fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015A7rII game plan. What are you doing

  
 
justruss
Offline
Details
p.12 #1A7rII game plan. What are you doing
mmurph wrote:
GMPhotography wroteSony kind of screwed us by keep discounting the A7r and used prices have pretty much tanked. Lets face it I got 1200 for my A7r and that was with extras so I lost or depreciated 1k or more in my time with it.
This is where the non-pros really need to take a close look at their needs versus their wants. For a pro, $1,000 per year is a pretty small expense. Especially compared to the film days that we were talking about.

The depreciation on a $3200 camera is probably going to be similar to or greater than the depreciation on that $2,200 A7R. The depreciation on the Nikon D800 and D800E and D810 have all been pretty substantial too.

But for someone like me, who is no longer a pro, and who isn't a landscape photographer - who is not making big
...Show more →

If one is in any way cash-constrained (most of us) and not a professional photographer-- waiting is always prudent. If you can make it to 12 or 18 months you can get massive discounts, avoid most of the day-zero design issues/defects, and buy into a system with a lot more confidence regarding what you're getting.

Even as a professional photographer it often makes sense waiting-- but the evaluation moves further towards the need spectrum and away from the want spectrum when it comes to managing a purchase like this. There's also tax/income strategy to take into consideration (I, for instance, have a year where I should be trying to buy as much gear as possible... front loading spending for a few years).

But remember, for most professional photographers... the price isn't really $3,200. That price reduces our income and therefore out taxes. If we're (un)lucky enough to live in the EU (rumors of €3,500 msrp, which is absurd), where list prices include VAT, most of us don't have to pay VAT on business purchases (so, for instance, in Germany, subtract 19% from the price immediately and then reduce our income by what's leftover).

And of course that's not to mention we should pay back the body in anywhere from 1/5th of to 3 assignments/gigs.

Look at the A7r... it's getting down to around $1K about now. That's an incredible buy if you could have waited + can hold back the temptation to get the newest, greatest, (least bug-fixed) model on the market.

Side Note: These non-native AF tests do tempt me to keep my 35L to at least try it out...
Jun 16, 2015 at 12:43 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.12 #2A7rII game plan. What are you doing
Phillip Reeve wrote:
and I turn if off the moment I take it away from my eye..



This.

With all of these cameras, keeping a video feed from the sensor to either the EVF or the LCD is responsible for almost all of the power consumption. AFAIK there is no workaround with settings, the camera needs to be turned off when you don't use it. I have got 2500 shots from one battery on a NEX camera with AF and OSS engaged in every shot, in continuous shooting with refocusing every time. Cycling power does not cost much more power that keeping the camera on for the startup-time period.

Jun 16, 2015 at 12:55 AM
ecarlino
Offline
Details
p.12 #3A7rII game plan. What are you doing
Phillip Reeve wrote:
ecarlino wrote
Phillip Reeve wroteI took the time to write a bit more extensively about the camera
Why?
Have you gotten your hands on one?
Just yesterday you were on here poo-pooing everyone else's enthusiasm, now we should hop on over to your 'blog' to see what sort of thoughts you can divine?
Because there is plenty of over enthusiastic writing in the net and I wanted to expand a but on my point of view. I think it's fine if we disagree, after all it's just a camera, but please use a more civilized language when you talk to me.


You don't like the phrase "poo poo"?
Perhaps it's a cultural mismatch, but you really seem to have an unnecessarily overly high opinion of yourself.

Jun 16, 2015 at 01:08 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.12 #4A7rII game plan. What are you doing
ecarlino wrote:
Phillip Reeve wrote
ecarlino wrote
Phillip Reeve wroteI took the time to write a bit more extensively about the camera
Why?
Have you gotten your hands on one?
Just yesterday you were on here poo-pooing everyone else's enthusiasm, now we should hop on over to your 'blog' to see what sort of thoughts you can divine?
Because there is plenty of over enthusiastic writing in the net and I wanted to expand a but on my point of view. I think it's fine if we disagree, after all it's just a camera, but please use a more civilized language when you talk to me.
You don't like the phrase "poo poo"?
Perhaps it's a cultural mismatch, but you really seem to have an unnecessarily overly high opinion of yourself.



I highly respect Phillip and his reviews and contributions, they are very helpful, sincere and thoughtful. Besides, I like his photograps.
Jun 16, 2015 at 01:17 AM
jonrock
Offline
Details
p.12 #5A7rII game plan. What are you doing
EB-1 wrote:
I normally get 2000-2500 frames from the 5D III on a single battery charge at normal temperatures. Recently I had 2246 with 37% left for example. It does drop noticeably in very cold temperatures.

I got about 400 frames before the A7r was rather low, though that was with some manual focusing. I hope the A7rII is more battery efficient.

EBH


I don't think it will be. The EVF and the IBIS probably drain out a lot of power compared to the A7r. If specification sheet I read on the camera is accurate, it's only rated for 290 shots CIPA though that would probably vary depending on your usage.

Edited on Jun 16, 2015 at 03:03 AM · View previous versions
Jun 16, 2015 at 02:04 AM
ecarlino
Offline
Details
p.12 #6A7rII game plan. What are you doing
alundeb wrote:
ecarlino wrote
Phillip Reeve wrote
ecarlino wrote
Phillip Reeve wroteI took the time to write a bit more extensively about the camera
Why?
Have you gotten your hands on one?
Just yesterday you were on here poo-pooing everyone else's enthusiasm, now we should hop on over to your 'blog' to see what sort of thoughts you can divine?
Because there is plenty of over enthusiastic writing in the net and I wanted to expand a but on my point of view. I think it's fine if we disagree, after all it's just a camera, but please use a more civilized language when you talk to me.
You don't like the phrase "poo poo"?
Perhaps it's a cultural mismatch, but you really seem to have an unnecessarily overly high opinion of yourself.
I highly respect Phillip and his reviews and contributions, they are very helpful, sincere and thoughtful. Besides, I like his photograps.


That's great, but the fact that he "liked" your comment about you liking him says everything I came here to say.
Jun 16, 2015 at 02:25 AM
Phillip Reeve
Offline
Details
p.12 #7A7rII game plan. What are you doing


ecarlino wrote:
alundeb wrote
ecarlino wrote
Phillip Reeve wrote
ecarlino wrote
Phillip Reeve wroteI took the time to write a bit more extensively about the camera
Why?
Have you gotten your hands on one?
Just yesterday you were on here poo-pooing everyone else's enthusiasm, now we should hop on over to your 'blog' to see what sort of thoughts you can divine?
Because there is plenty of over enthusiastic writing in the net and I wanted to expand a but on my point of view. I think it's fine if we disagree, after all it's just a camera, but please use a more civilized language when you talk to me.
You don't like the phrase "poo poo"?
Perhaps it's a cultural mismatch, but you really seem to have an unnecessarily overly high opinion of yourself.
I highly respect Phillip and his reviews and contributions, they are very helpful, sincere and thoughtful. Besides, I like his photograps.
That's great, but the fact that he "liked" your comment about you liking him says everything I came here to say.

Do you really have to take this to a personal level? We have different opinions about a camera, lets argue about that.
Jun 16, 2015 at 02:46 AM
thedictionary
Offline
Details
p.12 #8A7rII game plan. What are you doing
I'm not being a grammar nazi, so please do not think that, but I've been reading this conversation and it's painful. It would be less painful if people did a quick google.

Firstly, it's "pooh-poohed" or "pooh-poohing", not "poo pooing".
Secondly, it's a transitive verb.

He was in no way being offensive, which you'd know if you bothered to look at a dictionary.

http://www.thefreedictionary.com/pooh-poohed

To express disdain or scorn for; dismiss or belittle.

Therefore, Phillip was the one to be offensive before ecarlino did, by claiming he had used an uncivilized language. This is libellous, moreover, saying you took the "time" to do something makes it sound like your time is more precious than someone else's (in this context). You wrote as though you are doing us a favour when really people are doing you a favour by clicking the link. If you think my reply is too personal; then perhaps question why you wrote something so personal to begin with. Saying "I took the time" seems rather personal, do you agree?

"here poo-pooing everyone else's enthusiasm"

This is simply NOT offensive.

"Perhaps it's a cultural mismatch"

It's not a cultural mismatch; it's not a colloquialism, it's a transitive verb in the dictionary.

"Do you really have to take this to a personal level? We have different opinions about a camera, lets argue about that."

