun 16, 2015 at 12:47 AM
balga
Offline
Details
p.2 #19Does M4/3 have a viable future?
If you like to use long zooms, i.e. when travelling, then m43 is probably the best option, although for primes and for low light situation nothing can beat the a7 series.
However, the 40-150/2.8 still weights 880g, whilst the sony 70-200/4 it's 850g, yes it has less reach, but still...
I reckon that if it's true that BSI sensors can work better than the standard ones with rangefinder lenses, then we'll see smaller primes and the size advantage of M43 will be almost cancelled.
Jun 16, 2015 at 01:41 AM
sflxn
Offline
Details
p.2 #20Does M4/3 have a viable future?
johnvanr wrote:
sflxn wrote at all the m43 fans saying APS-C is getting squeezed. It's ironic since m43 is losing marketshare faster than Canon and Nikon. Unfortunately for them, they are so wrong. APS-C is the single biggest interchangeable lens mount there is. Yes, Sony is not currently paying much attention to their APS-C lenses, but it hasn't had an effect on sales. In fact, that also holds true for Canon and Nikon, whose APS-C lineup (each) still dwarfs the mirrorless market. Even Sony's APS-C mirrorless is bigger than all of m43.

Having said that, I don't think either m43 nor APS-C have great futures. It's not that FF will completely displaced those format. It's just that smartphone and 1" sensors will make cropped sensors seem like a waste of time to most user, and most users are low end users who won't see the value in slightly better images when a smartphone + RX100 will do the job for most of their shooting. The market will shrink, and FF will survive as the pro and enthusiast preferred mount. It's also the market that spends the most money on glass and accessories. Sure, the lenses are much bigger but people who spend a lo of money tend not to care that much. Unfortunately for m43 and APS-C, their demographics are easily swayed by the convenience and cost savings of a smartphone or RX100. APS-C will stick around as the bargain mount for entry level users, but m43 is likely dead long term. The cropped sensor market has never suffered from lack of lenses as Canon and Nikon has demonstrated. m43's lens superiority over Sony's APS-C lineup won't matter. It never has. It never will. It's not an opinion. It's the plain objective fact.
You might be right overall, but as a MFT user, I can say you're wriong about just everything you assume about my photographic needs. I think you're forgetting about the user experience when you think phones or a RX100 are comparable to MFT.


I don't assume any individual's shooting needs, and companies don't exist to cater to small groups of individuals. m43 and APS-C are definitely better than a smartphone. The 1" sensor is quite close to m43 but still not as good. However, diehard m43 users are a minority. The vast majority are still light users with lower end kits, just like those who go out and buy a Rebel kit. That vast majority is swayed by cost. Companies hate catering to market segments that are sensitive to costs -- low margins. It's why Sony and Zeiss are both now catering FF users. FF users are not as sensitive to costs. This is why m43 and APS-C may not have great futures if smartphones and 1" sensors continue to encroach in the ILC market -- it becomes less profitable for those companies if their market dwindles down to just a small group of diehards.
Jun 16, 2015 at 03:47 AM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister