chez wrote:
molson wrote
chez wrote
arbitrage wrote
Well I finally got to try out the A7RII + Metabones + Canon 70-200 f/2.8 IS II and the Canon 16-35 f/2.8 II at TheCameraStore in Calgary this past weekend.
My impressions are it is a poor solution. Sometimes focus was fast, but 1 second later another focus attempt resulted in the most pain-staking focus hunting I've ever seen. This at first was in-store so lighting not the best but then I went to outside and still it hunted every second or third attempt.
Now on the plus side, with the native Sony FE 70-200 f/4 and the Sony 16-35 f/4 the focus was awesome. So this made my decision easier...I still haven't committed to buying the A7RII but now I know that if I do I will be sticking with native FE glass (Sony, Zeiss) and not putting my hopes on some great performance with my Canon glass. I was hoping I could use my Canon 16-35 f/4 IS and 24-70 f/2.8 II and my 70-200 f/2.8 IS II with Metabones with confidence but after the test I don't think it is going to be a workable solution for AF.
I'm now waiting for prices to drop on the A7RII or for the CDN $ to rise so I can get arbitrage pricing from the US. But for now I'll hold off on the purchase...that said, I may look at the 5DSR if its price continues to drop to replace the 5D3. We shall see.... The whole AF performance with the Metabones adapters has been evolving at a rapid pace recently as Metabones release new firmware. An adapter sitting on a store shelf for the last 6 months probably does not really give you the best feel for how well the camera works with the various lenses. With the current firmware, there's little to no difference in AF performance between my Canon 16-35mm f4L and 24-70mm f4L lenses on the adapter versus the native Sony FE lenses. It's only on the longer and slower zoom (70-300L IS) that the A7R II begins to falter.
If the adapter you tried doesn't have up-to-date firmware, the performance will be worse. Cliff, that's good to hear. My longest lens is the 300 f4 which is very old so I'm not holding my breath on it being god...but I do hope my other Canon AF lenses like the 70-200 f4, 85 1.8, 35L etc... Will AF with decent speed.
Good points regarding the MB firmware updates and AF functionality. Again, it depends a lot of personal preference how important AF is for the shooting. In my next mirrorless camera upgrade I won't even look at AF capability of the camera after realizing that (a) I only needed AF and my long lens on one occasion this year so far and (b) I like smaller sized manual focus lenses simply better. Therefore I won't even upgrade my MBII adapter - if I use it with my Canon lenses, I am in the big majority of cases always using them in MF mode, too.