fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII

  
 
helimat
Offline
Details
p.60 #1Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
molson wrote:
chez wroteJust need to purchase the A7R2 now.
Be patient... I'm still trying to decide whether to keep mine or not.

The cost of an A7R II makes it hard to justify purely as a supplement to my Canon system, but I just can't see any way it could entirely replace my Canon gear.


Hi Cliff.

I am late to the party here, but out of curiousity, if you had to sell one system today to pay for a kidney or something, which would you keep? I am curious what you think of the 5Dsr vs. the A7rII.
Oct 11, 2015 at 04:44 PM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.60 #2Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Hi, Mat;

I recently spent 10 days our in your part of the country (Port Renfrew/Ucluelet) and had the 5DsR and A7R II in tow, along with a 5D III as a backup. I only used the A7R II on parts of two or three days, and the 5DsR was in use virtually every day. So, based strictly on usability, I would keep the Canon system, but...
Oct 11, 2015 at 05:10 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.60 #3Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
molson wrote:
You also have to be very careful not to say anything negative about Sony... so any real or percieved flaws or deficiencies quickly get swept under the rug on that forum.


Frankly, that is more of a problem when Sony issues come up in this forum than in the Sony forum. I learn a lot more about real world concerns of a wide range of Sony users (and their positive experiences, too) by reading the Sony forum than I do by reading the very small number of Sony shooters who persistently post in the Canon forum.

On another subject... The reflexive discounting of knowledge gained from a variety of sources is a persistent problem among those who don't want to hear dissonant voices. There is a kind of knowledge and experience gained by personal experience with a tool, but it is not the only valid kind of knowledge.

There are those who carefully and fully research multiple products before purchasing one of them. These folks often get their information from a wide range of people who have direct experience with more than one product or whose profession it is to compare such things. In the end, one might make a very, very informed decision about that product category and, in fact, know more about a variety of products and their relative strengths/weaknesses than a person who limits their knowledge to only that which can be acquired first hand. In fact, if we look around at first-hand reports from those whose sample size is exactly one, we find some fairly strong personal biases among their reports, and more useful and balanced knowledge comes from going beyond the report of such people or even beyond our own individual biases.

Beyond that, all of us (or at least many of us) can develop some expertise in things we have not actually done ourselves. I know a lot about, to pick one subject, the oboe. I'm married to a professional oboist, so I live in the world of oboists and learn from them. That said, I couldn't carve a reed if my live depended upon it and even with weeks of practice my oboe playing would sound awful. Yet, my knowledge of the instrument, while incomplete, is not wrong or lacking.

Of course, it would be extra ironic if any person expressing or holding the view that no one who doesn't own a thing can know anything about it ever expressed an opinion on any thing that he doesn't personally own... ;-)

Dan

Edited on Oct 11, 2015 at 09:41 PM · View previous versions
Oct 11, 2015 at 07:04 PM
Monito
Offline
Details
p.60 #4Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
helimat wrote:
I am late to the party here, but out of curiousity, if you had to sell one system today to pay for a kidney or something, which would you keep? I am curious what you think of the 5Dsr vs. the A7rII.


I would keep my 5DS, in a heartbeat. If someone gave me an A7R2 I'd play with it for a week and then sell it and buy Canon gear.

I have some specialties (esp. landscape) but I'm more of a generalist than a specialist.
Oct 11, 2015 at 07:32 PM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.60 #5Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
gdanmitchell wrote

There are those who carefully and fully research multiple products before purchasing one of them. These folks often get their information from a wide range of people who have direct experience with more than one product or whose profession it is to compare such things. In the end, one might make a very, very informed decision about that product category and, in fact, know more about a variety of products and their relative strengths/weaknesses than a person who limits their knowledge to only that which can be acquired first hand.

Dan


I used to believe this too, but the problem with that logic nowadays is that most (if not all) of those people "whose profession it is to compare such things" are being paid, directly or indirectly, to sell those goods, so their opinions are anything but objective.
Oct 11, 2015 at 08:35 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.60 #6Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
molson wrote:
gdanmitchell wroteThere are those who carefully and fully research multiple products before purchasing one of them. These folks often get their information from a wide range of people who have direct experience with more than one product or whose profession it is to compare such things. In the end, one might make a very, very informed decision about that product category and, in fact, know more about a variety of products and their relative strengths/weaknesses than a person who limits their knowledge to only that which can be acquired first hand.

Dan
I used to believe this too, but the problem with that logic nowadays is that most (if not all) of those people "whose profession it is to compare such things" are being paid, directly or indirectly, to sell those goods, so their opinions are anything but objective.


Be careful to not tar everyone with the same brush. Some certainly are being more or less paid for their endorsement and opinion — not that this is anything new — but others are ethical and knowledgable and are not saying only what they are paid to say.
Oct 11, 2015 at 09:43 PM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.60 #7Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
gdanmitchell wrote:
molson wrote
gdanmitchell wroteThere are those who carefully and fully research multiple products before purchasing one of them. These folks often get their information from a wide range of people who have direct experience with more than one product or whose profession it is to compare such things. In the end, one might make a very, very informed decision about that product category and, in fact, know more about a variety of products and their relative strengths/weaknesses than a person who limits their knowledge to only that which can be acquired first hand.

Dan
I used to believe this too, but the problem with that logic nowadays is that most (if not all) of those people "whose profession it is to compare such things" are being paid, directly or indirectly, to sell those goods, so their opinions are anything but objective.
Be careful to not tar everyone with the same brush. Some certainly are being more or less paid for their endorsement and opinion — not that this is anything new — but others are ethical and knowledgable and are not saying only what they are paid to say.


Right up until they're told they can't have any more samples to review...
Oct 11, 2015 at 10:01 PM
chez
Online
Details
p.60 #8Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
molson wrote:
gdanmitchell wrote
molson wrote
gdanmitchell wroteThere are those who carefully and fully research multiple products before purchasing one of them. These folks often get their information from a wide range of people who have direct experience with more than one product or whose profession it is to compare such things. In the end, one might make a very, very informed decision about that product category and, in fact, know more about a variety of products and their relative strengths/weaknesses than a person who limits their knowledge to only that which can be acquired first hand.

Dan
I used to believe this too, but the problem with that logic nowadays is that most (if not all) of those people "whose profession it is to compare such things" are being paid, directly or indirectly, to sell those goods, so their opinions are anything but objective.
Be careful to not tar everyone with the same brush. Some certainly are being more or less paid for their endorsement and opinion — not that this is anything new — but others are ethical and knowledgable and are not saying only what they are paid to say.
Right up until they're told they can't have any more samples to review...


Yep...like Rob G. who spilt the beans on the 1D3 and low and behold...Canon abandoned him.
Oct 11, 2015 at 10:37 PM
helimat
Offline
Details
p.60 #9Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
molson wrote:
Hi, Mat;

I recently spent 10 days our in your part of the country (Port Renfrew/Ucluelet) and had the 5DsR and A7R II in tow, along with a 5D III as a backup. I only used the A7R II on parts of two or three days, and the 5DsR was in use virtually every day. So, based strictly on usability, I would keep the Canon system, but...


Thanks Cliff. I am in a similar situation; Mostly Canon but dabbling in Sony. I really want to like it, but I don't think I do...
Oct 12, 2015 at 12:17 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.60 #10Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
helimat wrote:
I really want to like it, but I don't think I do...


I feel ya ...
Oct 12, 2015 at 06:03 AM
Sagar
Offline
Details
p.60 #11Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
I can't believe this thread is still alive and kicking
Oct 12, 2015 at 06:04 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.60 #12Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Sagar wrote:
I can't believe this thread is still alive and kicking




This is about two still relatively new cameras and many people are just getting them and want to know things.

The quality of the thread as a whole would be higher without the regular interrupts by people who have nothing else to say than that what we just heard. Hope you enjoyed reading still
Oct 12, 2015 at 06:25 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.60 #13Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
molson wrote:
gdanmitchell wrote
molson wrote
gdanmitchell wroteThere are those who carefully and fully research multiple products before purchasing one of them. These folks often get their information from a wide range of people who have direct experience with more than one product or whose profession it is to compare such things. In the end, one might make a very, very informed decision about that product category and, in fact, know more about a variety of products and their relative strengths/weaknesses than a person who limits their knowledge to only that which can be acquired first hand.

Dan
I used to believe this too, but the problem with that logic nowadays is that most (if not all) of those people "whose profession it is to compare such things" are being paid, directly or indirectly, to sell those goods, so their opinions are anything but objective.
Be careful to not tar everyone with the same brush. Some certainly are being more or less paid for their endorsement and opinion — not that this is anything new — but others are ethical and knowledgable and are not saying only what they are paid to say.
Right up until they're told they can't have any more samples to review...


Again, there are some writers who behave in such ways — you might be thinking of a particular site, given that example — but that does not mean that everyone writing about camera equipment is feeding us false and biased information or primarily telling us what they are paid to say.

Extreme points of view are easy but generally unlike to be true. It would be naive to think that all reviews are free of bias and uninfluenced by commercial considerations, but it is equally naive to think that all reviews are primarily pushing a particular point of view that the author was paid to push.

Points of view that require some judgment and discrimination tend to more likely be true, and this is the case when it comes to evaluating the sources of reviewer information. Keep a bit of perspective, balance cynicism with critical thinking, read more than one, and you can discover a lot of useful and accurate information.

Dan
Oct 12, 2015 at 07:17 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.60 #14Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
And after your critical thinking read of the review's ... check with your trusted fellow FM'ers to debunk or confirm as needed.
Oct 12, 2015 at 07:22 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.60 #15Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
gdanmitchell wrote:
molson wrote
gdanmitchell wrote
molson wrote
gdanmitchell wroteThere are those who carefully and fully research multiple products before purchasing one of them. These folks often get their information from a wide range of people who have direct experience with more than one product or whose profession it is to compare such things. In the end, one might make a very, very informed decision about that product category and, in fact, know more about a variety of products and their relative strengths/weaknesses than a person who limits their knowledge to only that which can be acquired first hand.

Dan
I used to believe this too, but the problem with that logic nowadays is that most (if not all) of those people "whose profession it is to compare such things" are being paid, directly or indirectly, to sell those goods, so their opinions are anything but objective.
Be careful to not tar everyone with the same brush. Some certainly are being more or less paid for their endorsement and opinion — not that this is anything new — but others are ethical and knowledgable and are not saying only what they are paid to say.
Right up until they're told they can't have any more samples to review...
Again, there are some writers who behave in such ways — you might be thinking of a particular site, given that example — but that does not mean that everyone writing about camera equipment is feeding us false and biased information or primarily telling us what they are paid to say.

Extreme points of view are easy but generally unlike to be true. It would be naive to think that all reviews are free of bias and uninfluenced by commercial considerations, but it is equally naive to think that all reviews are primarily pushing a particular point of view that the
...Show more →

Agreed, molson's first hand experiences that the A7r has shadow banding and that screws come out of Sony cameras are extreme and hardly representative of what users can expect.

Good reviewers who get to borrow a lot of equipment from different manufacturers for free because they write reviews, are sometimes good at writing about negatives in such a way that it doesn't offend too much.
Oct 12, 2015 at 07:27 AM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.60 #16Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
gdanmitchell wrote
molson wrote
gdanmitchell wrote
molson wrote
gdanmitchell wroteThere are those who carefully and fully research multiple products before purchasing one of them. These folks often get their information from a wide range of people who have direct experience with more than one product or whose profession it is to compare such things. In the end, one might make a very, very informed decision about that product category and, in fact, know more about a variety of products and their relative strengths/weaknesses than a person who limits their knowledge to only that which can be acquired first hand.

Dan
I used to believe this too, but the problem with that logic nowadays is that most (if not all) of those people "whose profession it is to compare such things" are being paid, directly or indirectly, to sell those goods, so their opinions are anything but objective.
Be careful to not tar everyone with the same brush. Some certainly are being more or less paid for their endorsement and opinion — not that this is anything new — but others are ethical and knowledgable and are not saying only what they are paid to say.
Right up until they're told they can't have any more samples to review...
Again, there are some writers who behave in such ways — you might be thinking of a particular site, given that example — but that does not mean that everyone writing about camera equipment is feeding us false and biased information or primarily telling us what they are paid to say.

Extreme points of view are easy but generally unlike to be true. It would be naive to think that all reviews are free of bias and uninfluenced by commercial considerations, but it is equally naive to think that all reviews are primarily pushing a particular point of view that the author was paid to push.

Points of view that require some judgment and discrimination tend to more likely be true, and this is the case when it comes to evaluating the sources of reviewer information. Keep a bit of perspective, balance cynicism with critical thinking, read more than one, and you can discover a lot of useful and accurate information.

Dan
Agreed, molson's first hand experiences that the A7r has shadow banding and that screws come out of Sony cameras are extreme and hardly representative of what users can expect.



You forgot the delaminated rear LCD on my A7R... that took over two months (and over $300) to repair... or my first A7R, that unfortunately died shortly after I sold it to a good FM member... so I guess that makes a 100% failure rate for the three A7R's I've bought.

My A7R II is the sixth Sony A-series camera for ma - three A7R's, one A7, and one A7 II preceded it. It is definitely the best of the lot so far, loose screws notwithstanding.
Oct 12, 2015 at 07:37 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.60 #17Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RustyBug wrote:
And after your critical thinking read of the review's ... check with your trusted fellow FM'ers to debunk or confirm as needed.


And be very aware (it isn't that hard!) of biases there, too, and listen to a range of voices with different opinions, and learn to recognize which posters seem more interested in argument and brand-humping and which have a history of trying to look at things more objectively. This is true whether you are consulting reviewers or forum posters. (For example, many would put posters like Roger Cicala in the latter, better category. I'll let each of you figure our for yourselves who fits in the former.)

Confirmation bias is a funny thing. Or not.
Oct 12, 2015 at 08:14 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.60 #18Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
+1 Dan ... I said "trusted"

There are those who have a difference of opinion, but I still trust them to shoot straight. That's all I really ask of anyone. We all have our biases, opinions and preferences ... but, those are different things from objectivity. Both have their place, but sometimes folks advocate one in lieu of the other.

The more trusted / respected ones seem to be very good at providing distinguishing clarification between the two, likely leaning more heavily on the objectivity for helping to answer questions from their fellow FM'ers.



Edited on Oct 12, 2015 at 08:33 AM · View previous versions
Oct 12, 2015 at 08:25 AM
justruss
Offline
Details
p.60 #19Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
molson wrote:
alundeb wrote
gdanmitchell wrote
molson wrote
gdanmitchell wrote
molson wroteI used to believe this too, but the problem with that logic nowadays is that most (if not all) of those people "whose profession it is to compare such things" are being paid, directly or indirectly, to sell those goods, so their opinions are anything but objective.
Be careful to not tar everyone with the same brush. Some certainly are being more or less paid for their endorsement and opinion — not that this is anything new — but others are ethical and knowledgable and are not saying only what they are paid to say.
Right up until they're told they can't have any more samples to review...
Again, there are some writers who behave in such ways — you might be thinking of a particular site, given that example — but that does not mean that everyone writing about camera equipment is feeding us false and biased information or primarily telling us what they are paid to say.

Extreme points of view are easy but generally unlike to be true. It would be naive to think that all reviews are free of bias and uninfluenced by commercial considerations, but it is equally naive to think that all reviews are primarily pushing a particular point of view that the author was paid to push.

Points of view that require some judgment and discrimination tend to more likely be true, and this is the case when it comes to evaluating the sources of reviewer information. Keep a bit of perspective, balance cynicism with critical thinking, read more than one, and you can discover a lot of useful and accurate information.

Dan
Agreed, molson's first hand experiences that the A7r has shadow banding and that screws come out of Sony cameras are extreme and hardly representative of what users can expect.
You forgot the delaminated rear LCD on my A7R... that took over two months (and over $300) to repair... or my first A7R, that unfortunately died shortly after I sold it to a good FM member... so I guess that makes a 100% failure rate for the three A7R's I've bought.

My A7R II is the sixth Sony A-series camera for ma - three A7R's, one A7, and one A7 II preceded it. It is definitely the best of the lot so far, loose screws notwithstanding.


You sure have a fanboy's patience-- or appetite for suffering!
Oct 12, 2015 at 08:25 AM
darbo
Offline
Details
p.60 #20Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Amazing to read of one person's bad luck with the a7 series cameras. I have owned a7, a7R, a7S, and now a7R II (still have the a7R), and they all have worked flawlessly. The lens-mount on the a7 and a7R is garbage and needs to be replaced (I replaced my a7R mount with the Fotodiox one).

Nonetheless, my concern about build quality/longevity/durability with the a7 series was significant enough that I feel keeping a Canon DSLR in my bag is a must - and, BTW, I happen to love my 5DS R.
Oct 12, 2015 at 08:53 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister