fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015A7rII game plan. What are you doing

  
 
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.7 #1A7rII game plan. What are you doing
Phillip Reeve wrote:
I am surprised how hyped the camera is here.

Sure the features sound great but they won't improve my pictures that much.

I would guess that if I compared it to my a7 it would make a difference in maybe 10% of my images and thats mostly because of the image stabilizer (which the much cheaper a7II offfers as well).

From the specs it seems to be a very nice camera and I can well imagine to get one in about two years times when the used price is half of what the new price is now. But right now the
...Show more →

Don't know so much about hyped but it really has more to do with the original A7r taking a PR bath than anything else. The shutter shock issue was a internet nightmare but the reality is its a issue at times and ways around it. Was made out to be to big a deal and yes the raw compression issue as well. A lot of over the top reviewers who IMHO are sensationalizing a lot for PR sake. I don't want to go here too much but like they say don't believe everything you read. The internet can bury a camera with just a few lines of BS. You have to be careful what you read sometimes and more important where its coming from.
Jun 13, 2015 at 01:10 PM
johnvanr
Offline
Details
p.7 #2A7rII game plan. What are you doing
millsart wrote:
GMPhotography wroteLet's face it 3200 price tag is going to weed some folks out as they just simply do not want to spend this much.
You know it funny, as I was thinking about this very thing, and how much camera we can get for so "little" money these days.



Maybe it's because in photography terms I'm an old geezer, since started with film, but I think digital is ridiculously expensive. The top of the line Canon and Nikon cameras used to be about $1500-1800. Other than that sensor and evolutionary improvements in AF etc. digital doesn't offer more camera, certainly not to warrant the enormous price difference. I think the manufacturers have made an absolute killing with digital. Problem is they got used to the easy times and have a hard time adjusting now that it's over. In the meantime, we think a $3000 camera is relatively cheap.
Jun 13, 2015 at 01:28 PM
mogul
Offline
Details
p.7 #3A7rII game plan. What are you doing
johnvanr wrote:
millsart wrote
GMPhotography wroteLet's face it 3200 price tag is going to weed some folks out as they just simply do not want to spend this much.
You know it funny, as I was thinking about this very thing, and how much camera we can get for so "little" money these days.
Maybe it's because in photography terms I'm an old geezer, since started with film, but I think digital is ridiculously expensive. The top of the line Canon and Nikon cameras used to be about $1500-1800. Other than that sensor and evolutionary improvements in AF etc. digital doesn't offer more camera, certainly not to warrant the enormous price difference. I think the manufacturers have made an absolute killing with digital. Problem is they got used to the easy times and have a hard time adjusting now that it's over. In the meantime, we think a $3000 camera is relatively cheap.

Don't forget those cheap cameras of old were just empty boxes to hold film with a lens stuck in front. Only Minolta went all out with the shutter box and put in a kevlar/carbon one that had 1/12000 speed.
Jun 13, 2015 at 01:33 PM
howard
Offline
Details
p.7 #4A7rII game plan. What are you doing
johnvanr wrote:
millsart wrote
GMPhotography wroteLet's face it 3200 price tag is going to weed some folks out as they just simply do not want to spend this much.
You know it funny, as I was thinking about this very thing, and how much camera we can get for so "little" money these days.
Maybe it's because in photography terms I'm an old geezer, since started with film, but I think digital is ridiculously expensive. The top of the line Canon and Nikon cameras used to be about $1500-1800. Other than that sensor and evolutionary improvements in AF etc. digital doesn't offer more camera, certainly not to warrant the enormous price difference. I think the manufacturers have made an absolute killing with digital. Problem is they got used to the easy times and have a hard time adjusting now that it's over. In the meantime, we think a $3000 camera is relatively cheap.


How about that it does not require film?
Jun 13, 2015 at 01:43 PM
mmurph
Offline
Details
p.7 #5A7rII game plan. What are you doing
millsart wrote:
Again, no $3200 isn't cheap, but its a lot more accessible than a $11,000 1Ds was when it came out, and gives you so many more features


Yes, we absolutely have great cameras today! But that also makes the A7RII relatively more expensive to the other choices, because an A6000 - a $350 used, 24 MP APS-C body, or a Sony A7II - a $1,200 24 MP FF body - can deliver a large percent of what most people need. Especially for non-pros, and hobbuyists who don't shoot landscape.

The question is the incremental value and the "pay back" for the expense in comparison oto teh other options.

+++

When I bought a full frame Canon 1DsII for $7,800 in 2004,itt was the first digital camera that could replace medium format film for me.

The previous year I had shot $5,000 worth of 6x7 professional color film on my Mamiya 7II's, at $1 per frame. That was in addition to the digital work that I did on my Canon D30, 10D, and then 20D, which had already replaced my 35 mm film use.

The Canon 1DsII cost me $1,200 per year in depreciation, or $2,400 in total before I sold it after 2 years. But it saved me $5,000 per year in film use, $10,000 total.

It basically paid for itself in 3 months each year, and I got to use it the rest of the year "for free." I rented it out a few times too (going rate was $350 per day), which probably literally made the camera "free."

I put 35,000 exposures per year on the camera, 70,000 total. I had a studio at the time, mostly shooting fashion and portrait.So the 1DsII was a great investment for me! I never touched my Mamiya 7II kit again after bought it.

+++


+++

Today I am retired and no longer a pro. I still do events and wildlife work. I also do portraits that get printed at 8.5x11, plus some "urban landscape" work, and causal personal and vacation work.

I print very rarely, to a maximum of 12x18 on my Canon Pro-100. Most of my work goes to the web. I haven't used my Epson 24" and 46" wide format printers in 3 years, and probably won't ever use them again.

My Sony A6000 is worth about $350. The Sony A7II is worth about $1,200. They both give me great 24 MP images that do everything that I need.

The biggest benefit of the A7rII to me would be the decent quality FF auto focus, and the ability to use my Canon lenses. Especially the Canon 24-70 2.8 II and 70-200 2.8 II for events - that extra stop would help a lot in lower light.

Hopefully Sony will include the same AF capability in another body like the A7II at a lower price point. Or the A7RII will depreciate to a range where I can justify it.

Cheers!

Jun 13, 2015 at 01:53 PM
Mystik
Offline
Details
p.7 #6A7rII game plan. What are you doing
Pre-ordering this on Wednesday.

Sold my a7r and recently picked up an a7II. I'll be returning the a7II this week (still within 30 day window), and will lean on solely on my 5DIII until August. My decision about how to proceed from here is dependent on the AF performance with my 24-70 2.8II and 70-200 2.8II on a7rII. If its at least on par with a native FE lens on the a7II (which has an AF that is plenty capable for my purposes), then the 5DIII gets sold. By selling the 5DIII and a7r, my net position in terms of $$ should be roughly even.

If the AF isn't on par, I'll have some tough decision to make, but I'll cross that bridge when I get there.

Photography isn't my main source of income, but I shoot weddings, events, and portraits to finance this hobby and generate some extra side income
Jun 13, 2015 at 02:25 PM
sflxn
Offline
Details
p.7 #7A7rII game plan. What are you doing
I'll play. I think I'll wait. Planning on big lenses and computer expenses this year, but I am very interested in the Canon lens AF capabilities of this camera. The mediocre FE 24-70 made me return it. It left me without my goto zoom lens, but now, I will be able to just use Canons's. I'll keep my A7R and A6000 even after I eventually buy the A7RII. I'll likely sell off my Fuji kit and more of my APS-C E lenses.

Prices of the A7RII will come down for sure within 6 months of release. As always, a lot of folks expecting perfection from Sony will start whining and complaining soon after release. For me, the A7RII ticks all the right checkboxes, except the lossless compression, but that point doesn't kill it for me. The banding and noise I have seen with other camera brands, including medium format, was an everyday problem. The compression issue with the A7 series is an issue you need to look hard to find. I'm really excited to see how much cleaner this BSI sensor is over the A7R.
Jun 13, 2015 at 02:59 PM
rattymouse
Offline
Details
p.7 #8A7rII game plan. What are you doing
howard wrote:
johnvanr wrote
millsart wrote
GMPhotography wroteLet's face it 3200 price tag is going to weed some folks out as they just simply do not want to spend this much.
You know it funny, as I was thinking about this very thing, and how much camera we can get for so "little" money these days.
Maybe it's because in photography terms I'm an old geezer, since started with film, but I think digital is ridiculously expensive. The top of the line Canon and Nikon cameras used to be about $1500-1800. Other than that sensor and evolutionary improvements in AF etc. digital doesn't offer more camera, certainly not to warrant the enormous price difference. I think the manufacturers have made an absolute killing with digital. Problem is they got used to the easy times and have a hard time adjusting now that it's over. In the meantime, we think a $3000 camera is relatively cheap.
How about that it does not require film?


Film is dirt cheap.

Jun 13, 2015 at 03:42 PM
flash
Offline
Details
p.7 #9A7rII game plan. What are you doing
SteveF wrote:
flash wrote
SteveF wroteI need a Zenmuse gimbal for the a7rii, and this is likely months away. So I'll shoot with the a7r until then.
What are you using for the mk1? I didn't think the A7 gimbal was released yet.

Gordon
Hi,

The a7 gimbal is out and works well. Fits the a7r and a7s. I've tried to squeeze the a7ii in there but it just isn't happening.



Thanks Steve. Must ring my dealer. I'm sure I'll be happy with an A7R under a S900. I really want it for stills not video.

Gordon
Jun 13, 2015 at 03:48 PM
Jman13
Online
Details
p.7 #10A7rII game plan. What are you doing
Film plus development is not dirt cheap. At least not in the U.S. Decent films cost at least $7 for 24 exposures, then another $8-15 for developing/scanning and you're up to around $20 for 24 exposures. $0.83 every time you click the shutter isn't exactly cheap. At my current output, given review shooting and my own personal shooting, I'd spend over $15,000 a year if I shot only film. And I'm not a spray and pray guy.
Jun 13, 2015 at 03:51 PM
howard
Offline
Details
p.7 #11A7rII game plan. What are you doing
rattymouse wrote:
howard wrote
johnvanr wrote
millsart wrote
GMPhotography wroteLet's face it 3200 price tag is going to weed some folks out as they just simply do not want to spend this much.
You know it funny, as I was thinking about this very thing, and how much camera we can get for so "little" money these days.
Maybe it's because in photography terms I'm an old geezer, since started with film, but I think digital is ridiculously expensive. The top of the line Canon and Nikon cameras used to be about $1500-1800. Other than that sensor and evolutionary improvements in AF etc. digital doesn't offer more camera, certainly not to warrant the enormous price difference. I think the manufacturers have made an absolute killing with digital. Problem is they got used to the easy times and have a hard time adjusting now that it's over. In the meantime, we think a $3000 camera is relatively cheap.
How about that it does not require film?
Film is dirt cheap.



Can you reformat it too?
Jun 13, 2015 at 03:53 PM
rattymouse
Offline
Details
p.7 #12A7rII game plan. What are you doing
Jman13 wrote:
Film plus development is not dirt cheap. At least not in the U.S. Decent films cost at least $7 for 24 exposures, then another $8-15 for developing/scanning and you're up to around $20 for 24 exposures. $0.83 every time you click the shutter isn't exactly cheap. At my current output, given review shooting and my own personal shooting, I'd spend over $15,000 a year if I shot only film. And I'm not a spray and pray guy.


Develop film yourself and costs drop to almost nothing. I can develop a roll of black and white film for under 20 cents. Twenty cents! Color for under $1. I shoot 500 or more rolls of film per year and the cost to me is negligible. I spent far more on digital playing the rat race buying new gear all the time.

Further, if you know the shot you want, if you can conceive of the image before the shot, then you certainly dont need $15,000 worth of film to execute it properly. Pros can and do make a profit shooting film. Not as many as there used to be, but they are still out there. You are a spray and pray type of shooter if your film costs exceed your budget.

Photography is never going to be a cheap hobby, but the cost difference of digital vs film is greatly over exaggerated in many cases. Numerous times I'll read a post from some hobbyist here, add up the gear that he lists as being owned and see it cost well over $6000 and he STILL wants more.

When indexed for inflation, film is still today very much dirt cheap.



Edited on Jun 13, 2015 at 04:37 PM · View previous versions
Jun 13, 2015 at 04:36 PM
rattymouse
Offline
Details
p.7 #13A7rII game plan. What are you doing
howard wrote:
rattymouse wrote
howard wrote
johnvanr wrote
millsart wrote
GMPhotography wroteLet's face it 3200 price tag is going to weed some folks out as they just simply do not want to spend this much.
You know it funny, as I was thinking about this very thing, and how much camera we can get for so "little" money these days.
Maybe it's because in photography terms I'm an old geezer, since started with film, but I think digital is ridiculously expensive. The top of the line Canon and Nikon cameras used to be about $1500-1800. Other than that sensor and evolutionary improvements in AF etc. digital doesn't offer more camera, certainly not to warrant the enormous price difference. I think the manufacturers have made an absolute killing with digital. Problem is they got used to the easy times and have a hard time adjusting now that it's over. In the meantime, we think a $3000 camera is relatively cheap.
How about that it does not require film?
Film is dirt cheap.
Can you reformat it too?


Not really relevant is it?

Jun 13, 2015 at 04:36 PM
howard
Offline
Details
p.7 #14A7rII game plan. What are you doing
rattymouse wrote:
howard wrote
rattymouse wrote
howard wrote
johnvanr wrote
millsart wroteYou know it funny, as I was thinking about this very thing, and how much camera we can get for so "little" money these days.
Maybe it's because in photography terms I'm an old geezer, since started with film, but I think digital is ridiculously expensive. The top of the line Canon and Nikon cameras used to be about $1500-1800. Other than that sensor and evolutionary improvements in AF etc. digital doesn't offer more camera, certainly not to warrant the enormous price difference. I think the manufacturers have made an absolute killing with digital. Problem is they got used to the easy times and have a hard time adjusting now that it's over. In the meantime, we think a $3000 camera is relatively cheap.
How about that it does not require film?
Film is dirt cheap.
Can you reformat it too?
Not really relevant is it?



Very, if you think about it.
Jun 13, 2015 at 04:37 PM
rattymouse
Offline
Details
p.7 #15A7rII game plan. What are you doing
howard wrote:
rattymouse wrote
howard wrote
rattymouse wrote
howard wrote
johnvanr wroteMaybe it's because in photography terms I'm an old geezer, since started with film, but I think digital is ridiculously expensive. The top of the line Canon and Nikon cameras used to be about $1500-1800. Other than that sensor and evolutionary improvements in AF etc. digital doesn't offer more camera, certainly not to warrant the enormous price difference. I think the manufacturers have made an absolute killing with digital. Problem is they got used to the easy times and have a hard time adjusting now that it's over. In the meantime, we think a $3000 camera is relatively cheap.
How about that it does not require film?
Film is dirt cheap.
Can you reformat it too?
Not really relevant is it?
Very, if you think about it.


If i think about it, it seems you have no idea what film is.

Jun 13, 2015 at 04:38 PM
howard
Offline
Details
p.7 #16A7rII game plan. What are you doing
rattymouse wrote:
Jman13 wroteFilm plus development is not dirt cheap. At least not in the U.S. Decent films cost at least $7 for 24 exposures, then another $8-15 for developing/scanning and you're up to around $20 for 24 exposures. $0.83 every time you click the shutter isn't exactly cheap. At my current output, given review shooting and my own personal shooting, I'd spend over $15,000 a year if I shot only film. And I'm not a spray and pray guy.
Develop film yourself and costs drop to almost nothing. I can develop a roll of black and white film for under 20 cents. Twenty cents! Color for under $1. I shoot 500 or more rolls of film per year and the cost to me is negligible. I spent far more on digital playing the rat race buying new gear all the time.

Further, if you know the shot you want, if you can conceive of the image before the shot, then you certainly dont need $15,000 worth of film to execute it properly. Pros can and do make a
...Show more →

How many have a chemical lab at home? How many have an image editing software at home?

I'm not saying film does not have its place in photography; I think it does. But I think your claim that it is "dirt cheap" is overly exaggerated.
Jun 13, 2015 at 04:41 PM
howard
Offline
Details
p.7 #17A7rII game plan. What are you doing
rattymouse wrote:
howard wrote
rattymouse wrote
howard wrote
rattymouse wrote
howard wroteHow about that it does not require film?
Film is dirt cheap.
Can you reformat it too?
Not really relevant is it?
Very, if you think about it.
If i think about it, it seems you have no idea what film is.



I do. I did. Thank you.
Jun 13, 2015 at 04:41 PM
rattymouse
Offline
Details
p.7 #18A7rII game plan. What are you doing
howard wrote:
rattymouse wrote
howard wrote
rattymouse wrote
howard wrote
rattymouse wroteFilm is dirt cheap.
Can you reformat it too?
Not really relevant is it?
Very, if you think about it.
If i think about it, it seems you have no idea what film is.
I do. I did. Thank you.


The available evidence does not confirm this.
Jun 13, 2015 at 04:42 PM
howard
Offline
Details
p.7 #19A7rII game plan. What are you doing
rattymouse wrote:
howard wrote
rattymouse wrote
howard wrote
rattymouse wrote
howard wroteCan you reformat it too?
Not really relevant is it?
Very, if you think about it.
If i think about it, it seems you have no idea what film is.
I do. I did. Thank you.
The available evidence does not confirm this.


Whatever, I don't feel compelled to have to convince you. I'm also not arguing for argument's sake. You started by comparing the cost of digital cameras with film ones and concluding that the digital ones are way overpriced. Then you try to support your conclusion by using the shaky argument that film is "dirt cheap". I can tell you that nowadays when I shoot birds I routinely shoot 200-300 frames per session. I used to shoot Velvia 50 and Provia 100, film+E6 processing is not "dirt cheap" for 200-300 frames, I can tell you that.
Jun 13, 2015 at 04:48 PM
Jman13
Online
Details
p.7 #20A7rII game plan. What are you doing
You're also counting your time as free. My time is worth more than free. Since I do reviews, I need to put a few hundred frames through each piece of gear to properly evaluate things, and I do 20-30 reviews per year. That's 15,000 frames just on review gear. Not counting my personal work.

Even shooting modestly, tripod mounted and deliberate, I take 50-60 frames in a two hour outing. That's pretty meager. It also would still result in 100 frames a week MINIMUM, which is 5,200 frames a year. Even that, assuming good film and negligible processing (and assigning no cost to the hours upon hours of development myself (which I do not have the space nor the time to do even if I wanted to), that's going to cost me $1,400 a year.

500 rolls here is going to cost about $3,500 here in the US. That's still more expensive than digital. With having the film developed and scanned (which is cheaper than my own time), we're at $10,000 a year. Makes my $1500 A7 II look cheap, especially since I'll use it for well more than a year.

In any case, I'm glad film works well for you, though it won't fit everyone's shooting needs.

rattymouse wrote:
Jman13 wroteFilm plus development is not dirt cheap. At least not in the U.S. Decent films cost at least $7 for 24 exposures, then another $8-15 for developing/scanning and you're up to around $20 for 24 exposures. $0.83 every time you click the shutter isn't exactly cheap. At my current output, given review shooting and my own personal shooting, I'd spend over $15,000 a year if I shot only film. And I'm not a spray and pray guy.
Develop film yourself and costs drop to almost nothing. I can develop a roll of black and white film for under 20 cents. Twenty cents! Color for under $1. I shoot 500 or more rolls of film per year and the cost to me is negligible. I spent far more on digital playing the rat race buying new gear all the time.

Further, if you know the shot you want, if you can conceive of the image before the shot, then you certainly dont need $15,000 worth of film to execute it properly. Pros can and do make a
...Show more →
Jun 13, 2015 at 05:18 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister