sflxn wrote: johnvanr wrotesflxn wrote at all the m43 fans saying APS-C is getting squeezed. It's ironic since m43 is losing marketshare faster than Canon and Nikon. Unfortunately for them, they are so wrong. APS-C is the single biggest interchangeable lens mount there is. Yes, Sony is not currently paying much attention to their APS-C lenses, but it hasn't had an effect on sales. In fact, that also holds true for Canon and Nikon, whose APS-C lineup (each) still dwarfs the mirrorless market. Even Sony's APS-C mirrorless is bigger than all of m43.
Having said that, I don't think either m43 nor APS-C have great futures. It's not that FF will completely displaced those format. It's just that smartphone and 1" sensors will make cropped sensors seem like a waste of time to most user, and most users are low end users who won't see the value in slightly better images when a smartphone + RX100 will do the job for most of their shooting. The market will shrink, and FF will survive as the pro and enthusiast preferred mount. It's also the market that spends the most money on glass and accessories. Sure, the lenses are much bigger but people who spend a lo of money tend not to care that much. Unfortunately for m43 and APS-C, their demographics are easily swayed by the convenience and cost savings of a smartphone or RX100. APS-C will stick around as the bargain mount for entry level users, but m43 is likely dead long term. The cropped sensor market has never suffered from lack of lenses as Canon and Nikon has demonstrated. m43's lens superiority over Sony's APS-C lineup won't matter. It never has. It never will. It's not an opinion. It's the plain objective fact.You might be right overall, but as a MFT user, I can say you're wriong about just everything you assume about my photographic needs. I think you're forgetting about the user experience when you think phones or a RX100 are comparable to MFT.I don't assume any individual's shooting needs, and companies don't exist to cater to small groups of individuals. m43 and APS-C are definitely better than a smartphone. The 1" sensor is quite close to m43 but still not as good. However, diehard m43 users are a minority. The vast majority are still light users with lower end kits, just like those who go out and buy a Rebel kit. That vast majority is swayed by cost. Companies hate catering to market segments that are sensitive to costs -- low margins. It's why Sony and Zeiss are both now catering FF users. FF users are not as sensitive to costs. This is why m43 and APS-C may not have great futures if smartphones and 1" sensors continue to encroach in the ILC market -- it becomes less profitable for those companies if their market dwindles down to just a small group of diehards....Show more →
True, but I think that applies to the whole camera market. The lower end is gone. What I'm saying is that there's is a space, or there should be, for small prosumer cameras like the better MFT ones.
balga wrote:
If you like to use long zooms, i.e. when travelling, then m43 is probably the best option, although for primes and for low light situation nothing can beat the a7 series.
However, the 40-150/2.8 still weights 880g, whilst the sony 70-200/4 it's 850g, yes it has less reach, but still
This is why you compare the 70-200/4 vs the Panasonic 35-100/2.8, which is only 360g
Also for primes (but not low light) I'd say m43 still has the A7 beat.
14/2.5, 20/1.7 and 45/1.8 are all smaller than anything the A7 has. Then you've got the 7.5 Rokinon FE, body cap lenses , 12/2 is pretty small, etc.
Not that the A7 and small primes are HUGE, but you'll still lose out to the "bulk" war pretty quickly unless you're extremely careful.
balga wrote:
If you like to use long zooms, i.e. when travelling, then m43 is probably the best option, although for primes and for low light situation nothing can beat the a7 series.
However, the 40-150/2.8 still weights 880g, whilst the sony 70-200/4 it's 850g, yes it has less reach, but still...
I reckon that if it's true that BSI sensors can work better than the standard ones with rangefinder lenses, then we'll see smaller primes and the size advantage of M43 will be almost cancelled.
I would not say "nothing can beat the A7 series". Remember that the EM5II has 4-5 stops of effective IBIS, and when coupled with a f/2.8 aperture of the pro series zooms (not to mention the 1.2 aperture of the Nocticron) that is some good low light capability. Also, as mentioned, the proper comparison is the Panasonic 35-100 f/2.8 vs the Sony 70-200 f/4, not the Oly 40-150 f/2.8. Great IBIS (acknowledging that Sony also has this, but not quite as good), f/2.8, and lighter weight (in many cases) all combine for some fairly good low light shooting. It's not a clear cut situation of one being vastly better than the other. Now if you are trying to stop action in low light, that is another story. Still u4/3 is not too bad. I have used the Nocticron for shooting basketball in low light gyms with decent results (need to get on the side lines near the basket).
sflxn wrote:
companies don't exist to cater to small groups of individuals.
They certainly do -- there are lots of niche markets served by lots of companies.
sflxn wrote:
Companies hate catering to market segments that are sensitive to costs -- low margins
That must be why Leica is doing great while Walmart is struggling to survive! Oh, wait...
But to answer your main point, there is a noticeable gap between the performance that smartphones can provide (it's not only the sensor, it's also that your lens must fit in the body a few mm thick) and the performance that FF cameras deliver. Something will live in this gap, but it's not clear what. m4/3 is a contender, as are variations on the 1" sensor cameras.
Smartphones killed the P&S segment, but small mirrorless cameras, once they figure out quick AF, can potentially replace entry-level DSLRs with kit lenses which is what people buy now when they want better performance for not a lot of money.
Thanks for putting this in perspective. m43 is a very viable option to me. I have the Sony A7 II and I have yet to be blown away by it - compared to the E-M1. In good light, I cannot see the advantage of the A7 II over the E-M1. Okay, maybe I am somewhat blind or clueless, but that's my personal opinion.
I would pick the E-M1 + 300/4 PRO + 1.4x TC over any DSLR or FF Sony + 600/4 + 1.4x TC any day. A FF Sony may be better at landscape work but it's not better for birding/wildlife in my books ... at least not when you compare the bulk/size/weight and cost for a similar combo/setup.
galenapass wrote: balga wroteIf you like to use long zooms, i.e. when travelling, then m43 is probably the best option, although for primes and for low light situation nothing can beat the a7 series.
However, the 40-150/2.8 still weights 880g, whilst the sony 70-200/4 it's 850g, yes it has less reach, but still...
I reckon that if it's true that BSI sensors can work better than the standard ones with rangefinder lenses, then we'll see smaller primes and the size advantage of M43 will be almost cancelled.I would not say "nothing can beat the A7 series". Remember that the EM5II has 4-5 stops of effective IBIS, and when coupled with a f/2.8 aperture of the pro series zooms (not to mention the 1.2 aperture of the Nocticron) that is some good low light capability. Also, as mentioned, the proper comparison is the Panasonic 35-100 f/2.8 vs the Sony 70-200 f/4, not the Oly 40-150 f/2.8. Great IBIS (acknowledging that Sony also has this, but not quite as good), f/2.8, and lighter weight (in many cases) all combine for some fairly good low light shooting. It's not a clear cut situation of one being vastly better than the other. Now if you are trying to stop action in low light, that is another story. Still u4/3 is not too bad. I have used the Nocticron for shooting basketball in low light gyms with decent results (need to get on the side lines near the basket). ...Show more →
My wife used to have an m4/3rds kit and switched to a Sony A7 II, and that has its advantages, but there is no question that m4/3rds still has a huge advantage if you want small size. If you go primes a kit with the Olympus 12 f/2, the Panny/Leica 15 f/1.7, the Olympus 25 f/1.8, and the Olympus 45 f/1.8 makes a fabulous set of 4 high perfuming but very small and light lenses, and if you get to longer focal lengths the difference is even more dramatic. The excellent Olympus 75 f/1.8 is way smaller than anything close to the same field of view, and the upcoming Oly 300 f/4 will be several orders of magnitude smaller than anything for full frame.
And if you want zooms, the excellent Panny trio of the 7-14 f/4, the 12-35 f/2.8, and the 35-100 f/2.8 are much smaller as individual lenses and especially as a set than the Sony/Zeiss FE 16-35 f/4, the 24-70 f/4, and the Sony G 70-200 f/4.
You summed it up well, Steve! Yes, m43 can survive alongside the FF mirrorless - possibly better than the APS-C mirrorless can. m43 is fairly mature as a systems camera with an amazing selection of good AF and MF lenses.
Steve Spencer wrote:
My wife used to have an m4/3rds kit and switched to a Sony A7 II, and that has its advantages, but there is no question that m4/3rds still has a huge advantage if you want small size. If you go primes a kit with the Olympus 12 f/2, the Panny/Leica 15 f/1.7, the Olympus 25 f/1.8, and the Olympus 45 f/1.8 makes a fabulous set of 4 high perfuming but very small and light lenses, and if you get to longer focal lengths the difference is even more dramatic. The excellent Olympus 75 f/1.8 is way smaller than anything close to the same field of view, and the upcoming Oly 300 f/4 will be several orders of magnitude smaller than anything for full frame.
And if you want zooms, the excellent Panny trio of the 7-14 f/4, the 12-35 f/2.8, and the 35-100 f/2.8 are much smaller as individual lenses and especially as a set than the Sony/Zeiss FE 16-35 f/4, the 24-70 f/4, and the Sony G 70-200 f/4. ...Show more →
cputeq wrote: howard wrote. Sure, they are still larger and heavier than comparable M4/3 counterparts, but then again they have larger sensors.Therein lies the flaw in your argument. m43 shooters have obviously valued size and weight more then the size of the sensor.
In other words, let me take your argument to its next logical step -- Why don't we shoot medium format? Sure they are larger and heavier than FF, but then again they have larger sensors
For me, quite frankly APS-C just isn't enough of a size / weight savings to shoot it over mirrorless FF. Not that I think APS-C is a bad system, it's pretty good, but I still prefer m43
I think we've all gotten so accustomed to attributing the smaller size to only the sensor instead of also considering the lens priority and marketing decisions made by each company. Fuji for example has clearly decided for now at least to prioritize quality over size while still offering a number of small lenses when you need them. Micro four thirds started with the opposite approach making small and typically slower lenses first and then adding faster and usually bigger lenses more recently. Fuji could now prioritize smaller lenses if they wanted to and they appear to be doing that with the 35/f2 that was announced. That doesn't mean that if Fuji concentrated on smaller lenses they would be as small as micro four thirds in every case but they would be just that much closer while still giving you the option to go with the fast lenses that in general are going to have an advantage over micro four thirds. Now that the high quality, fast lenses are out there Fuji may want to trade the aps-c sensor advantage to add some smaller and slower lenses.
Does this mean that Sigma is now taking a more serious interest in m43 as they see a long term future of this format and are now planning to design lenses specifically for this format rather than just changing the mounts on their DN series of lenses? Not that I am interested in Sigma lenses as m43 lens offerings are already pretty crowded with some really fine lenses. Still good to know that they may be jumping on the band wagon.
bobbytan wrote:
Does this mean that Sigma is now taking a more serious interest in m43
It means Sigma is sufficiently interested to have a group in their R&D department work on (and patent) m4/3 lenses. Whether anything comes to the market is a different question.
If they are channeling part of their R&D resources on m43 lenses it would mean that they are quite serious about developing a line of native m43 lenses ... unlike Zeiss who have said from the very beginning that they have no plans to develop a line of m43 lenses.
KaaX wrote: bobbytan wroteDoes this mean that Sigma is now taking a more serious interest in m43It means Sigma is sufficiently interested to have a group in their R&D department work on (and patent) m4/3 lenses. Whether anything comes to the market is a different question.
Just as the D8xx cameras have replace a 4x5 view camera for many photographers there will also be a similar trend with the mirrorless 4/3 cameras replacing the DSLR cameras. Three reasons why I see this happening and they are size or bulk, weight, and cost of the MFT as compared to the DSLR cameras and their lenses.
The IQ of the Olympus E-M1 is on par with that of the D7200 and close to that of the D800. I can make a 20x30 print from the image file even at ISO 6400. Noise is manageable up to ISO 12,800.
The Olympus 75-300mm has the field of view of a 150-600mm lens on a full frame sensor camera and yet unlike the 7 lb. DSLR lens the Olympus lens weighs less than 1 lb. and is a quarter the size. The Olympus 12-40mm f2.8 (DSLR 24-80mm) and 40-150mm f2.8 (DSLR 80-300mm f2.8) sell for $1000 and $1500 respectively or a fraction of what their full frame camera equivalent lenses. Image quality is outstanding from these lenses.
I read posts all the time by someone going on a trip and wanting advice as to which lenses to take and which to leave at home. With a MFT kit the traveler can take everything and still have a compact and lightweight kit, even with two bodies. This is while people like pro photographer Bob Krist have switched to 100% mirrorless.
The big difference with the current MFT systems is the availability of the pro level f2.8 zoom lenses and the high resolution electronic view finders. The electronic view finders are better than the optical ones as they amplify the light so are much easier to use in low light situations.
I don't see m4/3 going away anytime that soon, though I don't see that it has a shiny future.
The take up has very much been laymen who associate a camera with better pictures (than the phone).
These are purchased from the whole pool of discounted and brand new models ranging from (EP3 to EM10; G1X to G7)
Over here (Singapore/Asia) its weekend ads every week on the papers trying to sell off these old stock.
These folks (most anyway), will only keep to the kit lens and not buy any camera for quite a while.
So very little money is to be made here.
On the enthusiast side, I see a trend away from m4/3 to the Fuji and FF MILC.
At most the m4/3 is an accompaniment to an existing system.
1 camera, 1-3 lenses.
Coming from Pentax, which makes small lenses and DSLRs as well as a range of lenses catered for the aps-c focal length, I never felt that m4/3 was the better choice.
Though a bit smaller, the m4/3 system I had needed a smallish bag to tote around.
The Pentax system with a few small primes, I also needed the same smallish bag.
I felt limited by x2 crop factor in that working distances had to be further for the same FL of lenses. (general kit was a 14, 20, 45)
45/1.8 already had me standing quite a distance away for full body shots w/o the shallow DOF benefits of a larger sensor.
Once I moved to the serious zooms, they were neither small nor cheap.
I only liked m4/3 when I started off with it very simply with a GF1+20mm.
The moment I moved into it as a system, I just did not see an advantage.
So to me, apsc was the better middle ground (and I do realize that everyone has a different middle ground, esp so if their prev system was larger like a Canon or Nikon)
Now, there is the A7.
The A7 itself can be had for $800-900 2nd hand here.
Just a few years ago, even 3rd-4th hand Canon 5D were selling for more.
FF, the size not much bigger than an EM5.
ASPC share is being eaten up on the high and low end of course.
The low end, cheap entry camera buying base is no more and gone to the handphone.
The upper end is threatened by cheaper FF
However, it does hold promise if the makers are willing to design lenses for the system.
Fuji has done it from ground up and they have been well received (enthusiast level anyway).
Canon/Nikon never did, until more recently and only the zooms. (still large though)
Pentax did so right from their entry into digital, but their philosophy of small and slower lenses, don't agree too well with the modern market for fast and faster.
That's lame. If you are having trouble with your working distance it just means that you are using the wrong FL. Try using a 7mm or 12mm lens. And besides, most Olympus lenses will focus really really close.
Cost is not the reason why I switched from FF to m43. I am spending just as much money on m43 gear as I did when I shot with a Canon. For travel, nothing can beat m43 MILC. My backpack used to weigh like 30 lbs. I am now down to about 20 lbs. That is a significant difference.
IQ-wise the E-M1 is better than the old Canon 7D and almost as good as the 5D II ... and that is good enough for me.
pinholecam wrote:
I felt limited by x2 crop factor in that working distances had to be further for the same FL of lenses. (general kit was a 14, 20, 45)
45/1.8 already had me standing quite a distance away for full body shots w/o the shallow DOF benefits of a larger sensor.
Once I moved to the serious zooms, they were neither small nor cheap.
galenapass wrote: balga wroteIf you like to use long zooms, i.e. when travelling, then m43 is probably the best option, although for primes and for low light situation nothing can beat the a7 series.
However, the 40-150/2.8 still weights 880g, whilst the sony 70-200/4 it's 850g, yes it has less reach, but still...
I reckon that if it's true that BSI sensors can work better than the standard ones with rangefinder lenses, then we'll see smaller primes and the size advantage of M43 will be almost cancelled.I would not say "nothing can beat the A7 series". Remember that the EM5II has 4-5 stops of effective IBIS, and when coupled with a f/2.8 aperture of the pro series zooms (not to mention the 1.2 aperture of the Nocticron) that is some good low light capability. Also, as mentioned, the proper comparison is the Panasonic 35-100 f/2.8 vs the Sony 70-200 f/4, not the Oly 40-150 f/2.8. Great IBIS (acknowledging that Sony also has this, but not quite as good), f/2.8, and lighter weight (in many cases) all combine for some fairly good low light shooting. It's not a clear cut situation of one being vastly better than the other. Now if you are trying to stop action in low light, that is another story. Still u4/3 is not too bad. I have used the Nocticron for shooting basketball in low light gyms with decent results (need to get on the side lines near the basket). ...Show more →
I may have done the wrong comparison, but was considering good pro lenses, the panasonic is not as good. Btw, the noctitron is 450g whilst the batis 475g. If we compare say the 17mm and the fe35/2.8 size and weight is the same.
This year the fe135 will come out, and hopefully will be 2.8 or the like, and if that happens I don't believe it would be much bigger than the 75.
Don't get me wrong, I like m43 as a system, so much that I'll probably buy when the next gen of cameras will come out, just to try it with my own hands.
bobbytan wrote:
That's lame. If you are having trouble with your working distance it just means that you are using the wrong FL. Try using a 7mm or 12mm lens. And besides, most Olympus lenses will focus really really close.
Cost is not the reason why I switched from FF to m43. I am spending just as much money on m43 gear as I did when I shot with a Canon. For travel, nothing can beat m43 MILC. My backpack used to weigh like 30 lbs. I am now down to about 20 lbs. That is a significant difference.
IQ-wise the E-M1 is better than the old Canon 7D and almost as good as the 5D II ... and that is good enough for me.
...Show more →pinholecam wroteI felt limited by x2 crop factor in that working distances had to be further for the same FL of lenses. (general kit was a 14, 20, 45)
45/1.8 already had me standing quite a distance away for full body shots w/o the shallow DOF benefits of a larger sensor.
Once I moved to the serious zooms, they were neither small nor cheap.
Lame? for giving my own user experience?
You may disagree, but I don't see a need to call anyone who disagrees lame.
Anyway, like I mentioned, once you go the more serious lenses (7mm, 12mm, and the higher end zooms), the price/size benefits don't weigh up as well compared to apsc.
14,20,45 is are reasonable (28mm, 40mm, 90mm equivalents to 135 format) , thing is to me, they have to be rather extreme FL, costs, size to get to the working distances I prefer.
Personally, I'd prefer say a Pentax DA15, 35, 50 or 77mm as an overall balance of size/encumbrance/performance/DOF options.
Or even the A7+19/30/50 in crop mode.
These are options/preferences here, I'm just sharing mine.