Also explains here why 42 MP was chosen. This leads me to another question - will there even be a sort of A9 camera on the forseeable horizon? It looks like the A7R II contains everything which the A9 should have included as features. What do you guys think?Thanks for posting this link. If the A7R II is only using phase detect AF with Canon lenses, then there is no AF micro adjustment or contrast detect fine tuning. Is it possible that Sony will offer AF MA on lenses using an adapter? Without something like AF MA it would be pretty frustrating shooting my 20 Canon lenses on this body and expecting to use AF. Maybe I am out of line, but at $3,200 this seems like a required feature for how the camera is being presented and sold.A sensor-based PDAF system should not require an AF tuning mechanism. The reason a traditional PDAF system requires it is because the optical path to the PDAF sensors is separate from the optical path to the image sensor and because of this it's susceptible to alignment differentials caused by lens aberrations, mirror misalignment, phase sensor misalignment, etc. Btw, current A7-series cameras do have an AF adjustment feature even for CDAF-only bodies like the A7r; it's not clear what it does or how it works though.
At least with Nikon systems the AF fine tune is to compensate for both the AF system mis-adjustment AND lens problems since the PDAF system calculates what it thinks the lens is supposed to do, then tells the lens and never checks back to make sure things are in focus. So with a pure PDAF lens you can still need AF fine tune, but it would be just to compensate for the lens.
Hopefully a hybrid system that uses both CDAF and PDAF together is what they are doing.
Also explains here why 42 MP was chosen. This leads me to another question - will there even be a sort of A9 camera on the forseeable horizon? It looks like the A7R II contains everything which the A9 should have included as features. What do you guys think?Thanks for posting this link. If the A7R II is only using phase detect AF with Canon lenses, then there is no AF micro adjustment or contrast detect fine tuning. Is it possible that Sony will offer AF MA on lenses using an adapter? Without something like AF MA it would be pretty frustrating shooting my 20 Canon lenses on this body and expecting to use AF. Maybe I am out of line, but at $3,200 this seems like a required feature for how the camera is being presented and sold.A sensor-based PDAF system should not require an AF tuning mechanism. The reason a traditional PDAF system requires it is because the optical path to the PDAF sensors is separate from the optical path to the image sensor and because of this it's susceptible to alignment differentials caused by lens aberrations, mirror misalignment, phase sensor misalignment, etc. Btw, current A7-series cameras do have an AF adjustment feature even for CDAF-only bodies like the A7r; it's not clear what it does or how it works though.At least with Nikon systems the AF fine tune is to compensate for both the AF system mis-adjustment AND lens problems since the PDAF system calculates what it thinks the lens is supposed to do, then tells the lens and never checks back to make sure things are in focus. So with a pure PDAF lens you can still need AF fine tune, but it would be just to compensate for the lens.
Hopefully a hybrid system that uses both CDAF and PDAF together is what they are doing.
The AF tune adjustment for all DSLR PDAF systems is to adjust for the optical path to the PDAF sensors only. That's the only way it can work - you can't introduce a lens-movement bias into a semi-closed loop system (link) because that bias would be feed back into the multiple AF commands sent to the lens (more details in my thread here). This is why lenses on DSLRs can be AF tuned via DotTune without ever having to engage the AF mechanism of the camera or lens. It's also why MF lenses can be tuned via the same adjustment method.
Also explains here why 42 MP was chosen. This leads me to another question - will there even be a sort of A9 camera on the forseeable horizon? It looks like the A7R II contains everything which the A9 should have included as features. What do you guys think?Thanks for posting this link. If the A7R II is only using phase detect AF with Canon lenses, then there is no AF micro adjustment or contrast detect fine tuning. Is it possible that Sony will offer AF MA on lenses using an adapter? Without something like AF MA it would be pretty frustrating shooting my 20 Canon lenses on this body and expecting to use AF. Maybe I am out of line, but at $3,200 this seems like a required feature for how the camera is being presented and sold.A sensor-based PDAF system should not require an AF tuning mechanism. The reason a traditional PDAF system requires it is because the optical path to the PDAF sensors is separate from the optical path to the image sensor and because of this it's susceptible to alignment differentials caused by lens aberrations, mirror misalignment, phase sensor misalignment, etc. Btw, current A7-series cameras do have an AF adjustment feature even for CDAF-only bodies like the A7r; it's not clear what it does or how it works though.At least with Nikon systems the AF fine tune is to compensate for both the AF system mis-adjustment AND lens problems since the PDAF system calculates what it thinks the lens is supposed to do, then tells the lens and never checks back to make sure things are in focus. So with a pure PDAF lens you can still need AF fine tune, but it would be just to compensate for the lens.
Hopefully a hybrid system that uses both CDAF and PDAF together is what they are doing.The AF tune adjustment for all DSLR PDAF systems is to adjust for the optical path to the PDAF sensors only. That's the only way it can work - you can't introduce a lens-movement bias into a semi-closed loop system (link) because that bias would be feed back into the multiple AF commands sent to the lens (more details in my thread here). This is why lenses on DSLRs can be AF tuned via DotTune without ever having to engage the AF mechanism of the camera or lens. It's also why MF lenses can be tuned via the same adjustment method....Show more →
Since DotTune and focus confirmation works for MF lenses, we can deduct that AFMA is implemented as an offset on the phase information output from the PDAF sensor. This offset is then applied to the algorithm checking that the phase difference is within the window for giving a green blink.
However, this does not mean that it is used to compensate for the optical path difference bewteen PDAF sensor and image sensor only. It also effectively compensates for calibration error in AF lenses. If not, so it would be impossible to close the loop, and we wouldn't need AFMA for individual lenses in the first place.
So then the different AF fine tune adjustment necessary between different copies of the same lens are due to different optical aberrations and not due to different movement accuracies of the AF mechanism in the lens (or is it both?)? Or perhaps due to the slightly different lens mount differences of each lens (to the exit pupil?
jhinkey wrote:
So then the different AF fine tune adjustment necessary between different copies of the same lens are due to different optical aberrations and not due to different movement accuracies of the AF mechanism in the lens (or is it both?)? Or perhaps due to the slightly different lens mount differences of each lens (to the exit pupil?
Out of my league here obviously.
I would say mostly due to different movement of the AF mecahnism, but also due to microscopic lens mount / optical elements calibration differences. The nice thing is, that as long as it is within the PDAF loop, and is consistent, it doesn't matter.
I'm probably just waiting for 1-2 years while the A7R II falls in price. I'll probably pick up some native E-mount lenses in the meantime and perhaps an A7 II this upcoming Christmas if I can find a good bargain for one. If it's true about autofocus speed with adapted lenses, I would be tempted in switching from Nikon to Canon to gain access to certain lenses.
jonrock wrote:
I'm probably just waiting for 1-2 years while the A7R II falls in price. I'll probably pick up some native E-mount lenses in the meantime and perhaps an A7 II this upcoming Christmas if I can find a good bargain for one. If it's true about autofocus speed with adapted lenses, I would be tempted in switching from Nikon to Canon to gain access to certain lenses.
I won't be switching to Canon any time soon, but I've been so happy with the full time IBIS in my EM1 that I think I'm going to order the A7RII right away - I still have to wait until August to get one - perhaps it will be in time for an upcoming climb. Inability to quickly focus my legacy glass with the A7R due to the non-steady image in the viewfinder is one of the reasons I sold it (plus I got a great deal on it and essentially sold it for what I paid 9 months later). IBIS and the fully electronic shutter are killer for me . . .
As I did with the A7R, I will use A7RII along side with my D800 with my Nikon mount MF primes - 16/3.5 FE, 20/2.8AIS, 45/2.8P, 90/3.5CV, 135/2 Zeiss (and AIS), 180/3.4 APO Telyt, and 400/5.6 ED AI.
ecarlino wrote: thedictionary wroteWell it would have certainly helped if he spelled it correctly.FYI, "poo poo" is a slang and as such has a variety of spellings:
Sorry to register just to say this, but please accept when you are wrong.
Urbandictionary is a site where someone can upload a word and a meaning, any meaning. It's not necessarily a slang term or a colloquialism, it can be something someone simply makes up. Wikipedia used to (perhaps it still does) have this problem because anyone could edit the pages.
If you actually look at the definition provided by the person on urbandictionary, it says
"Claiming something to be useless, unnecessary, stupid, or dumb. Characterizing an action as superfluous or unimportant"
Now if you look at the definition of pooh poohing,
"To express disdain or scorn for; dismiss or belittle"
The meanings are basically the same only the urbandictionary version is not worded as well and makes no logical sense when looking at the etymology. It is quite clear that both you, and him, do not know how to spell the word "pooh poohed".
To say "pooh"; to make a dismissive, contemptuous sound. Therefore, pooh poohed means you (object; transitive verb) are being dismissive. "Poo" meaning excrement, would mean "poo pooing" has a TOTALLY different meaning, if we're to stand by the etymological context. Therefore, the phrase "poo pooing" is simply illogical and it is quite apparent that it's a misspelling.
That is fair enough but at least accept when you have been proven wrong. Like I said, I didn't want to be a grammar nazi, but "pooh poohed" or "pooh poohing" is simply NOT slang. It's in the dictionary. Your post is comparable to saying "I live in a howse", I say "it's spelled house", and you say "howse is slang for a place you live in!"
Moreover, slang means "a type of language consisting of words and phrases that are regarded as very informal, are more common in speech than writing, and are typically restricted to a particular context or group of people." The pronunciation of "poo pooing" and "pooh poohing", is EXACTLY the same so how can it be a slang term if it sounds the same when spoken, and has an almost if not identical meaning? I suggest you get a refund from wherever you studied, lol.
Excrement is often the basis of swearwords and insults, so if you're going to misspell "pooh" as "poo", then at least give some thought about what you are saying.
ecarlino wrote: Phillip Reeve wroteI took the time to write a bit more extensively about the cameraWhy?
Have you gotten your hands on one?
Just yesterday you were on here poo-pooing everyone else's enthusiasm, now we should hop on over to your 'blog' to see what sort of thoughts you can divine?
You've included a hyphen, so even if you are going to clutch at straws and claim you mean the urbandictionary version of the word, it's still illogical because the hyphen changes the meaning a second time and the urbandictionary link you provided has no hyphen. At least you didn't say you like cooking your family and your pets. Perhaps I mean you like cooking, your family and your pets. In either case, I'm sure even after 9,000 words have been spilled to try help you understand, you'd argue and use any site to prove your point. http://pastebin.com/S6mEDsep it looks like someone agrees.
Phillip, in some ways I even regret defending him and arguing against you. While I still think you could have worded your argument slightly better, I'm not sure it would have made a difference against this guy. I explained thoroughly how he is wrong and he still persists, by linking to urbandictionary as some form of authoritative article!?
I should end my post on a positive note. It would be nice if sony added a gasket to their sealed lenses or if zeiss added sealing to their lenses with a gasket as they make a nice combination for this camera. If anyone gets this camera and uses a zeiss manual focus lens, please let us know what it's like in a dusty environment. I'm concerned about the lack of sealing in both the camera and the lens
Love how people have to be right all the time. Time to move on.
Today is the day to put your wallet to the test. Leap of faith? Feeling crazy? Money to burn? Bored? Really hoping this is the ONE? Have faith in Sony to pull it off?
My gut says gen 2 this one hits the mark. One needs to remember one thing. First there is no perfect camera just like there is no perfect spouse. You marry it you learn to love it and accept the compromises. That's life
The trick is at least get close to what you want and need the rest will fall into place. We are not perfect either
alwang wrote: ecarlino wrotefor all of those you joining in the conversation, let me please remind you how this got started with my original post to PR's statement to this thread saying how "surprised he was at all the hype":
Phillip, I know you get a lot of respect around here, you've posted a lot of nice shots. But frankly, I've seen a few people on the web with galleries who shot with an iPhone and theirs look even better, only to prove the point it's never about the equipment.
But even in non technical fields people enjoy their equipment. I know woodworkers who get excited about their tools. The common thread I find amongst artists of any variety is an appreciation for when their tools get out of their way.
The a7r2 improves upon the a7r by getting out of the way in many respects along with advancing the state of the art in others.
Enjoy your a7. Contentment is a virtue.Keep in mind, Phillip doesn't get a lot of respect here just because he's posted a lot of nice shots. He gets respect here because he has a long history of helpful, courteous contributions to the discussions.
Exactly. Philip has been a great contributor for the Sony A7 series and lenses very early on. His pictures are great too. I value the opinion from someone like him a lot more than those who just argue and talk...
Looking to get in-body stabilization via either the A7II, or A7RII. Personally, don't need the megapixels, either for cropping or monster prints, so discounted prices on gently used A7II may be the way to go. The faster focusing of the A7RII is appealing, though. At this point, I'm buying most of my Sony gear used. Owners get bored quickly and that provides much saner deals for the lot of us who aren't independently wealthy, pros, or are willing to go into debt for the sake of the latest and greatest, which only ages out in six months....
Also explains here why 42 MP was chosen. This leads me to another question - will there even be a sort of A9 camera on the forseeable horizon? It looks like the A7R II contains everything which the A9 should have included as features. What do you guys think?Thanks for posting this link. If the A7R II is only using phase detect AF with Canon lenses, then there is no AF micro adjustment or contrast detect fine tuning. Is it possible that Sony will offer AF MA on lenses using an adapter? Without something like AF MA it would be pretty frustrating shooting my 20 Canon lenses on this body and expecting to use AF. Maybe I am out of line, but at $3,200 this seems like a required feature for how the camera is being presented and sold.A sensor-based PDAF system should not require an AF tuning mechanism. The reason a traditional PDAF system requires it is because the optical path to the PDAF sensors is separate from the optical path to the image sensor and because of this it's susceptible to alignment differentials caused by lens aberrations, mirror misalignment, phase sensor misalignment, etc. Btw, current A7-series cameras do have an AF adjustment feature even for CDAF-only bodies like the A7r; it's not clear what it does or how it works though.At least with Nikon systems the AF fine tune is to compensate for both the AF system mis-adjustment AND lens problems since the PDAF system calculates what it thinks the lens is supposed to do, then tells the lens and never checks back to make sure things are in focus. So with a pure PDAF lens you can still need AF fine tune, but it would be just to compensate for the lens.
Hopefully a hybrid system that uses both CDAF and PDAF together is what they are doing.The AF tune adjustment for all DSLR PDAF systems is to adjust for the optical path to the PDAF sensors only. That's the only way it can work - you can't introduce a lens-movement bias into a semi-closed loop system (link) because that bias would be feed back into the multiple AF commands sent to the lens (more details in my thread here). This is why lenses on DSLRs can be AF tuned via DotTune without ever having to engage the AF mechanism of the camera or lens. It's also why MF lenses can be tuned via the same adjustment method.Since DotTune and focus confirmation works for MF lenses, we can deduct that AFMA is implemented as an offset on the phase information output from the PDAF sensor. This offset is then applied to the algorithm checking that the phase difference is within the window for giving a green blink.
However, this does not mean that it is used to compensate for the optical path difference bewteen PDAF sensor and image sensor only. It also effectively compensates for calibration error in AF lenses. If not, so it would be impossible to close the loop, and we wouldn't need AFMA for individual lenses in the first place. ...Show more →
There is no way to introduce a single movement bias into a closed-loop "sense+movement" system without that movement bias being eliminated by the recursion of the system itself. It would be possible if there were two AF tune values - the existing in-band sensing bias plus an additional out-of-band movement bias. And the proof is in the pudding - I've never handled a lens that required engaging AF system movement (lens motor or body) to tune properly, out of about 50 lenses I've tuned for myself and others. In fact, it's the requirement that an AF acquisition occur that makes other tuning methods prone to error because they introduce AF motor mechanical variability into what is strictly an optical issue. A lens can be out-of-spec with respect to its positioning mechanism but that can't be solved reliably by existing AF tune values because again that is only used as an offset into the sensing. Those lenses have to be calibrated mechanically using the adjustment points provided in the design.
The reason individual lenses need AFMA (in addition to body calibration issues like mirror misalignment) is due to lens-specific aberrations, specifically decentered or tilted elements that affect the two optical paths to the phase sensors.
snapsy wrote:
There is no way to introduce a single movement bias into a closed-loop "sense+movement" system without that movement bias being eliminated by the recursion of the system itself. It would be possible if there were two AF tune values - the existing in-band sensing bias plus an additional out-of-band movement bias. And the proof is in the pudding - I've never handled a lens that required engaging AF system movement (lens motor or body) to tune properly, out of about 50 lenses I've tuned for myself and others. In fact, it's the requirement that an AF acquisition occur that makes other tuning methods prone to error because they introduce AF motor mechanical variability into what is strictly an optical issue. A lens can be out-of-spec with respect to its positioning mechanism but that can't be solved reliably by existing AF tune values because again that is only used as an offset into the sensing. Those lenses have to be calibrated mechanically using the adjustment points provided in the design.
The reason individual lenses need AFMA (in addition to body calibration issues like mirror misalignment) is due to lens-specific aberrations, specifically decentered or tilted elements that affect the two optical paths to the phase sensors....Show more →
I'm inclined to agree with this interpretation. If the camera issued absolute positioning commands to the lens (e.g. move to position x) then you could have a lens that required microadjust on a perfect camera body, if every time it was told to "move to x", it actually moved to x+1.
However it seems much more likely that the camera issues relative movement commands, "move forward x units", "move backwards y units". Then microadjust wouldn't work - either the lens moves less than it is supposed to each time, then AF will just be slower and require move move commands (since we know it operates until lock is confirmed) or the lens moves more than it is supposed to each time, in which case it will oscillate and never lock on focus.
Matt Grum wrote: snapsy wroteThere is no way to introduce a single movement bias into a closed-loop "sense+movement" system without that movement bias being eliminated by the recursion of the system itself. It would be possible if there were two AF tune values - the existing in-band sensing bias plus an additional out-of-band movement bias. And the proof is in the pudding - I've never handled a lens that required engaging AF system movement (lens motor or body) to tune properly, out of about 50 lenses I've tuned for myself and others. In fact, it's the requirement that an AF acquisition occur that makes other tuning methods prone to error because they introduce AF motor mechanical variability into what is strictly an optical issue. A lens can be out-of-spec with respect to its positioning mechanism but that can't be solved reliably by existing AF tune values because again that is only used as an offset into the sensing. Those lenses have to be calibrated mechanically using the adjustment points provided in the design.
The reason individual lenses need AFMA (in addition to body calibration issues like mirror misalignment) is due to lens-specific aberrations, specifically decentered or tilted elements that affect the two optical paths to the phase sensors.I'm inclined to agree with this interpretation. If the camera issued absolute positioning commands to the lens (e.g. move to position x) then you could have a lens that required microadjust on a perfect camera body, if every time it was told to "move to x", it actually moved to x+1.
However it seems much more likely that the camera issues relative movement commands, "move forward x units", "move backwards y units". Then microadjust wouldn't work - either the lens moves less than it is supposed to each time, then AF will just be slower and require move move commands (since we know it operates until lock is confirmed) or the lens moves more than it is supposed to each time, in which case it will oscillate and never lock on focus....Show more →
Both absolute and relative movement commands would suffer the same bias-cancelling result in a single-bias close-loop system. PDAF relies on the sensing phase to know when AF has been acquired and since the tune value is a bias into this phase it can't also serve as a bias into the movement; if it did then you'd have an infinite loop of sensing+movement operations. For example, if the final lens movement to +x adjust produced objectively perfect focus it would then be sensed as OOF by the sensing portion of the system because that same +x bias is applied to the evaluation of the phase-sensing differential. And we know the bias is always applied to the phase-sensing differential by dint of being able to tune lenses without ever engaging the AF system; more direct proof is the fact that if you take a perfectly focused subject and then change the AF tune value, the VF dot-confirmation will flicker to indicate that the camera no longer believes the subject is in focus.
snapsy wrote:
There is no way to introduce a single movement bias into a closed-loop "sense+movement" system without that movement bias being eliminated by the recursion of the system itself. It would be possible if there were two AF tune values - the existing in-band sensing bias plus an additional out-of-band movement bias. And the proof is in the pudding - I've never handled a lens that required engaging AF system movement (lens motor or body) to tune properly, out of about 50 lenses I've tuned for myself and others. In fact, it's the requirement that an AF acquisition occur that makes other tuning methods prone to error because they introduce AF motor mechanical variability into what is strictly an optical issue. A lens can be out-of-spec with respect to its positioning mechanism but that can't be solved reliably by existing AF tune values because again that is only used as an offset into the sensing. Those lenses have to be calibrated mechanically using the adjustment points provided in the design.
The reason individual lenses need AFMA (in addition to body calibration issues like mirror misalignment) is due to lens-specific aberrations, specifically decentered or tilted elements that affect the two optical paths to the phase sensors....Show more →
What difference does it make to the loop if:
A: The AF drive system sets the focus distance to 10.1 m nominally and the real focus distance becomes 1.02 m because of miscalibrated AF drive, or
B: The AF drive system sets the focus distance to 10.1 m nominally and the real focus distance becomes 1.02 m because of misaligned elements
alundeb wrote: snapsy wroteThere is no way to introduce a single movement bias into a closed-loop "sense+movement" system without that movement bias being eliminated by the recursion of the system itself. It would be possible if there were two AF tune values - the existing in-band sensing bias plus an additional out-of-band movement bias. And the proof is in the pudding - I've never handled a lens that required engaging AF system movement (lens motor or body) to tune properly, out of about 50 lenses I've tuned for myself and others. In fact, it's the requirement that an AF acquisition occur that makes other tuning methods prone to error because they introduce AF motor mechanical variability into what is strictly an optical issue. A lens can be out-of-spec with respect to its positioning mechanism but that can't be solved reliably by existing AF tune values because again that is only used as an offset into the sensing. Those lenses have to be calibrated mechanically using the adjustment points provided in the design.
The reason individual lenses need AFMA (in addition to body calibration issues like mirror misalignment) is due to lens-specific aberrations, specifically decentered or tilted elements that affect the two optical paths to the phase sensors.What difference does it make to the loop if:
A: The AF drive system sets the focus distance to 10.1 m nominally and the real focus distance becomes 1.02 m because of miscalibrated AF drive, or
B: The AF drive system sets the focus distance to 10.1 m nominally and the real focus distance becomes 1.02 m because of misaligned elements
The difference is that AF tune as designed today can account for B but not A, for reasons I listed in earlier posts. To account for A in its current design the AF tune mechanism would would have to ignore its last sensing operation since that sensing would show that focus is off by the phase equivalent of .08m if the last movement operation included a +.08m bias.
snapsy wrote: alundeb wrotesnapsy wroteThere is no way to introduce a single movement bias into a closed-loop "sense+movement" system without that movement bias being eliminated by the recursion of the system itself. It would be possible if there were two AF tune values - the existing in-band sensing bias plus an additional out-of-band movement bias. And the proof is in the pudding - I've never handled a lens that required engaging AF system movement (lens motor or body) to tune properly, out of about 50 lenses I've tuned for myself and others. In fact, it's the requirement that an AF acquisition occur that makes other tuning methods prone to error because they introduce AF motor mechanical variability into what is strictly an optical issue. A lens can be out-of-spec with respect to its positioning mechanism but that can't be solved reliably by existing AF tune values because again that is only used as an offset into the sensing. Those lenses have to be calibrated mechanically using the adjustment points provided in the design.
The reason individual lenses need AFMA (in addition to body calibration issues like mirror misalignment) is due to lens-specific aberrations, specifically decentered or tilted elements that affect the two optical paths to the phase sensors.What difference does it make to the loop if:
A: The AF drive system sets the focus distance to 10.1 m nominally and the real focus distance becomes 1.02 m because of miscalibrated AF drive, or
B: The AF drive system sets the focus distance to 10.1 m nominally and the real focus distance becomes 1.02 m because of misaligned elements
The difference is that AF tune as designed today can account for B but not A, for reasons I listed in earlier posts. To account for A in its current design the AF tune mechanism would would have to ignore its last sensing operation since that sensing would show that focus is off by the phase equivalent of .08m if the last movement operation included a +.08m bias.
Now I see what you mean. AFMA cannot compensate for a mismatch between The AF drive and sense if implemented as you describe. I was thinking of the AF drive and AF sense in the lens as one unit.
What I really meant to point out, more specifically, was:
What difference does it make to the loop if:
A: The AF drive system sets the focus distance to 10.1 m nominally, and the AF sense reports 10.1 m, and the real focus distance becomes 10.2 m because of miscalibrated AF both drive and sense, or
B: The AF drive system sets the focus distance to 10.1 m nominally, and the AF sense reports 10.1 m, and the real focus distance becomes 10.2 m because of misaligned elements
snapsy wrote:
Both absolute and relative movement commands would suffer the same bias-cancelling result in a single-bias close-loop system. PDAF relies on the sensing phase to know when AF has been acquired and since the tune value is a bias into this phase it can't also serve as a bias into the movement
Yeah I realised this about five minutes after making that post - if the AF is a multi-read closed loop system, as the very-long-dpreview-article-that-I-haven't-quite-read-all-of claims, then the only source of errors can be in the AF sensor itself (either the position of the sensor being out, or spherical aberration making the measured correlation wrong).
If the AF sensor is working properly it will always be able to tell if the lens moved incorrectly!
alundeb wrote: snapsy wrotealundeb wrotesnapsy wroteThere is no way to introduce a single movement bias into a closed-loop "sense+movement" system without that movement bias being eliminated by the recursion of the system itself. It would be possible if there were two AF tune values - the existing in-band sensing bias plus an additional out-of-band movement bias. And the proof is in the pudding - I've never handled a lens that required engaging AF system movement (lens motor or body) to tune properly, out of about 50 lenses I've tuned for myself and others. In fact, it's the requirement that an AF acquisition occur that makes other tuning methods prone to error because they introduce AF motor mechanical variability into what is strictly an optical issue. A lens can be out-of-spec with respect to its positioning mechanism but that can't be solved reliably by existing AF tune values because again that is only used as an offset into the sensing. Those lenses have to be calibrated mechanically using the adjustment points provided in the design.
The reason individual lenses need AFMA (in addition to body calibration issues like mirror misalignment) is due to lens-specific aberrations, specifically decentered or tilted elements that affect the two optical paths to the phase sensors.What difference does it make to the loop if:
A: The AF drive system sets the focus distance to 10.1 m nominally and the real focus distance becomes 1.02 m because of miscalibrated AF drive, or
B: The AF drive system sets the focus distance to 10.1 m nominally and the real focus distance becomes 1.02 m because of misaligned elements
The difference is that AF tune as designed today can account for B but not A, for reasons I listed in earlier posts. To account for A in its current design the AF tune mechanism would would have to ignore its last sensing operation since that sensing would show that focus is off by the phase equivalent of .08m if the last movement operation included a +.08m bias.Now I see what you mean. AFMA cannot compensate for a mismatch between The AF drive and sense if implemented as you describe. I was thinking of the AF drive and AF sense as one unit.
What I really ment to point out, more specifically, was:
What difference does it make to the loop if:
A: The AF drive system sets the focus distance to 10.1 m nominally, and the AF sense reports 10.1 m, and the real focus distance becomes 10.2 m because of miscalibrated AF both drive and sense, or
B: The AF drive system sets the focus distance to 10.1 m nominally, and the AF sense reports 10.1 m, and the real focus distance becomes 1.02 m because of misaligned elements
Not sure if for B you mean misalignment for sensing or movement. I don't think misaligned elements can cause misfocusing in terms of movement; they could cause misfocus in terms of sensing, esp for the peripheral AF points that would be more sensitive to the misalignment. At least for decentered/tilted misalignments. If instead by misaligned you mean the focusable element within the lens is misaligned such that its position is wrong relative to where the AF drive though it put the lens. I believe most USM systems have positional sensing mechanisms that account for that and so they don't rely on absolute element position assumptions.
Lastly, if by misaligned you mean as detected by phase sensing afterwards (which would be correct and what I think you meant), then there would be no difference between A and B as both would be detected as out-of-phase by the sensing mechanism. But in both cases there may not be a final AF movement to correct that differential for a given PDAF acquisition cycle; as the experiments in this article demonstrated, the system is not entirely closed loop; sometimes the system will perform a final AF movement and either not re-sense the phase or not correct if the phase is slightly off, likely because it thinks it's already "close enough" to not warrant the performance penalty of another movement cycle.