ecarlino wrote: Phillip Reeve wroteAs I wrote in the last post: Maybe I shouldn't have posted the link, linking to ones own content it a sensitive topic and yeah that article does not contain any new information, just my assesment. I appreciate it if people point out to me that it might be inappropriate to post such a link. BUT if you want me to take you serious you should take me serious as well.I don't take you seriously - you criticized people for being enthusiastic about a new product and then come back with the good news that "you took the time to write down your thoughts" and want everyone to stop what they're doing and go see what you have to say.
If you wanted to be taken seriously, how about waiting until you've had a chance to use the product for a while and then offer a review.
In any case, i've had a long night of celebrating the BLACKHAWKS Stanley Cup, so, i'll leave you alone now - the sun is about to rise here in Chicago and i'm off to bed........Show more →
Congratulations on the Blackhawks victory. People here in Canada take that very seriously. Perhaps you celebrated a bit too much before your posts last night. Rhetorically you are a force with strong opinions that are expressed powerfully. At times, however, the force of your posts works against you or so it seems to me. The strength of the opinions that you express seems at times to convey a lack of respect for those to whom you are talking. I bring this up because I too have this fault sometimes. I think discussion works best on this forum when we all show respect for each others point of view. I think you can make a good contribution here, but it will be much better if as you form your posts you are careful to show respect for even those with whom you disagree. I think showing such respect will get you a lot more in return as well.
ecarlino wrote: Phillip Reeve wroteecarlino wrotealundeb wroteecarlino wrotePhillip Reeve wroteBecause there is plenty of over enthusiastic writing in the net and I wanted to expand a but on my point of view. I think it's fine if we disagree, after all it's just a camera, but please use a more civilized language when you talk to me.You don't like the phrase "poo poo"?
Perhaps it's a cultural mismatch, but you really seem to have an unnecessarily overly high opinion of yourself.I highly respect Phillip and his reviews and contributions, they are very helpful, sincere and thoughtful. Besides, I like his photograps.That's great, but the fact that he "liked" your comment about you liking him says everything I came here to say.Do you really have to take this to a personal level? We have different opinions about a camera, lets argue about that.Actually, it was never about a camera for me.
It was the fact that you criticized people on this board for being too enthusiastic about new gear - and a day later wanted everyone to read what your highness thought about it by visiting your blog, since "you took the time".
And then you continue your arrogance by suggesting that because YOU do not have affiliate programs that somehow your opinion is better than other reviewers, yet your commentary (which i wasted 2 minutes reading) was no more insightful than any of the hundreds of forum posts that have flooded the internet in the past week. Instead, it advances your notion that since YOU don't print larger than 12x18 - well then why would anyone need more than what you use, the original a7....Show more →
If it's not about the camera for you...then move on. This thread is about the camera.
for all of those you joining in the conversation, let me please remind you how this got started with my original post to PR's statement to this thread saying how "surprised he was at all the hype":
Phillip, I know you get a lot of respect around here, you've posted a lot of nice shots. But frankly, I've seen a few people on the web with galleries who shot with an iPhone and theirs look even better, only to prove the point it's never about the equipment.
But even in non technical fields people enjoy their equipment. I know woodworkers who get excited about their tools. The common thread I find amongst artists of any variety is an appreciation for when their tools get out of their way.
The a7r2 improves upon the a7r by getting out of the way in many respects along with advancing the state of the art in others.
Im a forum owner , admin and moderator and trust me I have seen it all. Plus I have been on forums for years and I had my moments for sure. Best advice I can give, sometimes its just best not even to bother. As much as you want to punch that keyboard and say this is the internet and I have my right to a opinion sometimes its best to just change the channel. Myself I have tremendous restraint as I see stuff that is so wrong that you want to correct someone. Sometimes its best to just ignore things. Be it someone has excitement or doubts thats there feelings. BTW the internet has changed everyone and there brother and sister plus even cousin Joey has a blog be it they make money or not they want to be heard and the linking will forever go on. Just the way it is
I know one thing going back to this camera. The more data thats been coming through it sounds better daily. Now do I believe it all 100 percent well like anything else I take a percent of doubt and a percentage of truth and mix it in a bowl and see what happens.
I need something to make me happy right now. Im designing a Program book of about 190 pages with about 1500 head shots with Indesign and almost at the end and half way in the middle of the book this freaking file corrupted and I need to go back and delete about 30 pages and recreate it without a mistake. Been up since 4 am on this crap and Im ready to pull my hair out. Whats left of it
ecarlino wrote:
for all of those you joining in the conversation, let me please remind you how this got started with my original post to PR's statement to this thread saying how "surprised he was at all the hype":
Phillip, I know you get a lot of respect around here, you've posted a lot of nice shots. But frankly, I've seen a few people on the web with galleries who shot with an iPhone and theirs look even better, only to prove the point it's never about the equipment.
But even in non technical fields people enjoy their equipment. I know woodworkers who get excited about their tools. The common thread I find amongst artists of any variety is an appreciation for when their tools get out of their way.
The a7r2 improves upon the a7r by getting out of the way in many respects along with advancing the state of the art in others.
Sorry ecarlino, but I have a hard time taking what you say seriously because you are showing so little respect for Phillip. He is a very talented photographer, and even if someone else has even more talent and so much so that they can post better work with even an iPhone that doesn't mean that we shouldn't respect Phillip for the superb work he has done.
You make a good point that people often enjoy tools that gets out of the way and you hope that the A7r II get our of the way, but that point is hard to appreciate because of your lack of respect for Phillip.
By the way, as woodworking is one of my other hobbies, I thought I would point out it too can be technical.
ecarlino wrote:
for all of those you joining in the conversation, let me please remind you how this got started with my original post to PR's statement to this thread saying how "surprised he was at all the hype":
Phillip, I know you get a lot of respect around here, you've posted a lot of nice shots. But frankly, I've seen a few people on the web with galleries who shot with an iPhone and theirs look even better, only to prove the point it's never about the equipment.
But even in non technical fields people enjoy their equipment. I know woodworkers who get excited about their tools. The common thread I find amongst artists of any variety is an appreciation for when their tools get out of their way.
The a7r2 improves upon the a7r by getting out of the way in many respects along with advancing the state of the art in others.
Keep in mind, Phillip doesn't get a lot of respect here just because he's posted a lot of nice shots. He gets respect here because he has a long history of helpful, courteous contributions to the discussions.
Also explains here why 42 MP was chosen. This leads me to another question - will there even be a sort of A9 camera on the forseeable horizon? It looks like the A7R II contains everything which the A9 should have included as features. What do you guys think?
Also explains here why 42 MP was chosen. This leads me to another question - will there even be a sort of A9 camera on the forseeable horizon? It looks like the A7R II contains everything which the A9 should have included as features. What do you guys think?
I think there will be an A9 camera next year sometime. It will include a larger weather sealed body with likely a larger battery, so the battery won't have to be swapped as often. It will have two card slots (something very important for a lot of pro shooter, e.g., wedding shooters). It will have USB 3.0 (a small thing, but it will matter to some). It will have a nice improvement in the AF and with better tracking. I expect the A7r II to be good, but still not nearly as good as the best DSLRs in tracking AF. The A9 ought to be almost all the way there. It will shoot more frames per second. I expect that it will shoot at least 8 to 10. This can be achieved by just using more computing power and with a bigger body they can dissipate heat easier. The sensor will also be BSI which allows for this high frame rate as well. It might have a higher resolution sensor, but I am not sure it will. I do think it will have a larger higher resolution LCD and it may be fully adjustable. The EVF might well have more resolution and magnification as well. I expect the same shutter and IBIS as the A7r II, and I expect it will have very good 4K video as well. At introduction I expect a price close to $4,000, but I would not be shocked if it was closer to $5,000.
Also explains here why 42 MP was chosen. This leads me to another question - will there even be a sort of A9 camera on the forseeable horizon? It looks like the A7R II contains everything which the A9 should have included as features. What do you guys think?
Thanks for posting this link. If the A7R II is only using phase detect AF with Canon lenses, then there is no AF micro adjustment or contrast detect fine tuning. Is it possible that Sony will offer AF MA on lenses using an adapter? Without something like AF MA it would be pretty frustrating shooting my 20 Canon lenses on this body and expecting to use AF. Maybe I am out of line, but at $3,200 this seems like a required feature for how the camera is being presented and sold.
Also explains here why 42 MP was chosen. This leads me to another question - will there even be a sort of A9 camera on the forseeable horizon? It looks like the A7R II contains everything which the A9 should have included as features. What do you guys think?I think there will be an A9 camera next year sometime. It will include a larger weather sealed body with likely a larger battery, so the battery won't have to be swapped as often. It will have two card slots (something very important for a lot of pro shooter, e.g., wedding shooters). It will have USB 3.0 (a small thing, but it will matter to some). It will have a nice improvement in the AF and with better tracking. I expect the A7r II to be good, but still not nearly as good as the best DSLRs in tracking AF. The A9 ought to be almost all the way there. It will shoot more frames per second. I expect that it will shoot at least 8 to 10. This can be achieved by just using more computing power and with a bigger body they can dissipate heat easier. The sensor will also be BSI which allows for this high frame rate as well. It might have a higher resolution sensor, but I am not sure it will. I do think it will have a larger higher resolution LCD and it may be fully adjustable. The EVF might well have more resolution and magnification as well. I expect the same shutter and IBIS as the A7r II, and I expect it will have very good 4K video as well. At introduction I expect a price close to $4,000, but I would not be shocked if it was closer to $5,000....Show more →
Good points, the A9 might have the same 42 MP sensor or something even bigger than 50 MP which then needs to be a new design according to the statement in my link above. If it provides more MP, it might even a more powerful image processor - not sure if we would see 8 fps. Or the A9 is more an event/action shooting camera which compromises in resolution to get more fps for example. Larger battery also means bigger camera body....reminds me on current smartphone technology where latest models get bigger and bigger in size against the current miniaturization trend. $4K for a mirrorless camera.....wow. Well, maybe professionals are more willing to pay as much if they get the desired performance....but for this price they can easily also get a 5D MkIII or 5Ds......
Also explains here why 42 MP was chosen. This leads me to another question - will there even be a sort of A9 camera on the forseeable horizon? It looks like the A7R II contains everything which the A9 should have included as features. What do you guys think?Thanks for posting this link. If the A7R II is only using phase detect AF with Canon lenses, then there is no AF micro adjustment or contrast detect fine tuning. Is it possible that Sony will offer AF MA on lenses using an adapter? Without something like AF MA it would be pretty frustrating shooting my 20 Canon lenses on this body and expecting to use AF. Maybe I am out of line, but at $3,200 this seems like a required feature for how the camera is being presented and sold.
Good point also - I have no clue how well or bad the AF with Canon lenses on the A7R MkII will work in this regard.
Also explains here why 42 MP was chosen. This leads me to another question - will there even be a sort of A9 camera on the forseeable horizon? It looks like the A7R II contains everything which the A9 should have included as features. What do you guys think?Thanks for posting this link. If the A7R II is only using phase detect AF with Canon lenses, then there is no AF micro adjustment or contrast detect fine tuning. Is it possible that Sony will offer AF MA on lenses using an adapter? Without something like AF MA it would be pretty frustrating shooting my 20 Canon lenses on this body and expecting to use AF. Maybe I am out of line, but at $3,200 this seems like a required feature for how the camera is being presented and sold.
I asked this question earlier thinking there wouldn't be AF fine tuning, phigment who designs adapters thought it could be added by the adapter, and thinking more about it Bo Ming who works for metabones developed AF micro adjustment for Contax N lenses covered to EF mount when he was converting lenses for Conurus, so I think it is likely that metabones will be able to offer AF micro adjust.
Also explains here why 42 MP was chosen. This leads me to another question - will there even be a sort of A9 camera on the forseeable horizon? It looks like the A7R II contains everything which the A9 should have included as features. What do you guys think?Thanks for posting this link. If the A7R II is only using phase detect AF with Canon lenses, then there is no AF micro adjustment or contrast detect fine tuning. Is it possible that Sony will offer AF MA on lenses using an adapter? Without something like AF MA it would be pretty frustrating shooting my 20 Canon lenses on this body and expecting to use AF. Maybe I am out of line, but at $3,200 this seems like a required feature for how the camera is being presented and sold.
A sensor-based PDAF system should not require an AF tuning mechanism. The reason a traditional PDAF system requires it is because the optical path to the PDAF sensors is separate from the optical path to the image sensor and because of this it's susceptible to alignment differentials caused by lens aberrations, mirror misalignment, phase sensor misalignment, etc. Btw, current A7-series cameras do have an AF adjustment feature even for CDAF-only bodies like the A7r; it's not clear what it does or how it works though.
BTW on SAR in a interview the raw compression will be fixed. It will be a firmware upgrade. No rumor
The reports of Canon lenses looks better everyday. They say this is faster than the A7II with regards to AF. The more I read and I take in about 50 percent as truth than we are looking pretty darn good here. If it beats my A7II and said to work as good as Canon bodies with Canon lenses than Im sitting here with a smile. Can you all do me a big favor sleep in the morning so I can get my order in ahead of you all.
Also explains here why 42 MP was chosen. This leads me to another question - will there even be a sort of A9 camera on the forseeable horizon? It looks like the A7R II contains everything which the A9 should have included as features. What do you guys think?Thanks for posting this link. If the A7R II is only using phase detect AF with Canon lenses, then there is no AF micro adjustment or contrast detect fine tuning. Is it possible that Sony will offer AF MA on lenses using an adapter? Without something like AF MA it would be pretty frustrating shooting my 20 Canon lenses on this body and expecting to use AF. Maybe I am out of line, but at $3,200 this seems like a required feature for how the camera is being presented and sold.A sensor-based PDAF system should not require an AF tuning mechanism. The reason a traditional PDAF system requires it is because the optical path to the PDAF sensors is separate from the optical path to the image sensor and because of this it's susceptible to alignment differentials caused by lens aberrations, mirror misalignment, phase sensor misalignment, etc. Btw, current A7-series cameras do have an AF adjustment feature even for CDAF-only bodies like the A7r; it's not clear what it does or how it works though.
Good points. AF seems like a topic that should just be put aside until the A7R II is shipping and the actual performance can be analyzed. It seems clear that significant progress has been made here; the only question is will it be enough to use in demanding situations where you need results.
GMPhotography wrote:
BTW on SAR in a interview the raw compression will be fixed. It will be a firmware upgrade. No rumor
I see the key words "could", "should", "we are working on it" and specifically with regard to firmware, the non-committal "could" shows up again. Maybe I missed the definitive "will be fixed" part?
I am almost sure that the uncompressed RAW will compromise the speed/buffer of the camera. Storage space is one thing and SD cards are inexpensive nowadays but I am afraid that that feature it would turn the A7r II into a strictly studio/landscape camera. But at least, we would have the option to select what we want. Add a non-lossy compression as another option and we are all good .
tsdevine wrote:
I'm just waiting until everyone clamoring for uncompressed RAW get their wish.....and then realize they really wanted non-lossy compressed RAW.
-Tim
I'd like lossy compression, lossless compression, and uncompressed as the three options and let me choose which. I assume that things will get slow, but for me that's OK as 1 fps is really fast.
Choice is good! We might just have to wait a while to get it.