molson wrote:
gdanmitchell wrote
molson wrote
gdanmitchell wrote
There are those who carefully and fully research multiple products before purchasing one of them. These folks often get their information from a wide range of people who have direct experience with more than one product or whose profession it is to compare such things. In the end, one might make a very, very informed decision about that product category and, in fact, know more about a variety of products and their relative strengths/weaknesses than a person who limits their knowledge to only that which can be acquired first hand.
Dan I used to believe this too, but the problem with that logic nowadays is that most (if not all) of those people "whose profession it is to compare such things" are being paid, directly or indirectly, to sell those goods, so their opinions are anything but objective. Be careful to not tar everyone with the same brush. Some certainly are being more or less paid for their endorsement and opinion — not that this is anything new — but others are ethical and knowledgable and are not saying only what they are paid to say. Right up until they're told they can't have any more samples to review...
Again, there are some writers who behave in such ways — you might be thinking of a particular site, given that example — but that does not mean that everyone writing about camera equipment is feeding us false and biased information or primarily telling us what they are paid to say.
Extreme points of view are easy but generally unlike to be true. It would be naive to think that all reviews are free of bias and uninfluenced by commercial considerations, but it is equally naive to think that all reviews are primarily pushing a particular point of view that the author was paid to push.
Points of view that require some judgment and discrimination tend to more likely be true, and this is the case when it comes to evaluating the sources of reviewer information. Keep a bit of perspective, balance cynicism with critical thinking, read more than one, and you can discover a lot of useful and accurate information.
Dan