It seems to me that you linked your website to a pseudo-review to gain e-popularity by leeching off of this website's popularity, then you had the audacity to imply he was behaving improper on this website, all because you're too illiterate to have heard of the phrase "pooh-poohed" and resorted to attacking him rather than wanting to learn. I'm not criticizing you for being illiterate, I don't expect you to know every word in the dictionary, and like I said I am not being a grammar nazi, but if you don't know of a word or phrase, that's fair enough. To criticize someone and offend them, claim they have not spoken to you with civilized language, PURELY because you're ignorant, and unwilling to learn what the word means, is far more offensive than anything he wrote. I'm illiterate too, especially in other languages, however, if someone said a word in another language, my first response would not be to accuse them of behaving improper, it would be to educate myself as to what that word means.

We can argue about the camera and our opinions but I think it's illogical to form loads of opinions and be certain on them based on a product we haven't seen, touched or held in person. Specification sheets aren't always reliable, and a lot of people are kinaesthetic learners.

The opinions I have based on the spec sheet are -

The camera is too large and heavy (I'll be off the grid for months and the lighter, the better).
The sensor could prove to be amazing.
There's no micro-sd secondary card slot (I respect dual sd would be difficult).
There's no external USB module to implement a secondary card slot (for redundancy).
I like that there's no GPS (there's better GPS options available, and this saves battery life. I don't want to wait for it to spool).
I like that there's no on board flash (on board flashes are always terrible due to the size of the light source and power, furthermore, they're often a water leak).
I dislike that there's been no mention of a new flash with it. I'd like a comparable radio flash to canon.
Sony for years have over-priced their products upon release. I do not like this strategy but I understand why they do it. It's just disgusting to me how much money they'll make on early cameras.
Mirrorless cameras are far cheaper to make than DSLR cameras.
I'm concerned about the sealing.
I like IBIS but I think it's slightly over-rated. It won't slow a subject, and it's not good enough for long exposure landscape shots. I'd be more in favour of this if they stopped putting OSS in their lenses, otherwise it seems somewhat of a 150 gram redundancy. I'm aware that it's good for all lenses, I'm just not 100% sold on the weight.
I'd like an uncompressed raw option. I don't care whether it'd only be able to shoot one frame a second, I'd still like that option.
I'd prefer the exposure compensation dial to be an ISO dial.
I'd prefer a full sized usb port.
I'd like the camera to be fully functional when a usb charger is plugged in, even if it doesn't receive its power from the charger. That way I could leave an external charger plugged in and wouldn't have to keep unplugging it. It'd charge the battery up when I turned the camera off.
The battery is archaic.
I'm mostly happy with the previous model except the poor shutter button, shutter lag, shutter, poor sealing, and a few other things. I'd be happy if they released a non IBIS version of this camera, in a lighter body.
The video features are great but I doubt I'll use them. I don't like being forced to put money into something I won't use. I'd rather there was a photographers version that skipped video, if it meant the price was considerably less.

Most of these opinions could change once I use the camera. They're minor points too. I will be buying it, I just don't know when. The price is a bit of an insult. The specification is good, but apple should have taught most people about computers that specification and cost aren't completely related


Edited on Jun 16, 2015 at 03:33 AM · View previous versions
Jun 16, 2015 at 02:53 AM
ecarlino
Offline
Details
p.12 #9A7rII game plan. What are you doing
Phillip Reeve wrote:
ecarlino wrote
alundeb wrote
ecarlino wrote
Phillip Reeve wrote
ecarlino wroteWhy?
Have you gotten your hands on one?
Just yesterday you were on here poo-pooing everyone else's enthusiasm, now we should hop on over to your 'blog' to see what sort of thoughts you can divine?
Because there is plenty of over enthusiastic writing in the net and I wanted to expand a but on my point of view. I think it's fine if we disagree, after all it's just a camera, but please use a more civilized language when you talk to me.
You don't like the phrase "poo poo"?
Perhaps it's a cultural mismatch, but you really seem to have an unnecessarily overly high opinion of yourself.
I highly respect Phillip and his reviews and contributions, they are very helpful, sincere and thoughtful. Besides, I like his photograps.
That's great, but the fact that he "liked" your comment about you liking him says everything I came here to say.
Do you really have to take this to a personal level? We have different opinions about a camera, lets argue about that.


Actually, it was never about a camera for me.

It was the fact that you criticized people on this board for being too enthusiastic about new gear - and a day later wanted everyone to read what your highness thought about it by visiting your blog, since "you took the time".

And then you continue your arrogance by suggesting that because YOU do not have affiliate programs that somehow your opinion is better than other reviewers, yet your commentary (which i wasted 2 minutes reading) was no more insightful than any of the hundreds of forum posts that have flooded the internet in the past week. Instead, it advances your notion that since YOU don't print larger than 12x18 - well then why would anyone need more than what you use, the original a7.

Edited on Jun 16, 2015 at 03:38 AM · View previous versions
Jun 16, 2015 at 03:31 AM
Phillip Reeve
Offline
Details
p.12 #10A7rII game plan. What are you doing
Oh I looked it up but in the context of ecarlino's post I came to the conclusion that it was meant offensively. English is not my native language so it happens that I misunderstand things or express myself mistakeable. I might have been wrong when I asked ecarlino to write more civilized, sorry if I was. Next time I will ask for clarification first. But this could have deescalated if ecarlino had clarified how he meant it. Instead he called my full of myself.

About the link: I have been a very active member of this forum for 3.5 years now and I think pmemebers from the ALT board will confirm that I have contributed to the community quite a bit. Whenever I post a link to my blog on this forum I ask myself if it would be a contribution and not just spam. I might have misjudged the situation this time, and I would have been glad if someone who felt way had sent me a polite PM.

Now your short paragraph contains the words "pseudo-review", "leeching", "audacity","illiterate", "ignorant" and "unwilling". All my illiteracy aside I find it very hard to understand it as a factual.
Jun 16, 2015 at 03:34 AM
twoeye
Offline
Details
p.12 #11A7rII game plan. What are you doing
Keep up the good work, Phillip!

This guy is better ignored.
Jun 16, 2015 at 03:37 AM
Phillip Reeve
Offline
Details
p.12 #12A7rII game plan. What are you doing

And then you continue your arrogance by suggesting that because YOU do not have affiliate programs that somehow your opinion is better than other reviewers
Just for clarification: I have affiliate programs on my site and I know many reviewers I respect who use them as well. But they create a strong incentive to hype new gear and not every news site and reviewer is immune to that.

As I wrote in the last post: Maybe I shouldn't have posted the link, linking to ones own content it a sensitive topic and yeah that article does not contain any new information, just my assesment. I appreciate it if people point out to me that it might be inappropriate to post such a link. BUT if you want me to take you serious you should take me serious as well.

Edited on Jun 16, 2015 at 08:52 AM · View previous versions
Jun 16, 2015 at 03:44 AM
thedictionary
Offline
Details
p.12 #13A7rII game plan. What are you doing
Well it would have certainly helped if he spelled it correctly.

"this could have deescalated if ecarlino had clarified how he meant it. Instead he called my full of myself."

I agree with that. I don't think he is going to stop.

"English is not my native language so it happens that I misunderstand things or express myself mistakeable"

English is my native language and I still misunderstand it, but my point was more to not assume straight away that someone is being uncivilized. The problem with that is then people DO become uncivilized. In either case, I don't know that he is going to stop. He didn't help things, I understand that.

I agree with many points in the article. I'm not sure I'd call it a review because the camera isn't out yet, but the interpretations.

My main gripe is that sony are trying to cater to many people with the one camera. They want the video crowd, the landscape crowd, etc. The a7r used to be a small, lightweight high resolution camera. For most people, 150 grams really isn't a problem. For me, it's on the breaking point of being too heavy.

The a7r is now £1,000 and the a7II is £1,000. If the a7rII is going to be £2,500, it's a bit steep. I think I'm going to pay £1,800 for it
Jun 16, 2015 at 03:49 AM
ecarlino
Offline
Details
p.12 #14A7rII game plan. What are you doing
thedictionary wrote:
Well it would have certainly helped if he spelled it correctly.


FYI, "poo poo" is a slang and as such has a variety of spellings:

http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=poo+pooing


but now we are WAY off topic....
Jun 16, 2015 at 04:01 AM
ecarlino
Offline
Details
p.12 #15A7rII game plan. What are you doing
Phillip Reeve wrote:
As I wrote in the last post: Maybe I shouldn't have posted the link, linking to ones own content it a sensitive topic and yeah that article does not contain any new information, just my assesment. I appreciate it if people point out to me that it might be inappropriate to post such a link. BUT if you want me to take you serious you should take me serious as well.


I don't take you seriously - you criticized people for being enthusiastic about a new product and then come back with the good news that "you took the time to write down your thoughts" and want everyone to stop what they're doing and go see what you have to say.

If you wanted to be taken seriously, how about waiting until you've had a chance to use the product for a while and then offer a review.

In any case, i've had a long night of celebrating the BLACKHAWKS Stanley Cup, so, i'll leave you alone now - the sun is about to rise here in Chicago and i'm off to bed.....
Jun 16, 2015 at 04:11 AM
howard
Offline
Details
p.12 #16A7rII game plan. What are you doing
At some point, this thread really took a turn for the worse. I hope everyone gets the camera in their hands soon!
Jun 16, 2015 at 04:41 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.12 #17A7rII game plan. What are you doing
Agree. All opinions count, so let's move on please.
Jun 16, 2015 at 05:20 AM
Matt Grum
Offline
Details
p.12 #18A7rII game plan. What are you doing
thedictionary wrote:
Phillip was the one to be offensive before ecarlino did, by claiming he had used an uncivilized language. This is libellous


Firstly who bothered to take the time to register an account, today, just to say this? Secondly, are you serious? The first comment went like:

ecarlino wrote:
Why?
Have you gotten your hands on one?
Just yesterday you were on here poo-pooing everyone else's enthusiasm, now we should hop on over to your 'blog' to see what sort of thoughts you can divine?


To me comes off as quite aggressive, a series of short accusative questions and using quotes around 'blog' to suggest it's in some way not a real blog. That's just how it comes across to me. This was followed up by Philip politely asking for different language (being sure to use the word please).

thedictionary wrote:
Saying "I took the time" seems rather personal, do you agree?


I'm afraid I can't see how that can possibly be construed as personal, given the post wasn't directed at anyone in particular, nor was it in reply to anyone.

thedictionary wrote:
It seems to me that you linked your website to a pseudo-review to gain e-popularity by leeching off of this website's popularity, then you had the audacity to imply he was behaving improper on this website... To criticize someone and offend them, claim they have not spoken to you with civilized language, PURELY because you're ignorant


Ok, that's enough. I've never used the hide function before, but likewise I don't recall ever reading anything like that on here.

ecarlino wrote:
I don't take you seriously - you criticized people for being enthusiastic about a new product and then come back with the good news that "you took the time to write down your thoughts" and want everyone to stop what they're doing and go see what you have to say.


Nowhere did Phillip say he wanted anyone to stop what they're doing, all he said was: here are some thoughts about the new camera - people are free to either read it or move along if they don't want to. That really seems like the mildest thing to prompt such an attack. I think you are slightly too aggressive on here in general, to be honest. I can be at times but only when it concerns facts, optics electronics maths or otherwise, never when discussing someone else or their work.

ecarlino wrote:
If you wanted to be taken seriously, how about waiting until you've had a chance to use the product for a while and then offer a review.


Phillip doesn't need to do anything to be taken seriously, his photography ought to speak for itself, but if not you might notice that over 4 years he's received 6210 likes from other FM users, at an average of over three and a half per post!
Jun 16, 2015 at 05:37 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.12 #19A7rII game plan. What are you doing
Phillip Reeve wrote:
Oh I looked it up but in the context of ecarlino's post I came to the conclusion that it was meant offensively. English is not my native language so it happens that I misunderstand things or express myself mistakeable. I might have been wrong when I asked ecarlino to write more civilized, sorry if I was. Next time I will ask for clarification first. But this could have deescalated if ecarlino had clarified how he meant it. Instead he called my full of myself.

About the link: I have been a very active member of this forum for 3.5
...Show more →

Phillip you have contributed greatly to the community over the years and I, for one, greatly respect your point of view. I think in this case linking to your blog post made sense. It was a much longer elaboration of your views on the camera and simply reposting it here would have been too long. It fit the thread well as we all are reporting our take on the camera. A small improvement might have been posting a short summary of it before the link, but I appreciate that you shared your views.
Jun 16, 2015 at 05:59 AM
mmurph
Offline
Details
p.12 #20A7rII game plan. What are you doing
Thank you Matt and Steve! I agree 100%

Phillip expressed his opinion. He didn't force anyone to click through, much less read it.

If you think you know what he will say and will disagree with that - don't read his post and move on. And picking apart the language skills of a non-native speaker is silly.

This is not DPReview. This type of interaction is the reason that many of us left that forum 10+ years ago. Let's not re-create that atmosphere here. Act like a professional please, and extend some courtesy to others. Or at least like an aspiring professional.

Peace.
Jun 16, 2015 at 06:12 AM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister