charlyw wrote:
justruss wrote
charlyw wrote
justruss wrote
The short version is: There's virtually no disadvantage to offering IBIS beyond a slight weight penalty. There are lots of advantages. False. There are huge disadvantages to IBIS: you can't have a decent sized heat sink connected to the sensor. There are plenty of problems with the sensor heating up in long exposures and video use with the A7R2. I won't argue that there are potential disadvantages of that sort-- I was thinking in terms of stabilization and weight. So yes, I agree to an extent. And I'm very stills-centric, so I wasn't thinking about video. Your point carries water.
Huge disadvantages though? Not sure I'd characterize it that way, but then the magnitude of that disadvantage is a subjective thing. IBIS presents design challenges, certainly, but challenges (like the heat sink) that can be surmounted by other design choices. Just because it wasn't executed perfectly on the A7rII doesn't mean another camera won't get it more right.
I haven't shot a lot of 4K 100 mbps video (which is where I've heard about overheating... in direct sun, in hot temperatures, with the LCD closed, when shooting clips upwards 15+ minutes), but I haven't had any overheating issues myself yet.
Of course, back down on the ground (away from pure hypotheticals about design choices and implementations), bringing up video overheating, given current options, doesn't score many points for the non-IBIS systems we're discussing-- since I don't think the 5Ds can shoot 4K at all. I definitely don't have enough data points to say that IBIS presents a "huge" disadvantage when it comes to cooling as opposed to adds a challenge to designing a system that stays cool; I've definitely read about systems like the 1DC and RED overheating too in hot conditions when shooting 4K as well. Let's see how the A7sII does. You are not considering all the facts. Even if you don't use video actively, on the Sony camera there is no viewfinder image without video. And there is a marked increase in sensor temperature on long exposures....
Not considering all the facts? How do you know that?
In any case, if someone wants to primarily do long exposure night shots (over 30 seconds), or make such shots a significant part of their photography work (or video, as already mentioned), particularly in hot climates-- I would not recommend an A7rII as the best option. But my lack of recommending this particular camera on this front wouldn't necessarily apply to all cameras that have IBIS. That would be ridiculous.
If we're talking about video, I also wouldn't recommend a 5Ds, A7r, or 5D2 (which I also own).
On the A7rII I haven't seen any indication from anyone (nor in my own experience-- do you have any personal experience with the A7rII that says otherwise, I'd honestly be interested in hearing it?) that using the EVF or LCD is an issue when shooting stills besides this niche case of >30s night time exposures (which I already would suggest is not the A7rII's strength or a good primary purpose for buying this camera)... but I wouldn't preclude all current and future cameras with IBIS from being stellar at such types of work. Just that the A7rII isn't great at that.
It sound to me you're somehow stuck on the A7rII in an odd way: All features it has must be huge disadvantages when applied to all other cameras.
If it makes you feel better, I'll concede that there are challenges to having IBIS. I'll even call it a disadvantage (but I will not personally-- subjectivity alert-- agree it's a "huge advantage"), for your benefit.
But please, go back to my original post about IBIS: a personal experience using IBIS, and the impact it has on my shooting, compared to shooting the same or similar lenses on my 5D2 and X-E1. It's just a datapoint coming from a non-scientific, personal experience... which you're more than welcome to entirely discount since we disagree on the semantics (we agree on the use cases where the A7rII itself isn't the best tool!) surrounding the terror that is IBIS.