fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015A7rII game plan. What are you doing

  
 
chez
Online
Details
p.6 #1A7rII game plan. What are you doing
GMPhotography wrote:
I think we may have our numbers wrong. The A7r I believe was 2200 on release at least my pocket felt that so the new is 3200 thats a 1k difference. Have to go by release numbers and not discounted numbers to be a fair comparison. Lets be honest we are really paying for the 4K internal video. No question about it, be it that you use it or not it still brings value to the still guy as we get a lot of extras and more important we got almost all our fixes completed. Maybe 3 things we could
...Show more →

I go by the difference in price today. I might get $1400 for my A7R and will need to put down $3200 plus tax on a new A7R2...that's a $2,000 difference, not chump change.
Jun 13, 2015 at 08:48 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.6 #2A7rII game plan. What are you doing
Tariq Gibran wrote:
I suspect Sony realize the price will drop significantly over the next year or so due to other market forces/ competition which is perhaps why they have initially priced the A7rII as high as they have.



You might be right, but I believe the $3200 price tag simply comes in regard to Canon's 5Ds(R) price tag. Sony stays $600-800 below those cameras to make it more attractive in comparison, but since Canon set the margins high again, Sony thinks let's try the same. I am sure the price will come down about 6 months later into the $2500 area for the A7R II.
Jun 13, 2015 at 08:57 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.6 #3A7rII game plan. What are you doing
I understand that we all will sell and buy and the numbers will be high to purchase. But thats not a real fair way to think about it all its a 900 cost difference on release dates of both systems. Is it worth it lets say yes to make this simple. Now we have to look at what our sale prices will be and BTW blame Sony for chewing up your used price for your A7r they discounted it and the used prices follow that. So yes your going to have to pay a bigger difference of about 2k. This is why we have folks saying i will wait till they discount it. Im afraid being there top tier camera with no issues like the A7r original that may not happen. Also not important to us still shooters but video guys will be buying these up in droves. It is a very cheap high end solution for video. This is a tough call for current A7r users me included. We did not buy a perfect camera , now we see this maybe it and we want to get away from the issues. Unfortunately its like being underwater on car payments type scenario. For those that never heard of that expressions its having car payments exceed the value of the car. Thats where we are at here. Im honestly buying my way out of the A7r issues I had with it. As A Pro I have no choice, as a hobbyist you get far better options.

Im not saying go buy it, your money your call and as a consumer you look at all the value propositions and make a call. I know what I am doing because I wanted out of the A7r to get something that does not have the issues. Im clearly buying my way out of it. I am accepting that as a cost to do business.

This is tough because your applying all the logic you can muster to make a decision but that I want to have this little devil on your shoulder is a pretty strong. Decisions are tough and it gets worse with increase out of pocket decisions.

Edited on Jun 13, 2015 at 09:15 AM · View previous versions
Jun 13, 2015 at 09:01 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.6 #4A7rII game plan. What are you doing
GMPhotography wrote:
I understand that we all will sell and buy and the numbers will be high to purchase. But thats not a real fair way to think about it all its a 900 cost difference on release dates of both systems. Is it worth it lets say yes to make this simple. Now we have to look at what our sale prices will be and BTW blame Sony for chewing up your used price for your A7r they discounted it and the used prices follow that. So yes your going to have to pay a bigger difference of about 2k. This
...Show more →

I can understand your opinion especially if you are a professional and make money with your photography. As pure hobbyist even if I have the money to purchase this camera, I don't see a justification for me at this point. I never felt that the A7R had many issues which bugged me for my way of photography. It is very subjective (a) how much we want to spend for a camera and (b) if we feel the improvements are worth this money.
Personally I think that the A7R II is the generation of the A7 series which I might skip before evaluating its successor options about one year later.
Jun 13, 2015 at 09:14 AM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.6 #5A7rII game plan. What are you doing
millsart wrote:
Again, no $3200 isn't cheap, but its a lot more accessible than a $11,000 1Ds was when it came out, and gives you so many more features


I wonder what the equivalent "tech" years are to human years if one human year equals seven dog years? That 1Ds came out 13 years ago - an eternity tech wise - and it also was a 1 series and all that goes with that.... build quality/ durability/ service/ upgrade cycle/ etc. The Sony A7 series is not that. It's closer to the equivalent of the Minolta Maxxum 7000. Lot's of features and innovation but still enthusiast oriented in other respects. Hopefully an A9 will be more like that comparison to a 1 series though.
Jun 13, 2015 at 09:15 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.6 #6A7rII game plan. What are you doing
retrofocus wrote:
GMPhotography wroteI understand that we all will sell and buy and the numbers will be high to purchase. But thats not a real fair way to think about it all its a 900 cost difference on release dates of both systems. Is it worth it lets say yes to make this simple. Now we have to look at what our sale prices will be and BTW blame Sony for chewing up your used price for your A7r they discounted it and the used prices follow that. So yes your going to have to pay a bigger difference of about 2k. This is why we have folks saying i will wait till they discount it. Im afraid being there top tier camera with no issues like the A7r original that may not happen. Also not important to us still shooters but video guys will be buying these up in droves. It is a very cheap high end solution for video. This is a tough call for current A7r users me included. We did not buy a perfect camera , now we see this maybe it and we want to get away from the issues. Unfortunately its like being underwater on car payments type scenario. For those that never heard of that expressions its having car payments exceed the value of the car. Thats where we are at here. Im honestly buying my way out of the A7r issues I had with it. As A Pro I have no choice, as a hobbyist you get far better options.

Im not saying go buy it, your money your call and as a consumer you look at all the value propositions and make a call. I know what I am doing because I wanted out of the A7r to get something that does not have the issues. Im clearly buying my way out of it. I am accepting that as a cost to do business.
I can understand your opinion especially if you are a professional and make money with your photography. As pure hobbyist even if I have the money to purchase this camera, I don't see a justification for me at this point. I never felt that the A7R had many issues which bugged me for my way of photography. It is very subjective (a) how much we want to spend for a camera and (b) if we feel the improvements are worth this money.
Personally I think that the A7R II is the generation of the A7 series which I might skip
...Show more →

Im in total agreement with you . Im stuck as a Pro and I have said this many times I much rather be a hobbyist on these buy decisions because your not being forced into a corner, you folks have real options. I envy that freedom.

Im just trying to help folks think logically and act without impulse. You have to do what makes sense. No one is right here and no one is wrong here.
Jun 13, 2015 at 09:18 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.6 #7A7rII game plan. What are you doing
Tariq Gibran wrote:
millsart wroteAgain, no $3200 isn't cheap, but its a lot more accessible than a $11,000 1Ds was when it came out, and gives you so many more features
I wonder what the equivalent "tech" years are to human years if one human year equals seven dog years? That 1Ds came out 13 years ago - an eternity tech wise - and it also was a 1 series and all that goes with that.... build quality/ durability/ service/ upgrade cycle/ etc. The Sony A7 series is not that. It's closer to the equivalent of the Minolta Maxxum 7000. Lot's of features and innovation but still enthusiast oriented in other respects. Hopefully an A9 will be more like that comparison to a 1 series though.


Tariq let me ask a question and not just directed at you either . But we hear about the A9 and that if I am correct came from a rumor site that lets say has not been so darn accurate either. Are we taking this A9 to heart and think its a 100 percent done deal that it will come. I personally find it hard to think that far ahead and I see a lot of folks talk about waiting for it. Im a little nervous it maybe vapor wear. How solid do you think this is
Jun 13, 2015 at 09:22 AM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.6 #8A7rII game plan. What are you doing
I would just point out that it's not only if one is a "Pro" or not. Some Pro's do a little of every type of work and need one camera that is extremely versatile while others work in more specialized niche markets and don't require a camera to have extreme versatility feature wise.
Jun 13, 2015 at 09:25 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.6 #9A7rII game plan. What are you doing
Tariq Gibran wrote:
I would just point out that it's not only if one is a "Pro" or not. Some Pro's do a little of every type of work and need one camera that is extremely versatile while others work in more specialized niche markets and don't require a camera to have extreme versatility feature wise.


Totally agree and that part of my issue is a I do need a very versatile camera and honestly its a struggle to find that. My shooting is all over the place as far as diversity in jobs and subjects. I rent a lot too which does help that

Edited on Jun 13, 2015 at 09:32 AM · View previous versions
Jun 13, 2015 at 09:29 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.6 #10A7rII game plan. What are you doing
For folks lets say that do a lot of landscape this cam may not help you much. The A7r is perfectly capable of that type of work. Yea you pick up a few extras here but if you avoid some of the problem areas its not that difficult to continue on with the A7r. 42mpx is nothing in the real world as far as file. IBIS is worthless your on a tripod mostly and so on. So you have to think this one out.
Jun 13, 2015 at 09:31 AM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.6 #11A7rII game plan. What are you doing
GMPhotography wrote:
Tariq Gibran wrote
millsart wroteAgain, no $3200 isn't cheap, but its a lot more accessible than a $11,000 1Ds was when it came out, and gives you so many more features
I wonder what the equivalent "tech" years are to human years if one human year equals seven dog years? That 1Ds came out 13 years ago - an eternity tech wise - and it also was a 1 series and all that goes with that.... build quality/ durability/ service/ upgrade cycle/ etc. The Sony A7 series is not that. It's closer to the equivalent of the Minolta Maxxum 7000. Lot's of features and innovation but still enthusiast oriented in other respects. Hopefully an A9 will be more like that comparison to a 1 series though.
Tariq let me ask a question and not just directed at you either . But we hear about the A9 and that if I am correct came from a rumor site that lets say has not been so darn accurate either. Are we taking this A9 to heart and think its a 100 percent done deal that it will come. I personally find it hard to think that far ahead and I see a lot of folks talk about waiting for it. Im a little nervous it maybe vapor wear. How solid do you think this is


"A9" is pure rumor at this point. If we go by history though and include how Sony and Minolta have designated there model range, there should be a higher model released. Historically, this is still a "7" series and shares the same basic body of the A7II (this almost certainly would not be the case if the A7rII is supposed to be the highest end model). Marketing wise, It's extremely feature rich, something also found historically in both the Sony and Canon model range that sits just below the "Pro" versions.

There was a Sony a900, a Sony a99 and I highly suspect we will have a Sony "A9" (and I'm one that thinks it might mean the end of the A-mount as we know it and complete the transition to only E-mount, particularly if AF is as good as claimed on the A7rII now). The body would be noticeably different than the one shared by the A7II and A7rII. The upgrade cycle will be longer and the camera will be even more of a niche market tool (probably with no video and very high resolution). This is what I 100% expect to see by Photokina next year if not sooner. For me to believe otherwise is to also believe that Sony has broken completely away from their past model designation. That just doesn't make sense, particularly as I know there must be a higher resolution sensor waiting in the wings from Sony. No way I think Sony will cede that to Canon! All this is just what I think though (speculation based on precedent).
Jun 13, 2015 at 09:46 AM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.6 #12A7rII game plan. What are you doing
GMPhotography wrote:
Tariq Gibran wroteI would just point out that it's not only if one is a "Pro" or not. Some Pro's do a little of every type of work and need one camera that is extremely versatile while others work in more specialized niche markets and don't require a camera to have extreme versatility feature wise.
Totally agree and that part of my issue is a I do need a very versatile camera and honestly its a struggle to find that. My shooting is all over the place as far as diversity in jobs and subjects. I rent a lot too which does help that


That being the case, my hunch is that even if we see the mythical "A9", it might not offer the versatility you get with this A7rII.

Jun 13, 2015 at 09:51 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.6 #13A7rII game plan. What are you doing
Well that does make a lot of sense. I'm in the camp that the A mount itself does not have a lot of hope. I agree if the AF on this model does what it says than the lenses in the A mount become very useful. If it focus tracks really well than I'm looking at maybe getting a long lens in it
Jun 13, 2015 at 09:52 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.6 #14A7rII game plan. What are you doing


Tariq Gibran wrote:
GMPhotography wrote
Tariq Gibran wroteI would just point out that it's not only if one is a "Pro" or not. Some Pro's do a little of every type of work and need one camera that is extremely versatile while others work in more specialized niche markets and don't require a camera to have extreme versatility feature wise.
Totally agree and that part of my issue is a I do need a very versatile camera and honestly its a struggle to find that. My shooting is all over the place as far as diversity in jobs and subjects. I rent a lot too which does help that
That being the case, my hunch is that even if we see the mythical "A9", it might not offer the versatility you get with this A7rII.



For me if I see it now than im on it. This looks very promising to me and will see what happens down the road.
Jun 13, 2015 at 09:54 AM
Jeff Kott
Offline
Details
p.6 #15A7rII game plan. What are you doing
GMPhotography wrote:
Let's face it 3200 price tag is going to weed some folks out as they just simply do not want to spend this much.


It's not just the price tag - it's the price tag combined with the fact that the cameras we already own are so darn good. As I mentioned above, I'm pretty much doing everything I want with my A6000 and A7R. If I didn't have those cameras and was, for example, still shooting a D300, the $3200 wouldn't give me any pause and I'd preorder just as I preordered my A7R.
Jun 13, 2015 at 10:57 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.6 #16A7rII game plan. What are you doing
Heck Im going to grab a A6000 myself a backup. I had one before and I really liked it. I agree the A7r is one hell of a camera. For a lot of folks the upgrade may not be worth it as the files are gorgeous.
Jun 13, 2015 at 11:03 AM
dennishh
Offline
Details
p.6 #17A7rII game plan. What are you doing
Great posts, my initial response to reading about the new A7r2 was to run out right away and buy it, but now that after some days have pasted I am reconsidering this. I pre-ordered my A7r originally and felt that I wish I had waited for the price to click down. On this one I'm going to wait for the initial reviews and tests especially the one by diglloyd and hope he finds something wrong with it which drives the price down a few hundred dollars. I just sold off all of my Nikon equipment and am only using my Sony gear now which makes me still want to preorder and see if any major jobs come in before the middle of August. If these jobs don't materialize that I can wait for the spring without any problem. $3200 is too much money until we actually see what files like compared to the A7r. I'm still waiting for my Zeiss Batis 85mm f/1.8 Lens which should be phenomenal on the A7r2.
Jun 13, 2015 at 11:09 AM
Phillip Reeve
Offline
Details
p.6 #18A7rII game plan. What are you doing
I am surprised how hyped the camera is here.

Sure the features sound great but they won't improve my pictures that much.

I would guess that if I compared it to my a7 it would make a difference in maybe 10% of my images and thats mostly because of the image stabilizer (which the much cheaper a7II offfers as well).

From the specs it seems to be a very nice camera and I can well imagine to get one in about two years times when the used price is half of what the new price is now. But right now the price is pretty ridiculous for a hobbyist like me.

There are moments when I am annoyed by my a7 but they are rare and in general I am still very happy with it and I seldom test it's limits.
Jun 13, 2015 at 12:19 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.6 #19A7rII game plan. What are you doing
BTW nice discussion folks. Its really nice to hear many points of view on this. In all honesty this cam should have been what the original A7r should have been . At least the issues fixed out of the gate. For me its like starting over but now with a set of native lenses that really are nice and a better set of functions and features.
Jun 13, 2015 at 01:05 PM
ecarlino
Offline
Details
p.6 #20A7rII game plan. What are you doing
Phillip Reeve wrote:
I am surprised how hyped the camera is here.

Sure the features sound great but they won't improve my pictures that much.

I would guess that if I compared it to my a7 it would make a difference in maybe 10% of my images and thats mostly because of the image stabilizer (which the much cheaper a7II offfers as well).

From the specs it seems to be a very nice camera and I can well imagine to get one in about two years times when the used price is half of what the new price is now. But right now the
...Show more →

Phillip, I know you get a lot of respect around here, you've posted a lot of nice shots. But frankly, I've seen a few people on the web with galleries who shot with an iPhone and theirs look even better, only to prove the point it's never about the equipment.

But even in non technical fields people enjoy their equipment. I know woodworkers who get excited about their tools. The common thread I find amongst artists of any variety is an appreciation for when their tools get out of their way.

The a7r2 improves upon the a7r by getting out of the way in many respects along with advancing the state of the art in others.

Enjoy your a7. Contentment is a virtue.

Edited on Jun 13, 2015 at 01:13 PM · View previous versions
Jun 13, 2015 at 01:08 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister